4 ms·
No app gets special treatment for any of the user-grantable permissions like location, Bluetooth, local network access, contacts, photos... What makes this any
by lxgr 3y ago
No app gets special treatment for any of the user-grantable permissions like location, Bluetooth, local network access, contacts, photos...
What makes this any different? It really seems more like an oversight than a conscious decision, similarly to how (I believe) both iOS and Android have retroactively had to bucket some of the Bluetooth LE permissions into "location", since that's what you can effectively do with them.
- MBCook 3y agoIt could be. But the fact it’s behind a special permission you have to request from Apple tells me they likely think it’s secure enough.
- politician 3y agoWhat’s your basis for saying that Apple doesn’t provide special treatment to apps? I’ve directly experienced both of their special and their non public (phone calls only, refusal to communicate over email) processes.
- lxgr 3y agoI’m not claiming that at all in general, but I do believe it’s true when it comes to user-grantable permissions. Or do you have evidence to the contrary?
- facialwipe 3y agoGiving the world’s most valuable corporation the benefit of the doubt. This is an interesting worldview to have in 2023.
- lxgr 3y agoIt’s a pretty obscure API, and Apple has a strong interest in at least being perceived as pro user privacy. And assuming for a second this is indeed an intentional backdoor in plain sight of the world: What’s in it for Apple? Hanlon’s razor still cuts in 2023, at least for me.
- mrguyorama 3y ago>Apple has a strong interest in at least being perceived as pro user privacy. Perceived is doing a lot of lifting there. The public largely cannot audit Apple's ACTUAL security.
- lxgr 3y agoThat’s true, but arguably irrelevant here since this is a public, documented API that can be audited.