5 ms·
Chief justice centers Supreme Court annual report on AI's dangers
- dirtyhippiefree 3y agoLook at the AI issue and pay no attention to the gifts coming from the men behind the curtain… Why am I not surprised?
- plorg 3y agoIf I were John Roberts I, too, would rather talk about the shiny robot god than all of the specious, inconsistent rulings on literally made-up court cases I had been deciding.
- mc32 3y agoYah I don’t know where he got the ACA ruling from… that was a weird one. I’m for “you have a job, you automatically get enrolled” medical coverage. But how he went about the ruling was surprising.
- dirtyhippiefree 3y agoIt appears many here are nervous about the Elephant in the Room, which is why we’re graying out over Wagging the Dog…anything to avoid addressing the problem everyone is still talking about…
- namelessoracle 3y agoFor all the consternation about Copilot and AI coding tools, its looking like legal work is as much if not more setup for disruption. Document review is already being done by AI, lawyers are using AI to beef up closing arguments and review arguments, AI researchers to go through the relevant cases for citations have been worked on for awhile. Lawyers being lawyers have immediately reached to "make it illegal" and setting up protections for their trade like they always done. Roberts is commenting that they are going to be disappointed if they think they can get legal protections that X or Y must always be done by a human.
- ryandvm 3y agoAgreed. LLMs seem almost purpose built for the boilerplate part of legal work. "Read this user agreement and point out any unusual or particularly risky clauses."
- CapitalistCartr 3y agoAlso using AI (ChatGPT) to write briefs, appeals, etc. Just edit. Saves a lot of time, which reduces the number of paralegals needed. This ship has already sailed. But it does not eliminate the need for a well-trained person to edit and review.
- amalcon 3y agoThe editing and review part is critical. Judges really have not liked it when completely fictitious citations ended up in court filings...
- ExoticPearTree 3y agoYou will need really trained people to review whatever the AI writes and also need to be able to check sources in case the AI hallucinates and starts referencing made up case law or precedents. So maybe paralegals will transform into reviewers or something similar.
- namelessoracle 3y agothis is how document review works now basically. It used to be lots of lawyers got hired to go through the documents, now AI does it, and flags things for actual lawyer to review (along with suggestions), so what was the work of a couple of dozen lawyers is like maybe 2. this is one of the huge issues for the unemployed lawyer problem, as those jobs were the entry level for straight of school lawyers. I expect similar problems with dev roles coming soon.
- Spooky23 3y agoWorse, judges are writing decisions and evaluating cases based on this. The problem is that we’re going to have people litigating court cases and stupid bureaucratic nonsense within companies by lobbing nonsense that nobody has read at each other. Everyone will wink and nod, but these organizations and institutions will be exponentially more clueless. As technologists, it’s easy to shrug. What do you do when a judge takes your kid away after using an LLM to read and interpret bullshit generated case notes that a CPS worker generated with another LLM?
- gnarlouse 3y agoOf course the Supreme Court only cares about protecting their own jobs. Let everybody else be disaffected by AI—that’s fine. I hate this species
- darkerside 3y ago> “Judges, for example, measure the sincerity of a defendant’s allocution at sentencing,” Roberts wrote Sunday. “Nuance matters: Much can turn on a shaking hand, a quivering voice, a change of inflection, a bead of sweat, a moment’s hesitation, a fleeting break in eye contact. And most people still trust humans more than machines to perceive and draw the right inferences from these clues.” I'm not saying machines would do better, but this really lays bare how ridiculous the justice system is.
- watwut 3y agoYeah, it sounds like explanation why machine can be better after all, if it does not add or remove years of punishment based on sweat, moment of hesitation or fleeting break in eye contact.
- ryanklee 3y agoShouldn't a person's admittance of guilt and the sincerity of that admittance be a factor in determining their sentence?
- johngladtj 3y agoNo. You should not incentivise people to lie, or give a specific answer. Nor should you incentivise innocent people to proclaim their guilt
- ryanklee 3y agoI didn't say we should, I asked if someone's admittance of guilt and their sincerity is relevant to sentencing measures.
- johngladtj 3y agoIf it's relevant then people will be incentivise to lie to get better outcomes for themselves
- 3y ago
- temp0826 3y agoThere isn't something more pressing to worry about than blogspam generators?
- barryrandall 3y agoSomeone fell some AI-generated bullshit, and we have the misfortune of it being someone whose every utterance gets published.
- jmyeet 3y agoFake citations from ChatGPT generated motions has come up a few times, mentioned here. This highlights how AI is misused. It should be used to enhance human work not to replace it. Example: if AI allows a lawyer to effective write 10 motions a week instead of 2, that's a win. The human is still responsible for those motions. If they include fake case citations, that's on the lawyer, not the AI. But people want to use AI to replace that lawyer, taking them out of the loop completely. Every fake citations should be on the lawyer who submitted it. That'll end this real quick. > “Judges, for example, measure the sincerity of a defendant’s allocution at sentencing,” Roberts wrote Sunday. “Nuance matters: Much can turn on a shaking hand, a quivering voice, a change of inflection, a bead of sweat, a moment’s hesitation, a fleeting break in eye contact. And most people still trust humans more than machines to perceive and draw the right inferences from these clues.” Removing judges from this may well be a good thing. This allows a lot of bias to seep in to the process. Judges have been caught giving vastly different sentences to similar cases where the only real differences were race, gender and background (eg [1]). An extreme example is Brock Turner [2]. That judge should've been impeached. [1]: https://www.opensocietyfoundations.org/publications/racial-disparity-sentencing https://www.opensocietyfoundations.org/publications/racial-d... [2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/People_v._Turner#Sentencing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/People_v._Turner#Sentencing
- jqpabc123 3y agoDoes the Chief Justice have any personal interest in MSFT, AAPL or GOOG? Inquiring minds want to know because there are certainly more pressing legal issues than AI that can have trouble with simple math.
- mccrory 3y agoBetter to distract people with other things than face the important work.
- infecto 3y agohttps://www.scotusblog.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/06/Roberts-Jr-John-G-Annual-2022.pdf https://www.scotusblog.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/06/Robert...
- cormacrelf 3y agoAt least not directly, as of the 2022 disclosure form. https://www.scotusblog.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/06/Roberts-Jr-John-G-Annual-2022.pdf https://www.scotusblog.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/06/Robert...
- simonw 3y agoSadly it looks like Supreme Court financial disclosure forms aren't particularly accurate representations of their conflicts of interest: https://www.propublica.org/series/supreme-court-scotus https://www.propublica.org/series/supreme-court-scotus
- cormacrelf 3y agoSure, wasn’t sure that even needed to be said at this point, but even so, this form was probably produced by a broker. Even if it does not cover things like this https://www.businessinsider.com/jane-roberts-chief-justice-wife-10-million-commissions-2023-4 https://www.businessinsider.com/jane-roberts-chief-justice-w..., I think it was likely accurate as to his holdings in publicly traded stocks and index funds.
- 3y ago