11 ms·
2023 was the year that GPUs stood still
- jadbox 3y agoWe need a lot more memory for desktop GPUs with the need to run AI locally for productivity and gaming. 48gb+ would be the minimum ideal for running 70b+ models. If Nvidia, AMD, and Intel fail to deliver more to desktop users, I can see a lot more people switching to Apple's M3 or later chips with 80-128gb shared memory. Similar to rewind.ai, I want a 100% offline AI with Vision to run on every file and image I touch. Every file I use can be categorized and available to prompt against.
- brookst 3y agoI really hope that one day I will run into someone involved in Apple Silicon design who will tell me whether UMA was chosen with post-graphics GPU needs like AI in mind.
- brucethemoose2 3y agoThe UMA itself actually isn't being used in AI, just the big memory pool for a GPU. Intel canceled, and AMD sidelined, big APUs because they found the market didn't want them.
- brookst 3y agoA 128GB MacBook can devote almost all of that memory to AI.
- zamadatix 3y agoI don't think you'll find anything in the desktop segment cracking beyond 48 GB in the next 5 years. That said, the M3s with that much shared memory are really in the workstation segment, and priced like it. Macs are actually a great value for this use case all the way up through maxing them out. The inference performance itself is a bit lacking though, but at least you can do it.
- brucethemoose2 3y agoThere's also the huge caveat of CUDA project compatibility. AMD/Intel seem to be a more promising in that regard, and thats not saying much. Not that it isn't appealing... If the price is right. Also, both AMD and Intel are both reportedly coming out with M Pro-like SoCs. AMD's "Strix Halo" is rumored for 2025. Less is known about Intel's Arrow Lake SKU at the moment.
- sangnoir 3y agoHow many people are writing their own CUDA kernels? I think Pytorch compatibility is a bigger win for AMD amd Intel, when solving for the vast majority of AI practitioners who live in Jupyter Notebooks
- brucethemoose2 3y agoI don't see the distinction. Tons of popular PyTorch projects run hand made CUDA kernels, whether through a library or one written themselves. In some cases one can replace rocm/openvino incompatible libraries with pure PyTorch, but the performance hit is often severe, and not many inference projects are using torch.compile or triton kernels to compensate.
- sangnoir 3y ago> I don't see the distinction Performant Pytorch compatibility can be achieved without CUDA compatibility. > In some cases one can replace rocm/openvino incompatible libraries with pure PyTorch This is the crux of my point: AMD ought to focus on fixing these Pytorch incompatibilities instead of splitting focus with chasing CUDA translations.
- Baldbvrhunter 3y agoGreater than zero. Julia has a CUDA compiling and I've hand crafted CUDA kernels myself. https://cuda.juliagpu.org/stable/ https://cuda.juliagpu.org/stable/
- jmnicolas 3y agoI don't think it represents a lot of people, Apple high end offering is absolutely unaffordable for most of us. If you can afford a max specced M3 you can also afford 2 RTX 4090 which should theoretically be faster.
- joshstrange 3y agoA max-specced M3 would give you 128GB of ram vs 48 total from the 2 RTX cards and you'll still need a computer (CPU/MB/RAM/case/fans/etc). They might even out in price but you have more ram with the M3 and a way lower power usage if you care about (I know some people don't), not to mention it's portable. If all you want to do is AI/ML then yes, a M3 is not your best option but if you want an extremely powerful laptop that can run AI models locally fairly easily (and it's well supported) then the M3 is a great choice. I love being able to download and test out AI models on my M3.
- Der_Einzige 3y agoApple is well supported in that it's "better than everyone except Nvidia", and that's really only because a bunch of well known boutique developers seem to like the high quality of apple laptops and refuse to budge about mainly developing on them. Still, trying to do significantly fun or interesting things in any major AI ecosystem, such as the Stable Diffusion one through Automatic1111 or with the LLMs in Oobabooga (which supports nearly all LLM backends i.e. llama.cpp), will be mostly crippled and stuff will break in ways that simply don't happen to Nvidia hardware. I'll take the 2 4090s all day, because I know that quantization techniques which shouldn't even be possible (who knows maybethe fabled 1 bit quantization seems inevitable at this point) will make it possible for me to stuff even the most bloated LLM into my measly 48 GBs will be available on Nvidia first and Apple (maybe) second.
- J_Shelby_J 3y agoI bring this up all the time and get downvoted by apple defenders (usually I’m one). Apples policy of locking out 3rd party gpus might be the cause of a serious decline in Mac OS over the next decade. That or devs will start building Linux hosts for their gpus at home.
- brucethemoose2 3y agoThat limitation is totally artificial. There is nothing stopping AMD from allowing the sale of an affordable 48GB 7900 (or 32GB 7800) right now... In fact they already do in the form of the W7900, for $4500. They just don't sell those at competitive consumer prices, as they are playing the anticompetitive artificial segmentation game right alongside Nvidia, because they somehow think their tiny workstation market is more valuable than seeding AI development on their cards. Technically speaking, AMD could sell "cheap" 96GB+ GPUs by simply swapping the 7000 series memory controller die. This would take some time and money, but not an eternity + fortune like Nvidia would need to tape out a whole new GPU die. Intel has no workstation market to lose. I suspect the Arc A770 was kinda late and skimpy for a 32GB "AI" SKU, but the next generation could be very interesting.
- gruez 3y ago>as they are playing the anticompetitive artificial segmentation game right alongside Nvidia Product segmentation might be anti-consumer (in the sense that they can charge higher prices overall), but it's hardly "anticompetitive". >than seeding AI development on their cards *ceding
- badsectoracula 3y agoI understood "seeding AI development on their cards" as in "making sure AI development in the future will happen on their cards". "ceding" sounds like the opposite of that (i.e. giving up).
- brucethemoose2 3y agoThe anti competitiveness is from the pricing in the face of competition. W7900 margins are enormous. In a competitive market, AMD would massively undercut the 48GB RTX A6000 and the 24GB 4090, which Nvidia is price gouging even more. They absolutely can... But they don't. Separately, its also (IMO) a bone headed business decision.
- Der_Einzige 3y agoYou have no idea how deep the Nvidia lock-in goes. AMD only supports small fractions of the deep custom eco-systems built around models such as Stable Diffusion. Good luck getting half of the shit built for ComfyUI or Automatic1111 to run at all, and frequently those features are the killer ones which motivate folks to want to do AI in the first place. There's a reason why Nvidia is a first class citizen among all of the AI clouds. AMD is even behind Intel in this regard, because at least Intel had an existing robust ecosystem of accelerators (i.e. intel optimized sklearn/pytorch, OpenVino, etc) AMD can be 4x better in every way compared to Nvidia hardware wise but if they can't get developer communities to build around their equivalent to CUDA and its ecosystem than it's not looking rosy for AMDs future.
- dleeftink 3y agoWouldn't we rather trend model memory requirements down? This way models/devices meet in the middle.
- brucethemoose2 3y agoThe thing about ML is that memory helps everything. Take almost any given model that fits in X memory pool for some task. Double that, and everything gets better. Training quality goes up, inference quality potentially goes up, you gain the capacity for more batching which dramatically increases performance. Maybe more caching, depending on the app. You can add more models to the pipeline without much fuss.
- eachro 3y agowhy is this? I would have thought that more memory would help up to some point (wherever the entire model can fit in RAM) and then no gains after that. I'd also have thought that things like accuracy wouldnt be affected.
- brucethemoose2 3y agoEvery model and ecosystem has different compromises, and obviously small models hit diminishing returns quick. But the big models that are in fashion now... GPUs are basically always memory capacity limited to some extent.
- daemonologist 3y agoAgreed, and VRAM (GDDR6 at least) is _not_ that expensive. The going rate for an 8 Gbit chip is around $3 [0][1], so around $150 in raw chips for 48 GB. Unfortunately I suspect VRAM capacities in consumer cards will continue to be limited in order to differentiate enterprise products. [0] https://www.dramexchange.com/ https://www.dramexchange.com/ [1] https://www.tomshardware.com/news/gddr6-vram-prices-plummet https://www.tomshardware.com/news/gddr6-vram-prices-plummet
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- gruez 3y ago> The going rate for an 8 Gbit chip is around $3 [0][1], so around $150 in raw chips for 48 GB. I doubt 48GB cards are using 8 Gbit chips. How are you going to physically route 48 chips on a PCB?
- schmorptron 3y agoWouldn't you also need other higher-end components to interface with and support higher bandwidth to effectively make use of all of that VRAM?
- to11mtm 3y agoYes. Realistically you'd just go with higher density RAM chips, which I'm guessing are gonna be more costly per GB as well... But the upshot for a manufacturer for higher density memory, if the 'failure rate' of fresh parts is the same, well it's better to have less parts of a fixed failure rate ofc.
- ksec 3y agoIt wasn't that long ago the price for GDDR6 was up to $16, your 48GB would have cost $800. Or roughly $2000 more in retail price. What a lot of people dont understand is that RSP dont change with commodities ups and downs. If you price your product $1500 cheaper now due to DRAM cost reduciton, you will have a hard time getting it back up $1500 if things ever resume to normal. So generally speaking RSP comes down very slowly.
- staticman2 3y agoThe Apple M3 chips are expensive, not so great at gaming, and have significantly slower memory bandwidth than Nvidia chips. (A 3080 has 912 GB/s vs M3's Max being 400 GB/s with most M3 models being much slower). There are significant compromises in Apple's offerings.
- jadbox 3y agoThanks, I should have mentioned this. Lots of tradeoffs here and Apple is far from ideal. I really want a desktop equivalent of an A100 with 80gb, although $17k is just insane*. https://www.cdw.com/product/pny-nvidia-a100-80gb-pcie-gen-4-graphic-card/7065275 https://www.cdw.com/product/pny-nvidia-a100-80gb-pcie-gen-4-...
- iknowstuff 3y agoI guess you could get an M2 Ultra with 800GB/s if you care about this metric specifically?
- timschmidt 3y agoEven so, bandwidth to the CPUs, GPUs, and NPUs are segmented such that none have access to the full 800GB/s. The CPU gets more like 400GB/s in that SKU.
- iknowstuff 3y agoCorrect me if I'm wrong but 400GB/s is ludicrous for CPU memory isn't it? > DDR5 octuples the maximum DIMM capacity from 64 GB to 512 GB.[8][3] DDR5 also has higher frequencies than DDR4, up to 8000 MT/s which translates into 64 GB/s (8000 MT/s * 64-bit width / 8 bits/byte = 64 GB/s) of bandwidth per DIMM.
- timschmidt 3y agoDepends. DDR5 provides less bandwidth than Apple's on-package DRAM precisely because it allows larger sizes and user upgradeability. Intel has produced similarly packaged CPUs since https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xeon_Phi https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xeon_Phi in 2010, at least. A small amount of very fast memory is great so long as your workload fits within it. The moment it doesn't, everything goes awry. The best memory architecture is always the one which works for your workload. AMD produced a desktop part - the 7800X3D - which provides 2.5TB/s of bandwidth to 96Mb of L3. And an Epyc part with 768mb of L3 in a similar configuration across 8 chiplets. Then there are issues of prefetching algorithms, cache eviction and concurrency strategies as well as speed and associativity, TLB size, branch prediction algorithm especially as it relates to pipeline length and flushes, decoder width and complexity and execution units available for dispatch. There's just a lot more that goes into fast than memory bandwidth go brrrrr. Also x86 (and increasingly ARM and Risc-V) have many SKUs above those Apple offers in sleek packaging. Particularly silicon fabbed for high end desktop workstation or datacenter duty is a cut above what's available via other channels. For the cost of a Mac Pro you can easily afford an HP Z series or a whitebox from SuperMicro with dual sockets, 16 channels of DRAM, and enough PCIe lanes to make starving children cry.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ore0s 3y agoJust curious, why is rewind.ai falling short of this use case? I thought they looked at every file/photo
- pants2 3y agoApple's memory configurations for the M3 are confusing and expensive. Charging $400 for an additional 18GB of RAM is ridiculous. If they halved their memory upgrade prices maybe I would consider it, but as-is it's very hard to justify getting memory upgrades when you could just run LLMs on a dedicated Linux box.
- thedaly 3y agoPrices haven't come down though.
- bigmattystyles 3y agoEven adjusted for inflation? If they stayed put then they kinda did.
- nullindividual 3y agoThey never have. A top of the line Voodoo2 would be $535 today, only $235 more than the retail price in 1998.
- bigmattystyles 3y agoOh I meant over the last 2 years. But your point stands.
- jakeinspace 3y agoWhy should a top-of-the-line GPU cost similarly? GPUs in the late 90s were designed by tiny teams, with hardly anything spent on drivers, using fabrication processes which are like paper and glue compared to today’s TSMC processes. Just because an RTX 4090 is also top-of-the-line doesn’t mean there’s an equivalency between it and a Voodoo2, because the effort required is exponentially higher. In 1910, the most expensive comercially available passenger automobile in the US was arguably produced by Lozier, and would be around $250k today inflation-adjusted. But these days, super cars and hyper cars can go well into the millions of dollars. There is no sense comparing the top 1910 automobile market segment to the top segment in 2023. Likewise, the 1998 GPU market just does not map to that of 2023.
- pie420 3y agoActually, those million dollar cars aren't really cars, they're collectibles. the real top of the line cars today are probably either a Porsche GT2 RS, an Aventador SVJ, or Cullinan if you only want comfort. And all of those only run about $300k-$500k
- callroomlamp 3y agoThe most difficult trend in GPUs is the lack of midrange and low range affordable GPUs. This hurts the most
- zamadatix 3y agoOf the latest generation Intel has a model you can grab new for $99, AMD $270, and Nvidia $280. I think that covers low and mid range pretty well, even filtering to only the absolute latest generation. The big pinch on low/mid range for me was during the shortage period but that's long gone.
- brucethemoose2 3y agoThe cards at those prices are quite scrawny, and arguably poor value for the performance. Even accounting for inflation, ~$275 bought you physically beefy GPUs in previous generations. Everything has just moved up the pricing ladder.
- zamadatix 3y agoI've heard this a lot but I've never seen convincing reasoning, outside the GPU shortage era. It's also a bit laughable to call the 4060 scrawny by any means, but hey - it's not a 4090 if that's what we're marking expectations at. I'll use launch MSRP just to make comparison a bit quicker and this will raise the 4060 to $300 instead of the current $280. Taking that down to 2010 dollars that'd give you ~$200, exactly what you need for the low end sub-model of the shiny new GTX 460. The beefy pairing of that would be the 480 at $500, or 2.5x the price for roughly 1.6x performance. The 4060 vs the 4080 has a little more than twice that performance gap at around 2.4x performance difference or 1.5x more a performance gap but the price difference is also larger with $280 vs $1200, or than 4x the price or 1.6x the price gap. In all, the gaps themselves aren't significantly different but the price of the highest tier card is what has changed. Does that make the lower tier SKU inherently scrawny and poor value for the performance? I don't think it has any relation really, but if it did I'd say it would make more sense it was the opposite. Looking at absolute numbers one sees, just as expected, the 4060 is right in the top 3 for performance per dollar https://www.videocardbenchmark.net/gpu_value.html https://www.videocardbenchmark.net/gpu_value.html. This makes is hard to argue the performance took a huge dip either. It's not much faster than the same card in the previous generation, but it's also not much more expensive. Over many generations it's significantly advanced in both regards. Really the only card that was significantly faster than it's direct predecessor this generation was the 4090 and its pricing gives even more credence to the idea it's the price of the top SKU cards rising not the performance per dollar of the low tier SKUs rising that leads to the increased laddering. The other big change is you don't see cards like the 1030 coming out at launch. It's not as much that the market has stopped being served as much as integrated GPUs have come up to that level of task and anybody getting a dedicated wants something more not something the same.
- bloopernova 3y agoIf LLMs drive GPUs manufacturers to add more memory, will that mean game developers will create ever-larger textures to fill up that memory? Will we see multi-terabyte game downloads or streaming textures from a CDN? Alternatively: What would a AAA game be able to do differently if it had access to a GPU with 48GB or 96GB of fast memory?
- jadbox 3y agoNPC and world simulations would become far more dynamic. Imagine what The Sims 2025 could be like using that kind of hardware. I could imagine that gamedev AIs will be able to add weather and seasonal effects without much work from the game developers.
- pants2 3y agoNow they'll need to train an LLM to speak Simlish[1]. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simlish https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simlish
- holoduke 3y agoMaybe instead of high res textures you would load an AI upscaler in memory. These upscalers are also quite memory demanding.
- wmf 3y agoAAA games will be limited by the ~12GB usable VRAM in consoles.
- mewse-hn 3y agoIntel would be fucking crazy to give up on GPUs again, given the rise of AI processing workloads. I know a lot of companies cut their own throats chasing quarterly results but apparently Intel have a real engineer leading the ship right now.
- bluescrn 3y agoOr maybe the whole AI bubble is about to deflate as the inevitable copyright battles begin, and as more people turn against a technology that threatens to automate away interesting/creative jobs rather than mundane and repetitive ones...
- latchkey 3y agoI remember reading stuff like this in March 2000 when all the .com's were blowing up...
- pie420 3y agoAnd then a year later most websites died, and then it was 10-15 years until most of the tech companies like Cisco reached their 2001 stock valuations?
- latchkey 3y agoThe difference today is that AI companies aren't jumping at the chance to go public.
- pie420 3y agoBecuase the AI cycle is still in the hype phase, and VCs and private capital is getting in right now before unloading onto retail investors to hold the bags. And also, like every major tech invention in the past 40 years (smartphones, search, operating systems, social media, e-commerce), AI will quickly be dominated by a single corporation that will hold 80%+ of the market share. Nvidia on the hardware side and Microsoft/ClosedAI on the software side.
- kkielhofner 3y agoWhile I'm not as happy as anyone that consumer cards are "stuck" at 24GB I have been pleased with all of the software work that has been done to make the most of these cards. Quantization is the obvious one but you're also starting to see interesting approaches to further this (too many to list/name). As is often said "necessity is the mother of invention". Where this gets really interesting is when (hopefully not if) higher VRAM "consumer" cards become available we'll be able to do even more with the additional memory. Artificial market segmentation still sucks but it has led to some great software work that will continue to reap benefits for years to come.
- paulmd 3y agoI don't even know what people are really asking for anymore. 4070, 7800XT, 4060, and 7600 were all incredibly high-value launches, and in January we're incredibly likely to get price drops on 12GB cards as well as 16GB cards at the old 4070 Ti price point. The value is there, just a fairly large faction of people have an emotional investment in pretending like it's perpetual doom-and-gloom. Consider the reaction when Microcenter started putting a $100 steam gift card on the already-attractive 4070 price. People still flipped a shit even though a de-facto $500 price was obviously about as good as any 4070-tier product would get for this gen (apart from the firesales at the end). https://old.reddit.com/r/pcmasterrace/comments/12v790e/100_steam_gift_card_with_4000_series_purchase_at/ https://old.reddit.com/r/pcmasterrace/comments/12v790e/100_s... https://old.reddit.com/r/pcmasterrace/comments/12ug1ql/it_appears_that_micro_center_is_trying_there_best/ https://old.reddit.com/r/pcmasterrace/comments/12ug1ql/it_ap... https://old.reddit.com/r/buildapcsales/comments/12ucq6b/gpu_100_steam_gift_card_included_with_any/ https://old.reddit.com/r/buildapcsales/comments/12ucq6b/gpu_... https://old.reddit.com/r/nvidia/comments/12ucljb/micro_center_is_now_offering_a_100_steam_gift/ https://old.reddit.com/r/nvidia/comments/12ucljb/micro_cente... This is pretty much what super refresh is going to accomplish next month (a year later!) - 4070 will probably move down to $499-549, 4070 Super will be 95% of a 4070 Ti for $599-629, and 4070 Ti Super will offer 16GB at the same $749 price point. But people want a return to 2000s-level pricing (despite soaring wafer costs etc) and nothing short of that is going to satisfy some people. (and a fair number of people (including reviewers!) actively propagandize about these cards, like complaining the 4060 or 4060 Ti is actually slower than its predecessor - they're absolutely not, even at 4K (tough for a 6600XT tier card!) the 4060 Ti is still faster on average. And as a general statement, AMD made the same switch to 128b memory bus last gen already without catastrophic issues, like the aforementioned 6600XT. A card can still be a mediocre step without making shit up about it, and the 3060 Ti was the absolute peak of the 30-series value so it's understandable the 40-series struggles to drastically outpace it. But it's not slower, either.) https://old.reddit.com/r/hardware/comments/14phuh8/geforce_rtx_4060_meta_review/ https://old.reddit.com/r/hardware/comments/14phuh8/geforce_r... https://old.reddit.com/r/hardware/comments/13vm5ti/geforce_rtx_4060_ti_radeon_rx_7600_meta_review/ https://old.reddit.com/r/hardware/comments/13vm5ti/geforce_r... Since the RTX launch there has been the rise of what I'd call the "socially gamer, fiscally conservative" faction, the group of people that likes to think they'd be gaming, or likes to think they would upgrade, but this spending is too gosh-darn wasteful! However good the deals get, it's much more fun to just post dismissively on the internet about it, and it costs nothing to do so, but you get all the social clout of aligning yourself with the thing your in-group is excited about and signaling your social virtue (thrift), etc. Others are elder gamers who have lives and families now and are just drifting away in general and can't justify the money on a hobby they really no longer do, but they can't just let go of that identity/touchstone from their youth. And they're subconsciously looking for a deal that's so out-of-band good that they won't feel bad about not using it. But again, like the 4060 and 4070, there are plenty of deals at all times and in all price brackets, including older cards if that's your jam. 3080 and 3090 are good, 6800XT/7800XT is good, 4060 and 4070 are good, 7900XT has fallen as low as $700, etc. If you need to upgrade, then upgrade, but the slowing of moore's law has hit GPUs hardest. They are asymptotic perf-per-area machines that thrive on scaling out on cheap transistors (jensen has explicitly talked about this more than a decade ago) and now that cost increases are eating up most of the density gains it's understandable that gpus are the first and most affected by slowing gains/rising costs. https://youtu.be/Xn1EsFe7snQ?t=1075 https://youtu.be/Xn1EsFe7snQ?t=1075 At some point if people don't want to bite on deals like the microcenter thing, you will just see companies pivot to the products that are actually moving. 4090 did great, AI is doing great. Midrange and high-end will continue to sell and the "culturally gamer, fiscally conservative" folks will continue to seethe about the lack of a true Radeon 7850 successor or whatever. Everyone understands why the $150 price point is dead, but people don't want to accept that the cancer is going to continue to progress upwards, because fab tech isn't getting healthier either. And the perf/$ progress that AMD/NVIDIA can make is fundamentally determined by the transistors/$ that the fabs give them. Going above that rate of trx/$ gain is long-term unsustainable for them. If you can't be brought over by reasonable deals, like 4070 for $500 or Super Series refresh, are you really addressable market, from the perspective of NVIDIA and AMD? and in AMD's case, they benefit if you buy a PS5 anyway, that's still an AMD product, but doesn't carry the baggage of having to argue with the tech community (and big tech reviewers who increasingly view themselves as activists/participants rather than simply "calling balls and strikes") about the merits of cache vs bus width, or whether DLSS or RT or framegen is a good idea, or whatever. Sony will make a decision and you will take it or leave it, and seemingly that is more palatable than what AMD and NVIDIA are doing. Unified APUs are great, and have huge cost advantages, but it does involve many of the same compromises that gamers already hate. You're not going to be upgrading the memory of your Steam Console, and Series X/S both have GTX 970-style "3.5GB" slow-memory partitions, and there is a huge focus on upscaling (which will probably include AI upscaling in the PS5 Pro), etc. Those things are simply ground-truths in the console world. A huge part of the "console experience" is simply removing the option to even argue about these compromises, so that people don't feel bad about not being able to use ultra settings or having to turn on upscaling to do so, or for using a CPU with less cache/slightly lower IPC, etc. "Compromise pain" is quite similar to "choice paralysis" in practice, and by taking the choice away you relieve the pain.
- andrewstuart 3y agoNvidia has a monopoly and for that reason has lost interest in giving value to customers. It’s busy with AI and no longer seems interested in gaming. AMD seems to have no interest in competing with Nvidia and is content to release products that simply match Nvidia's terrible value. Despite being handed every possible chance to thrash Nvidia via competitive pricing, it simply releases slow GPUs at high prices and shrugs. Intel competes hard since its in distant third place but it’s products are far far behind in terms of performance. It’s lose lose lose for the GPU consumer. The general attitude of GPU manufacturers is very different from CPUs where it is a knockdown beat up sprint fight to the death to make the fastest and cheapest CPUs possible shipped as quickly as possible with the goal of winning. In GPUs it’s just a slow lazy fat gold grab in which no player is interested in making any further effort than they need to, for AMD and Nvidia anyway.
- ksec 3y ago>Nvidia has a monopoly and for that reason has lost interest in giving value to customers. It’s busy with AI and no longer seems interested in gaming. I look at Nvidia Reflex and DLSS improvement from what I thought was fancy to something I found more like magic. I dont see how they have lost interested in gaming. If anything, their AI business revenue has been partly subsidising their Gaming market where they are now the first player after Apple to get leading edge node capacity.
- cogman10 3y ago> Intel competes hard since its in distant third place but it’s products are far far behind in terms of performance. Not THAT far behind. The arc 770 is currently $280 and is competitive with the nVidia 3060 at $290. This is intel's first generation dedicated video card. I have a lot of hope for what comes with gen2. Assuming Intel doesn't just abandon the line (here's to hoping) there's a really good chance they come up from behind. Make sure you look into more recent arc benchmarks. One of the issues Intel had is their drivers sucked on release. They've mostly resolved a lot of those issues. I think the entire reason Intel entered the fray here is because they saw nVidia and AMD stagnating.
- 3y ago
- dimgl 3y agoThe 4090, although definitely overpriced, is one of the most impressive cards I've ever used. It handles almost every game I have at 4k120fps with little to no issues. It's by far the best card I've ever owned. I think the mid-range may not be as attractive but even the 4080 boasts some pretty impressive performance. I don't really think we need yearly releases of cards if the current generations are already doing so well.
- bsnnkv 3y agoMy experience of the 4090 is similarly positive. I ended up picking one up at a discount from a MicroCenter while I was traveling because someone had purchased it, realized when trying to install it into their case that it wouldn't fit, and then returned it. Probably the best purchase I've made all year as someone who plays video games, does some moderately intensive video editing for YouTube and likes playing around with local image generation and large language models. My advice to anyone in the market for a new graphics card is to just save until you can get a 4090.
- unethical_ban 3y agoI think it's funny that someone who can afford a 4090 wouldn't spend an extra 100-200 and swap out the case.
- unusualmonkey 3y agoSmall form factor builds are a thing - for all we know they picked up another.more expensive 4090 that fit better.
- bsnnkv 3y agoHonestly I had the same thought but I'm not complaining since I got a cheap(er) 4090!
- Zpalmtree 3y agohow do we determine the correct price?