6 ms·
What happens when you quit sugar? (2023) [video]
- rinka_singh 3y ago:-(( All this stuff - What happens when... is really nice. I know it. The problem is: I've been trying to cut sugar (forget eliminate) out of my diet for YEARS. 2 days into not having sugar and I go into such severe cravings that I knock off a sweetened glass of milk (with all its consequences - I'm lactose intolerant). HELP!!! Please can people here tell me HOW do I handle the cravings (and don't tell me "grin and bear it" - at its height, I'm just about ready to kill someone :-( and from there on, it's just a matter of time before I lapse). Any/all inputs that will help me get through the craving are very welcome.
- devilbunny 3y agoObviously, you will have to try things out for yourself, but have you tried getting rid of sugar with absolutely no attempt to limit caloric intake? I can't say it will be a perfect solution, but it did work for me when I first started eating very low carb, which was over a decade ago. Once you're used to not eating sugar, it does become easier to start cutting calories. I didn't worry about it for at least a few months.
- rinka_singh 3y agoThank you.
- devilbunny 3y agoYou are welcome, and I wish you the best of luck.
- snitch182 3y agoYou shure as hell have a lot trouble shopping food.
- adrianN 3y agoYou have a lot of trouble shopping for prepared food.
- anonym29 3y agoYou only have a lot of trouble if you're adamant about looking for all the same kinds of food you did before. It's actually pretty easy if you accept that the total number of items at the grocery store / restaurants has dramatically shrunk, and you stick to mostly whole foods (food category, not the corporation). Your staples start to become less processed crap and more animal products, vegetables, dairy, nuts/legumes, and more cooking at home. It's a big transition that most people are unprepared for, but not actually terribly difficult as a single person with no SO/kids.
- adrianN 3y agoSo you agree that it’s hard to find prepared food without sugar…
- anonym29 3y agoSugar alone? No, not really. A lot of stuff that doesn't need any added sugar has it (tomato sauce, baby formula, jams/jellies, gravy, salad dressing, etc), but overall, a plurality of the items for sale in my local grocery store don't have sugar. I can buy prepared pizzas, burgers, frozen dinners (just don't eat the dessert, be careful of gravies), lunch meats/cold cuts (almost all animal products really), many types of wheat-derived products like bread, pasta, cereal. Lots of veggies are super easy too. Sugar is pretty easy to avoid. Stop doing your shopping in the twinky aisle. Simple carbohydrates in general? That's more difficult. For reference, I say this as someome who's cooking skills consist of knowing how to use a microwave, knowing how to boil water, and knowing how to cook a frozen pizza, I'm not some kind of culinary wizard.
- anotherhue 3y agoYeah, learn some recipes before trying this experiment. Quality is almost always far superior but the time investment can hurt.
- msla 3y agoYou die of starvation when you can no longer produce glucose.
- electrondood 3y agoThis post is about dietary sugar, which is not necessary.
- nntwozz 3y agoThe body can produce glucose through gluconeogenesis.
- msla 3y agoOut of what? If there's no inputs, there's nothing it can do. Or do you think all sugar is the white stuff you get at the store?
- venv 3y agoOut of protein or fats.
- anonporridge 3y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gluconeogenesis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gluconeogenesis
- pengaru 3y ago> You die of starvation when you can no longer produce glucose. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ketosis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ketosis 2. Sugar is 50/50 fructose and glucose, the fructose half is arguably poison to humans. It's important to distinguish glucose from sugar when it comes to human health/nutrition.
- JonChesterfield 3y agoSucrose is 50/50 fructose and glucose. As in each molecule of sucrose is one of fructose and one of glucose stuck together. All three of those things are sugars. Fructose is usually considered healthier than sucrose or glucose - the whole "natural fruit sugars are OK" premise - though that seems likely to be nonsense given it's immediately and easily converted to glucose after you eat it. I don't know of any argument that says it's poisonous, or in any sense worse than glucose. That also seems unlikely to be true for the same reason - it's immediately converted to glucose. (replies suggest my recollection of fructose being metabolised by trivial conversion to glucose followed by the usual glucose pathway is incorrect, interesting)
- robg 3y agoCandida is also really interesting, where a yeast craves the sugar and you’re just feeding it. https://my.clevelandclinic.org/health/diseases/22961-candida-albicans https://my.clevelandclinic.org/health/diseases/22961-candida... Taking candibactin AR and BR I’ve found my sugar cravings disappear the next day.
- lacrimacida 3y agoIronically, the production of this video has the feel of a sugar spike
- unnamed76ri 3y agoFor those wondering where to start, I just began going through the meal plan in Danielle Walker’s Against All Grain. It isn’t strictly about no sugar but it definitely cuts out any processed garbage, including added sugars or course. When I did my grocery shopping for a week of meals, I spent more time in the produce section than ever and ended up with at least one vegetable I’d never heard of.
- throwup238 3y agoWhat was the vegetable you hadn’t heard of?
- unnamed76ri 3y agoJicama
- unnamed76ri 3y agolol people on this site will downvote anything…
- drakonka 3y agoI'm surprised this video links lack of sugar intake with ketone excretion. I did keto for about a year a long time ago and just cutting sugar was definitely not enough - I had to cut carbs in general to get keto readings or keto breath. I dropped keto after some time, but my sugar consumption never went back up to pre-keto levels. Checking nutrition labels for sugar content is just second nature at this point. If craving dessert, I usually make something like Greek yogurt with blueberries. If baking, most recipes end up tasting way too sweet now so I generally cut the sugar by at least half the amount listed. I do sometimes have a larger "dose": For example, if I'm at a new restaurant and want to try a unique dessert. Or my boyfriend's mom drops off some delicious pastry she made. But that leads me to the skin part of the video, which really resonated. Every time I do have a day or two of eating more sugar than usual, it shows up very quickly in my skin - I break out like crazy within days.
- ijustlovemath 3y agoCarbs are sugars! Ketosis involves cutting as many short- and long-chain sugars from your diet as is feasible
- drakonka 3y agoTrue! But this video from what I saw did not mention it (or maybe I missed it?). It came off as something that was intended to be approachable for the general population, and I don't think the general population sees illustrations of traditional granulated sugar and sugary drinks and thinks "Oh they're actually talking about carbs in general".
- ijustlovemath 3y agoYeah, there's a lot of bad information around dieting and blood sugar more generally! It's important to call it out when you see it!
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- nonameiguess 3y agoI see this sort of clickbait a lot and don't actually click and don't want to again, but what does this person claim? I've been keeping detailed daily food logs and preparing my own food largely from scratch for a few years now and the net result is I don't eat a lot of sugar. Most of the time, no sugar at all, unless you count all the berries I eat. What happens is nothing. I've never had a cavity, but that was true when I was a kid and still ate sugar. Seems to be genetics. Out of myself and three sisters, only one of us has ever had a cavity and it was only once. I'm not fat, but again, neither are any of my sisters. I'm very lean but that still required lifting to build muscle and intentional calorie restriction to lose fat. It didn't happen magically based on food choices. I suppose I'm less likely than most to get diabetes, but again, no one in my my family has diabetes, and as far as I'm aware, they all eat sugar. I'm the only one who has been religious about making my own food from scratch and never adding any kind of sweeteners. If anything has actually happened, it's not outwardly noticeable. I still get sick. Still get injured. Even still get some occasional minor acne. From looking over this video's transcripts, it appears they're fixating on cravings and ketosis. That seems to be something that happens if you eat no carbohydrates at all. Simply dropping sugar will not put you into ketosis. Whether it leads to any kind of more specific cravings will depend on how much you were eating before and what you replace it with, if anything.
- newsclues 3y agoFrom experience, you lose weight. Gradually cut out sugar and eat basically only whole foods, mainly meat and vegetables. Also try to time restrict eating to avoid morning and evening consumption. Lost over 75 pounds over a few years (no lose skin) and feel much better although colder without all the fat insulation! I’m am not overly active and generally spend most of my day sitting, so it’s mainly just diet control for weight loss.
- snitty 3y agoThis video is…weirdly researched. Like, they researched the effect of cutting added dietary sugars for various lengths of times, and picked seemingly random bits to talk about from the research. Please don't give it much weight. Also, they indicate that a water fast is when you have no water. It's when you have only water. Which also isn't a good indication of what happens if you just cut added dietary sugars.
- mmaunder 3y agoYouTube science. They’re describing what happens when you stop eating carbohydrates, of which refined sugar is one. That would include rice, for example. But they keep saying “sugar” because YT and views.
- mixmastamyk 3y agoSee glycemic index for comparison.
- anyonecancode 3y agoI dramatically cut down my consumption of added sugars several years ago (added sugars are, as the term suggests, those "added" where they wouldn't be on their own -- eg a bowl of blueberries on its own clearly has sugars. Package those blueberries in a preserve and the preserve will have "added" sugar, not just the sugar from the blueberries themselves). On the one hand, I'm afraid to say that I can't report any dramatic night and day difference. I do have in general more energy, better dental health, etc, but subjectively that all felt _slightly_ better, not click-baity better. On the other hand, I can report it hasn't been all that dramatic -- I didn't upend my life, made what really felt more like slight changes. Probably the biggest change for me was breakfast -- instead of carbs it's generally Greek yogurt, frozen fruit, nuts, and raisins (for sweetness), and coffee. I also check labels more -- who knew, for instance, that tomato soup had so much added sugar! I take that as a win since, objectively, it _is_ much healthier to have less added sugars in my diet, and I got this gain without anything overly dramatic or disruptive. And it kicked off a gradual changing of other habits -- I got back to going to the gym regularly a few years after that, and have gotten better at keeping a regular bed time. The tl;dr I'm trying to make here -- smaller, gradual changes do make a difference, are worth doing, and don't have to be dramatic (and are easier to stick to).
- bwanab 3y agoI quit eating sugar 4 years ago. No specific health problems, but having seen a couple of similar articles I thought it would be a good idea. When I got my first checkup about a year after stopping, my numbers had all improved drastically with essentially no other big changes in lifestyle. Positive reinforcement! You do have to be careful about your grocery selections. One of my favorite boogeymen is the product called peanut spread which comes in a jar just like peanut butter and looks just like it, but it's loaded with added sugar. Of course, some brands of peanut butter are, too, but this is a thing with the high end products that you'd think wouldn't do that. But, my advice is just stop adding sugar to recipes and stop eating stuff that is obviously sugar laden (muffins, cookies, etc). Over time, you become somewhat sensitized to foods that have it where you don't expect it. Check labels when in doubt, but basically, don't sweat the small stuff and absolutely don't refuse a small piece of your niece's birthday cake - it won't kill you.
- jncfhnb 3y agoAnd start with drinks. Drinks are by far the worst offender.
- eddd-ddde 3y agoKetchup is one of those products that are mostly sugar for no reason. Same with those processed juices. Ironically, tomato juice is usually not that sugary and I love it a lot.
- voisin 3y agoPresumably ketchup has sugar because tomatoes are acidic and it balances it out? I have never seen a sugar free ketchup, whereas there are plenty of “just nuts” peanut butters that taste fantastic with no sugar.
- ddejohn 3y agoI believe sugar is added to tomato-based products (sauces, condiments, etc) because tomatoes are pretty acidic by themselves and sugar is a common way to balance out acidic foods.
- yreg 3y agoI think that cutting back on sugar intake is going to be one of the next major health topics. Together with a psychologist friend we've made a simple app[0] for tracking that journey. My main motivation was to learn Swift/SwiftUI so it's iOS only, sorry. If anyone cares to try it out, we appreciate feedback. [0] https://sugarlessapp.com/ https://sugarlessapp.com/
- ourmandave 3y agoHere's another video where they quit sugar. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8UZJRR8OHhY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8UZJRR8OHhY
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Nifty3929 3y agoI think this is one of those things where you get the most benefit with the least cost to your lifestyle by focusing on the ~80% primary contributors - whatever those are for you. For example, sugary drinks. No need to avoid ketchup or peanut butter with sugar and such, as those probably small contributors overall, and working around them is tough. I'd suggest simply observing the sugar in various foods that you eat without judgement, and without a specific plan to cut them out. Just observe. Then if you think you're consuming too much overall, get rid of the easiest, highest-sugar ones first and see how it goes.
- mixmastamyk 3y agoOk, but it’s easy to avoid processed peanut butter and everyone should. Typically prefer the ones you need to stir.
- orwin 3y agoThe beginning was better than what I expected (mentioning the 'in mice' effect) so I thought I would look at it, but... It's mostly wrong? What? I mean, it shows they've done research, but isn't it really incomplete? I'm clearly not an expert, but I was obese and did some surface level research on the subject to loose weight (sadly sugar is not the only thing that triggers food cravings for me, all food do), I think they are mixing up a lot of different research but don't really understand? I mean, it's - mostly - okay as an entry level video, and if people reduce their sugar consumption thanks to that, it's a win. But really it's surface deep and you shouldn't take anything as facts (unless you have an almost obese nephew/niece who could profit from eating less sugar, in that case, anything goes).
- helph67 3y agoI read a news item (decades ago) reporting on excessive amounts of sugar and salt used in commercially produced foods. Decided I would no longer add those items to my diet and became careful of purchasing such foods. Consider it to be one of my best health related decisions of my life!