4 ms·
> It was even hard to explain kids 10 years ago, at a time when kids still watched cable, that there was once a time when cable TV didn't have ads. One thing t
by dragonwriter 3y ago
> It was even hard to explain kids 10 years ago, at a time when kids still watched cable, that there was once a time when cable TV didn't have ads.
One thing that may have made this difficult is that, in fact, there was never a time when cable didn't have ads. It was invented to deliver standard (advertising laden) TV to places geographically out-of-reach of broadcast, and basic cable always was a mix of broadcast stations and additional ad-laden stations.
Premium cable channels didn't tend to have advertising except for their own (or shared corporate parent) programming, but those were charged additionally on top of basic cable.
As someone who had cable since the mid-1980s, its been really weird to see this recent invention of a lost past where cable existed but was ad-free.
- elzbardico 3y agoWhere I lived the only reason to have cable was to watch premium channels. OTA worked perfectly fine for everything else. So, probably you're right on your perception, but it doesn't invalidate my point of view and of other people who clearly remember a time where you did have ad-free television in Cable, because we only cared for the premium channels.
- dragonwriter 3y ago“There was a time cable had no ads” and “there was a time you could spend additional money to buy separate ad-free channels on top of dozens of relayed broadcast channels and dozens to hundreds of basic cable channels, all with ads, on cable” are... very different claims. And using the latter to decry an evolving norm of it being possible to spend additional money to get the entire service ad-free on top of the basic cost of an (ad-supported) streaming service is... odd.
- elzbardico 3y agoOk. We are getting there. You do agree there was a paid service that had no ads. We're good on that, right? No objections, I reckon. I see you have a point with me and others calling it cable, when it was a subset of all the cable you could get. I readily concede your point here. So ok, there was a fucking paid service that had no ads, and I have no hard data to back what I am going to say, but I strongly suspect that those premium channels were all that mattered for most people. I never ever found a house amongst my friends and family during the 90's that had only basic cable. And this subset of people, who I suspect was a plurality of cable users, that cared most about those premium channels and paid for that, had the experience of seeing those channels introducing ads while charging the same for their packages.
- grogenaut 3y agoyou know cable existed before the 90s right? also the real ad free experience was large dish sattelite
- vel0city 3y ago> also the real ad free experience was large dish sattelite Mostly because for a while with the right equipment you'd get a lot of the original feeds direct.
- BeetleB 3y agoYou have to realize what an outlier you are. First, as others have pointed out, subscription based channels came later on. Cable TV had ads right from the get go. Second, the vast majority of cable subscribers did not have subscription based channels. Most people either had basic (e.g. 20 channels), or some sort of premium tier (50 channels) which did not have ad free options. You had to pay separately an extra $10-20/month to get the ad-free ones (e.g. HBO). To counter your anecdote, almost no one I knew paid extra for them. As in, sitting right now, I cannot even come up with one name. They were for "rich" folks. Plebes like us simply rented if we wanted ad free. Finally, I really don't get your point. When you got your ad free cable channels, the majority of cable channels carry ads. Even with the Prime/Disney degradation, the proportion of streaming services that have a paid no-ads option is still higher than you ever had at any point in cable history. You want ad-free streaming options? They still exist!
- vel0city 3y agoYou're really arguing pretty much everyone who had cable had multiple $10/mo (in the 80s and 90s!) premium channels and pretty much exclusively watched that? So there were pretty much zero people watching CNN, there were zero people watching USA,there were zero people watching Cartoon Network, zero people watching MTV, zero people watching ESPN, etc? Only HBO and Cinemax? Those were the only channels on at every single friends house, always? > I never ever found a house amongst my friends and family during the 90's that had only basic cable. Damn, and I thought I had a privileged childhood. Many of my friends didn't even have cable despite many coming from families making into six figures in the 90s. Literally nobody you knew only had or even spent any time watching basic cable channels? Even for the percentage of those I knew who did have cable, most didn't have the premium channels or would only have HBO or only Showtime or whatever. And no, they weren't paying tons of money to only watch HBO, many of those other channels were often watched. And by the fact you're scoping it to the 90s and beyond shows you're just ignoring the 40 years of history before. > I have no hard data to back what I am going to say You don't have the data because its 100% fiction. > who I suspect was a plurality of cable users Not even close. Supposedly in May 1987 it was reported HBO had 15 million subscribers. There were 41 million cable subscribers that year. In 2001 it was reported to have 25.5 million subscribers[2]. There were 66 million cable subscribers in the US. Never, in all of cable's history, have the plurality of cable subscribers had HBO. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_HBO https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_HBO [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cable_television_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cable_television_in_the_United... [2] https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-2001-oct-05-ca-53541-story.html https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-2001-oct-05-ca-53541...
- crazygringo 3y ago> OTA worked perfectly fine for everything else. That doesn't make any sense. You couldn't get basic cable channels like MTV or TBS or Nickelodeon over the air. That's the whole point of basic cable. And it was full of ads.
- vel0city 3y ago> OTA worked perfectly fine for everything else You got TNT over the air? CNN? USA? Cartoon Network? HGTV? Sci-Fi? Comedy Central? MTV?
- PH95VuimJjqBqy 3y agonope, cable was ad-free when I was a kid (also of the 80's). It's possible you were in an area with a shitty cable company, but many of us did not deal with ads while watching HBO, Cinemax, etc. There would sometimes be advertising between shows about other shows and while that's technically advertising it's not what people mean when they talk about ads (or the lack thereof). They're talking about interruption of content to show an advertisement. and yes, cable would also carry local channels, which had ads. No, that's not what people are referring to when they say cable did, or did not, have ads.
- crazygringo 3y agoNo. When major cable channels like TBS and ESPN launched in 1979, they had regular commercials just like broadcast. (You can read their histories on Wikipedia.) There were some channels that didn't have ads at first -- e.g. Nickelodeon was ad-free when it launched in 1979, and added commercials in 1984. But there was never a time when basic cable was free of ads, meaning ads for products (not just other shows). Premium cable channels are ad-free (HBO, Cinemax), but that's not cable. That's premium. You had to pay extra for that, on top of your basic cable subscription.
- Supermancho 3y ago> that's not cable. That's premium. Moving the goalpost is not compelling. Yes, national cable stations were commercial free for years (eg Z Channel^1, HBO, Showtime, et al), before every channel was advertised as being on cable, in a marketing shift to shift away from over-the-air broadcast and bundle programming rates. TBS was regional (Atlanta, Georgia^3), when it started off. The niche market of TBS was not industry defining anymore than my local bakery's donut deal is. This was a shift in terminology, but the history remains^2. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Z_Channel https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Z_Channel [2] https://www.everything80spodcast.com/hbo-showtime-the-rapid-growth-of-cable-tv/ https://www.everything80spodcast.com/hbo-showtime-the-rapid-... [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TBS_(American_TV_channel) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TBS_(American_TV_channel)
- 3y ago
- Trixter 3y agoI watched Nickelodeon in 1980 and there were most definitely no ads. (It also only broadcast from 6am to 2pm, having a static image outside of those hours.) I can't support your insistent viewpoint that cable TV always had ads.