11 ms·
Matter, set to fix smart home standards in 2023, stumbled in the real market
- rubatuga 3y agoTLDR: Matter with Philips Hue is unreliable. Matter doesn't support adaptive lighting on HomeKit (yet). My two cents: thread and matter has the potential to be more reliable than WiFi. The biggest blocker is that thread border routers have no vendor interoperability (you have to buy a bridge for every vendor)
- tjoff 3y ago> The biggest blocker is that thread border routers have no vendor interoperability (you have to buy a bridge for every vendor) Why? They all work ~fine on zigbee which is pretty much the exact same thing just with even less oversight. I haven't bought into matter/thread because I haven't found a single device I want yet.
- ianburrell 3y agoZigbee and Thread are not the same thing. They use the same 802.15.4 radio. Zigbee does its own wireless mesh protocol, and then adds profiles on top. With home automation being most common. Thread uses 6LoWPAN to run IPv6 on 802.15.4. Thread adds a mesh network. Matter is the home automation protocol on top of that.
- tjoff 3y agoFrom an systems perspective they are the same thing. Zigbee vs. Thread is just transport. The protocol on top of that is what matters and the sole purpose (from my narrow perspective) of Thread+Matter was that this would be a team effort to allow different vendors to talk to eachother. And with that in mind IPv6 feels like a decent choice. If vendors don't respect that foundation then the whole point of Matter+Thread is just gone.
- Tijdreiziger 3y agoEven on Zigbee, there are slight incompatibilities between vendors.
- rubatuga 3y agoYou can't add zigbee lights from IKEA to a philips hue bridge and have them show up in homekit. [0] [0]: https://www.reddit.com/r/Hue/comments/cpbu9w/ikea_tradfri_bulbs_hue_app_apple_home_kit/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Hue/comments/cpbu9w/ikea_tradfri_bu...
- tjoff 3y agoThat's an issue with the hue bridge though (and maybe homekit). There certainly are issues with the zigbee devices, but that is not it.
- upon_drumhead 3y agoI literary couldn’t get any eve matter devices to work at all on my network. Turns out matter requires some ipv6 features my router doesn’t support and isn’t easily found out what routers do support it. I’m a firm believer in matter and threads future, but ipv6s home network mess is going to hamper it for years imho.
- alphabettsy 3y agoIPv6 Unicast and Multicast. Seems like any consumer router made in the last decade should work as long as IPv6 is enabled. Consumer routers vary widely in software quality though.
- upon_drumhead 3y agoNo, it also needs to support: ICMPv6 (type 133) Router Solicitation (RS) ICMPv6 (type 134) Routing Advertisement (RA) Which my xfinity provided router does not. I spent weeks with support emails between xfinity and eve trying to get it sorted out before eve declared it an unsupported router and refunded me the purchase.
- rubatuga 3y agoRA and RS packets form the basis of IPv6, so objectively the router from Xfinity does not support IPv6.
- alphabettsy 3y agoFair enough. I haven’t used an ISP provided router in a decade. I can’t justify paying more for what’s usually pretty crap.
- aksss 3y agoRight but isn’t this kind of illustrating the problem with the state of home automation in general? I mean, if you care enough to know about the features of your router, your also likely the kind of person who can pay attention to and work out all the kinks in home automation, and it’s fun and really cool when you get it working. But for 90% of the population home automation is as elusive and as prohibitive as quality home espresso - expensive, delicate, and requires all the attention of a niche hobby. Not that most people aren't smart enough to figure it out, but for most people the juice isn’t with the squeeze. All the COTS hardware for easy implementation is a closed cul-de-sac and rather mediocre, and is condemned to be a neat gimmick that quickly loses its luster.
- dharmab 3y agoIn my personal experience, Phillips Hue is unreliable in general. I just replaced every Hue bulb in my home because one in four had either turned inti a flickering haunted house prop or failed entirely.
- alphabettsy 3y agoIn my experience they have been the most rock solid piece of all the smarthome tech for a decade for me in multiple homes and apartments. I still have and use the original bulbs that came in my first starter kit.
- dharmab 3y agoSome of the failed bulbs were purchased after 2020. I suspect quality has declined.
- shepherdjerred 3y agoI have something like 50 lights from them and only one has ever given me trouble
- cjdell 3y agoFor me, Phillips Hue has been the only bulb to have NOT done this, despite being the oldest. But the cheaper bulbs I've bought on Amazon have all started flickering or just out right failed completely. This has really enforced the "buy cheap buy twice" idea in my mind. It's possible you've been scammed. I suspect there's a big market in selling knock off Hue bulbs because they can mark up the price so much more.
- Volundr 3y agoI'm still unclear on why the need for a border router exists at all. My zigbee devices work just fine without access to my local network or the Internet, but the same devices using matter/thread claim to need a border router? What are they doing differently than my zigbee stuff?
- alphabettsy 3y agoThe protocol and network are open, but it’s encrypted and as far as I can tell none of the major vendors allow you to export or import the keys you would need to add a bridge from a competing platform.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoSounds like an FTC complaint around interoperability and anticompetitive behavior.
- tjoff 3y agoIsn't that what the Matter QR codes are for? Which I thought were mandatory for all Matter products? I guess a loophole might be to make the border router matter compatible but none of the actual devices. At which point you really shouldn't be buying them anyway.
- alphabettsy 3y agoNo. Thread and Matter are not the same thing. Matter is an interoperability standard so that devices expose a common API. It works over WiFi, Bluetooth or Thread currently. Thread is a network protocol like WiFi or Bluetooth. The QR codes are used for pairing devices to a Matter controller.
- tjoff 3y agoPairing it to the controller, yes. Not the border router. The controller could talk to the border router if needed but that should be it.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- wkat4242 3y agoThe problem is the investors. They love recurring revenue. Hence data mining apps and closed ecosystems with subscription fees. And bait and switch tactics like Hue where the conditions deteriorate over time (like needing an account now so they can track you better) Companies don't really want to give us freedom of choice. They just want to take our money. Ideally through subscriptions so they have to do almost nothing for it but can cash in easily. So all the "special sauce" doesn't have a technical reason but am economical one.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ahaucnx 3y agoIt's true that the trend in the industry definitely goes towards subscriptions and closed eco systems. We at AirGradient see that very well that more and more companies force their users into the cloud and some monitors even refuse to show current air quality when not registered to the cloud. Imagine you would need to register your fever thermometer with an app in the cloud before you could measure your temperature... Part of the problem is not only the investors in Matter but also VC funded smart home equipment manufacturers that are pressured to go down the recurring revenue business model. At AirGradient [1] we want to demonstrate a counter example. Our fully certified air quality monitors are open source hardware and thus we provide the firmware code and they can be easily re-flashed with whatever software you like to use. With this openness a great community has emerged that maintains integrations to various systems like Home Assistant via ESPHome. [1] https://www.airgradient.com/ https://www.airgradient.com/
- wkat4242 3y agoI think I'd seen your product before on HN. It looks nice but like the others say, I'm in Europe so it's a no go for now. Will keep an eye on it though for when you decide to expand!
- russell_h 3y agoI’ve got one of your pre-soldered kits running ESPHome in my office. It’s a great product, thanks for making it!
- metadat 3y agoIn the past few months, after doing a ton of research I ended up going with Z-Wave for a new home build. Z-Wave isn't not going away anytime soon. Zigbee is also pretty cool, between these and an odd Wi-Fi only device here and there, it seems more than adequate.
- colordrops 3y agoI came to the same conclusion and it has been fine.
- travem 3y agoI am using z-wave as well. It has been rock solid, and using the z-wave association capability I don’t even need the hub (using Hubitat) unless I want to do more complex automations. The only downside is the ecosystem has fewer options (but have been high quality IMO) and the cost is higher than the ubiquitous WiFi smart home devices that require their own apps and internet connection.
- acheron 3y agoYep I have Z-Wave stuff with a Hubitat box. Works pretty well. I do wish I could locate a Z-Wave water timer for sprinkler/irrigation.
- semi-extrinsic 3y agoFWIW, Gardena sells "dumb" irrigation valves that run on 24V. It's just a normally-closed solenoid valve IIUC, with proper fittings etc. Controlling these with a 24V power supply and a Z-wave relay should be easy?
- rlpb 3y agoI am also invested into Z-Wave with about 50 devices. It works well, doesn't require an Internet connection, degrades gracefully if the hub is unavailable (or indeed any RF) and Z-Wave JS UI is good enough for self-hosting and bridging to MQTT for full integration with anything else I want. The protocol is also excellent for battery powered devices in terms of super low power consumption: depending on the device's needs, the protocol allows for the device radio to be completely off for hours at a time. For example, I have a couple of key fob controllers that we use daily but we haven't replaced the batteries in them for years. My only fear is that "consumerist" IoT platforms that change every few years will usurp it and new Z-Wave devices will become unavailable.
- LanzVonL 3y agoI just don't trust smart home stuff, it all seems like a big data collection nightmare at best, at worst you could have criminals and government nannies both spying on you 24/7. I still use incandescent lights though too.
- postpawl 3y agoThere are some smart home hubs that support self hosting. Home Assistant and Hubitat are both really good solutions.
- LanzVonL 3y agoAre those Free and Open Source? If there's a security problem can I fix it myself and flash new software?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- piperswe 3y agoHome Assistant is FOSS software that just runs on a Linux box, its functionality/integrations all come from FOSS plugins that you can write and/or modify yourself.
- dns_snek 3y agoHomeAssistant is FOSS and it has an incredible number of integrations, it's extremely capable though not as user-friendly as commercial offerings when it comes to setting it up, which is to be expected. In similar vein ESPHome and Tasmota are 2 independent FOSS projects that can replace proprietary firmware on many commercial smart devices based on ESP32. Some WiFi-based smart devices like those made by Shelly work without internet access and integrate with HA via local HTTP API. Fully local smart home is possible, but you'll need to research what you're buying - as a general rule, you should avoid WiFi-based smart devices unless they offer a local API. Everything else (ZigBee, Z-Wave) should work offline without proprietary hubs, though I'm sure there are exceptions.
- anymouse123456 3y agoMatter. Not fit for human consumption. I understand how compelling the marketing hype seems at first, but a quick investigation reveals this to be yet another mafia shakedown and effort to lock down and prevent any meaningful competition. They have a 16-bit Vendor ID. That's 65,535 vendors supported. Globally. Ever. One must pay the CSA ([0] $2,500 per PRODUCT or $7,000 per YEAR) for one of these artificially scarce identifiers. In order to download specs, you're expected to accept TOS, authenticate and then you're emailed a (presumably authenticated) link to the PDF [1]. You need to wait for the consortium to define every single application layer detail for each and every type of thing [2]. Of course, the decision makers are unable to make high quality decisions since their own businesses depend on trapping customers in their respective walled gardens. The goal is to prevent any small or medium sized businesses from competing with the small handful of multinational megacorps. From what I can tell, it's all of the worst parts of USB, without HID and Serial to fall back on for things they didn't think to define. [0] https://csa-iot.org/become-member/#Membership https://csa-iot.org/become-member/#Membership [1] https://csa-iot.org/developer-resource/specifications-download-request/ https://csa-iot.org/developer-resource/specifications-downlo... [2] You must download the "Device Library" spec yourself, as my link is fingerprinted and I do not wish to violate a hidden TOS clause. [edit] formatting
- fnordpiglet 3y agoIt has a cool name and cute logo though. I’m sure it’s easy to silk screen onto a device.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- HankB99 3y ago> They have a 16-bit Vendor ID. That's 65,535 vendors supported. Globally. Ever. One must pay the CSA ([0] $2,500 per PRODUCT or $7,000 per YEAR) for one of these artificially scarce identifiers. I didn't know any of this. I pay attention to IoT (and run a modest Home Assistant setup in my home.) Had I known about these constraints, I would have written off Matter from the beginning. What were they thinking?
- the_mitsuhiko 3y agoI honestly feel like smart homes are getting worse each year for me. Now even Hue is an unreliable and unnecessarily frustrating experience. The only actual improvement in my setup has been that the IKEA Dirigera hub is now a solid improvement but some Hue stuff doesn’t work with it. On the other hand some manufacturers are now actively fighting home assistant and the matter switch is non existent. A total zero number of devices in my home run over matter, something that I didn’t expect given the huge amount of excitement early on. It feels like rather than everything slowly converging I now run two hubs still, custom smart home apps, a largely unreliable and useless home assistant next to some things with HomeKit. I really can’t stand it and I’m incredibly frustrated by it.
- ratiolat 3y agoDirigera still does not support Matter. I bought it for 'coming soon' Matter support, but it's still not there. Have been waiting for looong time now.
- the_mitsuhiko 3y agoThat’s why I originally replaced the hub. But it’s a much better hub on its own so I’m not too mad. I can’t find matter devices independently that I want to use and are actually working properly.
- tacticalturtle 3y agoDo you have any examples of manufacturers that are fighting Home Assistant? I just started using it and getting into home automation, and that’s disappointing to hear
- the_mitsuhiko 3y agoThe famous example at the moment is the family of MyQ garage doors (Chamberlain, Lift Master etc.). Integrations that break after an upgrade and don’t get fixed for longer than I can deal with are more common.
- simbolit 3y agoThe sub-headline says everything you need to know: "Gadget makers, unsurprisingly, are hesitant to compete purely on device quality."
- okeuro49 3y agoAnd you would have misunderstood... > If Matter can succeed in convincing companies to compete on the merits of their devices—not the incidental revenue that comes from being a single-system device provider, or phone app marketing...
- simbolit 3y ago...then in a few years, people won't even notice that they're simply scanning a code on their devices and adding them to whatever home control system they wish. The sentence you (partially) quote starts with "if" and ends with "wish". Cough.
- garphunkle 3y agoLutron Electronics is a good counter example
- blindriver 3y agoAfter trying to go in hard with IoT, I now just rely on Apple Home Kit to unify everything for me. It’s good enough except for the terrible interface to set lights on and off, it’s literally the worst I’ve ever seen.
- csnweb 3y agoSame here, I also don’t understand why the home app is rather lacking. The light switches in the control center are okay, but that quickly becomes too full. I mostly use voice commands to manage my lights and third party apps like the one from Eve for other accessories.
- spaceywilly 3y agoI have a widget on my Home Screen. It has 4 tiles for my 4 lights, tap a tile to turn the light on or off.
- toomuchtodo 3y ago+1 for Home Kit, using TP Link Kasa devices for power control.
- euroderf 3y agoDoes anyone know a good ELI5-type page for deCONZ and Phoscon ? Their documentation is kind of a mess.
- odiroot 3y agoMaybe because Zigbee is good enough. And Matter/Thread try to do too much.
- Avamander 3y agoIs it though? The lack of standardisation on the layer above means that compatibility between vendors is iffy at best. Even zigbee2mqtt unfortunately has its inconsistencies.
- napkin 3y agoI'm reserving my interest in smart home tech for when it's a clear win in terms of energy efficiency. Very recently I compared my current home lighting costs with a fully smart-equipped setup, and it basically just balanced out. I was surprised, because I calculated a best case scenario where the lights could basically always be off when not in use, compared to my current patterns where honestly I'm pretty lazy and leave all them on almost all day. The industry/general consumer priorities are pretty frustrating.
- ksplicer 3y agoReplace the switches instead of the lights and you can keep your energy efficient bulbs.
- napkin 3y agoYeah, that's what I was factoring. For my home, the 24/7 power consumption from a handful of switches + some kind of hub just balanced out the potential savings from having the same bulbs off more often.
- Someone 3y agoI guess you have plenty of lights that you don’t leave on “all the time” such as lights in toilets that typically run at low duty cycles (I guess the light in my toilet is on for less than ten minutes a day, and only in winter, for example) For such lights, the permanent power usage of the controller can be much larger than that of the light, even if you accidentally leave it on way longer than needed now and then. The EU limit allows each controller to use 0,5w. See https://commission.europa.eu/energy-climate-change-environment/standards-tools-and-labels/products-labelling-rules-and-requirements/energy-label-and-ecodesign/energy-efficient-products/mode-standby-and-networked-standby-devices_en https://commission.europa.eu/energy-climate-change-environme.... And they do use close to that. The Philips Hue bulb uses 0,4W when off. See https://www.anandtech.com/show/6805/philips-hue-automated-home-lighting-gets-colorful/6 https://www.anandtech.com/show/6805/philips-hue-automated-ho.... So, that’s about 10Wh a day. If you use that to control a 10W light, you’d have to decrease its ‘on’ time by a hour a day to come out positive in energy usage. I have many lights that aren’t even on that long each day. I think home automation of lighting fixtures as a way to conserve energy made way more sense before LEDs became common.
- FloatArtifact 3y agoFrom those that are privacy conscious matter also has an issue that seems largely underreported. You can't choose which device on the network is the controller when setting up a new device to a network. For instance if you have a home assistant blue it might choose your Amazon echo to initiate the network. Therefore you have multiple networks running which may not respect your privacy or choice.
- 9dev 3y agoThe first time I was reading about matter, I was also watching the last season of The Expanse (a hard sci-fi series). In that show, technology mostly just happens in the background, despite being central to the plot often. I think that is because the characters tend to have a very nonchalant way of using it: Whatever terminal is nearest can be used to interact with stuff in vicinity. There are no boundaries between devices, services, or the like; everything communicates with everything else, over any channel available, without further thinking. If we ever get past showing off how the ceiling bulb can do red light, maybe we could start having a protocol for automatic device capability negotiation/discovery?
- plasticchris 3y agoSomething with zero configuration?
- 9dev 3y agoYes, well, mostly: I’d expect you’d have to add new things to your network with some level of confirmation once–if anything, proper auth should be baked in. But after that, wouldn’t it be great if you didn’t have separate devices anymore, but a single digital identity across all of them, with an interface to control unique capabilities of each of them? For a banal example - there’s no reason we shouldn’t be able to set a timer on our phone, and check it on a computer, or kitchen counter display. On the other hand, I can’t check on the progress of my vacuum robot from my laptop, because the vendor only offers a mobile app. I can’t pull the stats from my car at all, I can’t check a hard drive without plugging it into something compatible, I can’t easily send a big file to someone nearby. Technology should allow us to do all that. Devices should promote their capabilities and offer a standard interface to control them, and simultaneously be able to display controls for the interface of other devices, depending on available means of input. Done well, this can actually be zero config.
- skydhash 3y agoThe closest to this is the Apple ecosystem. Most of their hardware works together, but sadly it's closed.
- para_parolu 3y agoSo far HomeKit and matter (with thread) was most reliable and easy to use system for me. Best part that I don’t need more apps to control devices.
- kurtoid 3y agoIOT it's not a technical problem, but a business problem. :(
- twarge 3y agoJust installed a bunch of Matter bulbs from Nanoleaf to my Apple Home. It worked just fine. Hardware and firmware just takes a long time.
- egberts1 3y agoThe main problem is there is still that single point-of-failure in this centralization of a Matter schema server.