8 ms·
New York’s attorney general says SiriusXM’s cancellation process is illegal
- chewmieser 3y agoOh great, Letitia James’ office is on a roll! It’s well known how annoying this process is with deal communities, to the point that everyone recommends using temporary cards (like Privacy) to avoid the hassle with cancellations. Unfortunately that doesn’t stop the mountain of sales outreach they’ll try after you’re no longer a subscriber.
- cyanydeez 3y agoI'm surprised someone hasn't started a "Warehouse POBOX" style address location where you can just maintain like a 5 dollar address as long as you complete appropiate paperwork. Obviously, that'd be abused, but man, all these lawless corporations acting with impunity to common decent regulation enforcement makes some aweful work for no particular value to society.
- jabroni_salad 3y agovirtual mailing addresses are real. I have one for my LLC (they bin spam and forward on real correspondence) and there are more involved services for RVers to forward batches to their current location or do mail-to-email.
- henrikschroder 3y agoThere's a ton of services like that. You pick one of the physical addresses they offer, get a unique mail address to you, and whenever mail arrives they scan the envelope, giving you the choice to either shred, open and scan contents, or forward.
- csdvrx 3y ago> they scan the envelope, giving you the choice to either shred, open and scan contents, or forward That's nice! Can you suggest one (or more) services you like? Does it have to be in the state you live in? (ex: matching the driver license address)
- henrikschroder 3y agoI used one years ago, and I think it was this one: https://travelingmailbox.com/ https://travelingmailbox.com/ They have a bunch of addresses for you to pick from, and it works the same way for any other similar service, so check around and see if one has addresses that you like. The keyword is "mail forwarding service". For US addresses, there's a form you have to sign and get notarized to authorize them to handle your mail, because USPS does not fuck around with people illegally handling someone's mail.
- hiatus 3y agoIn my experience, there is a bit of friction as you need to get a form from the post office and have it notarized before a third-party can accept and forward mail on your behalf.
- davchana 3y agoI hope (& have suggested) that USPS themselves should offer virtual po boxes like domain name, which themselves should have an underlying forwarding address (with no leakage to companies like data lists, forwarding address requested etc). Company sends a letter to me at that virtual po box, usps scanner systems see it, slap a yellow (or brown) sticker with correct/forwarding address.
- angryjim 3y agoThis is why things like Rocket Money exist-which itself is hard to cancel.
- apwell23 3y agonow do nytimes. Not sure how it compares to sirius but its one of the most ridiculous process i've personally experienced
- js2 3y agoIn the past you had to chat with a rep, but for at least a couple years now you can cancel your NYT subscription with just a couple clicks. You can also pretty much perennially keep your sub at $1/week w/o talking to a rep just by starting the cancellation flow when the promo rate nears expiration.
- garfij 3y agoThanks for this, I"d been meaning to work up the energy to deal with their retention ops, but this was super easy. For anyone else looking to do this, the trick is to choose "Other" instead of "Too expensive" or "My rate is going up" as the reason for cancelling. The later will just result in them trying to sell other standard subscription offers to you.
- rurp 3y agoSame for The Economist. I was about to enter my payment details for a subscription but then thought to check what the cancellation process was. Turns out it's one of those sleazy processes that's way harder than signing up. Just to be sure I contacted their customer support to see if there was a way to cancel online. They confirmed that there was not, and then had the gall to say that this is because it's better for customers this way. The content itself is good but I will never ever give money to a company that treats its paying customers this way. Substack probably has a similar customer base and does things the right way. A paid subscription can be cancelled with an easy to find button. The money I would have spent on The Economist instead goes to several substack authors that I like.
- wzy 3y agoSave the sale.
- bryan0 3y agoHah I went through this last year. I canceled Sirius/XM with an agent over chat. Basically you just need to paste: "no thanks, I would just like to cancel my account" to everything they say. After about 10 times they will actually do it.
- seiferteric 3y agoSame here, but just said I want to cancel, and am screen-shotting the conversation, if it is not cancelled I will file a complaint, and they ended the chat and cancelled it. Pretty egregious that you have to resort to that. Also they have the audacity to send me letters every couple weeks to sign back up for like $4 a month. I might consider that if I knew I it was easy to cancel... so they lost a customer over it. I think they must be desperate with how everyone can just stream music almost everywhere now.
- op00to 3y agoIf you have a modernish smartphone you have no need for SiriusXM unless you like to listen to sports or talk radio in the middle of nowhere. I stopped paying XM after getting tired of the cancel and get a cheaper offer dance, and never once missed it.
- dboreham 3y agoWaving from the middle of nowhere...also some content besides sports is annoying to acquire via IP (CNBC for example).
- defparam 3y agoThis is exactly why I place SiriusXM on a virtual credit card and a throw away email. I sign up for $6 per month SiriusXM promo with a $7 per month ceiling on the virtual card. When the 7th or 8th month comes around and the offer expires they have the audacity to charge $22+ for this content. The overcharge is caught and they don't get my money, and I'm happy to receive the disconnect signal.
- bogomipz 3y agoI'm curious why do business at all with a company who has such practices and requires such special workarounds?
- digging 3y agoNot the person you're replying to, but when you get in this mindset the workarounds are pretty easy. I don't trust any business to act responsibly with any information I give them, so I also use a lot of virtual cards and spoofed email addresses (actually I just use a catchall on my domain most of the time which is less secure I guess, but does most of what I need).
- defparam 3y agoIt's because generally I do like their product at a $6/mo price point. It's leagues better than FM radio. I just don't like their billing/promo practices and so these are the tricks to protect yourself as a consumer.
- bogomipz 3y agoI see. Might you or others recommend some virtual credit card products?
- tomcatfish 3y agoPrivacy.com is what I've used the past half decade
- 3y ago
- chimeracoder 3y agoSiriusXM is also in violation of GDPR/CCPA. Before shutting down Stitcher, they failed to respond to multiple data requests within the required 30 day window. Then, they contacted requestors 20 days before Stitcher shut down to direct them to complete a separate, redundant form for their request. They never responded to that form, and presumably they will claim that because the service was shut down within 30 days of that second form being completed, they have no obligations to provide the data anymore. Pretty scummy stuff.
- tacticalturtle 3y agoSiriusXM doesn’t operate in Europe - so I don’t think GDPR is among their concerns. https://www.siriusxm.com/help/service-outside-us https://www.siriusxm.com/help/service-outside-us
- chimeracoder 3y ago> SiriusXM doesn’t operate in Europe - so why would they care about GDPR? SiriusXM is a holding company that operates many products, some of which are sold in Europe, and in California, so as a company they are beholden to both GDPR and CCPA.
- tacticalturtle 3y agoWhich products are available in Europe? The only other major service I can see is Pandora - which also does not have a presence in Europe.
- yumraj 3y agoThis should apply to AT&T, Xfinity and such also who force you to speak with the retention department.
- LegitShady 3y agoDo gym membership cancellations next.
- seanw444 3y agoMy truck came with a short SiriusXM trial, and they have not relented in spamming me with physical mail, email, and phone calls, all to try and get me to renew. I'll stick to my downloaded music and Spotify.
- Sohcahtoa82 3y agoI had a similar experience when I had a trial with my previous car. I got the calls to stop by changing the phone number on my account. For e-mail/physical mail, there was an opt out that I found and to my surprise, they actually stopped. But yeah, it was ridiculous. I'd get mail a minimum of once a week asking for me to come back. So much wasted paper.
- brewdad 3y agoHonestly, if SiriusXM would simply offer a fair price for life I would pay for it. I refuse to do business with companies that force me to play the "threaten to cancel" game every year just to keep a fair price. My time is worth more than that.
- davchana 3y agoDont click any link in the emails, dont scan any qr code, don't call any numbers on postal mail, and they will stop in about 2 years (as in my case, no paid membership, used car came with some free trial, I didn't even used it once).
- Cthulhu_ 3y agoI love my European laws that would fine them if they were to do something like that.
- plagiarist 3y agoI would be thrilled if there were repercussions for this kind of scammer in the US. I keep getting "SECOND NOTICE" physical mail from scammers who have 1. never sent a first notice and 2. never had any business relationship with me (they have been trying to reach me about my car's warranty). Those make me so furious that I always report them as mail fraud.
- sarajevo 3y agoI hope Ooma is paying attention. Took over 40 minutes to cancel the other day…
- javier_e06 3y agoThis is good news. LA Fitness should be next. Is super-easy to become a member online. Enter CC ... click on agree ... done. Want to cancel your memebership?? ... well, please drive to the nearest LA Fitness and try to find a manager ... not a rep taking new members but an actual manager, the reps can't help you to cancel. I went twice to my neighborhood LA Fitness to try to cancel my membership and the manager was 'not available at the moment'.
- jacquesm 3y agoChargeback time...
- AlotOfReading 3y agoGyms are notorious for sending unpaid dues to debt collection. Even if the designated cancellation process ought to be illegal, you still have to end the contract to end your legal obligations.
- akomtu 3y agoBut there is no contract to begin with. Anyone can enter your credit card number on a LA Fitness website.
- AlotOfReading 3y agoThere's still a contract between LA fitness and the person stealing your identity. The debt just happens to get incorrectly assigned to you for collections because we allow "identity theft" to exist. Separate issue.
- sangnoir 3y ago> There's still a contract between LA fitness and the person stealing your identity There's a contract between LA fitness and someone commiting fraud with my CC. My identity can't be stolen because I still have it - LA Fitness has been defrauded by a 3rd party and they shouldn't involve me in their mess.
- binarymax 3y agoWasn’t there proposed legislation that stated cancelling needed to be as easy as signing up? What ever happened to that?
- lern_too_spel 3y agoCalifornia passed a law that took effect in 2022.
- kevincox 3y agoI've always wondered what the best way to prevent this is. There is clearly little motivation on the company's side to prevent this. One idea that keeps coming to mind is that the company should be forced to pay for the customer's time. I don't know how to handle this in the general case but for things like cancelling a subscription, making a warranty claim or fixing some other service issue that isn't the customer's fault the company should be required to pay for any time spent. You ask me 30min of questions before letting me unsubscribe? I look forward to my $50 in the mail next week. My warranty claim requires 3 calls and 2h to resolve? I'll take $200. Obviously implementing this would be super difficult. What if the customer talks slowly or ambiguously to get more money? But I feel that the core idea has merit. If the company is wasting my time they should be forced to compensate me.
- briffle 3y agoMy local west coast newspaper (Owned by USA Today) used to pull this crap. Offer a $8 subscription for 6 months with a simple click, then automatically switch to monthly billing at $15/month and you had to call, during east coast business hours (again, I live on west coast) and if! they answered, they would work very hard to make sure you didn't cancel. I started using the virtual cards from Privacy.com, and only authorizing the original purchase. its been a game changer.
- BobaFloutist 3y agoHow about every charge they pass you after you contact them in any verifiable way (including submitting a support ticket to their website and taking a screenshot, sending their support email an email, or writing a letter) requesting cancellation they have to pay back to you triple. Then the ball's in their court. You're happy to let them keep charging you, it's an investment. I bet that would get them off their asses.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- TriangleEdge 3y agoWhy does SiriusXM exist?
- mikestew 3y agoFor those times when you’re driving in the middle of nowhere, and your ‘52 Studebaker can’t pull in any AM radio stations. Otherwise, since the advent of smartphones, I have no idea how Sirius stays in business. Live sports, I guess. I’ve had satellite radio, and when I think of SiriusXm, at the front of my mind is what a pain in the ass it is to cancel. We bought a new car this year, and I didn’t even activate the free trial because I didn’t want the hassle of canceling later. Think about that: the UX is so bad, there are customers that won’t even use it if you give it to them.
- SoftTalker 3y agoIn a car, I find the radio to be far easier to use than fumbling around with my phone. I've never had SiriusXM so can't comment on that specifically, but I never use my phone for music in the car, I just turn on the radio.
- Racing0461 3y agoSiriusXM made the very grave mistake of starting their business before the invention of the iphone. This will be studied in MBA schools for decades.
- Demonsult 3y agoCancel by mail. Companies don't mess with letter writers. They know you have a paper trail if you need to dispute or sue. It often takes less time and way less mental energy than a phone call.
- LoganDark 3y ago> It often takes less time and way less mental energy than a phone call. Really now? Preparing a physical package and dropping it off at a physical location to be picked up and delivered is faster and more efficient than speaking into a wireless device for a few minutes?
- akira2501 3y agoI just drop it off and other people do the delivery for me. So, in terms of my effort vs SiriusXM's reclamation department, yes, it is more efficient. Perhaps that's why they're being sued?
- LoganDark 3y ago> I just drop it off and other people do the delivery for me. That's what I said. You have to create a physical letter and drop it off. Not everyone can just walk over to their mailbox and stick an outgoing letter in there for the delivery truck to pick up; I have the privilege, but it absolutely hasn't been common everywhere I've lived. You don't have to drop anything off in order to make a phone call, you don't even have to get up if you already have your phone.
- akira2501 3y agoThe amount of time I spend doing things costs me opportunities to earn money. So, minimizing time spent performing a single accounting action by writing a letter, while systematically "inefficient" is actually the most efficient financial decision I can make for myself. I am uninterested beyond that. The USPS maintains a pretty wide network of collection boxes. In a city you'd be hard pressed to not find one very close to you and most large apartment buildings have their own mail drops. There doesn't seem to be any "privileged" access issues here. Point is.. the differences are so small.. that the decision is going to be made by subjective preference in most cases, and trying to suggest that there's an objectively correct solution is easily disproved.
- keenmaster 3y agoThis post reminded me to cancel before my signup offer expires, so I tried via a chat agent. They claimed that they were having technical issues and told me to contact Sirius customer service again in 2 hours. I said that the “technical issues” were a lie, and that they can cancel now. All of a sudden they were able to cancel for me without technical difficulty, but only after refusing one more promotion. It looks like they use sentiment analysis to assess whether they can use poor excuses to hassle you out of cancelling.
- grogenaut 3y agoMy spouse loves the Sirius junk mail. More paper to shred and feed to the vworms in our compost bin.
- zacwest 3y agoI love SirusXM. They are a truly unique offer in the modern music landscape of algorithm-driven music listening experiences. The human curation of shows and stations is why I listen. That said, they have a lot of problems: I have to complain yearly to keep my $8/mo rate, and they seem to be slowly moving toward wanting more algorithmic content with their Pandora merger. I wish they'd focus more on growing their technology (e.g. a macOS app). They just did a big rewrite on all the platforms, seemingly toward this goal; I hope they keep going down that path. If the government forces them to adopt more modern subscription practices, I think _more_ people would use their platform, not less.
- tombert 3y agoThis is coming from a person who has a SiriusXM membership and who actually likes it, but is the human curation really that much better? I frequent SiriusXMU to listen to more obscure stuff, but I feel like I get pretty fairly comparable performance with YouTube Music's "Start Radio" on an Imogen Heap or Secret Machines album or something.
- threeio 3y agoYah, the merger between Sirius and XM was a dramatic difference in programming content. XM had spent most of their time getting quality PM and on air talent, Sirius was basically a glorified Winamp playlist. As the channels merged, you found yourself going from a base of 5000 songs a channel to a few hundred. The folks who used to have XMPCR's (computer connected receivers) published a comparison of songs at one point but my google fu can't find it right now.
- zacwest 3y agoI agree some of the stations are somewhat repetitive, especially those stuck intentionally in an older genre like Lithium or one of the decades channels. I think the mix tends to still be less than surface level in those. They also have DJ-hosted segments; I think Tom Morello has a lot more flexibility in what he's playing, for example. It's still their superpower compared to the algorithmic track selections.
- deleted 3y ago
- flatline 3y agoI subscribed for a few years and would renew each year when they jacked the rates back up. Finally decided it just was not worth it and went through their arduous cancellation process. Got a call back the next day asking to sign me back up and I took the customer service rep to task saying he knew perfectly well I just canceled yesterday. He gave a sheepish laugh, did not argue the point, and they have never called me back.
- jf22 3y agoGood for you for taking a low-paid customer service employee to task for doing their job.
- flatline 3y agoI wasn’t exactly rude about it, but they were acting as a representative of the company - probably the only one I could ever actually talk to - so I didn’t see any reason to sugar coat it either. I am often direct with sales people that I am not interested in their product, and I have been yelled at and harassed by them before. This is all late stage capitalism at its finest.
- dboreham 3y agoInterestingly it's actually not that bad. You do have to call them but when I did so for several cars they didn't try to waste my time further. I may have had to answer "because that's what I want" to some question about reason for termination. Also I still had several more active vehicles so perhaps they felt less pressure to Shane don't go me.
- JJMcJ 3y agoSomeone in South America had a subscription for a US company. The only way to cancel was to call a US 800 number. I don't even know if you can call 800 numbers from outside the USA.
- rowright8 3y agoIf you read the disadvantages to SirusXM from one of their own group companies (Pandora Media owns Cloud Cover Music) they admit it's hard to cancel. https://cloudcovermusic.com/music-for-business/siriusxm-radio/ https://cloudcovermusic.com/music-for-business/siriusxm-radi...
- FireBeyond 3y agoSirius' cancel process is absolutely painful. People reading robotically from scripts that don't sound convincing even to them. "Did you know that we now have award winning X? Maybe you would like to listen to that on your [insert car here]". Just repeating "No, I just want to cancel" and nothing else doesn't help, either. On the flip side, they have offered me ridiculous deals. As of right now I have the Music Showcase subscription for 2 vehicles (meant to be $13.99/mo each) for "$7.99 for 6 months, for both vehicles" - as in $7.99 for the entire 6 months, not per month, and for both vehicles, not each.
- Axien 3y agoDamn. That is a good deal. I’m paying $4.99/month for one car and online and thought that was amazing.
- boh 3y agoThis comment thread has way too much privacy dot com spam.
- LoganDark 3y agoTo be fair, it is very useful and plenty of people swear by it, myself included. I wish my bank hadn't introduced new debit cards that "aren't supported" by Privacy (whatever that means, it's literally just a visa), but whatever, I guess. None of the comments are sponsored or anything, but Privacy seriously is the hidden cheat code of using cards online, and the reason why you see so many mentions of it is because it prevents exactly these kinds of shady practices from working.
- bacchusracine 3y agoAnd isn't it interesting how the other half of the discussion was dominated by discussion of a specific fitness membership? I think these companies have gotten wise to the Streisand effect and no longer try to block discussion, they just very carefully make sure that a very active *offtopic* discussion dominates so people are distracted.
- pierat 3y agoI had a private conversation about customer service, rudeness, and such. It's terrible that in order to do something as simple as "I want to cancel this service", you have to scream and make legal threats of retribution. These are policies put in by terrible and shit capitalists to "make friction" of people leaving. But that's not all it does... It also introduces tremendous emotional labor (the rank and file employees) being screamed at by soon-to-be-former customers. Customers know that screaming gets heard, and responded to. Being decent gets you abused. But doing this pushes a large toll on the non-policy-making employees, who are exposed to massive emotional and sometimes physical abuse. I do blame the companies in setting up policies that screaming at the bottom employees 'gets shit done'. It's a choice by the companies that force that issue. But screaming retains rights, like "cancellation", or "being made whole when a problem occurs". It's all top-driven bullshit that screwing the non-loud people makes more money.
- LorenDB 3y agoNow if they'd only add a button to unsubscribe from their physical mail... I bought a used Prius this year and installed the Toyota app to see if it did anything for me. All it did was give SiriusXM my home address, so now I periodically get a plea from them to subscribe.
- diego_moita 3y agoWow! Thanks for posting that. I was actually contemplating the idea of subscribing them. I bought a new car with a 3 month trial period and it ended last week. You helped me to dodge a bullet.
- local_crmdgeon 3y agoProud to be a New Yorker. Small stuff adds up to make life a lot nicer here.
- jrockway 3y agoI kind of love these cancellation scripts. I recently cancelled my cable because I switched to Fios. The 15 minute script took me through: 1) "I can't believe you're paying that much. You should have called us sooner for a discount." (Blaming the victim? Classy.) 2) "According to our database, you can't get Fios at your address." "I have it. I'm using it right now." "That can't be correct, our database doesn't show it." (Is this the same database that can't tell me what the monthly taxes are going to be when I sign up? It might be time for a different database vendor.) 3) "You really don't want to switch to fiber. Cable has a higher signal strength because it's electrical instead of optical." (I... guess that's true. 0 coulombs of charge pass through the fiber optic cable each second, which is much lower than any other technology!) There was also something in there about how I don't really want symmetric Internet because asymmetric is better. That one I actually argued with; I have no argument for their database being out of date but them trusting it, or the signal strength thing... but uploading fast is actually important to me. I mentioned that I write software for a living and he didn't press me that much on it, which was nice. This article reminds me that I need to write to the FTC. This is all flat-out lying, which should be illegal. Obviously, you aren't going to scam someone that's worked at 2 fiber ISPs, but someone less technical probably believes their arguments. In the end, the 15 minute call was probably the most entertainment I've had in years. Very rarely do people confidently lie to my face, so it was a fun experience. However, if the FTC wants to put everyone in prison for this, I say that's a great idea.
- frankus 3y agoThere really ought to be a law against making cancellations any more involved than sign-ups (I understand California has something like this already), but failing that a public shit-list of companies that make it a hassle to cancel subscriptions would be a good stopgap.
- Scoundreller 3y agoI was a subscriber to my newspaper because I liked their paywall-light approach and was happy to support the free loaders. Then they made their paywall super hard and they make you call and cancel. I can still get around it anyway and I hate being logged in and tracked. The rep was pleasant but had trouble understanding why a paying user would cancel because of paywalls. They seemed to think I was in need of IT troubleshooting (but perhaps my brain is in need of it).
- stan_kirdey 3y agotook one AG to try to cancel their subscription :D
- asylteltine 3y agoSiriusxm isn’t even a good product. The quality is just awful hardly any better than FM and sometimes even worse. In the age of CarPlay, why in the hell would anyone use it? Even if you don’t have CarPlay, you have Bluetooth or an aux input.
- bdangubic 3y agoReading comments and wondering if anyone here has a Credit Card? :) Just stop payments on the Card, I have done this with every “can’t cancel even though I didn’t sign a long-term contract”