6 ms·
They've also begun heavily pivoting hiring for dev roles to India now as well. I have cousins who attended no name universities in India getting SWE roles in Am
by alephnerd 3y ago
They've also begun heavily pivoting hiring for dev roles to India now as well. I have cousins who attended no name universities in India getting SWE roles in Amazon - something that was unimaginable 5 years ago - and expanding Dev offices to lower CoL cities like Hyderabad while slowly pivoting away from Bangalore.
Addendum:
Also, the Indian branches (edit: of companies that aren't Amazon) are fairly remote work friendly. Now you have people earning $20-40k/yr living in their ancestral towns and villages where median incomes might be $3-5k
This is why I warned HN that remote first will make tech more competitive.
- timeagain 3y agoMaybe it is just circumstance but I had been working with devs in Hyderabad since at least 2016 when I was at Amazon. I’m sure they are expanding the workforce there, though
- alephnerd 3y agoThey've been in HYD for some time, but HYD is fairly new in the Indian software scene. Traditionally, Delhi NCR and Bangalore were the big 2 tech hubs since the 80s-90s, but politicians who were also massive landlords in Hyderabad [0][1][2] began giving tech companies tax incentives to move to Hyderabad in the early 2000s It began as low tier Infosys type work, but began climbing up the value chain in the 2010s [0] - https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/N._Chandrababu_Naidu https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/N._Chandrababu_Naidu [1] - https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/K._Chandrashekar_Rao https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/K._Chandrashekar_Rao [2] - https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Y._S._Rajasekhara_Reddy https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Y._S._Rajasekhara_Reddy
- justin66 3y agoI mean, I don't know what they do there, but haven't Microsoft had an office in Hyderabad for over 20 years?
- alephnerd 3y agoDelhi NCR and Bangalore were tech hubs since the 1980s, hence why I'm calling Hyderabad (and Pune) new as they began sprouting in the early 2000s Indore is becoming the next Hyderabad now as well. It's in the same position that Hyderabad was in the early 2000s.
- debarshri 3y agoI see the same trend with Google, Facebook, okta etc. There are multiple factors. Ofcourse from orgs perspective it is cost saving measure. But from another phenomenon that has happened is that graduates from lower tier colleges have gotten good in cracking leetcode, faang style interviews. There YouTube channels, blogs, website tuned to pass these interviews in India.
- alephnerd 3y ago> graduates from lower tier colleges Lower tier colleges have gotten much better in quality too. I remember Indraprashta came to recruit Indian PhD students at my Ivy League tier college to become tenure track CS/ECE/EE professors. Plenty of lower tier IIITs and regional engineering colleges are getting Western or Top Tier IIT trained faculty, and students are higher quality now as well. As the child of a dad who attended one of these no name RECs who ended up becoming tech leadership here in the Bay, I'm glad that this democratization has occurred. The BITS Pilani and IITian uncles were very snobby and annoying.
- raincom 3y agoWhat you cite is one factor. Another factor is access for students. Once upon a time, curious students had two choices: buy books to learn on their own; or go to whatever low quality teachers they had. Cheap internet, YouTube, LibGen, other resources help students as long as the latter desire to learn.
- debarshri 3y agoQuality is a relative term. We have been hiring in India for past 2 years. I can tell you there is lot of noise and no substance. There is only handful of good candidates and they know they are good.
- wyclif 3y agoIn India it's crazy because culturally they focus so much on the credential. It wasn't that long ago that if you were an Indian engineer and you weren't a graduate of IIT, you had no chance of working for these companies. The entire Indian hiring funnel is based on that system and it will be hard to change.
- hackernewds 3y agoI have encountered this during my time recruiting as well, where the same position I applied for was also listed for 1 day (then taken down) in Hyderabad. Likely stealthily collect applications. Ultimately, they said I passed the rounds, but the role was cut. Microsoft has also explicitly expanded their hiring in India robustly for dev positions. When companies tell you how infeasible remote work is and that you need to come in to the office, take it with a grain of salt that it is solely infeasible for you to wfh at your billing rate.
- jimbob45 3y agoHumana is starting to hire nurses in the Philippines. One would think that’s a national security hole but what do I know. The first candidate to promise an outlawing of outsourcing gets my vote.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoYou don’t have to outlaw it, just make it so economically painful as to be outlawed.
- intended 3y agoOh, yes please! As much as I would like labor laws to be improved Globally, I doubt governments will allow this. That said, I am dying to see some country try something similar again. There is something beautiful when voters hold politicians up to their values, and politicans fail to explain the competitive realities to their voters. Making outsourcing economically unviable is a magnicificent contender.
- raincom 3y agoCandidates can promise many things, but they won't pass laws to ban outsourcing. Even if they do, they dilute it to an extent that these laws become impotent by creative loopholes.
- pylua 3y agoThey might if the tax base decreases substantially and unemployment shoots up to unsustainable levels. The government definitely cannot afford , with the national debt, to lose tax dollars or to subsidize high levels of unemployment.
- alephnerd 3y agoNursing was always dependent on Pinoy labor. Because PH used to an American territory until 1946, the education system is largely the same [0]. PH is to the US Medical system as India/Pakistan/Bangladesh are to the UK NHS [0] - https://nursing.uw.edu/article/filipinos-and-filipinos-americans-nurses-in-the-united-states/ https://nursing.uw.edu/article/filipinos-and-filipinos-ameri...
- citizenpaul 3y ago>living in their ancestral towns and villages I mean its great to make more money than anyone where you are. However I've known a number of Indian people that have moved to the US that say they will never go back to India unless they are forced to even though comparatively make less money here. Money is only good if it can buy things. If all your village has is mud huts you are still living in a mud hut. Sure you can now pay people to build you a nice house but you will be paying much more due to the lack of infrastructure. When your plumbing breaks it takes 6mo for someone to come fix it. Still you probably have lots of money. But now you have a visibly nice house. In other words a target in a poor area that is likely crime prone. Now you need to hire security. As expenses pile up it becomes just like in the US where people making $500k+ complain about barely being able to afford their life. I guess I'm just saying I'm still not worried about India salaries being the magic bullet that companies need to kill high tech salaries.
- alephnerd 3y ago> a number of Indian people that have moved to the US that say they will never go back to India Yep! My parents and I are the same. The QoL in even a 3rd tier cow town in the US will be better than an economically vibrant city in India or China. Having clean tap water is (imo) the pinnacle of a developed country. > things. If all your village has is mud huts you are still living in a mud hut True, but most Indian villages aren't like that anymore. They have all fairly developed now with electricity, WiFi, decent schools, etc. Go use Google street view - Indian villages may seem messy by Western standards, but they've gotten much better now. If you're someone who lived in small town or village India your whole life, and go to college to get a good job, if you have the option to earn a big city salary in your small town while being close to your family can be hard to beat. It's the same reason you see plenty of Techies take remote jobs and live near their families in the Midwest.
- kburman 3y ago> They've also begun heavily pivoting hiring for dev roles to India now as well. I have cousins who attended no name universities in India getting SWE roles in Amazon - something that was unimaginable 5 years ago - and expanding Dev offices to lower CoL cities like Hyderabad while slowly pivoting away from Bangalore. Amazon always had a policy to not judge candidate based on their universities. It's not new. > expanding Dev offices to lower CoL cities like Hyderabad while slowly pivoting away from Bangalore. Please don't call hyd low CoL if you don't know about it. > Also, the Indian branches are fairly remote work friendly 3 days from office like all the other office. > Now you have people earning $20-40k/yr living in their ancestral towns and villages where median incomes might be $3-5k Covid time is long gone.
- alephnerd 3y ago> hyd low CoL Lower than Bangalore or Gurgaon. It's easier to operate a tech company from HYD financially than in Haryana or Karnataka. > Covid time is long gone Well, tell that to my cousins who are still working remotely in tech from their ancestral villages in Himachal/Jammu/Punjab.
- kburman 3y ago> Well, tell that to my cousins who are still working remotely in tech from their ancestral villages in Himachal/Jammu/Punjab. What I can say is that there is no special treatment for SDEs working from India, especially regarding the WFH policy.
- alephnerd 3y agoOh, you're talking solely about Amazon. Ok fair.
- pylua 3y agoThe U.S. government should be concerned. The U.S. tax base could very well implode with outsourcing, ai, and offshoring in the next 10 years.
- alephnerd 3y agoThis is why you encourage immigration. If you prevent talent from coming to the US, companies will follow the talent. This is why American cybersecurity and networking has almost entirely been outsourced to Israel and India and chip manufacturing to Taiwan and South Korea.
- pylua 3y agoI do not understand how we got to this point. India is not in the U.S. sphere of influence and has not even voted to condemn Russia. It’s really a sign of how weak the U.S. government has become, which is heartbreaking. US has found it too expensive to invest in its own citizens. It’s almost a ticking time bomb.
- alephnerd 3y ago> India is not in the U.S. sphere of influence Financing the Abraham Accords [0], using American engines in tanks [1], American fighter jet engines in Indian fighter jets [2], and being a part of 2 bilateral treaty organizations [3][4] absolutely puts India in the US Sphere of Influence. > has not even voted to condemn Russia India will never piss off Russia, because India doesn't want Russia to join the Chinese camp [5]. By keeping trade and defense ties with Russia, India minimizes the chances of Russia becoming pro-China instead of neutral during an India-China war (which almost happened in 2020) [6]. Mistreatment of Indian students in Ukraine during the war made a vote in favor of Ukraine politically untenable during election season [7] [0] - https://www.axios.com/2023/09/07/saudi-india-uae-us-railway-deal-g20-middle-east https://www.axios.com/2023/09/07/saudi-india-uae-us-railway-... [1] - https://www.thehindubusinessline.com/economy/logistics/americas-cummins-engine-to-power-zorawar-tank-after-germany-fails-to-relax-trade-restrictions/article67544664.ece https://www.thehindubusinessline.com/economy/logistics/ameri... [2] - https://www.reuters.com/business/aerospace-defense/why-ge-plan-make-fighter-jet-engines-india-is-big-deal-2023-06-22/ https://www.reuters.com/business/aerospace-defense/why-ge-pl... [3] - https://www.state.gov/i2u2/ https://www.state.gov/i2u2/ [4] - https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefing-room/statements-releases/2021/03/12/quad-leaders-joint-statement-the-spirit-of-the-quad/ https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefing-room/statements-releases... [5] - https://carnegieendowment.org/2023/11/06/india-in-emerging-world-order-pub-90928 https://carnegieendowment.org/2023/11/06/india-in-emerging-w... [6] - https://theprint.in/defence/nearing-breaking-point-gen-naravane-recalls-how-india-china-were-at-brink-of-war-in-aug-2020/1892648/ https://theprint.in/defence/nearing-breaking-point-gen-narav... [7] - https://www.tribuneindia.com/news/punjab/ukraine-crisis-stranded-students-face-racial-abuse-373916 https://www.tribuneindia.com/news/punjab/ukraine-crisis-stra...
- pylua 3y agoThe only issue I have with that is that they will not allow us citizens to live there and take on jobs. If it truly were free trade then we could choose to live there and accept a lesser salary. Eventually offshoring to South America will probably hurt India as that is poised to expand and has overlapping timezones.
- paxys 3y agoWho says you can't do that? They would be thrilled to have silicon valley (or equivalent) talent working for India salaries.
- pylua 3y agoI doubt India government would grant a business visa for that. They don’t want other countries citizens competing for jobs in their own country, which is effectively what is happening in the us now.
- alephnerd 3y agoThey do, and plenty of Westerners (Indian origin and non-Indian origin) return to India to work for Indian companies, found their own companies, or manage American operations. Though, IME, it tends to be Japanese, Israeli, Singaporean, and Korean expats who can hack it in India. Western European and Americans are too soft.
- pylua 3y agoI have not seen it happen in a permanent way. I doubt a visa for generic remote based web dev work would get approved. In fact, I believe the visa even states you have to have a skill that is not readily available in India. The reality is your generic dev would probably not qualify especially if they are outside of a company.
- Hypocritelefty 3y ago[dead]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- drubio 3y agoSame hiring dynamic in Mexico. They started hiring heavily for various roles in the country's 3 major metro cities. Senior engineering roles going for $60K/yr USD. Amazon, the retail side, has been operating in the country for years, but the hiring spree that started this summer 2023' has been for positions in Music, AWS, Devices and Real Estate.
- alephnerd 3y agoI heard about that. A good buddy of mine who attended UT ended up moving to CDMX to work remotely for Reddit. He's earning around $70k which is honestly pretty great.
- drubio 3y agoIf he's single, $70k for CDMX (Mty or Gdl, the other two metro cities) it can work, if he wants to raise a middle-class family not so much. Rents are $1.5-2K/month in nice neighborhoods (buy range $250K up); taxes are high with a 16% VAT across the board, income taxes are high as well for this bracket; and don't get me started with schools, cars, insurance and the like. Yeah probably half the population would 'kill' for a $70k job, but they want English fluent, highly-educated, middle-class people, cherry on top, with top notch tech skills. Those candidates either want, U.S. SDE level packages or can make more with run of the mill no-name companies remotely. I still don't know anyone who has worked for U.S. level pay as a FTE or contractor, take a position with a subsidiary office in Mexico, the salary discrepancy is too great.