6 ms·
> As a side note, this letter is exactly why I think a regulatory agency like the FDA is absolutely necessary. This isn't what anybody objects to about the FDA
by AnthonyMouse 3y ago
> As a side note, this letter is exactly why I think a regulatory agency like the FDA is absolutely necessary.
This isn't what anybody objects to about the FDA. "You have to list what's in the product" is a simple rule that every knows, is easy to comply with, and doesn't require any government interaction even in the case of a suspected violation because the FDA can just buy the product to test it and compare the lab results to the label.
What people object to is when someone wants to sell an accurately labeled product with a risk-benefit trade off, the customer knows what the product is and is exercising informed consent, and the government says they can't have it anyway.
- wredue 3y ago>doesn’t require any government interaction Dude what? Government around the world are constantly catching corporations for lying on their product lists. As for controlled substances, on this topic is a completely fine line which I’d probably tend to agree is not treaded properly. There are risk trade offs to allowing open markets on classes of drugs. With that said, the massive propaganda campaigns corporations get up to completely subvert that risk, and 100% leaves consumers uninformed even with the proper information at their fingertips: as a major example, the opioid crisis, leaded fuels, leaded paints, carcinogenic materials handling. I mean, the list really goes on and on. The issue with the FDA has time and time and time again been demonstrated to be how toothless it is. Corporations constantly ignore regulation for billions in profits, only to receive a sternly worded letter and MAYBE a 0.01% of profits fine.
- nickff 3y agoGovernments around the world are terrible at 'catching corporations for lying' in any way. There are manifold examples in every regulatory field, in every country. Examples include Wirecard, Theranos, Volkswagen, Johnson & Johnson talc, etc. In most cases, the regulators are handed the evidence, and take a long time to do anything about it. In my mind, the question is whether the massive regulatory burdens which protect incumbents and inhibit liberty are worth it. This is not an all-or-nothing question, and might be answered field-by-field, but regulators have not covered themselves in glory.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- wallaBBB 3y agoThe list of caught ones is immensely longer. It’s a cat and mouse game, it doesn’t really stop. Big pharma spends a lot of money on training the employees on how not to get caught. I worked 5 years in big pharma and it took me almost a year to understand why are the constantly repeating compliance and fair practice trainings. Giving examples how others failed, etc. Those were not there to tell you not to do it, but what to watch out for. And the sale targets and incentives are there to motivate you to cross the lines. I’m just grateful I was not in sales but application training. Btw how is a government responsible for Theranos? There was never a product there, just promises burning VC money. Wirecard is more a failure of trusted independent auditors (one of the big 4) that failed to do a proper international audit.
- nickff 3y agoThe FDA was the regulator for Theranos' products, which were used by customers, and the SEC was the regulator for Theranos' securities. https://theconversation.com/how-theranos-faulty-blood-tests-got-to-market-and-what-that-shows-about-gaps-in-fda-regulation-168050 https://theconversation.com/how-theranos-faulty-blood-tests-... https://www.sec.gov/litigation/litreleases/lr-24069 https://www.sec.gov/litigation/litreleases/lr-24069 Wirecard was actually a much worse regulatory failure in that the regulator attempted to prosecute the reporters which revealed the affair. Not only did the regulator fail to uncover either side of Wirecard's illegal behaviour, they went after the people who did. https://www.ft.com/content/4ebd9032-d3d1-4a9e-976c-d1235448ee20 https://www.ft.com/content/4ebd9032-d3d1-4a9e-976c-d1235448e...
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> Government around the world are constantly catching corporations for lying on their product lists. Obviously you have to interact with the government if they catch you lying. You're not intended to lie. The point is that you can have a labeling requirement and businesses can comply with it without having to make regulatory filings or prohibiting products. > There are risk trade offs to allowing open markets on classes of drugs. Which is why you have labeling requirements. This is cocaine, it's highly addictive, you probably want to try ibuprofen first.
- kayodelycaon 3y agoHaving things unnecessarily banned is a trade off of enforcing regulations effectively. Someone has to decide what substances safe and prevent them from sold. The FDA could do better but you’ll never fix that problem unless you don’t allow the FDA to enforce regulations.
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> Someone has to decide what substances safe and prevent them from sold. No they don't. If a product has a label that says "this product is considered unsafe by the Food and Drug Administration" and explains why and you buy it anyway, you got what you paid for.
- kayodelycaon 3y agoUnfortunately all this would result in is everything being labeled unsafe. See California and cancer.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoLabel the things unsafe that are currently banned. Not everything is currently banned, is it?
- VBprogrammer 3y agoI don't think you've understood the, very valid arguement in my opinion, that everything would end up with an unsafe label. In the same way that almost everything you buy either may contain nuts or is made in a factory which might process nuts - a practise which provides exactly zero useful input for the people it's intended to protect. Why would this happen for things which aren't currently banned? An abundance of caution - better to claim it's potentially unsafe than pay the claims later. Or economics - why pay more for a safe sweetener when you can use the cheap and cheerful one and just label it unsafe.
- 3y ago
- 2devnull 3y agoI disagree. I think the best generic argument against the FDA is that government isn’t very capable of doing the many things we want it to. I would love perfect security when it comes to foods, drugs and supplements but even with regulations a lot of bad stuff slips through. Imo, that’s a better argument than that the fda keeps us from having nice things. The fda fails to protect us because perfect security isn’t possible, and past a certain point it’s all diminishing returns if not actually counterproductive (consider the effects of prohibition).
- Veserv 3y agoThe problem is that the risk-benefit tradeoff is not accurately labeled and presented. Advertising laws in the US mean manufacturers can and should do everything in their power to obscure and mislead about the tradeoff. A person purchasing a unverified product should have tremendous misgivings. They should only purchase it in spite of tremendous misgivings. Anything less is not informed consent; it is deception masquerading as informed consent. Until you fix that you get companies downplaying risks and overstating potential benefits. Fix that and informed consent becomes a real possibility and a much more attractive proposition.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Spivak 3y ago> Anything less is not informed consent; it is deception masquerading as informed consent. Which is why I think the model for such things should just be "informed consent." It's a concept that already exists in the medical practice with a well-defined procedure. Someone who your state medical board has deemed competent and responsible has to explain in painfully explicit detail all the tradeoffs and answer any and all questions. If you still want to do it you sign some forms and go on with your day.
- rchaud 3y ago> accurately labeled product with a risk-benefit trade off, the customer knows what the product is and is exercising informed consent, and the government says they can't have it anyway. The FDA's regulatory purview is to limit the collateral damage (negative externalities) of even accurately labeled products. Informed consent from the customer is one side of the equation. Unfortunately they cannot consent to conditions like "Don't burden the hospital system if you take the wrong dosage".
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> Unfortunately they cannot consent to conditions like "Don't burden the hospital system if you take the wrong dosage". By this logic the FDA would have to ban Tylenol and Robitussin. Tens of thousands of ER visits every year. The government should generally be concerned with preventing deception and coercion and pricing externalities, because otherwise people have the incentive to do them and they would be prolific. Things nature punishes directly don't need the state to deter them. They happen by accident rather than by motive and we choose purposely to spread the cost of this across the population as a form of insurance and a cost of living in a free society, sometimes even when the misfortune is a result of their own stupidity. Other times we send them a bill for costs.
- growse 3y ago> By this logic the FDA would have to ban Tylenol and Robitussin. Tens of thousands of ER visits every year. It's almost like there's a balance of harms to be evaluated. I'd bet the cheap availability of paracetamol etc. saves more hospital visits than it causes, but I don't have the data to hand.
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> It's almost like there's a balance of harms to be evaluated. Which is a highly context-specific evaluation, so is it better decided by the person with the most knowledge of their own circumstances, or across the board with no context at all?
- chaxor 3y agoListing what is in a product isn't necessarily as easy as one might think. Certainly if an elemental analysis is required to ensure that the heavy metal content is lower than 1 ppb, it means something like a comprehensive SEM-EDX is required for every single batch. This should be required to avoid things like not noticing the enormous addition of lead chromate into turmeric, but it does require caring a bit about quality, and caring about quality in this way won't occur in a free market economy without some checks. The examples of this are everywhere, even in things as basic as water. If you ever want to worry yourself, learn a bit about characterization techniques for determining the amount of heavy metals or organic molecules ("forever chemicals") are in water to ppt levels. It's astounding how much different techniques will provide wildly different answers, and it's unclear which method to believe. When you look closely enough, it can get pretty scary how little we know about what is in our products.
- morkalork 3y agoIf the people advocating for this position aren't in favour of full legalization of narcotics they're complete hypocrites. If you want a total free for all of "anything accurately labeled is a-okay, let the consumer weight the risk/reward", then I don't want to hear a peep from the "moral majority" about my vices.
- pfisherman 3y agoSorry, I do not quite follow. FDA regulates the marketing of drugs, biologics, medical devices, etc. They do not regulate the practice of medicine. Your doctor can prescribe whatever they want “off label”. So for example, manufacturers cannot market erbitux as a cure for migraine headaches because no sponsor has submitted an application to FDA with compelling evidence that it is safe and effective for that particular indication. However, your doctor can still prescribe it for migraines if they so choose. Whether your insurance will pay for it is a different story.
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> Your doctor can prescribe whatever they want “off label”. They can prescribe a drug which is not FDA approved, can they? You also have the question of which drugs need a prescription or are considered a controlled substance, which is certainly government regulation regardless of whether or not the regulatory agency is the FDA.
- pfisherman 3y ago> They can prescribe a drug which is not FDA approved, can they? Yes they can. They can give you whatever medical advice or prescribe whatever regimen they want. They could tell you to drink bleach and the FDA would be powerless to do anything about it. I think the strongest argument for you would be a drug approved in another country; but not in the US. Your doctor can still prescribe it; and under the right conditions that prescription can allow you to obtain the drug in a foreign country and bring it back to the US. https://www.fda.gov/consumers/consumer-updates/5-tips-traveling-us-medications https://www.fda.gov/consumers/consumer-updates/5-tips-travel...