3 ms·
You are forgetting Edge. >That doesn’t seem like a good situation to me. Nothing is stopping alternate rendering engines from being created, but if the altern
by charcircuit 3y ago
You are forgetting Edge.
>That doesn’t seem like a good situation to me.
Nothing is stopping alternate rendering engines from being created, but if the alternates are not better and not worth integrating with a browser the resources might be better spent being invested in the most popular one that way it improves the web for the most people.
- elzbardico 3y agoEdge is based on chromium
- MBCook 3y agoRight. Edge used to have its own rendering engine, but they ditched it. At this point it’s the same as Brave and some other browsers. From a rendering point of view, it’s 100% Chromium. All of its customizations are above the engine, at least as far as I know.
- charcircuit 3y agoBut it has a good chunk of market share which is was being talked about.
- MBCook 3y agoDid it get very big? I know it obviously never challenged Chrome but did it ever get up to like 10% before the switch? Even if it didn’t it was an independent browser that could have been a competitor until they gave that up.
- charcircuit 3y agoIt currently is still a competitor. The switch of an internal browser engine doesn't make two products no longer competitors.
- MBCook 3y agoI’m speaking from the point of view of who is in charge of implementing web standards. If 80% of people used Edge but it was still based on Chromium, Google would still have a stranglehold on the web. It could be a four way tie between Chrome, Edge, Brave, and Opera. Google would still have the power.
- charcircuit 3y ago>Google would still have the power. None of the forks are required to accept every change Google makes or make their browsers a perfect clone. Edge, Brave, and Opera are all in control of their own destinies in making the best product they can.
- MBCook 3y ago> but if the alternates are not better and not worth integrating with a browser This is the problem. There is a MASSIVE sunk cost to get a modern browser off the ground compared to a static target. Even if you could do it, Chrome is going to keep moving forward. And they have enough power to change things in incompatible ways that everyone will follow because they have the vast majority of the market. Microsoft made a new modern browser engine. They gave it up because it was too hard to compete with Chrome. When Apple is forced to let people replace Safari, I fear we’re going to get into an IE6 situation. It doesn’t matter how good Chrome is, IE6 was great too. But when the company lets it stagnate for years because there’s no reason to invest, or decides to use it to push their advertising business to new heights, we are all screwed until a new competitor comes around. Firefox only exists because it was built from the Netscape code base. And ‘a modern browser’ was a WAY easier target 20 years ago. What if no group/company can muster enough effort to dethrone a stagnate Chrome? The web is in trouble. Even tagging along in 3rd place, Firefox is a good browser that could step up in such a situation. But only if development continues. If Firefox dies next year and Chrome stagnates five years from now we’ll be screwed.
- int_19h 3y agoFirefox was not the only competition back then. Opera was also around with its own engine, and it was very popular in Europe. But, yeah, this is when HTML and associated standards were a lot simpler.
- MBCook 3y agoYou’re right. I always forget Opera. I’m an American and it’s basically never been a factor here so it just never enters my mind.
- grodriguez100 3y ago> IE6 was great too Ouch. That hurts.
- MBCook 3y agoI was there, I was an IE user and proponent. It was a great browser. I think it was considered one of the best when it was released in 2001. IE 7 came out in… 2006. So IE 6 just sat there for 5 years. And it’s not like ever upgraded to 7 immediately. Lots of corporate PCs kept 6 for many years longer. That’s why it has the reputation it does. By 2006 IE 6 was horribly behind FF by every measure. Tons of security bugs had been found. By 2010 it was a total joke but developers were still having to make the modern web work on it, somehow. If it had been replaced in 2003 or 2004 and MS never paused development no one would remember IE 6 as a dumpster fire. But once you get a total stranglehold on the market, you can do stuff like that.
- aeontech 3y agoEdge switched to Chromium under the hood and is no longer using its own engine. Got to be bittersweet for the engineers who worked so hard on it.
- MBCook 3y agoI felt so bad for them. They worked hard and made a really good engine. They got out the door, started to see usage, and were then told by management one day “never mind we don’t care”.