7 ms·
The end of retirement
- wenebego 3y agoOk, so you cant retire if you dont save enough to stomach a tiny downturn.
- woodruffw 3y agoThis isn’t charitable: even besides the author’s case, there are all kinds of factors that make people retire (injury, new familial obligations, being forced to retire for legal/pension/political reasons).
- ekianjo 3y ago> Every generation lives longer than the one that came before—nothing new there No, that's completely wrong and this is a lie that keeps being repeated. Life expectancy has only been increasing because child mortality has decreased to almost zero. The upper end has not shifted much at all.
- Aeolun 3y agoAre we talking about the top 5% or the top 0.01%? Because it seems to me the top 5% is definitely going up. I don’t think people regularly aged to 8x in the 1500s (mostly due to higher prevalence of disease).
- woodruffw 3y agoIn most models, falling child mortality is responsible for about half of the life expectancy growth in the past 150 years. But the other half is indeed longer lives at all age groups[1]. So I don’t think this is a lie, or even misleading (since the author made no claim about non-childhood causes being disproportionate). [1]: https://ourworldindata.org/its-not-just-about-child-mortality-life-expectancy-improved-at-all-ages https://ourworldindata.org/its-not-just-about-child-mortalit...
- buzzy_hacker 3y ago“It’s not just about child mortality, life expectancy increased at all ages” https://ourworldindata.org/its-not-just-about-child-mortality-life-expectancy-improved-at-all-ages https://ourworldindata.org/its-not-just-about-child-mortalit...
- foundart 3y agoWhere do you get that information? I realize that the reduction of infant mortality has been a major factor in the change in expected lifespan, but there have also been gains in expected remaining lifespan at 65. For example, this study reported on in 2018: The researchers looked at birth and death data for people above age 65 from 1960-2010. They found that the average age of death in those who live to be older than 65 increased by three years in every 25-year period, which means that people can expect to live about six years longer than their grandparents, on average. Furthermore, this trend continued at a relatively stable pace over the entire 50-year period and in all 20 countries that they analyzed. Factors like medical breakthroughs caused minor fluctuations in how quickly lifespans increased, but these variations averaged out over time https://news.stanford.edu/2018/11/06/lifespan-increasing-people-live-65/ https://news.stanford.edu/2018/11/06/lifespan-increasing-peo...
- jodrellblank 3y agoNo that's completely wrong and is a lie that keeps being repeated. Life expectancy has increased at all ages: https://ourworldindata.org/its-not-just-about-child-mortality-life-expectancy-improved-at-all-ages https://ourworldindata.org/its-not-just-about-child-mortalit... and "Excluding child mortality, the average life expectancy during the 12th–19th centuries was approximately 55 years." - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Life_expectancy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Life_expectancy
- antisthenes 3y agoThe difference being that reduced mortality at age 60 adds mostly unproductive years, while reduced mortality at age 0-1 adds mostly productive years.
- j4yav 3y agoBut how does that make it completely wrong and a lie?
- antisthenes 3y agoWell, since I didn't say that, maybe you can enlighten us since you brought it up?
- j4yav 3y agoThe original comment said that every generation lives longer than the one that came before, and then gp said that that was a lie that keeps being repeated and is only infant mortality improving. Someone then replied with data showing that life expectancy is getting longer even setting aside infant mortality, to which you replied that the difference was that reduced mortality at age 60 adds mostly unproductive years, while reduced mortality at age 0-1 adds mostly productive years. My question was how that has any bearing on the question in this thread of whether or not people are living longer? It wasn't clear to me at least without more info. Or maybe it was just an unrelated tangent. But that lack of clarity is why I asked.
- subharmonicon 3y agoFrom: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK62591/#:~:text=On%20average%20across%20all%20population,of%201.3%20years%20per%20decade https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK62591/#:~:text=On%20av.... > On average across all population subgroups, people who survived to age 50 were expected to live over 8 years longer in 2000 than in 1940, corresponding to an increase in e50 from 23 years in 1940 to 31.3 years in 2006, or an average rise of 1.3 years per decade. An 8 year increase in life expectancy at age 50 (from 73 to 81.3) seems like a pretty large increase over the span of 60 years. I’d be more interested to know what the change in healthspan is, though. Living longer is less interesting to me than living longer in good health without worsening pain and disability.
- throw0101a 3y ago> Life expectancy has only been increasing because child mortality has decreased to almost zero. The upper end has not shifted much at all. A change of five to eight years makes a material difference in actuarial terms when you have to plan for retirement: > In 1920–1922, Canadian men who had lived to age 65 could expect to live for 13 more years, and women could expect to live for 13.5 more years (to age 78.0 and 78.5 respectively). The expected total life span of 65-year-olds was substantially higher than life expectancy at birth: 19.2 years higher for men and 18.0 years higher for women. > In 2009–2011, 65-year-old men were expected to live until they were 83.8, while 65-year-old women were expected to live until the age of 86.7. This means that from 1920–1922 to 2009–2011, the life expectancies of 65-year-olds increased by 5.8 years for men and 8.2 years for women. This is a much smaller gain than the 20-year increase in life expectancy for newborns during this same period. * https://www150.statcan.gc.ca/n1/pub/11-630-x/11-630-x2016002-eng.htm https://www150.statcan.gc.ca/n1/pub/11-630-x/11-630-x2016002... Starting at 65, the odds of hitting an age of 90 are worth considering when doing planning: > Assume we have 1,000 relatively healthy 65-year-old men. The chances of their staying alive at least until their 80s are quite good. More difficult, however, is avoiding critical illness – very serious conditions such as heart attacks, life-threatening cancers, stroke and Alzheimer’s. (There are 14 classifications in all.) While more than 500 of these men will survive until age 90, only 39 of them are expected to avoid a critical illness by that age. Of the 41 survivors at age 100, none is expected to be free of critical illness. * https://www.theglobeandmail.com/investing/personal-finance/retirement/article-what-are-the-odds-of-a-man-reaching-100-in-reasonably-good-health/ https://www.theglobeandmail.com/investing/personal-finance/r...
- jermaustin1 3y agoI get what you are trying to say, but your figures are a bit off. In the last few centuries (outside of war/famine/et), if you made it to "adulthood" (depending on the statistic 15-20 years old) and were male, you had a reasonable likelihood to live until "old age" (late-60s to early-70s). The problem is making it to adulthood wasn't straight forward. Until the 20th century, your likelihood to make it to adulthood was only 50/50. There even if you made it out of infancy, child labor, disease, food affordability, etc., were all major causes of death. Making it to adulthood meant that you were lucky or privileged. Now for calculating retirement ages for individuals who were adults when they started working, sure, the life expectancy has basically been flat. Maybe a few years of uptick, but nothing substantial like it seems looking at the overall stats of going from 45 to 75.
- bee_rider 3y agoRetirement seems like a pretty crucial process in the economy. If we set things up so that people can’t retire, that will slow down the process of getting the next generation into their positions. I do know some folks who have, instead, semi-retired (go in one or two days a week). People at the end of their careers have lots of experience to pass on. And it seems to keep them active and healthy. I wonder why we haven’t seen a growth in 1-2 day a week mentorship roles.
- pc86 3y ago> I wonder why we haven’t seen a growth in 1-2 day a week mentorship roles. If I had to hazard a guess I would say that most people in this position feel like they should get paid 50% of their previous salary for doing 20% of the work (and limiting their scope largely to mentorship rather than IC work), and with the combined scope reduction of both time and work performed, their employers would rather pay them even less than what a strict accounting of hours worked would indicate. Not to mention the fact that if your organization is so lop-sided that you only have experts near retirement and juniors who actually need 20% or more of their time being mentored, you're facing an existential staffing crisis.
- ethbr1 3y agoIt's funny that the companies I've seen do this productively all have "other justifications" for doing so. But effectively, yes, they're keeping high-performing older talent around so some hard won lessons rub off on the youngsters. I always thought companies should spend more time broadly categorizing employee allocation. E.g. this year you're going to be 20% mentor, 20% strategic advice, 60% IC Everyone wears multiple hats in a healthy company, and part of the ageism problem is that the only management-visible hat is "work produced."
- bee_rider 3y agoMaybe we need something like a university tenure program for private businesses, haha.
- siliconc0w 3y agoCompanies need to figure out how to keep the retiring around, a few days a week part time. There is a wealth of experience that gets lost . Companies are all in on AI but they're happy to let their pretrainined business domain finetuned trillion parameter models walk out the door.
- ghaff 3y agoAgeism is a thing. But most people want to wind down at some point. And that business domain knowledge probably leaks away over time. Certainly part-time work can be a thing. But to the degree it requires working together with other people it can be hard to manage, especially for a semi-retired person that wants to go on multi-week vacations.
- lolinder 3y ago> Ageism is a thing. But ... that business domain knowledge probably leaks away over time. This is ageism. A 66 year old hasn't lost their business knowledge yet, but they're often treated as though they're already senile.
- ghaff 3y agoI think you may have misunderstood me. It's not an age-related thing. If I only spend a day or so a week working in a domain, I am going to become less familiar with that domain as things change over time. It's certainly happened to me as my roles have shifted. Doesn't mean I forget everything about a space but I'm certainly less current if I spend 1 day per week than if I spend 5 days.
- throw0101a 3y agoTrying to do everything at once may not be practical. (Now-retired) Actuary Fred Vettese released a book a for those in the 20-40 age range on balancing major life expenses during that time period (mortgage/rent, kids/daycare, retirement), and he concluded that is was 'fine' if one didn't get a chance to really save for retirement during that time period: > In a nutshell, the 30 idea is a rule of thumb financial planners can use to guestimate how much young couples starting off on their financial journeys need to save for retirement. Rather than state something like save 10%, 12% or 15% of your gross (pre-tax) income each and every year, The Rule of 30 views retirement saving as occurring in tandem with daycare and mortgage repayment. > From the get-go, Vettese suggests young couples allocate 30% of their gross or after-tax income to those three major expenses: Retirement savings, daycare costs and mortgage payments. However, when starting out, they may have to save less in order to handle payments for daycare and the mortgage. Since daycare expenses are temporary after a few years or so (depending on how many children a couple has), once that expense has finished, they can ramp up the mortgage paydown and/or retirement savings. And if—ideally five years before retirement—the home mortgage is paid off, then couples can kick their retirement savings into overdrive by allocating a full 30%, or more, solely to building their retirement nest egg. * https://www.moneysense.ca/columns/retired-money/the-rule-of-30/ https://www.moneysense.ca/columns/retired-money/the-rule-of-... * https://www.myownadvisor.ca/the-rule-of-30-review/ https://www.myownadvisor.ca/the-rule-of-30-review/ * https://boomerandecho.com/the-rule-of-30-book-review/ https://boomerandecho.com/the-rule-of-30-book-review/ * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frederick_Vettese https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frederick_Vettese Anyone interested on reading up on retirement, especially if you're Canadian, should look at Vettese's work.
- voisin 3y agoIf you’re Canadian, and buying a house in the last 5 years, I think keeping those expenses to 30% of gross income is a dream out of reach for the vast majority of people. In larger markets where incomes are higher, mortgages alone are well over 30%.
- nytesky 3y agoMost people shouldn’t worry about how to work till retirement. Life expectancy trends have reversed and I suspect will worsen with more climate and zoonotic disease crossover, antibiotic resistance; though maybe mRNA cancer vax will balance that out. https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2022/12/22/1144864971/american-life-expectancy-is-now-at-its-lowest-in-nearly-two-decades https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2022/12/22/1144864... But the author is Canadian, working for the CBC, which I don’t think suffers from the ageism in most of corporate America. But if you are post retirement age, you are expensive and will be a target for employers because you certainly have lower future potential value by definition and there will be at least assumptions about reduced productivity. Outside of doctor/lawyer where people admire experience, maybe nearing retirement folks can work as teachers or walmart greeter, but high paying jobs will be in short supply and favor the young. If AI further quelches job creation, it will be even harder for old people to keep working.
- lolinder 3y ago> But the author is Canadian, working for the CBC, which I don’t think suffers from the ageism in most of corporate America About half the article is about ageism in Canada as an enormous barrier to working past 64. If anything what the author describes sounds worse than anything I've heard in the US (but maybe that's because I'm too young to see it yet).
- nytesky 3y agoI think ageism in Canada is bad, I just suspect CBC is less so — I equate it to NPR?
- apwell23 3y ago> “This is where our destitute end up, in these government-run facilities.” According to a 2019 report by the National Institute on Ageing at Toronto Metropolitan University, long-term care costs are expected to triple from $22 billion to $71 billion by 2050. “It will be the equivalent of the modern-day Victorian poor house for our old,” I would love to hear why old ppl don't choose to voluntarily end their life. What good is a life spent in 'poor house for the old' . seems kind of an obvious strategy to end your life but maybe will to live trumps all commonsense even in old age?
- dvngnt_ 3y agowhy should they? old people can live too
- automatic6131 3y ago>I would love to hear why old ppl don't choose to voluntarily end their life. 1) It's physically and psychologically hard to end your own life 2) You aren't going to feel old, you'll just feel like you do now, but with an achey body and some brainfog. 3) A society that encourages old people to shuffle off this mortal coil is probably a bad one
- voisin 3y ago> 3) A society that encourages old people to shuffle off this mortal coil is probably a bad one Why do you think this?
- WarOnPrivacy 3y agoI think this because declaring our loved ones extinguishable crosses the fattest line there is. And doing that based on a stat damns our judgment. Somewhere about here it becomes apparent that the value of our judgment is tied to the value we place on others.
- apwell23 3y ago> I think this because declaring our loved ones extinguishable crosses the fattest line there is. Maybe its just a social taboo and not a real line. most old ppl caring for elderly fulltime want their parents to be dead though. I've seen this personally in family members who totally transformed into different human beings in a good way once they were freed of the burden of caretaking. I could sense their hearts jumping with joy and relief when their parents finally passed away.
- Flux159 3y agoThe numbers in the article are quite alarming for some countries - 49.9 out of 100 Canadians dependent (so one dependent for every 2 workers according to article) by 2075, or 77 out of 100 for Japan by 2075. This seems like such a critical issue that governments around the world will need to have significant societal changes - at the moment this doesn't seem like something that tech or biotech will be able to solve simply.
- simbolit 3y agothe "significant societal changes" are immigration. as you can't change the birth rate overnight, and even if you could, it would take ~20years for the kids to begin earning, there needs to be a short-term solution. and that is immigration. good thing immigration is so popular in rich western societies at the moment.
- nec4b 3y agoThe problem is when the country can- or does not have any influence of what kind of immigrants they get. Not every country can get the best. In the case of Denmark for example, the immigration has been shown a net negative[0]. And you have to admit it is weird to live in a society with a self destructing culture, where foreigners are used as breading rabbits. [0] https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00148-017-0636-1 https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00148-017-0636-1
- simbolit 3y agoIf they aren't qualified, then you have to train them. If they don't have your values, you have to integrate them. That is complicated, takes a lot of effort and costs a lot of money. Everyone who thinks anything about the problem is cheap or easy is delusional. What is the alternative? Just let the population age?
- nec4b 3y agoWhat is the alternative? Just let the population age? I would say change the culture to become self sustaining again. The best time to start was yesterday and the second best time is today.
- d357r0y3r 3y agoOn one hand, we have older people retiring later and amassing wealth through their homes. On the other hand, we have young families who can't afford homes near their jobs and insane childcare costs. I think we just got too far away from the natural order where elders cycled out of the workforce and assumed family oriented duties. Doubt there's any going back though.
- WarOnPrivacy 3y ago> I think we just got too far away from the natural order where elders cycled out of the workforce and assumed family oriented duties. In a previous natural order, 3+ generations of families lived in close proximity and the labor of families was shared across grandparents, cousins, siblings, aunts & uncles. Natural orders seem to have acquired lifespans.
- zaptheimpaler 3y agohttps://www.cia.gov/the-world-factbook/field/dependency-ratios/ https://www.cia.gov/the-world-factbook/field/dependency-rati... Some numbers: Canada total dependency ratio: 52.1 youth dependency ratio: 23.9 elderly dependency ratio: 28.2 USA total dependency ratio: 53.7 youth dependency ratio: 28 elderly dependency ratio: 25.6 Japan total dependency ratio: 71.1 youth dependency ratio: 20.1 elderly dependency ratio: 51
- pc86 3y agoNobody is pushing abortion bans with retirement age or dependency ratio in mind.
- alephnerd 3y agoTell that to Ceaușescu /s You ain't wrong though, yet. We may see that argument coming up in the next 20 years.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ketzo 3y agoThe article talks about the dependency ratio in depth, including why it's not a perfect metric: aging people tend to disproportionately do work that is not tracked, e.g. volunteer work and caregiving.
- ethbr1 3y ago> Fewer than a quarter of retiring Canadians have a defined benefit pension plan The move from defined benefits to self -directed and -contributed retirement plans seems like a ticking time bomb. We know most people's financial literacy sucks. And the original reason for social security was that we don't want old people to suffer in poverty. Well... when people inevitably mismanage their own retirement, or suffer the whims of the market without the benefit of sophisticated pooling or hedging... we're going to be looking at that again. (Arguably, already are) A life of work isn't something you should be able to lose as quickly as you can.
- short_throw 3y agoFor much of the developed world, the ratio of retirees to working age people is going to get a larger, causing economic difficulties across age groups. Healthcare for the elderly will put huge strain on government budgets. With the young struggling to afford housing with fulltime work, I find the authors disappointments about not getting those lavish vacations obnoxious.
- ur-whale 3y ago> Want to keep your house? Support your kids? Stay alive? Move to a sane country.
- Nextgrid 3y agoIs there a list of such countries, primarily English-speaking? (serious question, as someone who left from one after it turned into an overpriced third-world dump and is now looking for a place to settle down)
- myvoiceismypass 3y agoWhich country did you leave? I'm curious.
- Nextgrid 3y agoUK.
- seydor 3y agoI expect economies will reshape to promote sorts of passive income in old age , particularly in europe which is decades ahead in the era of aging
- abledon 3y agoevery walrus article i've read seems to delivered in such a depressing and melancholic manner
- johnohara 3y agoI will work for as long as I am able. As my friend's father used to say, "I've never had a problem finding work. Ever. Getting paid for that work, now that's another matter."