9 ms·
Brexit has failed for UK, say clear majority of Britons – poll
- quickthrowman 3y agoEverybody saw this coming, even (especially?) the people who were campaigning for Brexit. The UK had negotiated itself all sorts of special perks as an EU member (keeping the pound, etc), and decided to throw it all away because..? Possibly the only ones who didn’t see it coming are the people who voted for Brexit. I’m sure the North is just booming after Brexit /s David Cameron’s legacy is Brexit and that thing with the pig. It’s what he deserves.
- isoprophlex 3y agoThus proving (again) that there are very real limits to democracy in current western societies; that democracy is not hardened against populist demagogues... All the possible fixes i can think of aren't really palatable: mandatory critical thinking training for voters (not egalitarian), strict long term accountability measures for politicians (chilling effect; can be weaponized by opponents)... Ugh.
- quickthrowman 3y agoI agree that populism is a threat to democracy and also that the obvious potential solutions are less than ideal. It’s a tough problem, and one I worry about in the United States. It’s hard to convince people that are pissed off about their lot in life that the person telling them they can fix all of their problems if they were only elected may not have their best interests in mind, or that their ‘solutions’ are not at all practical, or that they’re just interested in power and don’t plan to fix anything. I guess I just don’t understand how anyone gets emotionally invested in a politician.
- Whoppertime 3y agoHow can you say Populism is a threat to Democracy. It's like saying the biggest threat to democracy is voters. It's unelected unaccountable "experts" who remain in their jobs regardless of who is elected that is a threat to democracy. The so called Deep State
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jacquesm 3y agoIt's a real problem. I'm from NL where we just voted one of the worst assholes in dutch politics to the top spot, and I'm still in partial denial about it. "never again"... unless of course we do it again. The harder problem is what to do about it? Democracy doesn't guarantee 'good outcomes' it only guarantees 'somewhat supported outcomes'.
- TomK32 3y agoTo be fair, Top Spot in The Netherlands is only 23.5% and there isn't a new government yet. Does the average Nederlander know what bloc each of those 15 parties in the parliament belong to?
- jacquesm 3y ago'only'???
- isoprophlex 3y agoI'm Dutch too. It's been pretty wild, yeah.
- jdiez17 3y agoI think "mandatory critical thinking training for voters" is the only actual long term solution. I would generalize it as "better education".
- Whoppertime 3y agoCritical thinking about what issues? The cost and benefits of EU Membership? The cost and benefits of fighting climate change? The cost and benefits of fighting Russia, and fueling a proxy war that is effectively a bloodletting exercise for both sides and a chance for advanced militaries to test new hardware and tactics not unlike the Spanish Civil War?
- Tiktaalik 3y agoThe problem here was that in this case the UK abandoned representative democracy for direct democracy (a referendum) which instantly gets out of control as opportunists take it over and layer lie after lie in order to get the outcome they want. Being here in Canada I've been through a number of referendums and I've never seen one that wasn't instantly hijacked by insincere interests and the objectives twisted with utterly disingenuous arguments. In a democracy Referendums should be avoided at all costs.
- dfawcus 3y agoWe did not negotiate perks, we simply refused to move from our existing conditions when new treaties were negotiated. i.e. we stayed with something close to our entry conditions, accepted some changes from new treaties. So the "opt outs" were really declining to "opt in" to new treaty terms. Any new entrant to the EU has to accept the whole Acquis as it is at the time. So if the EU would have us again, we'd be in the same position as the most recent entrant, plus all of the changes which have happened since.
- woodruffw 3y agoNo particular surprise there, although 2000 Britons also seems like a pretty small sample size. A question for the Britons on HN: have you perceived any discernible benefits to Brexit? My outsider’s (American) perception is that it has been pretty uniformly negative.
- throwup238 3y agoAfter 13 years of austerity the 2010s are a lost decade for the Uk and Brexit is just the cherry on top of a shit sundae.
- switchers 3y agoThere are basically no benefits unless you are very very rich and knew what was coming far enough in advance for some convoluted disaster capitalism. Most reasonable non thick people were either against it to start with, or have since realised they've been misled.
- drxzcl 3y agoIf you plug in the numbers into a sample size calculator you will find that a sample size of 2000 enables you to get an estimate within 5% of the true value 99.999% of the time for an infinite population. So, not exactly small, no. https://www.calculator.net/sample-size-calculator.html https://www.calculator.net/sample-size-calculator.html
- midasuni 3y agoAs long as you have a decent sample set, which the reputable polling companies do.
- drxzcl 3y agoAnd as long as the thing you are polling is about 50:50. It’s hard to poll more skewed things, and you need larger sample sizes.
- zh3 3y agoAs long as the sample is representative, of course. 2000 does seem small enough that it would be hard to ensure no bias creeps in.
- andrewstuart 3y agoI’ve generally found ex girlfriends don’t want you back after you dumped her. I suspect this will also be true for the UK and Europe.
- ceejayoz 3y agoYeah. They’re not getting to keep the pound next time around.
- andrewstuart 3y agoKeeping the pound showed it was never going to work. Nothing says ‘commitment’ like “Sure let’s get married but I want separate bank accounts”.
- pokepim 3y ago[dead]
- cycomanic 3y agoWhile the UK had plenty of exceptions keeping the currency is not really the most telling IMO. Look at Sweden and Denmark, they both didn't join the currency union (is that the correct English term?), but sentiments are strongly pro EU in both countries. From the outside it always looked like British politicians used the EU as a convenient scapegoat much strongly than in most other EU countries which caused much of the population to have strong negative opinions. I think in many of the other EU countries this tactic has died down significantly at least within the major parties.
- midasuni 3y agoU.K. will simply never meet the euro criteria - just like Sweden doesn’t. I’d love the U.K. to join schengen though.
- PaulDavisThe1st 3y agoThat many-thousand-miles of coastline thing will make Schengen tricky.
- biglyburrito 3y agoBritons keep voting against their own best interests & expect anyone to sympathize. FFS look at who they voted for as their last four prime ministers!
- mjburgess 3y agoThe UK does not vote for prime ministers; none are elected. Voting regions vote for MPs, and MPs collectively choose their leader. A large part of why the last leaders of both major parties have been populists, out of keeping with UK history, is because parties let their own private memberships play significant roles in choosing their leader -- this has handed the choice of PM from directly elected MPs to profoundly unelected party members. The only reason the current PM is sane is because the ruling party decided to ignore the members this time, having seen how basically incompetent their members have become.
- bantunes 3y agoYou don't vote for a PM in the UK - you vote for a party, that is free to change their PM while in power.
- midasuni 3y agoNo. You vote in a representative who may wear a rosette at a time but has no obligation to stay wearing that rosette.
- Invictus0 3y agoPlenty of people sympathize with the Palestinians even after they voted for Hamas
- midasuni 3y agoVast majority of Gaza residents have never had the chance to vote for anyone. The last elections were 2006, vast majority are under aged 35 and thus too young to vote in 2006.
- xyst 3y agoUK should just rejoin the EU. Wonder what that will take? Another referendum or vote within UK? Then EU needs to accept their membership again?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- quickthrowman 3y agoThe UK has zero leverage and I doubt they would be willing to accept what the EU would offer. The EU holds all the cards in this game.
- rich_sasha 3y agoTo expand on it, UK had some special riders on the EU deal. Without arguing about whether they were fair, I guess these would be out, and EU membership would be less attractive. But more attractive still than the current mess, if you ask me!
- tim333 3y agoMy guess is we won't actually rejoin but the coming Labour government will undo some of the more stupid brexit changes.
- avmich 3y agoUK should join, and should join on equal conditions with other countries. It's not only rather silly to talk about Europe leaving UK outside; it's also beneficial for positions in talks with other countries and for less economical barriers inside EU. The benefits of Brexit may not be realized yet - so opponents of joining EU may have some arguments - but so could be said about drawbacks, and general agreement is that unions are more successful. When it should join? If today both EU and UK are cold enough about joining, it shouldn't be forced. However, in the long run it looks rather like inevitability. EU should and I think will have interest in UK joining them. UK should also have an opportunity to improve EU as part of the joining talks, which both make UK joining easier and EU stronger in the long run. One of the biggest complaints about EU - not even only in UK, but in EU itself - is the bureaucracy in Brussels. It's a complex problem, but UK-EU crisis seems like a great opportunity to improve the situation. Information transparency on all levels - with laws and law applications clearly visible to all the population, law clarification itself, all efforts to bring that "common sense" the lack of which is so disliked by people - all of that could be in the package for UK to join EU on a better terms for everybody.
- yawboakye 3y agoi’d disagree here solely because whether brexit has failed or not is empirically measurable. we don’t have to defer to public/majority opinion for whom what ‘failure’ represents might be different from one person to the other. so let’s see some data that strongly suggests that brexit has and continues to fail. disclaimer: i’m not british and so whether brexit succeeds or not isn’t in my interest. but i’d like to read/study better report than an opinion poll as i strongly believe that failure or success here is scientifically determinable.
- hardlianotion 3y agoI'd like to see these measures too, and particularly measures that compare UK against similar countries in the EU.
- manojlds 3y agoWhat are these? Last I saw, UK economy is projected to do better than EU
- jacquesm 3y agoA bunch of small fish got a bunch of even smaller fish to vote to reduce the size of the pond so they could all look so much bigger.
- MichaelAza 3y ago> [Britons beleave Brexit] has hampered government attempts to control immigration I'm not very well versed in UK politics but what's the narrative behind this? In what way do Britons believe Brexit has made controlling immigration harder? While the ways it has hurt trade and the economy in general are obvious to me (both on the factual level and what I presume Britons believe) I have a hard time imagining what they could possibly think on this subject.
- rich_sasha 3y agoA lot of Brexit politics was about immigration: how EU rules mean you cannot bar any European from entering and reading, except in extreme circumstances. And indeed, UK is much more international than many European peers. But what happened post-Brexit is that (legal) immigration numbers are at all time high. There is a high fraction of low skilled immigrants from outside EU, often with questionable English and, well, looking different - which matters to some people. My point isn't to disparage hard working people, but that it's very visible. So that's a major Brexit pledge gone completely awry. I don't think there is anything Brexit-related that made migration control objectively harder, only that the control failed. Although what also happened, not unrelated, is that high-skilled immigrants from EU largely left, because post-Brexit UK is not very attractive to Europeans. This is very perceptible especially in health care, where shortages of doctors and nurses are now quite scary. And the immigration is so high in then because UK has always had labour shortages, patched by foreigners. It's only the country of origin that changed.
- rebuilder 3y agoSo basically Polish workers stopped coming because it was harder thanks to Brexit, and had to be replaced by less-white people?
- rich_sasha 3y agoKinda. Also Spanish nurses and doctors left, too. And immigration, of people of any colour, is at all time high.
- highwaylights 3y agoTo be fair, this is the Guardian reporting on their own (by way of The Observer) poll. Further down the article you can piece together most people seem to have given “I don’t know” answers given the low numbers for both answers on Boolean questions. I wouldn’t take this seriously as representative of the population at large. That said, and more concerningly, you could also find that most Brexiteers might agree with this poll entirely and would still do it all over again “to teach Brussels a lesson” whatever they think that means.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- benzible 3y agoDo you have a reason to doubt their methodology? Pollsters working for news organizations with an editorial point of view still produce accurate poll. In the US, Fox News, which I think can be fairly characterized as an arm of the Republican Party, produces high quality polls that are not reflective of their overall orientation.
- mike_hearn 3y agoUnfortunately yes, there are lots of reasons to doubt. Some UK polling firms routinely return results that are clearly impossible, are called out on it publicly, but don't investigate or fix anything. The root causes of their unreliability are known but not well understood outside the polling industry itself. A good example of that happening recently was with a poll commissioned by the BBC from Savanta via Kings College London. Savanta is a member of the British Polling Council, and the poll supposedly canvassed people about misinformation related topics. The results claimed several things so absurd and implausible that once people noticed, Kings College London attempted to backtrack [1]. The results were very obviously indefensible garbage. Amongst other things, if you assumed the poll was representative you'd be required to believe that: • 15% of British people get "a great deal" or "a fair amount" of their information from Truth Social. • A quarter say COVID was a hoax. • Around 3.7 million people in the UK had attended protests about COVID and central bank digital currencies and "15 minute cities". No protests of any such size have been seen anywhere, needless to say. • Around 7.4 million people had heard of an obscure hobbyist conspiracy newspaper called The Light, and half of all the people who had heard of it had helped distribute it. In reality The Light has a tiny number of subscribers. The poll itself is clearly misinformation. Ironically, it was commissioned for the BBC's "Marianna in Conspiracyland" which promoted the poll relentlessly; the BBC has never accepted that the poll's results are nonsensical and simply ignored the problems. The Guardian also jumped all over it [2] without subjecting the results to even basic reality checks. The actual meaning of these results is that Savanta's panel has become extremely unrepresentative and the company is simply ignoring this problem. This is a problem that has been affecting all panel-polling companies and it's been getting worse with time, albeit Savanta seems to be truly hosed to an extent that maybe YouGov isn't (yet). Panels are deeply unrepresentative, in particular with time they become deeply skewed towards women and people who volunteer for things (for obvious reasons). They attempt to weight the results to make them more realistic, but the models are calibrated only for elections and other moments when they can get ground truth. Ask non-election related questions and you will routinely get absurd results that don't reflect the actual views of the population. The polling industry is in deep trouble as panels degrade over time (the rewards for taking part are meaningless), but are currently able to ignore it because people generally accept their results as gospel. There's Advanced Math™ involved so it must be correct, right? Still, I think eventually people will get more savvy about this. I certainly wouldn't take any poll promoted by the Guardian at face value given their disinterest in checking the results. [1] https://www.kcl.ac.uk/news/conspiracy-theory-research https://www.kcl.ac.uk/news/conspiracy-theory-research [2] https://www.theguardian.com/society/2023/jun/13/quarter-in-uk-believe-covid-was-a-hoax-poll-on-conspiracy-theories-finds https://www.theguardian.com/society/2023/jun/13/quarter-in-u...
- ReptileMan 3y agoBecause the Britons got betrayed on the biggest issue - immigration. The powers that be just replaced the immigrants with different kinds. It seems that there is nothing the native population of a western country can do to stem the inflow of foreigners even when the ruling people have clear mandate - like in Italy and UK.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- midasuni 3y agoPeople voted brexit to stop non European immigration — specifically Muslim immigration. “ The movement of people in Europe fair enough. But not from Africa, Syria, Iraq, everywhere else, it's all wrong” https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/worldviews/wp/2016/06/27/this-video-shows-what-some-brexit-supporters-are-fearful-of-muslim-immigration/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/worldviews/wp/2016/06/27...
- PaulDavisThe1st 3y ago> People voted brexit to stop non European immigration Well then they are pretty fucking stupid.
- midasuni 3y agoYes. You’ll also notice correlation between brexit voting and educational achievement, one with income, and interestingly one with prevalence of leaded petrol during formative years (which is linked to age) Weigh brexit vote by tax paid per year, lifetime tax paid, or years having to live with the consequences, by educational attainment, and you get a remain landslide.
- Whoppertime 3y agoWhy didn't Theresa May implement that policy if that's what people were voting for? Sounds like pretty fucking stupid leadership to me
- bogtog 3y agoLooking at the list of specific points, it really just seems like most people voted “bad impact” down the line, even for things like “the NHS” and “control over immigration.” I’m not British, but surely for these it would be more accurate to say “no impact” or so?
- sp332 3y agoRecruiting staff for the NHS is a lot harder now.
- philk10 3y agoOne of the main Brexit promises was "“we send the EU £350 million a week – let's fund our NHS instead” - was a lie, was never going to happen and the NHS has got worse
- ben_w 3y agoPeople pointed out at the time that the UK literally never gave 350 million a week to the EU in the first place, and that a significant fraction of the much smaller amount of money that it did give to the EU was spend on projects in the UK anyway. Given the discussions at the time, I think this changed nobody's mind.
- acdha 3y agoYeah, I remember some of those threads here, back when the “libertarians” and right-wing UK posters weren’t quietly distancing themselves from it. It was very obvious that even people who sounded rational were confabulating excuses for what they were going to do anyway from the way they’d just smoothly pivot to something else whenever pushed for support on that figure.
- buserror 3y agoThis was a massive infowar against the whole country. There are tons of gullible people to 'convince' using their own prejudice, and there were quite a few people who saw it as a quick rise to power -- most of these people did very well with it as well! The goal was never in doubt really, and it was never the 'good of the country', or its people.
- mcphage 3y agoI’d blame the politicians, mostly… taking a <4% margin on a non-binding referendum as an excuse to self-immolate was entirely a decision by the people in charge.
- Whoppertime 3y agoSo how else should have they responded to the referendum and the people's will?
- sk11001 3y agoIt's not about the response after it happened, it's about whether you should set decades of foreign policy based on a single vote with a small margin.
- Whoppertime 3y agoThe 2000 Election between Bush and Gore was a single vote with a small margin that decided the course of middle east policy for the next 100 years 2016 and 2020 has Small margins and shaped a lot of important foreign policy 2024 seems like it may be more of the same
- sk11001 3y agoThe difference from the EU referendum is that there's a presidential election every 4 years and 2-term limit.
- 3y ago
- Tiktaalik 3y agoTo the last point, in a few days part of Canada and the UK’s special deal around cheese will expire and UK cheese will become more expensive and the UK’s quota will go to EU countries that will be able to export more to Canada. Overly beneficial trade deals are harder to come by for the UK than they thought because outside the EU they’re a minor market with little clout. https://nationalpost.com/news/canada/british-cheese-in-canada-more-expensive/wcm/e251360d-8d76-4a4b-8cc6-de42e60425e2/amp/ https://nationalpost.com/news/canada/british-cheese-in-canad...
- FridgeSeal 3y agoBrexit really is like the Robot Chicken skit with Darth Vader (“I have altered the deal, pray I do not alter it further” [1] every piece of news I hear about it involves things inevitably getting worse for the UK. The very personification of Lando’s “this deal is getting worse all the time”. 1: https://youtu.be/WpE_xMRiCLE https://youtu.be/WpE_xMRiCLE
- OscarCunningham 3y agoIt seems likely that a majority has been against Brexit before, during and after the vote. But that's democratically irrelevant since a lot of them chose not to vote.
- labrador 3y agoI have a theory that behind Brexit and since Brexit there has been an unconscious desire and actuality that Great Britain, The United States, Canada, Australia and New Zealand have merged into an new Anglo-American empire. From listening to Russian media, it seems they see it that way.
- manojlds 3y agoCheck sibling comment on Canada cheese trade.
- labrador 3y agoThis will change as the historically WASP English speaking countries become more integrated
- paxys 3y agoPerhaps it's time to stop listening to Russian media then.
- labrador 3y agoIt could be argued that the "deep state" in the U.S. and the U.K. are a closely knit team.
- tim333 3y agoThere was always a cultural link between the Anglo countries but leaving the EU hasn't actually helped much there.
- labrador 3y agoAs the American empire continues to decline as the British Empire has done, there will be increasing pressure to team up. I would go so far to say that Prince Harry in California is British Royalty establishing a new outpost in rising world power California (now the 5th largest economy by GDP, recently surpassing the UK)
- 3y ago
- blagie 3y agoWhenever I think of Brexit and Britain's imperial legacy, I think of Mechanical Orange. You know, in the end, where Alex's tormentors come back to torment him? I travel the world a lot, and a lot of people /really/ don't like England. Heck, even the Scots and especially the Irish have bones to pick with England. I can't imagine that doesn't translate into passive-aggressive policy on just about everything. UK, as part of the EU, was shielded from that. - On one hand, every policy was with Europe and not just the UK, so there wasn't any way to pick on the UK. - On the other hand, the EU was a major economic block, both as a market and as a source of technology. It has massive negotiating leverage. You can't really research this sort of thing, since China won't go out and say "Century of Humiliation" and "Opium Wars" in trade policy (at least much). India won't reference the "Eat the Meat" scene in the Gandhi movie, but it sets a lot of the national zeitgeist. Kenya probably won't talk about the Mao Mao rebellion. Ireland isn't going to talk about the potato famine or Bloody Sunday. I simply can't imagine those aren't in the back of everyone's minds as they talk to English diplomats. In terms of friends, they have a few, but not many (although a few, like the US, are disproportionately useful as friends). I think things will only get worse for the UK from here. That kind of broad-based deep-seated resentment is very rare in diplomacy. They'd be best off rejoining the EU. If they decide to do that, I think the EU will invite them back, but I really don't think they'll get the same kind of sweetheart deal this time around. I don't know if they will want that, or if they do, if they'll accept a less-than-sweetheart deal.
- alexchamberlain 3y agoI'm not passing an opinion on Brexit (that's rather dangerous as a Brit). I went to NZ back in 2019, and yes, we met a bunch of Kiwis and Aussis that didn't like the UK. (Now this could be a side effect of who we met/their age etc) What was interesting was that their dislike generally centred on the UK _joining_ the EU in the '70s, as we dramatically decreased trade via the old trade routes and they felt "abandoned". I haven't checked how true that is, but it was an interesting perspective that we weren't hearing from within the UK at the time.
- kcartlidge 3y agoI'm British, and agree with everything you said. We did what we did, so I understand (to the extent I am able to, not having lived it). All I would say in our defence (and I'm aware it isn't a great defence and certainly doesn't excuse it) is that: - That wasn't the current us, it was back then and I'd hope we were more enlightened now (despite the dross of our political machine). - Pretty much every nation at some time in their past has dealt terribly with others. We are in the position of being the most recent old-fashioned empire, whilst having had the technology (Industrial Revolution, coal, guns, ships) to scale our oppression. Most (all?) nations would have done the same thing if they'd got to that point of power first. I'm not my ancestors. I wouldn't choose the paths they did. But the above points are both true and also excuses, so to the extent that any current citizen is representative of their national history I apologise. As for the lack of sweetheart deals for re-joining the EU, again I agree but with the added comment that I think that's a good thing. Only by going all in could we ever truly be a part of the EU. As long as we demanded exclusion from, or preference in, so much we put our national interest first whilst ignoring the wider supranational interest that comes from a united whole. To be part of a union of equals we ought to go in as equals in the first place, thus forcing upon ourselves the incentives to do it properly and build a shared future.
- tycho-newman 3y agoThe voters of Britain made their choice and now they must deal with the consequences as best they can. Leaving the EU customs union was an own-goal when the EU is Britain's largest trading partner. There's too much money to be made in simplifying the customs rules, so that rollback is perhaps inevitable. The viability of the EU as a political union, though, remains to be seen. It is not clear that European politics will ever transcend nationalism. The last two world wars started in Europe for nationalist reasons. The third one probably will too. The challenges that face all of us cannot be solved by nation-states. We are already seeing EU nations grumble about supplying weapons to Ukraine to counter Russian aggression. The Ukrainians have shown themselves to be capable warfighters. The Russians have shown themselves to be consummate bullies. European politicians remain focused on narrow national interests in the face of Putin's imperialist plans. "It is not in our national interest to support Ukraine," says Orban. He will say that until Russian tanks are again on the streets of Budapest. Perhaps even after. The only time Europe was politically a unit was during the Roman empire, and that included large parts of North Africa. I don't see the EU expanding that far. Heck I don't see them admitting Turkey. All because European politics is still based on nationalist interests. It is here that Britain was perhaps wise to leave the EU. The EU is an insular club of developed nations that are socially liberal but ultimately inward-looking conservatives seeking to preserve a privileged status-quo. If the EU cannot innovate, it seeks to regulate - e.g. GDPR, and AI. Such a project fails to engage with the dynamic world and is doomed to failure.
- weatherlite 3y ago> Heck I don't see them admitting Turkey Should they? Why? Should the U.S create a union with Mexico?
- thriftwy 3y agoThey (EU countries) allowed Turkey to court them for a long time and get expensive treats then bailed out of it by ghosting Turkey. Do they have to admit Turkey? Hell no. Is it a sign of a good personality? Also no.
- 3y ago
- daxfohl 3y agoI can't say I know much about UK politics, but this seems like a nonsense poll. It's a generally down global economy. People will blame it on whatever poll you put in front of them. If it was a booming global economy, this poll could easily be reversed, even if Brexit has nothing to do with it.
- zeagle 3y agoI joke that the most elegant solution for this is if Scotland votes for independence, separates and joins the EU, the rest of the UK joins Scotland, nothing changes in terms of monarchy or government except titles but they backdoor their way into the EU, and everyone heads down to the pub for a pint to pretend this never happened.
- PaulDavisThe1st 3y agoIf the England/Wales version of the NHS is "taken over" by the Scottish one, that's almost certainly an improvement for everyone in England and Wales.
- midasuni 3y agoScottish NHS has more funding per head and worse outcomes https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-scotland-67828648 https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-scotland-67828648 Funding is still way below european levels though, always has been, the crisp is that the money is being spent on agency staff rather than employed ones, meaning not enough staff and a lot of rich people creaming a lot off the top Brexit is one key cause of that staff shortage.
- monkeydust 3y agoAs a Brit I can not associate a single positive outcome to us leaving the EU. Not saying one doesn't exist but to me, personally, I can't. Many probably feel this way so they blame all the big issues we have like prices and immigration on Brexit. Is there direct causation here? Not sure, maybe. Either way I suspect we will end up joining again just might take a decade or two. Edit: one positive this year was us becoming part of the Horizon programme. https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/detail/en/IP_23_6327 https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/detail/en/IP_23_...
- WediBlino 3y agoSlightly smaller wine bottles of course!
- FridgeSeal 3y agoFinally! Slightly smaller wine bottles! Just what the people were asking for!!! /s
- Whoppertime 3y agoWhat were you getting out of EU regulations? Rules on the curvature of Cucumbers and bananas passed by unelected unaccountable bureaucrats who do not represent your interests but that of the collective?
- WediBlino 3y agoHow elected is David Cameron again?
- monkeydust 3y agoNot at all. He's an unelected minister by virtue of being a made a life peer in the house of lords. He stopped being an elected MP a long time ago.
- ceejayoz 3y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Euromyth https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Euromyth
- mytailorisrich 3y agoLeaving aside the actual or claimed pros and cons of Brexit, I think it required to be bold and break from the status quo to at least have a real go at making it a success. Instead, it seems that the government decided to keep things as they were as much as possible, which is the sure route to failure.
- tim333 3y agoThey (Boris) tried to be bold but there are a lot of practicalities to deal with.
- Log_out_ 3y agoIt was the country rebelling against the city. And it didn't work out, but at least it showed everyone, who is the sovereign..
- jibbit 3y agoit still surprises me how badly understood brexit is outside of the uk (as most of the comments here demnostrate). it feels like failure to understand it is going to have consequences..
- Ekaros 3y agoWhat makes this whole thing even bigger mess is that part of the city wanted to recreate Britain like Singapore or Hong Kong. A ultra-liberal(economically) trading hub operating in multiple markets, extracting as much monetary value from global economy as possible... And looting Britain to boot...
- parpar 3y agoConnex question: as an EU national trying to relocate to the UK, has anyone been able to obtain Tier 2 visa sponsorship post-Brexit? What’s the market looking like for skilled European immigrants? Anyone willing to share their experience — either as a recruiter or recruitee?
- mrtksn 3y agoThe grand fallacy of Brexit was that only if they(far right and far left) can get rid of EU, they will be able to make UK a pure capitalist utopia or pure socialist utopia. For the far-left, EU was this neo-liberal globalist org that won't let them turn Communist and for the far-right EU was this socialist bunch that won't let them do their thing in the name of protecting human rights and the environment. The horseshoe phenomenon helps with gathering the numbers necessary to break something but it makes it impossible to build anything. The Tories, that turned far-right, found out that just because you won the elections and EU is no more it does't mean that you can drop all the laws, regulations, taxes and public services because the country still has leftist and centrists. The next elections the Labour will find out that just because you win the elections and the EU is no more, you can't just nationalise everything and expand the government because a significant portion of the population does want free market economy and low taxes. As a result, what Brexit did was only to complicate bureaucracy and reduce the talent pool by erecting barriers with their closest neighbours. No positives, only negatives. Anything positive that happened after Brexit could have been done within EU anyway. Why? For two reasons: either it's allowed within EU or you can change the EU law because you are the EU. Yep, that't the other tragic fallacy about EU: That EU is some 3rd party organisation that you subscribe and consume. In reality, EU is made of its members and the people in "Brussels" are not some Belgians cranking out laws and regulations but British among others and great deal of EU laws are actually made by the British themselves. It's simply mathematically impossible for UK to be better off outside the EU. It can be good for some, though.
- einpoklum 3y agoAh, a new poll... let me offer a proper British response: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ahgjEjJkZks https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ahgjEjJkZks and indeed, that bit is not without application to the story in the Guardian.
- MattPalmer1086 3y agoOld but still surprisingly relevant after all this time! I've just been rewatching all of them with my son.
- Nifty3929 3y agoFailed in what sense? The article leads with questions about improved personal finances and NHS - but were those things the goals of Brexit? Do voters feel like they'd be better off back in the EU, or would have been better off never leaving? Maybe they should ask the survey participants what THEY think the goals of Brexit were, and then whether they think Brexit has achieved them. I don't really know, as I don't live in the UK and didn't follow Brexit much except for a few headlines. My (low-knowledge) impression was that it was more about control, sovereignty, and chaffing under Brussels.
- tim333 3y agoThe Guardian who ran the article are kind of biased against Brexit. There never were really clear goals so it's dubious to say failed. But I think most people including leavers don't think it has gone very well. The story was a bit like: Farage and friends: The EU is rubbish, we should have a referendum on leaving. Tory govt: No Farage: I've set up a rival party, UKIP, to campaign for leave. If we don't have a referendum we'll split the Tory vote and Labour will win Tories: Ok have your damn referendum - you'll lose anyway Referendum: Do you want the current EU mediocrity or the sunshine and unicorns of an imaginary unspecified Brexit? People: voted slightly for the imaginary unicorns Reality: Everyone agrees the reality is a bit rubbish really. My personal take is the referendum should have been in a couple of stages. Like when you buy a house it's do you like that one? Yeah. Ok let's do a survey and look at making an offer. Not do you like that one? Yeah. Ok you're committed now for the next few decades, any second thoughts are a betrayal of the saying yeah.
- vinniepukh 3y agoNot too late to re-apply to join the EU.
- bluelightning2k 3y agoAs an Englishman I hate Brexit. I don't know many people who ever wanted it (it tends to be the older generation). There's two big things for me: 1. The debate on the BBC etc. focused on the economy, sovereignty, and immigration. Nobody even addressed diplomacy - that unity leads to peace and better relationships. 2. A lot of the coverage was on the personalities. Boris Johnson in particular. There was no equal calibre spokesperson for remain. Most people don't remember who was the face of remain. It's because David Cameron (the most natural spokesperson for remain at the time) didn't want the optics of a fractured Tory party. So it's incredibly unsurprising to me that most people regret Brexit. I think frankly this was true even the day after (remain was the presumed winner and a lot of people regretted not voting). One last point here: if the referendum was to stay, there would have been more referendums every few years. But it gets 51% or whatever it was and that's the final word on it? Absolute disaster.
- amadeuspagel 3y agoAny discussion of brexit inevitably illustrates why it happened in the first place.
- andrewstuart 3y agoThe absolute most batshit crazy thing about brexit is all it took was one simple 50% majority vote and the work of 50 years was undone. Surely there should have been something in place that meant it could only be undone progressively or required supermajority or best of three or something. Surely there was a better way to trial be separate but default back to being together. I don't know there must be other ideas. A simple 50% vote and out is way too fragile. And an off topic comment on democracy: Everyone should start with 100 votes and you lose one for each year you are alive. The older you are, the less say you should have in the future.
- Thuggery 3y agoThis has been a talking point pretty much from the day the Brexit vote happened. The usual suspects then repeatedly publish that same line in the usual papers (The Guardian for one) hoping to reify the "belief" into being with their domination of PR. Eventually a broken clock will be right. Regardless of the truth of this talking point though, its process of dissemination is unambiguously propaganda. Certain elites really want the public to believe this. Examples: https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/2018/12/11/does-britain-regret-brexit-crisis-confusion-leaves-country-even-more-divided/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/2018/12/11/does-britain... Half a decade ago https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2020/dec/31/the-guardian-view-of-brexit-a-tragic-national-error https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2020/dec/31/the-gu... https://www.businessinsider.com/yougov-poll-brexit-regret-remain-second-referendum-2019-2 https://www.businessinsider.com/yougov-poll-brexit-regret-re... Honestly just search Brexit in the News section of google and try to find a mainstream paper that has anything positive to say.
- simonblack 3y agoSeems most of the brexiteers had never heard of the concept of 'Economies of Scale'. I didn't and couldn't believe that the British would be so dumb as to cut themselves off from their main markets, and their main sources of imports. As events have followed my predictions, I can't help a certain sense of schadenfreude.
- yetanother12345 3y agoThis may be a stupid question, but there's England, Britain, Great Britain, The City, United Kingdom, and The Commonwealth, and whathavewe... All is somewhat related, some is (sometimes) part of something else, but nothing is quite the same it seems. It's not easy for a non-native to navigate what is what among this set of boxes-in-boxes ... > Brexit has failed for UK Did UK exit, or did Britain? is this the same thing, or did the article headline mess something up? --- That said, congrats to Britain/UK for leaving, and thanks for showing all of us remaining in the so-called "Union" that there is still hope, and a leave is indeed possible (at least as a last resort if things turn too distasteful). I for one is absolutely certain that it is too soon to analyze consequences at this early stage where there's still too much post-Brexit turbulence - also I feel confident that in ten year's time or so it will prove to have been beneficial for you (as a country) to leave. If you don't re-enter that is. At the very least you will still be a country (boxes-in-boxes, imperial measurements, left-side driving, pints, pubs, pounds, and all.)
- dfawcus 3y agoGreat Britain is an Island. England is one country and geographical region within that island. Wales and Scotland are the other countries within that island. Some of the surrounding islands are respectively part of the countries of England, Scotland and Wales. The UK is the state, the British state. It operates within Great Britain (and its surrounding islands), and part of the island of Ireland - i.e Northern Ireland. The meaning of Britain varies with context, sometimes it refers to the state (the UK), sometimes the island of Great Britain. The City is the square mile of London, a quasi city state which in some respects is not even part of the state (see the Norman Conquest of England), but that is usually ignored. The Commonwealth currently refers to parts of what were previously the British Empire. Officially, the UK exited, as the UK was the member. However, arrangements were made for Northern Ireland such that it sort of stayed within the Single Market (for Goods) and observes EU customs rules. Hence GB fully exited, NI exited, but has special arrangements such that many aspects of EU law still apply. The headline is trying to indicate that Brexit had detrimental effects, but only because the UK did succeed in leaving the EU. If it had not managed to leave, there would have been none of the complained of detrimental effects - i.e. the 'failure'.
- 3y ago
- shantnutiwari 3y agoThese constant “Britain sucks “ posts in HN are really starting to get on my nerves. And I say this as someone who opposed Brexit and votes against it. The guardian and their types have been saying “brexit failed” from the 1st day of brexit. It’s getting a bit tired. Yes we left the EU , can we move on now ?
- somewhereoutth 3y agoBrexit is an ongoing tragedy, the only way to stop the bleeding is to reverse it. So no, we can't move on until we rejoin.