4 ms·
>For a lot of things the problem is essentially a problem of scale. Those "ancient human tribes" who did so much better were tribes of 100-200 people, and it's
by coldtea 3y ago
>For a lot of things the problem is essentially a problem of scale. Those "ancient human tribes" who did so much better were tribes of 100-200 people, and it's actually not that hard to "do the right thing" with a relatively small group of people.
And yet other societies in the present do the right things in a lot of areas even with comparable groups of people.
Not to mention today we have tools like the fast text, voice, and even video communications, the internet, roads, distributed power structures, an educational system, etc. to combat scale issues.
>Blaming it on the two-party system is such a short-sighted US-centric point of view. There are plenty of countries with other types of democracies, and they have roughly similar problems. Details differ and some things are better (and others worse!) but overall: it's not that different.
Is it really a wash? Or rather most things are better in other western countries with big economies?
>"We could fix everything, we just don't" seems far too simplistic. "Everything" encompasses quite a lot
Which doesn't really matter, as it's a figure of speach. It means "most things" or even "a hell of alot of things".
- SpicyLemonZest 3y agoI’m not gonna argue that it’s precisely a wash, but I’m not aware of any country without political factions who strongly oppose each other and think the country would be much better if everyone else would just get on board. What can sometimes be true is that multiparty systems make the hardness of problems more legible; if you have 5 different parties with 5 different perspectives on how the education system ought to work, it’s a lot less tempting to think that one perspective is unambiguously correct and it’s only The System that’s stopping us from following it. The author mentions, for example, that we know “providing free college to everyone would be a good idea”. But we don’t know this, and there are many other rich countries that don’t do it; in some, college is entirely unavailable to people who don’t enroll in the appropriate high school track.
- coldtea 3y ago>The author mentions, for example, that we know “providing free college to everyone would be a good idea”. But we don’t know this, and there are many other rich countries that don’t do it; in some, college is entirely unavailable to people who don’t enroll in the appropriate high school track. We can change this however to "we know that massively cheeper or free college to anyone in the appropriate high school track is better" and it becomes true.
- xboxnolifes 3y agoNot necessarily. It's still possible there are confounding factors that led to it's success, unknown to all implementers and observers. Maybe there are other pre-requisites to the success of the implemented education system.
- coldtea 3y agoWe still know not having millions of people in debt out of university, and not giving millions of others the possibility to even go into university without big spending, is not good - confounding factors or not.
- concordDance 3y agoHow do we know that a university degree isn't primarily a signalling mechanism? That would make universal university incredibly wasteful of people's most energetic years.
- coldtea 3y agoBecause people don't just learn to be doctors, physistics, biologists, structural and civic engineers, chemists, and countless of other professions on their own (not in any significant nunber after the 18th century at least), they learn it in university, with a structured curriculum, theoritical tuition, supervision, labs, and so on.
- concordDance 3y agoThe vast majority of people with degrees will not use that degree in their job. I certainly didn't and looking at my fellow physics or maths grads the same is true of almost all of them.
- coldtea 3y agoNot sure what part one wont use. The degree as in "the printed paper"? Because I guarantee that the "vast majority of people with degrees" in the professions I described and many more, will use the knowledge acquired during their degree in their jobs. I'm not sure what physics or maths grad doesn't use the math he was taught/practiced/and picked up during his tutoring for the degree. The implication is that they learn those things before going to university? Or that they learn them in grad school? (as if studying for graduate school is not also university, and as if the prior knowledge acquired during their BSc and such wasn't necessary to understand what they encountered in grad school -- and to have a basic understanding of their field).
- concordDance 3y ago> Or rather most things are better in other western countries with big economies? Not sure which other countries you're thinking of, but each of then have their own issues. E.g. the UK has insane house prices and its rail is awful (I live here).
- jhbadger 3y agoYes, compared to many places in Europe (and even parts of Asia), UK's rail system is pretty bad. But it is still a practical way to get from city to city in the UK. In the US, except for the Washington-NYC-Boston corridor (and maybe the San Diego-Los Angeles route) it isn't really anymore. You can technically take a train from NYC to Chicago, but it will take you longer than the same train trip took 100 years ago! And insane house prices are very much a problem in the US as well.
- concordDance 3y agoI wouldn't call it very practical. Unless you want to go to London you're better off driving from a time, cost and reliability perspective. It's bizarre to me that it's much cheaper to fly to Edinburgh or Nice than to take trains... The ratio of hourly wage to meter of housing is from 2x to 10x worse in the UK than the USS.