6 ms·
The rise of the forever renters
- paulcole 3y agoI’m not wealthy by the standards discussed in the article but I’m a forever renter (a different kind than those in the article). I like living in dense cities, I dislike large living spaces, and I dislike being responsible for anything or doing any maintenance. Renting a small cheap apartment is something that fits my lifestyle and lets me do quite well financially.
- consp 3y ago> I dislike being responsible for anything or doing any maintenance Unfortunately so do a lot of property owners who rent out the spaces.
- paulcole 3y agoI’ve been renting cheap places in medium/large cities for 20+ years. So far it hasn’t been my experience. But my standards are probably lower than most people’s.
- Fergazi 3y agoThis has been my only experience in HCOL areas. Either the tenants do the maintenance or no maintenance occurs. Despite the fact that this is actually illegal in some instances, landlords are aware that legal action is not worthwhile from a tenants perspective. Its not so bad if you move around every year or two because landlords will do maintenance between tenants, or if you're renting higher-end properties. But if you're a forever-renter of cheap apartments, it can be quite a problem.
- skadamat 3y agoRenting is underrated, especially in the US I feel where people are constantly encouraged to buy a house. https://www.iwillteachyoutoberich.com/renting-is-not-a-waste/ https://www.iwillteachyoutoberich.com/renting-is-not-a-waste...
- Iulioh 3y ago[flagged]
- recursive 3y agoCould you be more specific about which parts you disagreed with and why?
- whateveracct 3y agoMaybe in the market this very moment it's tougher to buy, but I bought in 2020 and my mortgage + other expenses pretty much match what I was paying in an expensive city (Seattle). I didn't buy in Seattle but it's an easy drive away. And my house is 3k sqft vs the 800 I had in the city. And that space is put to work: Proper office, guestroom, gym room, much larger and nicer kitchen (which in turn saves me even more money because I cook more), charcoal grill outside, room for more guitars and drums, proper dining room for hosting family gatherings, a porch I can sit and smoke on. The list goes on. Grocery store is walkable and the neighborhood is nice to walk in for exercise. City experiences are 20-40 min away depending on which city I wanna hang out in. I guess I have to have a car but I had one in the city anyways since I liked to drive to destinations around Seattle. It's an old Civic still kicking so it's pretty cheap all told. For the same money per month, locked in for years. If I renewed my lease in 2020 during the pandemic instead of owning, I'd be materially less well off.
- blackguardx 3y agoWhat city do you live in now? When I lived in Seattle, most of the suburbs with 3k sqft houses weren't that walkable.
- whateveracct 3y agoI moved to a Tacoma suburb instead. Tacoma is a very cool city in its own right! It's my main city I do stuff in.
- daveguy 3y ago
- franczesko 3y agohttps://archive.ph/RRnUx https://archive.ph/RRnUx
- petermcneeley 3y agoAre they happy?
- irrational 3y agoI don’t understand how people are happy even when buying. The vast majority of homes I see being built around here have pretty much zero yards. How can anyone be happy when your neighbors are nearly close enough to reach out the window and touch on every side?
- reactordev 3y agoKids don’t play outside anymore. The more room you have for their screens the better. /s It’s an issue all around the United States. That and HOA’s. HOA’s had originally been a good thing (help a community pool together resources to pay for services the city can’t afford to provide). Things like paving, trash, landscaping, etc. Now, people see it as a business that they can run a “neighborhood” and charge $400/mo for each dwelling under their control. Add that to mortgage and insurance and some people end up having to pay more vs renting in the same area. Most people who commented here that they moved further out to afford the space is pretty much the status-quo since 1960. Push people to the burbs. Jack up the city price. “Don’t worry, there’s always another sucker”.
- RoyalHenOil 3y agoHOAs were never originally a good thing. From their very beginnings in the early 1900s, they served to exclude racial and religious minorities from buying homes. These racial/religious covenants were only struck down in 1968 with the Fair Housing Act. But because HOAs still get to investigate, interview, and reject prospective buyers, many of them still discriminate unofficially. As a consequence, some minorities (e.g., Black people) are underrepresented in HOA neighborhoods.
- inamberclad 3y agoThe problem with renting is that it's so expensive that it's hard to stop renting. How, in this market, do you save enough to buy when you can't afford to pay less rent? Most people are being squeezed between a rock and a hard place.
- dvh 3y agoLive with your parents, save money, then buy.
- micromacrofoot 3y ago“just don’t be poor”
- Groxx 3y agoAlso "be born somewhere with decent employment options". Tons of people move to find work.
- reactordev 3y agoSome people don’t have that luxury
- dsgnr 3y ago[dead]
- mattnewton 3y ago“Just have well off parents”
- dvh 3y agoThey didn't gave me a cent. Just living with them and not paying rent and food meant I could save almost 100% of income. After 13 years I was able to buy apartment.
- 3y ago
- markfinn 3y ago[dead]
- blindriver 3y agoThis is exactly what they turn us into: subscribers. They want us to keep paying them month after month, year after year a portion of our earnings forever. It’s the exact definition of indentured servant. It’s insidious and evil.
- epistasis 3y agoWhat do you think homeownership entails? No maintenance, carefree profits from ever increasing land rents only? No property taxes? Who is "they" here, beyond the typical business person?
- blindriver 3y agoIt’s generational ownership. My house will be paid off by the time I die. My kids will inherit it and probably in 25 years house prices will be so high that no one will be able to afford a house. I truly envision the situation so dire that they may need to both live in our house with 2 families but that will be better than suckling off the rest of the hedge funds buying up all the houses and developers forcing prices sky high. Hedge funds need to be barred from owning single family homes. Them buying tens of thousands of homes is hurting the country and future generations.
- EA-3167 3y agoHouses don't last forever, you pay taxes, have to make fixes (sometimes really big ones), you need insurance and most people have a mortgage. Even if you're able to buy a house outright, and the future maintenance is no bother, who's to say that anyone in your family will want to hang on to your idea of good property? Maybe they'll sell it for cash, or turn around and rent it. The odds of a single average dwelling staying in one family for a LONG time can't be that high.
- RoyalHenOil 3y agoWhen you rent, you are still paying for taxes, fixes, insurance, mortgage, and all other costs associated with the home you live in. But you pay even more, on top of all of that, so that the landlord can make a profit. Otherwise, there is no incentive to rent the home out. If you own your own home, though, you are not paying for anyone else's livelihood: that profit all goes to you in the form of reduced living expenses. And in the end, you pay off your mortgage and now outright own an asset that can benefit your descendants for generations (whether they choose to keep it or sell it).
- ebiester 3y agoAlternatively, the kind of real estate that these "forever renters" would like to buy are either not built or not available at the prices that they can afford. I wasn't able to buy in San Francisco or Boston without a two hour commute, but renting was achievable. Now that I live in a middle cost-of-living area making a remote salary, I was able to buy at a reasonable price relative to renting. On top of that, the labor market as it is rewards those who are willing to be flexible with their city of residence in many industries, and the transaction costs of moving are more expensive when you are buying and selling real estate. Further, the costs of buying in many cities are higher than renting for time periods of less than 10 years. This is again an article that couches structural issues as personal decisions.
- kazinator 3y agoDue to immigration, the demand is practically inexhaustible. You cannot build fast enough to fix the problem.
- epistasis 3y agoWhat will all those new people do, maybe some fraction will build homes... For places like the US, which this article is about, we are nowhere near a high rate of immigration, and population growth is nowhere near historical rates. What is at historical rates is restriction on the ability to build homes. We have never had greater artificial restrictions on growth than now. Our history do the past century is coming up with ways to prevent the natural densification that humanity has used throughout its history.
- RecycledEle 3y agoIf you want to increase home ownership, you either need to change renters priorities, or pay them more, or make buying a house more affordable.
- wnc3141 3y agoI think this all boils down to steering all economic policy toward increasing the labor share of income.
- Gibbon1 3y agoOld idea of mine was to institute renters old age insurance systems sort of like social security. Tax rentals and use the money to provide a subsidy for retired renters. I've gotten any number of objections when I've mentioned it. But I think it's fair when you consider the tax advantages homeowners and landlords get.
- ponector 3y agoIf you will pay renters more - prices will simply go up. The only solution is to increase available for rent housing. Good solution could be city owned condos with apartments for rent.
- vlark 3y agoThese developments are being built "stick and brick" style, with highly flammable softwood two-by-fours for their framing structures and less-than-an-inch thick brick veneers for the overlay over the Teflon building wrap. I don't want to be at the mercy of someone else's misplaced cigarette, grease fire, or electrical short circuit. We need to build more affordable, smaller homes instead of more ugly McMansions and apartment buildings. Additional reading: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2019-02-13/why-america-s-new-apartment-buildings-all-look-the-same https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2019-02-13/why-ameri... Non-paywalled version: https://archive.is/rfnFz https://archive.is/rfnFz
- mupuff1234 3y agoI wonder how the housing market will cope when we start seeing falling demographics around the world.
- jmoak3 3y agoYou don't need to wonder. Look to Japan for the broad strokes: property in cities will still have value while rural areas fall into decay. In more words: young people will crowd into cities in order to meet other young people and find work, while aged areas descend into irrelevance and whatever this is: [1] Due to this, Greater Tokyo now contains 1/3rd the population of Japan[2]. While you can find a number of articles claiming it's cheap compared to metros in other countries, or horrifically expensive[3][4], whichever it may be it is certainly better than what's in [1]. [1] https://unusualplaces.org/nagoro-a-creepy-japanese-village-where-dolls-replace-the-departed/ https://unusualplaces.org/nagoro-a-creepy-japanese-village-w... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greater_Tokyo_Area https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greater_Tokyo_Area [3] https://www.reuters.com/markets/asia/surging-tokyo-property-prices-squeeze-out-young-professionals-2023-10-04/ https://www.reuters.com/markets/asia/surging-tokyo-property-... [4] https://www.businessinsider.com/america-build-like-tokyo-housing-crisis-doom-loop-2023-10 https://www.businessinsider.com/america-build-like-tokyo-hou...
- tagami 3y agoFrom the article: "Homes in Scranton—which is a roughly two-hour drive from Philadelphia, New York City and Syracuse and is now known for being where the hit mockumentary show “The Office” took place—are listed at a median price of $179,900 on listing platform Realtor.com. With a $150,000, 30-year mortgage at a rate of 7% on such a home, average monthly payments would be around $1,000. " Homes are affordable. Just not where most people would like to live.
- deterministic 3y agoI can afford to buy a house but it makes more sense economically to buy assets instead. A house is not an asset in my view unless you buy it to rent out. And buying a house to rent out might not be the best way to invest long term. I highly recommend actually sitting down and doing a detailed value/cost comparison of what makes most sense over the long term. The result might surprise you. It certainly surprised me when I did it.
- wjcroft 3y agoNo mention of CLT Community Land Trusts. https://groundedsolutions.org/strengthening-neighborhoods/community-land-trusts https://groundedsolutions.org/strengthening-neighborhoods/co...