4 ms·
I have mixed feelings about this. It could be a great tool to help people, but on past experience it seems more likely that HR departments/ financial service pr
by anigbrowl 3y ago
I have mixed feelings about this. It could be a great tool to help people, but on past experience it seems more likely that HR departments/ financial service providers/ governments would use it to write people off if they have too many negative life indicators.
- reactordev 3y agoThis. It would be the envy of every insurance company. How risky are you really? I’m glad I’m not the only one that immediately thought about this.
- matrix87 3y agoInsurance companies are probably already doing something like this anyway
- m463 3y agoI remember talking to an actuary once. Actuaries have to be scientifically accurate with respect to risk. If they underestimate the risk, the premiums don't cover the losses. If they overestimate them, they lose in the market. So I asked her if a red sports car should REALLY be that much more expensive to insure than a grey family car. She told me, yes, the pricing actually correlates very well with the risk. The only time when pricing is NOT correlated with the risk is AFTER an accident. Statistically after an accident, drivers become safer, but the insurance companies will not lower the rates charged to reflect it.
- junofan 3y agoThey’re doing it anyway. Sunlight is the best disinfectant.
- MattDaEskimo 3y agoI'd like to believe that lives are way too nuanced to properly train and evaluate a transformer this way. Also, I would wager that upon release, suddenly everybody says they eat healthy and exercise daily.
- shadowgovt 3y agoI have an acquaintance who is convinced that Google ads stalk him because the ads make inferences yet shouldn't be able to, like offering flight prices from one city to another he frequents when he's never done that search in Google before. I've tried to explain to him that people aren't actually very unique in large models, and there's probably several signals Google does have from his other searches to conclude he's interested in those two cities.
- jedberg 3y agoDoes he use Gmail? Because it gets all of his flight confirmations and Calendar events. Does he use Google Maps, because it gets his realtime location whenever he uses it. If he frequently goes to those cities, they would certainly know if he uses any other Google service.
- wharvle 3y agoEvery time we get better at things like this, all the power tends to stay with organizations, and individual people are lucky if they get anything out of it. Amazon, Wal-Mart, MacDonalds, giant banks, insurers, et c., analyze their competition, suppliers, and consumers in great detail with computer data and models. Where’s the widespread automated buyer’s agent for consumers, to balance that power so strongly that it shoves profit margins the other direction, so it’s not just megacorps pushing ever closer to some absolute limit of the last tenth of a cent they can wring out of us? Fucking nowhere, they’d never allow that kind of access to the data we’d need, the best we get is “CamelCamelCamel”, not some Siri-alike we can casually tell to go find the best price/quality intersection on the market for [product] and have that show up a couple days later. And we’ll never get it. Just an ever-tightening noose of perfect price discrimination and risk calculation that goes only one way. Short of legislating radical levels of availability (and reliability and consistency—standards and minimums) for price and product information, anyway, and I’m pretty sure that’s on nobody’s radar.
- zmgsabst 3y agoScraping is legal; as are assistive technologies. What’s lacking is the collective willpower to develop social organizations, which could orchestrate and fund such efforts. There’s a complete lack of organization among the public. The problem is neither technical nor legislative: people just don’t care to, and are happier accepting the status quo.
- garrisonhh 3y agoPeople don't have the time, money, or energy. And they will continue to lose all three until there is no option but to figure out collective organisation
- nehal3m 3y agoIt definitely feels deliberate and yeah it is a feedback loop.
- 3y ago
- derbOac 3y agoThis is a critical problem of our time in my opinion. Persons are approached as static unchangeable objects, as if their trajectories are deterministic and what you're doing with these models are resolving the trajectories like a telescope or microscope. Measuring the substance of the person so you can extract from them. The other schema is one where you're modeling manipulation effectiveness, to probe and predict how you can best (most effectively with the least resources) achieve some change in the trajectory. Engineering a person. It seems like we really only think of interventions as trying to return someone to some baseline condition, rather than to try to improve people beyond the baseline, to invest in them. The paper has a bit at the end about using it for personalized interventions but it feels performative, like lip service. I know one of the authors professionally in a distant sense so I think they're probably genuine about it, but I can't help but wonder how the paper might be different if intervention was actually their focus. Wouldn't they be modeling changes in trajectories, the deviations or something?