4 ms·
Even if the outcome is the right one, mob justice doesn't sit well.
by temporary_ac 3y ago
Even if the outcome is the right one, mob justice doesn't sit well.
- gruez 3y agoWas this an instance of "mob justice", or an instance of her seeing the writing on the wall and then resigning rather than trying to put up a fight? I skimmed the article and it doesn't look like she was explicitly forced out, although it's certainly plausible that public ("mob") pressure was a factor.
- noitpmeder 3y agoThe "mob" part is that people went digging for dirt as a reaction to their dislike of her recent comments in front of congress.
- gruez 3y agoGreater public scrutiny is bad? Or is it only bad when it's in retaliation for something? More importantly, why is this form of "mob justice" bad? It's easy to see why it's bad to subject people to extrajudicial violence, but in this case all conduct is done within the bounds of the legal system.
- wredcoll 3y agoSo now we're in favor of cancel culture? This whiplash is confusing.
- gruez 3y agoThere's a huge difference between being "canceled" for one's opinions and/or unsubstantiated allegations, and being canceled for actual misconduct. I'm not even sure how you'd defend the latter. Suppose someone lied about their credentials to get a position, and he got found out a few years later thanks to angry partisans, are we supposed to let him off the hook because "cancel culture"?
- danso 3y agoPeople have been “canceled” for plagiarism long before “cancel culture” became a popular phrase
- noitpmeder 3y agoNowhere am I arguing she does not deserve the consequences of her actions, all I'm saying is that no-one seemed to care nearly this much until her congressional testimony.
- laborcontract 3y agoThe “dirt” here you refer to is her own work, not some petty digging into her personal life.
- kcplate 3y ago…Or perhaps not entirely her own work
- dekhn 3y agoThere was no mob justice here. Congress (Stefanik) is not a mob, and the plagiarism was real (and sent in the form of an amazing letter to the board/research integrity folks at Harvard). If anything, the Board resisted the mob pressure until it was clear that Gay had plagiarized.