6 ms·
Teslas Have a Minor Issue Where the Wheels Fly Off While Driving, Documents Show
- clouddrover 3y agoWashing the cars has been a problem too. From the Reuters report: > Lundeen said in an interview that a Tesla service manager told him that a power-steering connector had corroded. The manager said the likely cause was a car wash, which he described as a known problem. Lundeen paid $4,400 to replace the steering rack and a wiring harness. “This is the only car that I’ve ever heard of where a car wash can damage the wiring,” Lundeen recalled telling the manager. Lundeen said he was so shocked by the manager’s frank explanation of Tesla’s part failures that he wrote it down: “All I can tell you,” the Tesla manager said, “is we’re not a 100-year-old company like GM and Ford. We haven’t worked all the bugs out yet.”
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- FireBeyond 3y ago> “All I can tell you,” the Tesla manager said, “is we’re not a 100-year-old company like GM and Ford. We haven’t worked all the bugs out yet.” Meanwhile, his boss: > At this point, I know more about manufacturing than anybody else on Earth.
- nothercastle 3y agoToyota had this problem and they recalled all the vehicles.
- hedora 3y agoI’m a bit surprised tesla managed to get the guy with 115 miles on the car to pay for the collapsed suspension. Maybe they don’t have lemon laws there? I hoping a class action lawsuit more than covers these peoples’ expenses.
- dkjaudyeqooe 3y agoLemon laws apply to individual cars that cannot be fixed after repeated repair attempts. This though is simply Tesla abusing customers.
- posguy 3y agoA fool and his money are quickly separated. The guy probably didn't educate himself as a consumer and did not want to put more effort into chasing Tesla to uphold their legal commitments. Perhaps he read about https://www.theverge.com/2020/10/5/21502379/tesla-modely-roof-flies-off-convertible-quality-issue https://www.theverge.com/2020/10/5/21502379/tesla-modely-roo... and decided to take the loss and move on. Tesla's target demographics often skew towards those that are well to do financially, a good subset of which are not native. This is an easier to abuse subset of the population as they are not clued into how to use their state Attorney General to push Tesla to make it right, or use the other legal avenues available.
- netsharc 3y agoI suppose someone who's done the research wouldn't buy a Tesla in the first place... A bit like Nigerian spammers and phishers having sloppy writing, which is (either by design or not) a filter so only the less mentally able readers would fall into their net by responding.
- fifteen1506 3y agoHow come the market doesn't fix this?
- jeffbee 3y agoNot enough credible competitors.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dilyevsky 3y agoYou take the population of vehicles in the field A and multiple it by the probable rate of failure B, then multiply the result by the average cost of an out-of-court settlement C. A times B times C equals X. If X is less than the cost of a recall, then we don't recall.
- jtaft 3y agoAssume we lived in a communist society instead. How would you view the problem differently?
- code_duck 3y agoAct to prevent maiming and killing customers and the public even if it costs the company more money?
- dieselgate 3y agoIt's a quote from Fight Club
- tempestn 3y agoYou'd be less likely to recall, because there's no longer a risk of lawsuit.
- inamberclad 3y agoWhy would a communist society not have a risk of a lawsuit?
- dilyevsky 3y agoIn all the attempts that have been tried there was no separation of judiciary power (generally it’s a lot easier to murder and rob millions of their property when this is the case) so good luck suing the state that controls all courts
- jtaft 3y agoInteresting, In either system I don’t think I would take resources used for lawsuits into account and get the vehicles fixed (or replaced, until they are safe). We have the responsibility to care for each-other.
- blindriver 3y agoWhy aren’t Tesla sales taking at this point? It’s been two years of continuous bad news against Elon.
- fleventynine 3y agoWhen the news stops being consistent with my lived experience, I stop paying attention.
- kbos87 3y agoIn my experience, enough of the “news” about Tesla has proven to be strongly biased that I default to assuming this is another piece of clickbait following a narrative that reporters know has traction at this moment in time.
- jameshart 3y agoThis - "TESLAS CRASH MORE THAN ANY OTHER BRAND" - https://futurism.com/the-byte/teslas-crash-more-brand-analysis-finds https://futurism.com/the-byte/teslas-crash-more-brand-analys... - certainly ought to be manifesting in differential insurance rates, right?
- natch 3y agoThis is such a ridiculous distortion. Not by you, by the headline writers. The study found nothing of the sort. The study found that people who were interested in insuring a Tesla had a higher accident rate than other people. These are people many of whom do not even own a Tesla yet. And have never driven a Tesla. And did not have an accident in a Tesla. SOME of them did have an accident in a Tesla, but many (an unknown number, the article is not interested in facts) did not. They did have an accident, probably not in a Tesla, and possibly not even their fault. So. They have an accident, and for some subset of people, the accident was bad enough that they need to acquire another car. Then some of them think "hmm, what kind of car should I buy." And some of them think "hey, what about Tesla?" And some of them go ask for a quote to see how much insurance would cost. And they just had an accident. And the study records, for people looking to insure a given brand, who may not even own that brand yet, how many of them had accidents in the past. The study says less about whether Tesla owners have accidents, and more about what new car people are interested in. And yet the article distorts this to be "Teslas crash more than any other brand." Wow. And then people uncritically repost it, and here we are. There is a reason the media gets criticism, and a reason people are advised to be skeptical.
- ramadan_steve 3y ago[dead]
- userbinator 3y agoEVs don't need to be any different in suspension parts than conventional vehicles, yet Tesla apparently thought otherwise. Reinventing the wheel, literally. I'm not an expert but I know that the cast suspension parts they're using won't take overloads as gracefully as traditional stamped steel ones; the latter will bend before breaking and give a lot of early warning of failure, while the former tends to just snap. Combine that with aggressive cost/weight optimisation along with natural manufacturing variance and these failures are not surprising.
- jader201 3y ago> EVs don't need to be any different in suspension parts than conventional vehicles This came across HN a few week ago. It seems like there are fundamental reasons why/how EV wheels/suspension can be designed differently than ICE vehicles: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38471815 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38471815
- dieselgate 3y agoGood call out about the cast vs stamped parts, didn't know that. One of the owners in the article mentioned "didn't know metal could break like that" - it usually doesn't unless it's cast
- anigbrowl 3y agoConcerning
- dieselgate 3y ago> who's had to pay over $10,000 to keep his 2016 Model X on the road Jeeez, I know this is an exception and not the rule but this is bonkers.
- simondotau 3y agoYou say it’s bonkers, I’d argue that a very small risk of a large repair bill is the norm for 10 year old cars from many brands. There are some brands (e.g. Range Rover) where bills like that are closer to the rule than the exception. A friend of mine paid more than that on a Volkswagen Passat engine replacement. Another friend of mine received a bill for nearly $10k to rebuild a diesel engine in a Volkswagen Golf (which he didn’t pay, the car was ultimately totaled).
- Fischgericht 3y agoAs an owner of a 2020 Model 3 in Germany I can say: The build quality is shockingly bad, and the quality assurance basically non-existing. When I picked up the car, the doors weren't aligned properly and would not close. I had to point this out for them to correct it. Everything that you take for granted with all car manufactures to work in a middle-class sedan does not work. They did not put in a $3 Bosch rain sensor, so not even the camera-based automatic wipers work correctly. Everything that worked in my 15 years old Chrysler 300C does not work. It's insane that any of their Autopilot related features are legal. The system is detecting 100% of trash bins next to the road, but maximum 50% of kids crossing the road. If you don't manually disable the various driver assistance systems every time you enter the car, the "emergency lane assist" stuff will happily drive you into opposing traffic for no reasons and will do dangerous phantom emergency braking etc. Whatever traditional car feature you are looking at - compared to the 15 years old Chrysler everything is worse. Wind noise. Audio system. Comfortable seats. All the "But it works in my Tesla" fan boys are part of a religious cult and are simply lying. Whenever I checked, the "works for me" replies stopped when I either did a test drive together or asked for a video showing that things like wipers and assistance systems really work. So, why did I buy this car then and did not return it? - Their battery technology is mature. When you try to buy a EV from an "established" car manufacturers most of them still don't have a heat pump and battery temperature conditioning. - You can BUY them. While Germany's big pride, Volkswagen, are announcing to maybe have a competitive EV in 2026, and other manufacturers have waiting lists of 6 months and up, when I wanted to buy the Model 3 I ordered it and was able to pick it up one week later. Actually being able to BUY a real car instead of vaporware is a killer feature. - All of the nerd humor, Easter eggs etc. It's refreshing to see that they fail on getting basic car software features to work, but that at least they are having fun implementing wacky fun stuff. Obviously due to Elon Musk meanwhile having turned into a conspiracy-spewing crazy fascist, I would not buy a Tesla car again. But if I'd want to buy a EV in Germany today with proper battery technology and acceptable delivery times, I still would not have any other choice. I would have to buy something far inferior at a higher price "just" for political reasons.
- saturn_vk 3y ago> All the "But it works in my Tesla" fan boys are part of a religious cult and are simply lying. Whenever I checked, the "works for me" replies stopped when I either did a test drive together or asked for a video showing that things like wipers and assistance systems really work. So all those fanboys are lying, but we should definitely trust your take on this?
- pacunningham 3y agoMaybe it was the Focus groups fault for not reminding Tesla this shouldn’t happen https://youtu.be/8YDpvMYk5jA?si=3pMVgoOHBo8T9_hM https://youtu.be/8YDpvMYk5jA?si=3pMVgoOHBo8T9_hM
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoWhen I lived in Beijing I saw a poorly modified compact car (maybe a civic or a scion?) have all four of its wheels pop off while speeding down the third ring road. We were in the taxi behind, these things always happen in slow motion so the wheels popped, the sparks flew beneath the car, it hit another car and finally careened to the side of the road, we saw him get out of the car before our taxi just continued on as if nothing happened. Anyways, I scratched that off my list of things to see.
- tivert 3y ago> What keeps Tesla from having that knowledge, then, isn't that the company is too young to have acquired it, or that it simply cannot be had except by learning it from scratch. The knowledge can be had in the person of any number of far-less-than-100-years-old engineers Tesla could hire; moreover it can be had by reverse-engineering a frickin' Miata. The reason Tesla hasn't "worked all the bugs out yet" is that the company is run by people who hold established best practice in ideological contempt, and is defined by a tech-industry culture that fetishizes innovation and regards product quality as a third-order concern. There simply isn't as much investment money and credulous tech-media adulation to suck up in the promise of iterating on what already works. You must reinvent, almost literally in this case, the wheel—this time, apparently on the premise of "...and what if it sucked?" > All the upside-down incentives and warped prerogatives of the startup world are on display here (including a preference for lying and monkeying with data over actually doing good work). They're also, in turn, mere appendages of a deeper and more profound decadence. In 2023, discovery, exploration, and invention are just vibes you rent, by investing in a future-costumed effort to ignore all of what's already been learned and pretend "making a car that works" (or tunnels, or spaceships, or social media) is a new frontier. Yes.
- enslavedrobot 3y agoSo easy to manipulate people. My control arms were the bad kind. One side of the car started squeaking after 4.5 years. They switched them out for the latest revision in an afternoon for 200 bucks. Gave me a sweet loaner car in the meantime. That was the first maintenance I ever had to pay for on my car aside from new tires. In my now 5 years of ownership my Tesla has been less hassle than any other car I've ever owned. Its "up time" has been spectacular.