8 ms·
Social media companies made $11B in US ad revenue from minors, study finds
- superduty 3y agoHow is that revenue different than the ad revenue TV networks make with the wall of toy commercials during morning cartoons?
- com2kid 3y agoI'll vouch and reply because I feel your comment may be in earnest. Historically, in the US, there have been strict limits on what ads are allowed around children's TV. There has to be a distinction between the TV show and the ads. For example kids TV shows in the US used to (not sure about now) have a very distinct break saying that the show was going to be back soon, indicating that what followed wasn't part of the show. There is also a difference in that 20 years ago, if a kid wanted to buy a toy, they had to see an ad on TV that happened to be for a toy they wanted and then convince their parent to go to the store and buy that toy. Now with targeted ads and IAP, kids are being targeted directly to buy shiny goods for games that they play. Cosmetic upgrades in the more "honest" games that bestow social status between peers, or gacha tokens in pay to win games to get needed items/characters to progress. (And some games combine the worst of both!) Targeting a child with an ad for a game they play gets insidious very quickly. "Hey Timmy, did you know all your friends are laughing behind your back because you don't have the latest and greatest armor upgrade? Better buy it now!"
- tmpz22 3y ago> Targeting a child with an ad for a game they play gets insidious very quickly. "Hey Timmy, did you know all your friends are laughing behind your back because you don't have the latest and greatest armor upgrade? Better buy it now!" Chime Chime Level up! Good job! Makes In-app-purchase Chime Chime Purchase completed
- droopyEyelids 3y agoOne nit, I think you mistyped about 'cosmetic upgrades' in pay to win games. Like you probably know, the games become impossibly difficult at a certain point, unless you start paying for tokens or whatever.
- broscillator 3y agoThose ads cannot cater their content and their timing towards your vulnerabilities based on behavior analytics, such as metadata indicating that you might be depressed, going through a breakup, etc. An app can shoot varied content at you and determine that if you view happy cat content, then enraging political discourse, then sexual stimulating content, and then and ad, you're more likely to click on the ad, or stare at it for longer, etc. Social media ads are essentially interactive, but their mechanics are hidden and there's no winning state for the player. And just to play with dark ideas: what exactly (besides technological limitations) would stop any of the big companies from basically running a long social experiment to determine whether, over years, you can shape a kid to become an adult that's a big consumer? An ad on TV has no information on who you are when you view it. An ad on SM has detailed information of who you were years ago, who you are now, and there's no reason why it can't make predictions about who you'll be based on the growing data. Nor is there a reason not to try to shape that to their benefit.
- jahewson 3y ago> An app can shoot varied content at you and determine that if you view happy cat content, then enraging political discourse, then sexual stimulating content, and then and ad, you're more likely to click on the ad, or stare at it for longer, etc. Yeah, no. Facebook ads are mostly pay per impression, not click, so there’s no reason to even do this. Ad targeting is controlled by advertisers for the most part, not algorithms - they want to target specific demographics, not some random cross-section of humanity. It’s very different from the kind of algorithms that power your news feed.
- broscillator 3y agoHuh? A demographic is a random cross-section of humanity. The only thing that matters is if the way you're determining the group yields more sales. The final goal is obviously a sale, but the real commodity is attention. I'm not saying "this is how it is", I'm saying "show my a reason why this is not the case now or where we're heading. Like, if FB could do this, and it yielded more money for them, what would stop them? You sound very convinced, so I'd be glad if you can go into detail as to what that conviction is founded on. Have you worked on these algorithms?
- hinkley 3y agoLike a lot of things, I expect the only difference is time and space. There are adult generations where large swaths don’t remember Saturday morning cartoons now. If you’re a millennial with tech savvy parents you may have grown up with streaming entertainment only. Though today ads can show up there as well, so maybe this will be another way where children and grandparents bond over things the parents don’t understand.
- jahewson 3y ago> If you’re a millennial with tech savvy parents you may have grown up with streaming entertainment only I agree, though the youngest millennials were already 11 when Netflix launched its streaming service. And that was just movies.
- lacrimacida 3y agoMinors probably respond best to ads since they’re not familiar with the deceiving paterns of advertising. However, im not sure how they make money as minors usually don’t have their own money, they’ll have to aks their parents. As a parent I am terrified of my children falling prey to all this kind of crap as I’ll have to pay in the end. For now Im shielding my children from advertising as much as I can and attempt to instill some common sense in them. This will not fully work at first as they’ll most likely cave in with their peer group but hopefully they’ll remember it later.
- com2kid 3y agoIn countries with disposable income, kids have been a huge market. Christmas comes every year, and so do birthdays, and the birthdays of friends. When I was a kid, Super Soakers printed money. Every kid wanted one, and the bigger the super soaker the cooler the kid. Does no one remember Tickle Me Elmo? Or Furby? Now days it may be roboblox gift cards, but the cash is still flowing.
- broscillator 3y agoI suspect the numbers (adjusted for inflation) are much different, but it would be interesting to see this backed up.
- jeffreygoesto 3y agoI do. "Jingle all the way" was hillarious and parodied that at that time.
- stickfigure 3y ago$11B is a small portion of total social media advertising revenue, so it probably doesn't work as well as you think.
- codingdave 3y agoIf I'm reading this correctly, they made this revenue by displaying ads to minor audiences. Not by directly collecting money from minors. Which makes this statistic interesting and worth attention and discussion... yet also no different than any other marketing that kids see.
- broscillator 3y agoWhich other kinds of marketing? An ad on TV or on the highway does not have the capability of taking into account the network of people you follow and whether you have a habit of being awake at 3AM browsing posts about break ups. There's a constant, gradual pervasive shift towards having ads in more private and intimate spaces.
- codingdave 3y agoFair point - I was saying that making revenue from minors is in no way unique to social media, but you are 100% correct that the depth of the placement points to different incentives to the marketing teams who create that revenue. Turning 18 doesn't magically make those concerns go away, either. If anything, my takeaway is that as parents, we need to teach our children to critically think about the marketing they see while they are still minors, to avoid raising adults who blindly accept anything put in front of them.
- jahewson 3y agoI guarantee you that Facebook does not have an audience of “people who stay up until 3am” available for advertisers to target.
- nonrandomstring 3y agoI see that as eleven billion dollars of damage done to the mental health of children.
- dvngnt_ 3y agoI don't. wouldn't the ad itself have to be harmful to mental health? maybe if it was for plastic surgery. or if Kim K did a sponsored post for diet tea
- hanniabu 3y agobrain rot
- nonrandomstring 3y ago> wouldn't the ad itself have to be harmful to mental health? No, the mere presence of the advertisement is sufficient harm to a person without capacity to understand the difference between what they need, what they want, and what other people want of them.
- dvngnt_ 3y agoI'm certainly against ads, but I'm not convinced that an ad is inherently damaging to mental health. seeing an ad for 5 gum probably won't harm a developing teen. seeing a celebrity live a lifestyle you will never have and look 'better' than you ever will might. though using revanced and the IG equivalent certainly is a QoL improvement, but I don't think my doctor will prescribe pihole to improve my mental health
- munk-a 3y agoAt this point I'm pretty convinced that ads are damaging to mental health (at least the ones we see today). Modern advertising normalizes consumerism, drives down our attention span, and overloads us with blinking lights and exciting sounds causing us to, IMO, existing in a much higher general state of stress than previous generations. I'm no mental health professional but I suspect this period of advertising will be looked back on in a similar way to leeching and leaded gasoline.
- hinkley 3y agoIt’s like nobody remembers Saturday morning cartoons.
- TehCorwiz 3y agoThe tv didn’t track your movement through stores and websites and our other online activities.
- hinkley 3y agoThey didn’t bother. They just carpet bombed everyone.
- bdcravens 3y agoOnly because it was technically impossible, not because they had good ethics.
- PH95VuimJjqBqy 3y agoand now that it's technically possible we need regulations to prevent it.
- duringmath 3y agoThey used census data to estimate the number of users under 18. This is just BS PR from probably the least reliable kind of researcher, the social science crowd.
- internetter 3y agoI'm shocked this number isn't higher. Are you telling me that only fraction (because not all of that 11B was made on facebook property) of facebook's 116.6 yearly income is from one of the most avid groups of social media users?
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> one of the most avid groups of social media users? Are they spending much?
- internetter 3y agoSocial media companies don't make much profit on selling stuff to users. They make profit on advertisements. If what you're saying is that younger folks see less advertisements because they buy less things, I can assure you that is not the case.
- 0xEF 3y agoAnecdotal, but my Gen Z and his friends abhor and avoid FB/IG like the plague. From my perspective, FB is rapidly losing the interests of the younger generations and increasingly looking like a right-wing retirement community. Do we have a reliable source of user data that shows the breakdown of each social media platform by age group?
- internetter 3y agoI agree FB is unused among GenZ, but in my anecdotal experience Instagram (and to a lesser extent, threads) continues to be relevant, alongside Snap and TikTok. Heck, let's run with TikTok for a second, ByteDance made 110 billion[0] this year. Does anybody use TikTok more than GenZ? [0]: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2023-12-20/tiktok-owner-bytedance-s-revenue-set-to-surpass-china-s-tencent-s-this-year https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2023-12-20/tiktok-ow... Edit: Also, IG seems more popular among girls, which could explain the opinion of your kid. I found an article from pew to corroborate this that also shows that IG is very much still relevant: https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2023/04/24/teens-and-social-media-key-findings-from-pew-research-center-surveys/ https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2023/04/24/teens-and...
- chopete3 3y agoI tried multiple ways (brave browser,paid youtube account,paid games etc.,) to prevent kids from ads online but it is hard. There are ads embedded in videos and links that take them to ad sites. I am now training them on how to recognize ads and scams faster. It is fun watch a 6 year old say all free Robux offers are ads and don't click on the link. All energy drinks are sugar water Caffeine is bad for health People who drink those are addicts If online exposure is hard from 5 years or above, there should be some level of ads education from 5 years itself.
- blfr 3y agoBetween uBlock in the browser, ReVanced apps[1] (YouTube, Twitter/X, TikTok), DNS ad filtering[2], and Spotify Premium, I don't see ads. It takes some effort but isn't that hard for an HN poster. Also, I'm quite skeptical of caffeine and aspartame being bad for health (in adults at least). [1] https://revanced.app/ https://revanced.app/ [2] https://mullvad.net/pl/help/dns-over-https-and-dns-over-tls#android https://mullvad.net/pl/help/dns-over-https-and-dns-over-tls#...
- google234123 3y agoSo why Spotify premium and not YT premium?
- stevenicr 3y agonot op - but I have been doing YT premium for about a month now, and find the music thing lacking immensely. If I wasn't doing 30 hours of training / learning each week with YT I would not pay for premium. Yet I have paid for premium https://DI.fm https://DI.fm for years and everyone tells me that spotify is really good at curation / playlists / discovering new stuff.. I could see if just using YT for random entertainment stuff not seeing real value in it overall - it could easily be replaced with videos hosted on FB or Insta or anywhere else basically for a lot of people.
- blfr 3y agoReVanced integrates SponsorBlock in addition to omitting regular ads and has some cool features like custom/definable playback speeds.
- bdcravens 3y agoIn related news, grocery stores still have candy in the checkout aisles.
- morkalork 3y agoI fall for this one more as an adult who's shopping while completely crashed and still needs to drive home and cook dinner.
- CM30 3y agoThis is sadly not too surprising; a quick glance at what does well on YouTube, Reddit, Twitter, etc will show that a high percentage of the userbase are probably under 13, and that percentage probably jumps even more when counting minors in general. Given that: 1. Many parents see giving their kids an iPad and access to a social media service as a way to keep them quiet 2. And pretty much every kid on the planet will lie about their age in order to sign up for whatever site or service they want I'm not sure there's a whole lot these services could do about it, and any attempt to fix this would probably make them even more privacy invasive and obnoxious than they already are.
- WalterBright 3y agoMy dad simply said "no" to all the stuff I wanted to buy as a kid. But I could buy it if I earned the money first. (No allowance) I'd have to wait for Christmas or birthday to get new toys. I suppose these days that would be considered child abuse :-/
- edmundsauto 3y ago> I suppose these days that would be considered child abuse :-/ I suppose you could find someone who believes this, but it sounds more like sour grapes and doesn’t add anything to the comment except an eye roll at an entire generation. We can all do better than throwaway comments like this one.
- WalterBright 3y agoSour grapes? My point was he was right. Having to work for the things I wanted was good for me. For example, to get a car I had to work to buy it, and all I could pay for was a clunker. Hence I learned a great deal about auto mechanics, which has paid off handsomely. For example, just today I drove my car after it returned from the shop after some major maintenance. I noticed it was spitting antifreeze out the bottom. Oh crud, the shop must have screwed up the hoses. Looking under the car, the outflow was coming from the radiator overflow hose. This is a normal thing if the radiator overflow tank was filled a bit too much - nothing to worry about. If I didn't know anything about cars, I would have wasted an afternoon taking it back to the shop.
- bnprks 3y agoReading the methodology of the underlying paper makes this estimate seem quite dubious. Quoting from the paper [1]: > Due to lack of data, we assumed that revenue per minute of platform use was constant by age. Surely ad rates targeting minors without disposable income are much lower than for age demographics with higher spending power. I'm happy to have an excuse to discuss our opinions on the ethics of social media use by minors, but I'd appreciate if the "science" was a little more forthright about what we know and don't know. In this case the paper seems to make a reasonable estimate of the fraction of total social media usage time spent by minors. But it's sloppy bordering on dishonest to extrapolate that to revenue numbers without looking at any data on ad pricing. [1]: https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0295337 https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0295337
- mkhpalm 3y agoI'm curious to see how much ad revenue is gained from impressions to those scam farms that plague what remains of Facebook's actual users. Typically preying on the elderly.