6 ms·
heat exchangers are pretty important. does anyone have a summary of the high points in this thread? https://ecorenovator.org/forum/showpost.php?p=54888&postco
by kragen 3y ago
heat exchangers are pretty important. does anyone have a summary of the high points in this thread? https://ecorenovator.org/forum/showpost.php?p=54888&postcount=518 https://ecorenovator.org/forum/showpost.php?p=54888&postcoun... seems to be kostas's summary of their completed build, documented in more detail at https://diyvmc.wordpress.com/ https://diyvmc.wordpress.com/ and with an overview video at https://youtu.be/phIWQD5LAcA https://youtu.be/phIWQD5LAcA
i have a couple of big unknowns about ventilation heat exchangers for houses, and i'm wondering if anybody knows the answers to these questions:
- why is everybody using recuperators when a regenerator would be mechanically much simpler? i'd understand if preventing mass flow was important, but in fact this thread says that in some cases they build their recuperators with water-permeable heat exchange membranes in order to facilitate mass flow of water, which is the main mass flow that a regenerator would introduce here. why don't people use regenerators?
- now that the price of solar energy has fallen so much, and in particular solar panels cost half what they did even a year ago, will house ventilation heat exchangers remain economical?
- nine_k 3y agoI suppose that heat exchanger ventilation makes most sense at winter time. Not everybody lives in San Diego, a lot of people live in New York, Boston, Chicago, Seattle, etc, where a winter is a thing.
- genman 3y agoAlso during hot summer when outside temperature is hotter than inside - you don't want ventilation to bring in hot air.
- kragen 3y agoi think heat exchanger ventilation makes roughly the same amount of sense whenever you're spending costly energy to change the temperature of your space, doesn't it? it works just as well to keep summer heat out as to keep winter heat in, and staying cool in summer can be just as critical as staying warm in winter, depending on where you live the main difference is that you can heat up a house (inefficiently) with a nichrome wire or a gas burner, while cooling it requires considerably more elaborate equipment but if electricity costs 2¢ per kilowatt hour and daytime electricity is free, will the savings of a heat exchanger be enough to pay for the device?
- spockz 3y agoElectricity here is €0,30-0,40/kWh after tax. (Netherlands) (For fixed contact, dynamic contacts have bigger variation). That makes it way more interesting to save on energy. Although getting solar panels is still the fastest investment. Heat pumps typically have 10-15years payback time, especially now they are insanely overpriced due to Ukrainian-Russian war and climate goals increasing demand and lowering supply.
- kragen 3y agoso when electricity costs drop by 15–20× the payback time will be 150–300 years?
- marcosdumay 3y agoThe temperature difference most home heaters work on is much higher than the one most home coolers work on. Using a regenerator to get 5°C of cooling back with some 30% of efficiency probably won't be cost-effectice. But if you have to heat by some 30°C, the numbers change a lot.
- kragen 3y agohmm, are you saying that the regenerator (or recuperator) has lower efficiency at lower ΔT? or lower efficiency when it's more a ΔH than a ΔT? because if that 5° of cooling and dehumidification costs you the same US$100 a month as the 30° of heating, saving 80% of it will still be US$80 a month
- nine_k 3y agoWinter has much less sunlight, so powering a heat pump via solar panels + moderate battery becomes much harder. It's no longer mostly free.
- Open_erv 3y agoYou can understand quantitatively how this goes for different areas using Heating degree days and Cooling degree days, factoring in latent heat in both cases, ideally. There are calculators for this. I made a spreadsheet on my website www.openerv.ca that shows some of how to reckon this, there are links in there to get data. In Austin, texas, I think you got quite a bit more energy and money saved per year from avoiding cooling costs, but in Ottawa, Canada, you save about 100x as much in winter as you ever could in summer.
- kragen 3y agothanks, this is fantastic information!
- schiffern 3y ago>why is everybody using recuperators when a regenerator would be mechanically much simpler? They exist, search for "ductless HRV." They're simply a small fan that reverses every few minutes and a heat storage material. They also have wireless ones that coordinate the fan direction between them.
- kragen 3y agothanks! don't you need at least two fans and two chambers of heat storage material?
- schiffern 3y agoThat's how the wireless kind works. One unit blows in while a second identical unit (theoretically located across the house) blows out, and they switch roughly every minute. This balances the airflow, so you don't get non-regenerated (or more accurately, less regenerated) airflow "somewhere else" like you do if you use a single unit. "in thermal regenerators, the hot and cold fluids pass through the same channels in the packing, alternately, both fluids washing the same surface area. In recuperators, the hot and cold fluids pass simultaneously through different but adjacent channels."[0] So these regenerative-type HRVs alternate the flow direction of the air, using the packing material as a thermal "battery" to warm the incoming fresh air from the outgoing exhaust air. While they are indeed simpler, my understanding is that they don't really perform well. There's no humidity recovery, the CFM is too low, the cheap units don't do any active pressure balancing, you can't continuously exhaust from bathrooms/kitchens, and the lack of net flow to distribute air throughout the house means you're mostly exhausting the fresh air you just brought in. Not great. If you're going cheap, skip the regenerator-type and the HRVs altogether and go straight to a jury-rig ERV.[1] Though again, ideally you can run flex duct (or temporarily on the interior, even just dryer hose) to pull exhaust air from the opposite side of the house, and specifically from bathroom/kitchen areas. However, first you should test your CO2 levels and/or do a blower-door test. Most buildings aren't tight enough to need an ERV anyway! [0] https://www.thermopedia.com/content/1087/ https://www.thermopedia.com/content/1087/ [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CnLwJxCbxfM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CnLwJxCbxfM
- andbberger 3y agocommercial systems often use rotary regenerators
- kragen 3y agoindeed!