16 ms·
What are farm animals thinking?
- andrewstuart 3y agoI saw a YouTube video where cows were given music on speakers to listen to. The cows would go listen to the music. Apparently they also like having special scratching posts they can scratch themselves on.
- crooked-v 3y agoThere are actually machines for that - giant rotating brushes that are time-activated when a cow pushes it upward. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5Rlext8BDpE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5Rlext8BDpE
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ggm 3y agoI really hope the journals pick up the work. The article implies publication is proving difficult. If they don't, this field my become career limiting or give way to studies which directly improve yield rather than indirectly through well being.
- OnAironaut 3y ago[flagged]
- kaikai 3y agoThis article and the research it describes are so confusing to me, as someone who owns livestock and has been around a variety of farm animals. Of COURSE they have friends, can hold their pee, and have complex emotions. If people spent time with meat animals, there would be a lot more vegetarians. I feel like the only reason we tell ourselves otherwise is because we want to be able to excuse terrible practices like battery cages and feed lots. If they’re dumb animals that can’t feel, it’s easier to allow that treatment. I didn’t think actual farmers or people who research farm animals would be surprised at these kinds of results.
- browningstreet 3y agoMy son and I often joke that in the same way that some countries require a period of military service, we could require a period of agricultural and meat farm service. Maybe even garbage disposal service.
- jmkr 3y ago> One of the animals raises her head over her enclosure and gazes pensively at me, her widely spaced eyes and odd, rectangular pupils seeking to make contact—and perhaps even connection. One time I did scuba, and I'm swimming in the water. There were fish, I have no idea what kind of fish, kinda small, maybe they size of an open hand. One fish swam in front of me, facing me, and stopped. It just chilled there. You can't speak under water, and even if you could you can't communicate with a fish. But there was some kind of connection we were making. I realized at that moment, in that moment, we were both experiencing something, and we were both inquisitive of each other. Me, a foreigner to the water, a tourist, and the fish, a local, wondering about this one biped that looks kinda funny. After a few minutes I guess it decided that the "conversation" had come to a natural ending and swam away. Out of the many fish that were near me that day, that was the one to stop and say hi. There are many tourists in this world. I have gone abroad and witnessed the tourists expecting something from the locals. I also see a lot of tourist and noticed they look at me, a local, like I'm a (non-human) animal. Over the years I like to think back to that specific individual fish, and realize that our differences aren't so great, and humans are the tourists that expect something from them, entire industries that capture a number of them every year that's so large many of us can't even comprehend. I have a few stories similar to this fish with other animals, and because of that the above quote resonates with me. I hope more articles come out which are not about just "sciency things" void of the humans and non-human condition, but the self actualization and realization of the individual that we're not alone.
- BelleOfTheBall 3y ago> I also see a lot of tourist and noticed they look at me, a local, like I'm a (non-human) animal. How exactly is that expressed? I often gawk at things and people on the streets when I'm traveling (and at home), but not out of disrespect, the exact opposite - awe, interest, desire to spot the details. Such as seeing a local in cool clothes and trying to figure out if it's from a local brand that I could buy from. Does that come off as treating people like animals? How can one get better about not doing that?
- jmkr 3y ago
- wrsh07 3y agoOf course much of this seems obvious, but I think it's also required to pave the way for more complex research. If you jump into research that does not show results because it's too complex, you don't learn anything. (That particular experiment didn't work, not "the species is too stupid to do X") You have to build up to it both to provide a path of credibility (we know they can do A,B,C, but when we tried D or E those didn't work) and also to develop the facilities, tools, techniques to be able to ask and answer these questions. It feels shameful because so many farmers or 4H students know all of this stuff. We shouldn't need to publish papers to know these animals are intelligent. This is referenced in the article, though - they publish both types of research (this animal can do that & treating your animals well in this way gives these specific benefits) I'm excited for the future where we have a much finer-grained understanding and can probe more specific questions from individual animals though
- zubairq 3y agoComments very interesting to me. Yes everyone should do farming service to understand where meat comes from!
- zoklet-enjoyer 3y agoI understand where meat comes from. That's why I've been vegan since the age of 14.
- Cockbrand 3y agoGenuinely curious questions, as I only know people who have made the decision to go vegan as adults: do you feel or know that this diet had any side effects on you growing up? How much attention did you pay to getting a diverse diet and all required nutrients? How long have you been vegan now?
- zoklet-enjoyer 3y agoNo side effects. I was quite healthy in my teen years and early 20s. Not saying I'm unhealthy now, but I don't workout like I did back then. I'm no less healthy than my brothers. 1 follows a regular omnivore diet, the other is vegetarian. I eat a good variety of fruits and vegetables, but have started eating more processed crap as I've got older and busy with work and life. When I was younger I was really into cooking intentionally healthy meals. Most of my protein comes from beans and tofu. I get asked about that a lot. I've been vegan for 21 years. Spring of 2002 I started cutting back on meat, slowly went mostly vegetarian over the summer, then vegan that autumn. Initially I stopped eating beef because of seeing some of the health issues my uncle's were experiencing and I attributed it to overconsumption of beef. I don't know if that's true, but anyway. Then reading about antibiotics and hormones given to the animals, I just didn't want to eat that. So I was in the mindset that I wouldn't eat factory farmed meat. I thought hunting was ok. Until I went hunting. Deer and pheasant seasons are early autumn, I think. Hunting both was what made me decide I was completely done with all animal products. My dad got a deer and I helped butcher it. That was some fucked up shit. I went pheasant hunting, shot one, didn't kill it, strangled it to put it out of its misery/not shoot it again and ruin the meat. That shit was really fucked up. So yeah, killing an animal and helping to skin and cut up that animal and another one are what really did it for me. Had I not gone hunting I might have just stayed a vegetarian and maybe eaten the occasional meat. These animals were no different than my pets and I would never do that to one of those guys.
- rowyourboat 3y agoI am surprised again and again that people are surprised that animals, and social ones at that, have thoughts and emotions and relationships. Have you never been around animals? Do you truly have believe humans are that special?
- beebeepka 3y agoAllowing other animals to be like glorious humans would mean they deserve better. Can't have that. Story as old as the world
- ornornor 3y agoI’m surprised too. But I suspect it’s more because it’s a very inconvenient truth: what about factory farms, the suffering we make billions of animals go through so we can eat them cheaply, and having to change our habits to accommodate this reality? It’s way easier and socially accepted to ignore this entirely and assume animals are dumb so it’s ok to keep doing what we do to them.
- threeseed 3y ago9 million people die every year from hunger. Humanity will do just fine ignoring the suffering of animals however smart they are.
- frakrx 3y agoLess meat consumption should lead to more production and decrease in price of of other types food. Also despite all the suffering in the world people still care very much about the wellbeign of dogs and cats. If anything with inflation and more and more wars around the globe the world needs cheaper food now more than ever.
- randomdata 3y ago> the world needs cheaper food now more than ever. We are getting there. The price of food has crashed pretty hard over the last couple of years, and we're already back to 2019 levels, with little sign of that trend stopping. Barring some major shift, food will be cheaper than ever by next year. It may not actually be cheaper food that you need, but rather cheaper retail workers. While food has crashed, the price of food in the grocery store still seems to be climbing.
- avodonosov 3y agohttps://www.google.com/search?q=elephant+paints+a+picture&tbm=vid https://www.google.com/search?q=elephant+paints+a+picture&tb...
- Cockbrand 3y agoIf it looks too good to be true, it probably isn't - two links from further down the same Google results page: Painting Elephants? Here’s Why Making an Elephant Paint For Entertainment is Cruel, Not Cute - https://www.onegreenplanet.org/animalsandnature/why-making-an-elephant-paint-is-cruel-not-cute/ https://www.onegreenplanet.org/animalsandnature/why-making-a... Does a Video Show an Elephant Painting a Picture of an Elephant? - https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/elephant-painting/ https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/elephant-painting/
- avodonosov 3y agoThank you. I suspected something like that actually, but didn't have time to check.
- lgkk 3y agoThis is why I try to be as vegan as possible. Obviously not always possible. But I try. At home I don’t eat meat or use animal products. Outside if my friends want to go Korean or something it almost always has eggs or beef broth but what can I do? Sucks but I get the tofu options.
- Mandelmus 3y agoSame for me. I've been mostly vegan for over ten years now. I "downgrade" to only vegetarian when it really cannot be avoided – which, luckily, has been only when I've travelled to countries where there really weren't any vegan options.
- c048 3y agoWhy would you be against eating animals products? Many produce them naturally themselves. For example, chickens lay eggs if we want them to or not. If humans don't take the eggs, chickens would eat them themselves or leave them to rot. If you're against industrial farming of them, fine, but there are plenty of eggs you can buy from certified ethical farms. Or even better, you can keep them yourself! They are great to get rid of food scraps. Same with bees and honey. The only times you hear it mentioned that it harms the bees is when no sources are provided or the study turns out to be garbage (and waylaid by multiple other studies that are tiptoed around).
- jhanschoo 3y ago> If you're against industrial farming of them, fine, but there are plenty of eggs you can buy from certified ethical farms. The parent notes that they are willing to compromise on being vegan for convenience, so presumably they are not against ethically produced animal products, but would forgo animal products altogether as a matter of convenience as well. Ethically produced animal products may not be verifiably accessible for someone for many reasons.
- lgkk 3y agoI’m against industrial farming because of the horrific conditions. Also stuff drinking the milk of another animal, something that’s reserved for its child, is kind of horrible. All those cows are lined up and pumped and then what? Probably killed. At least to me it is fuckin brutal. The only thing you can legitimately call me out on is that I don’t go to the doctor or engage much in modern medicine. Seeing monkeys with their brains exposed or puppies and cats suffering “for science” is also wack to me. When it’s my time I’ll go. Hopefully not too much pain.
- efitz 3y agoWhen you spend a lot of time around a mammal, you will start to see that it has a personality, particularly if you’ve spent time around other individuals of similar species. Humans have very similar neurological equipment to other mammals. I don’t see why anyone finds it surprising that mammals have intelligence or even consciousness. Consciousness in others is a leap of faith. We have no unambiguous way to measure it. Most people take it for granted that other people are conscious, if they communicate in certain ways. Animals lack those manners of communication; that doesn’t mean they aren’t conscious; it means we don’t have a common language. I’m happy that people are doing this research; I hope it leads to more kind treatment of livestock. No, I won’t stop eating meat regardless of the results, but I would choose to support both regulation and private efforts to reduce stress and discomfort when harvesting animals.
- berkes 3y agoI've once spent a summer herding cows in Switzerland. Mostly bringing the to and from pastures in de morning and evening. I've had farm animals and pets most of my life, but here I learned something new. I quickly learned that cows have personality. Multidimensional. E.g. one (older one) was mischievous but also ver sweet. Another one mischievous and aloof. One was lazy and easily frightened. It was one herd and I presume they were well adjusted to another until I came along and ruined their balance. It took us about a week to get used to another. Moenie,the bull, challenged me twice and had to stay home even, I could not assert dominance. Cows, I learned, are complex, deep, and above all very sweet animals. Needles to say that it strenghtened my vegetarianism. When media and people make me think of animals as production units I think back at this herd I got to know some 27 years ago and realize that no: they are not ever "units of production"
- bobse 3y ago[dead]
- noobly 3y agoI have farm animals and am a farmer. I raise these animals as a hobby to get cheaper high quality meat. Veganism bothers me because it places animal life on a pedastool over plant life. Plants suffer upon death too.
- slimebot80 3y ago[flagged]
- Scarblac 3y agoBut if you eat animals, then they first eat the plants, much more than you do, and then you eat the animals. Veganism doesn't "put animal life on a pedestal", it just uses fewer resources.
- iosnoob 3y agoAn interesting read on the relative likelihood of consciousness of various lifeforms on earth: https://rethinkpriorities.org/publications/opinion-estimating-invertebrate-sentience https://rethinkpriorities.org/publications/opinion-estimatin... Long story short, relative chance of plant consciousness is a lot lower than that of members of animal species. Regardless, the point is moot - if plants are sentient, that's even more an argument to consume less of them, directly, vs a lot more of them, via animals.
- timeon 3y ago> animal life on a pedastool Humans are animals too.
- iosnoob 3y agoGrowing up always thought about the thought experiment of how aliens would treat us compared with how we treat our fellow sentient beings in the animal kingdom (I couldn't find a good answer and stopped consuming animals). Now with a potential for AGI and perhaps sentient AI in coming years or decades, those philosophical questions suddenly become a lot more pressing
- frakrx 3y agoAs AIs can only be trained on datasets of colected human experiences if/when one day a superintelligent AI comes about I am sure it will only percieve us as inferior, unrational and dangerous beigns.
- frakrx 3y agoNot caring about animals leads to not caring about nature in general and that is leading towards us destroying earth ecosystem and making our planet not be able to sustain human civilization.
- timeon 3y agoThere are some philosophies which teaches that everything was created for human. It was and is good excuse for exploitation of nature. No wonder we have climate change now.
- ggpsv 3y ago"The very notion of the domination of nature by man stems from the very real domination of human by human." - Murray Bookchin
- PakG1 3y agoRemember the scene in the first avatar movie where Jake is learning how to be like the Na'vi and he gives a solemn speech to the animal as he kills it, thanking it for its sacrifice and showing it respect? I wonder, if we took indigenous perspectives for animal life, would it be more acceptable to take the life of animals for consumption? Minimize suffering, use the whole animal, don't overconsume so that the species can sustainably live on, let them live life more free range, not in prisons, etc. Or would it still be just as bad because the animal still can suffer? Indigenous thinking is something that is being promoted by certain sustainability movements, and I wonder if it applies here and would make animal consumption more ethical, or would it just be whitewashing?
- globular-toast 3y agoFor me it comes down to choice. I don't think it's right to kill anything if you don't have to. It's trivially easy to live well on a vegetarian or vegan diet. People don't kill animals because they are hungry. They kill them because they want to.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- giantg2 3y ago"overturn the idea that livestock are dumb and unworthy of scientific attention." Where's this idea? Most of the farmers I know don't believe this. They know their animals have some level of intelligence. There is a huge amount of scientific attention given to livestock - from genetics and breeding, to disease, management practices, etc. Maybe this is just what people who have never been around livestock believe?
- worldvoyageur 3y agoFully agree. I grew up on a farm. The animals included cows, sheep, goats, chickens and donkeys. You quickly learned their distinct personalities. You could tell when they were stressed and when they were content. It sure felt a lot better when they were content and you went out of your way to achieve that, both short term in what you did that day and longer term as you structured the farm to better fit what the animals wanted. The animals learned about the humans as well. For instance, walking to the back edge of the farm in the fall to fix fencing, the cows would change their routine to follow - especially the part were you might route through the field full of apple trees. Sure enough, you'd see that the cows had eaten all the apples they could reach but there were vast quantities of ripe apples higher up. So you climbed the tree and used your legs to shake branches, causing bushels of apples to thunder down. The cows that had followed would call loudly to summon their herd mates, who would come at the run. If the sheep saw me on the same trip, I'd be ignored...unless I was carrying a bucket, which meant it probably had oats, at which point I'd have a herd of sheep converging on my position.
- stubish 3y agoI thought it well known that pigs were considered as smart as dogs. Pigs might be a special case, as they are kept as pets much as a dog would be in a few countries.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- astrostl 3y agoThis seems like one of the bigger potential use cases for LLM interpretation of EEG, FMRI, etc. data to me: decoding animal thoughts (inc. pets).
- fuzzfactor 3y agoWhen it's breakfast time and the chicken complains about having her eggs stolen before they have a chance to hatch, the pig says "you think you've got it bad, I'm in whole hog!"
- neontomo 3y agoI've had conversations with people who are entirely convinced that animals like cats, dogs, birds, have no conscious experience and therefore are not aware of our presence or feel any pain. They think the pain is simply a signal to make the animal act in different ways, like a robot would. It actually made me speechless to hear that people believe this, and I wonder if it's an effect of being too distanced from the animal world so we start to think of animals as being there for our benefit and nothing else.
- tim333 3y agoMaybe now they can use MRI scans to see what people are thinking they could do something similar with animals? https://www.popularmechanics.com/science/health/a27102/read-thoughts-with-brain-scan/ https://www.popularmechanics.com/science/health/a27102/read-...