4 ms·
The personal, political art of board-game design
- pseudolus 3y agohttps://archive.ph/iCYt4 https://archive.ph/iCYt4
- slackfan 3y ago[flagged]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- yawpitch 3y agoNot sure how tired one can be of a state of affairs that’s existed since the first humans humanned.
- mcpackieh 3y agoWhat a strange remark. Would you object to somebody saying they are tired of human conflict, hunger, disease? These have all existed for the entirety of humanity, so by your thinking people cannot be tired of them?
- lazyasciiart 3y agoI’d consider it more like someone saying they are tired of talking about conflict, hunger and disease.
- mcpackieh 3y agoYou think it implausible that somebody might grow weary of discussing such dreary things?
- DonHopkins 3y agoThen maybe they should choose to adopt some non-dreary political beliefs to embrace that they can rationally and honestly defend without lying and gaslighting, so they don't get so weary of people being offended and disagreeing with them. Then they wouldn't have to play the victim and complain about cancel culture so dramatically.
- ethanbond 3y agoIt’s totally plausible and not really all that respectable to whine about it. Especially in this context where one option they have is simply not to click on the article.
- lazyasciiart 3y agoNo, but it is not so high minded and praiseworthy as your example implied.
- muzani 3y agoThe politics itself isn't tiring. It's the constant lies and selling that's tiresome. I'm not tired of the sky being blue. I'm tired of people insisting that the sky is either black or colorless and then constantly shifting the definition of sky to suit their purposes.
- DonHopkins 3y agoDiscussions about politics with reasonable people you disagree with are fascinating and illuminating, but I've found it's always the unreasonable people who have reprehensible indefensible politics who try to unilaterally inject them into the conversation, but then when somebody calls them on it and stands up to their bullying and gaslighting, they suddenly don't want to talk about politics any more after bringing it up, because they don't want to discuss or defend or justify what they just said, "loftily indicating by some phrase that the time for argument is past" [1]. Many people unfortunate enough to have brainwashed alt-right relatives they're seasonally visiting are experiencing that this holiday season. I recently lost a long term friend of several decades I used to adore and respect, John Gilmore, to this disgracefully common pathological mental decline and intellectually dishonest trolling. It started with his gleefully and frequently bringing up climate change conspiracy theories, then finally degenerated into blatant racism, a straight white privileged over entitled libertarian millionaire man bitterly complaining about white victimhood and reverse discrimination and the woke mind virus, and literally quoting and enthusiastically agreeing with and intellectually dishonestly arguing in support of Scott Adams statements that "Blacks people are a hate group" and "White people should stay the hell away from Black people" and White Supremacist slogans like "It's OK to be White". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/It%27s_okay_to_be_white https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/It%27s_okay_to_be_white https://time.com/6259311/dilbert-racism-scott-adams/ https://time.com/6259311/dilbert-racism-scott-adams/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/media/2023/02/28/rasmussen-poll-scott-adams-dilbert/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/media/2023/02/28/rasmussen-po... It sucks to lose a friend, but it sucks a hell of a lot more to tolerate racism and abuse and gaslighting from a troll. Tolerating him and his ilk but just avoiding talking about politics around him is exactly the wrong approach, since he's never going to change. Packing up my luggage, leaving his house, returning his key, checking into a hotel, terminating the friendship, and never talking with him again is much cleaner and healthier for all involved. That's what the EFF did too, when they voted to kick him off the board of the organization he founded. But it's also important to warn other people about him and others like him, because he certainly wouldn't want me to self censor or keep my experiences and what I think a secret. "The Net interprets censorship as damage and routes around it." -John Gilmore https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Gilmore_(activist) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Gilmore_(activist) https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2021/10/john-gilmore-leaves-eff-board-becomes-board-member-emeritus https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2021/10/john-gilmore-leaves-ef... My heart and sympathy goes out to others stuck with sociopathic trolls like John Gilmore, because of family or financial or other commitments, and all I can suggest is don't tolerate any of it, don't try to fix them, just cut them out of your life as much as you can. [1] “Never believe that anti-Semites are completely unaware of the absurdity of their replies. They know that their remarks are frivolous, open to challenge. But they are amusing themselves, for it is their adversary who is obliged to use words responsibly, since he believes in words. The anti-Semites have the right to play. They even like to play with discourse for, by giving ridiculous reasons, they discredit the seriousness of their interlocutors. They delight in acting in bad faith, since they seek not to persuade by sound argument but to intimidate and disconcert. If you press them too closely, they will abruptly fall silent, loftily indicating by some phrase that the time for argument is past.” ― Jean-Paul Sartre This quote is from Jean-Paul Sartre's work "Anti-Semite and Jew" (originally "Réflexions sur la question juive"), written in 1946. In this passage, Sartre analyzes the behavior and motives of anti-Semites. He argues that anti-Semites are aware of the absurdity and frivolity of their arguments. According to Sartre, they engage in such discourse not to persuade through rational debate but to amuse themselves and to disconcert their opponents. They do this by undermining the seriousness of any conversation, thus avoiding genuine discussion. When pressed, they may cease the discussion, indicating that they are above argumentation. This approach, Sartre suggests, is a form of bad faith, a concept he discusses in his existentialist philosophy, referring to acts of self-deception or dishonesty in one's dealings with oneself and others.
- drewcoo 3y ago[flagged]
- freddie_mercury 3y agoEh, I think piece is better viewed as just an extended interview/thinkpiece on Holland. But it is let down a bit by the framing, which doesn't really convey that. Yes, it starts out of the gate with Amabel but that kind of thing is so common nowadays in "long form journalism" that it doesn't really signify anymore that she's the actual centerpiece of the article rather than just some "inciting incident" kind of character. Another article in the same issue of The New Yorker on crossword puzzles does exactly this with Mangesh Ghogre. It leads with him but is really meant as more of a "broad" piece in contrast to the one about Amabel Holland which is more a deeper dive on a single individual. Because, I agree, if it were really going to be a broader piece about the personal, political art of boardgame design I don't know how you can't talk about Spirit Island and it's anti-colonialist theme pushing back against decades of thoughtless boardgame theming, which could contain dozens of examples of things like Mombasa/Skymines.
- morelisp 3y ago> No mention of on-shot Daviau's lack of replay-ability. Ok, that's not entirely fair. Pandemic is infinitely replay-able as a mansplaining exercise. Daviau didn't design Pandemic, and has designed dozens of well-rated games besides his Legacy series.
- freddie_mercury 3y agoGiven the subject matter, I was a bit surprised not to see a mention of Cole Wehrle, who is probably the designer most famous for including the political into boardgames at the moment. See this recent Sit Up & Shut Down review on his game John Company for a great video intro https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ykrqCX2_mhU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ykrqCX2_mhU Or Space Biff (aka Dan Thurott, mentioned in the OP) for a written review of his game Molly House https://spacebiff.com/2023/10/17/molly-house/ https://spacebiff.com/2023/10/17/molly-house/ Amabel Holland's publishing company Hollandspiele is also an interesting case study in how much creative people can benefit from having full control. She previously published via other publishers but now self-publishes. AFAIK none of the self-published games are remotely as popular as e.g. her Iron Rails series that Capstone publishers. But she's said that she makes more in a month from Hollandspiele than she makes all year from her non-Hollandspiele titles.
- zimpenfish 3y agoMay have been updated since you read it but it does mention Cole Wehrle twice, albeit perhaps in less detail than you'd want? > the success of An Infamous Traffic, a game by Cole Wehrle about the opium trade in China, allowed them both to go full time > Escobedo, in turn, had learned about the company only because it had previously published a title by a big-time designer named Cole Wehrle
- freddie_mercury 3y agoYeah "mention" wasn't the right phrase. I thought those were way too brief given his outsized impact at the moment.
- morelisp 3y agoMolly House is primarily Jo Kelly’s game.
- WobbuPalooza 3y agoBoard games with a moral/didactic dimension have a very long history that might be of interest here, e.g. -- Mark Tatz and Jody Kent (1978), _Rebirth: The Tibetan Game of Liberation_: https://www.himalayanart.org/search/set.cfm?setID=1524 https://www.himalayanart.org/search/set.cfm?setID=1524 -- May-Ying Mary Ngai (2011), "From entertainment to enlightenment : a study on a cross-cultural religious board game with emphasis on the Table of Buddha Selection designed by Ouyi Zhixu of the late Ming Dynasty": https://open.library.ubc.ca/soa/cIRcle/collections/ubctheses/24/items/1.0071581 https://open.library.ubc.ca/soa/cIRcle/collections/ubctheses... -- Jingyi Yuan (2021), "Blurring the Boundary between Play and Ritual: Sugoroku Boards as Portable Cosmos in Japanese Religion": https://etd.ohiolink.edu/acprod/odb_etd/etd/r/1501/10?clear=10&p10_accession_num=oberlin163023273917632 https://etd.ohiolink.edu/acprod/odb_etd/etd/r/1501/10?clear=... In Europe, many parlor games had some moral, didactic, or personal aspect to them: -- Innocenzo Ringhieri (1551), _Cento giuochi liberali, et d'ingegno_ gave players 100 different games that were kind of complicated and often didactic in themselves, but the idea in making them complicated was for players to make mistakes they'd pay for at the end by answering questions that often had a moral dimension. I've made a rough translation here of seven of them that were translated into French in 1555 and that have to do with classical mythology: https://wobbupalooza.neocities.org/1555 https://wobbupalooza.neocities.org/1555 -- One specifically political parlor game that I can recall off the top of my head is the variant of Avocat that GutsMuths gave in 1796 called Parlament, in which players become King, Chancellor, Secretary, etc. to address strategic matters of state such as "whether one should be allied with the [Ottoman] Porte, recognize the [French] Republic, continue the war, [or] levy a new tax or not," the trick being to respond to the question in lieu of a partner: https://www.google.com/books/edition/Spiele_zur_Übung_und_Erholung_des_Körp/DzViAAAAcAAJ?hl=en&gbpv=1&pg=PA318&printsec=frontcover https://www.google.com/books/edition/Spiele_zur_Übung_und_Er... -- But that's pretty close in time to the 1804 astronomy board game that Margaret Bryan consulted on: https://collections.vam.ac.uk/item/O26305/science-in-sport-or-the-board-game-wallis-edward/ https://collections.vam.ac.uk/item/O26305/science-in-sport-o... / https://www.rmg.co.uk/collections/objects/rmgc-object-264736 https://www.rmg.co.uk/collections/objects/rmgc-object-264736 / https://www.cultureandcosmos.org/pdfs/16/Saridakis_INSAPVII_Margaret_Bryan.pdf https://www.cultureandcosmos.org/pdfs/16/Saridakis_INSAPVII_...
- 3y ago
- DonHopkins 3y agoMonopoly is the paradigm of personal political artistic board game design, with a brutally ironic story behind it. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ralph_Anspach https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ralph_Anspach >Ralph Anspach (15 March 1926 – March 2022) was a German-born American economics professor and games creator from San Francisco State University. Anspach was a graduate of the University of Chicago and fought with the Mahal in 1948 in support of the independence of Israel. He is best known for creating the game Anti-Monopoly and the legal battles that followed. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-Monopoly https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-Monopoly >Anti-Monopoly is a board game made by San Francisco State University Professor Ralph Anspach in response to Monopoly. The idea of an anti-monopoly board game dates to 1903 when Lizzie Magie created The Landlord's Game, which later inspired Monopoly. Reading Ralph Anspach's book "The Billion Dollar Monopoly Swindle" inspired me to design and produce a board game called "Micropoly" in 1999, about Microsoft's monopoly in the computer industry and free open source software. (Not to be confused with "Micropolis", an old hard disk manufacturer and the original name of SimCity before it was published, and the open source version of SimCity after EA released it under GPL-3. Nor with the micro poly industrial lubricant of the same name.) Micropoly is delightfully dated procedural rhetoric and ham-fisted interactive agitprop, as you can see by the names of the circa-Y2K companies like Netscape, SGI, and Sun, the Windows 95 motifs, $200 salary for passing the Window "Start" Menu instead of "Go", "Free Software" instead of "Free Parking", "Corrupted Registry" goto "Reinstall Windows" instead of "Jail", "Download" instead of "Chance" cards, "Open Sources" instead of "Community Chest" cards, "ISP" instead of "Utility", "Network" instead of "Railroad", "Deposition" and "Antitrust Ruling" properties, etc. Here's a page I wrote explaining it with links to pdf files for the board and cards: https://donhopkins.com/home/Micropoly/ https://donhopkins.com/home/Micropoly/ https://donhopkins.com/home/Micropoly/micropoly-board-big.jpg https://donhopkins.com/home/Micropoly/micropoly-board-big.jp... Micropoly is the Microsoft Monopoly Game! It's a parody of Microsoft that's fun to play, a free board game based the rules of Anti-Monopoly, and a political statement protected under the First Amendment. This web site exists to freely distribute the full set of graphics and rules for Micropoly, in the "open source" spirit of the original folk game monopoly invented by an Atlantic City Quaker woman. You are encouraged to download the graphics, print out copies of the game set for yourself and friends, and have fun playing Micropoly! The Goals of the Micropoly Project: To make a political statement about the effect of Microsoft's monopoly on the economy. To raise awareness of the original folk game monopoly invented by Quakers and illegitimately patented and pirated by Parker Brothers. To promote the alternative Anti-Monopoly rules, invented by Ralph Anspach in 1973, that teach why monopolies are bad. To distribute the graphics and rules of Micropoly as a free "open source" game, true to the spirit of the Quaker who originally invented monopoly. To develop a computerized version of monopoly, that can be customized with any local theme and artwork, and played over the Internet. To imitate life imitating art imitating life imitating art, and so forth. Micropoly synergistically illustrates several important points, by drawing parallels between the time of the Great Depression and the end of the Twentieth Century: Monopolies are bad, and competition is good. The original rules of monopoly require everyone to play as a monopolist. That's why companies like Microsoft and Parker Brothers like the lesson it teaches: being a monopolist is good, and in order to win you have to make the biggest monopoly. But the rules of Anti-Monopoly divide players into monopolists versus competitors, resulting in a dynamic, unpredictable, more interesting game. Competition has the same benefits in real life! The "open source" philosophy has been around a long time before computers. The Atlantic City Quaker woman who invented the original board game spread it around to her friends for free. She would invite people over to play, and they loved the game, so they made their own copies with crayons on oil cloth. This free folk game spread around the country and was played by many people, long before Parker Brothers knowingly decided pirated it. Today we have computer networks, desktop publishing, color printers, and the "open source" model of software development, so it is much easier to spread the free Micropoly game all over the world. Big companies abuse the patent and legal systems to pirate and exploit other peoples original ideas. Parker Brothers pirated monopoly from its original inventors, illegitimately patented an "open source" folk game, perpetrated an extremely successful propaganda campaign to convince the world that Monopoly(TM) was invented by Charles B Darrow, and aggressively drove other companies out of business with frivolous lawsuits. They waged a nasty 10 year legal assault on Ralph Anspach, inventor of the "Anti-Monopoly" game, ruining his successful game company, even though his case finally made it to the Supreme Court and won! As a result of his hard fought victory, the true story of Parker Brother's Billion Dollar Monopoly Swindle has been published for all to read, and it's safe to call a game "anything-opoly". We are very grateful that he never gave up, and won in spite of Parker Brothers' dirty tricks. We thank him, because he made it possible for us to publish Micropoly, and generously offered to let us use his superior Anti-Monopoly rules, which so perfectly illustrate the point of Micropoly. The similarities in the monopolistic behaviors of Parker Brothers and Microsoft should be obvious. Micropoly Board: https://donhopkins.com/home/Micropoly/micropoly-board-whole.pdf https://donhopkins.com/home/Micropoly/micropoly-board-whole.... Micropoly Cards: https://donhopkins.com/home/Micropoly/micropoly-cards.pdf https://donhopkins.com/home/Micropoly/micropoly-cards.pdf Micropoly Properties: https://donhopkins.com/home/Micropoly/micropoly.html https://donhopkins.com/home/Micropoly/micropoly.html
- DonHopkins 3y ago>In “Persuasive Games,” published in 2007, the video-game designer and professor Ian Bogost coined the term “procedural rhetoric” to describe the use of mechanics for persuasion, which he’d seen in video games going back to the nineteen-seventies. Some notes on Procedural Rhetoric from a unfinished paper I've been writing: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Procedural_rhetoric https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Procedural_rhetoric Ian Bogost defined the “Procedural Rhetoric” game design philosophy as an unholy blend of Will Wright and Aristotle, that explains how people learn through rules and processes, analyzes the art of persuasion, and focuses on conveying ideology by crafting laws and rules within games. Ian Bogost, Persuasive Games: The Expressive Power of Videogames. Procedural rhetoric. (Ian Bogost, Janet Murray) “I developed my own design philosophy that I called procedural rhetoric, an unholy blend of Will Wright and Aristotle.” -Ian Bogost, Video Games Are Better Without Characters Procedural rhetoric or simulation rhetoric [1] is a rhetorical concept that explains how people learn through the authorship of rules and processes. The theory argues that games can make strong claims about how the world works—not simply through words or visuals but through the processes they embody and models they construct. The term was first coined by Ian Bogost in his 2007 book Persuasive Games: The Expressive Power of Videogames. [2] Procedural rhetoric analyzes the art of persuasion by rule based representations and interactions rather than spoken or written word. Procedural rhetoric focuses on how game makers craft laws and rules within a game to convey a particular ideology. [1] Frasca, Gonzalo (2003). “Simulation versus Narrative: Introduction to Ludology.” In The Video Game Theory Reader. Ed. by Mark J. P. Wolf and Bernard Perron. New York: Routledge. 221–37 ISBN 9780415965798 [2] Bogost, Ian (2008). "The Rhetoric of Video Games." The Ecology of Games: Connecting Youth, Games, and Learning. Ed. by Katie Salen. The John D. and Catherine T. MacArthur Foundation Series on Digital Media and Learning. Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press. 117–40. ISBN 9780262693646 For better or worse, games can deliver pre-programmed propaganda and procedural rhetoric for advancing ideologies and changing minds. Some designers push clichéd narratives, stereotypical characters, and institutionalized prejudices that normalize and encourage homophobia, sexism, racism, bigotry, and violence. The Sims has evolved with society over two decades towards a more inclusive, tolerant world celebrating diversity and creativity. Its procedural rhetoric promotes inclusivity, diversity, personalization, and tolerance, and supports self-expression, creativity, storytelling, and sharing. Players impress their own identities, families, homes, communities, and stories into the game, and share their own personal emergent narratives with tools like The Sims Family Album and The Sims Exchange. The Sims presumes to model human minds and relationships, but necessarily makes brazen simplifications due to technological constraints. It optimizes for playability instead of realism, while making concessions to marketability, corporate interests, societal norms, and taboos. But somehow it works, and this paper attempts to explain some of the magic. Will Wright defined the “Simulator Effect” as how players imagine the simulation is vastly more detailed, deep, rich, and complex than it actually is: a magical misunderstanding that you shouldn’t talk them out of. He designs games to run on two computers at once: the electronic one on the player’s desk, running his shallow tame simulation, and the biological one in the player’s head, running their deep wild imagination. The “AI” of The Sims is scripted in a noodly visual programming language called “SimAntics”, and is distributed throughout the objects and characters of the Sims microworld. But it magically offloads most of the heavy lifting into the player’s own imagination, incorporating and enriching their intertwingled tapestry of common-sense knowledge and stories about people, families, and communities. The graphical design of The Sims was inspired by Scott McCloud’s “Understanding Comics”, in which he illustrated how the “Masking” visual style draws abstract characters against realistic backgrounds, which increases empathy and projective identification, empowers emotional connections, and permits players to easily and deeply identify with characters. The educational philosophy of The Sims and SimCity was inspired by Seymour Papert’s “Constructionism” learning theory, with which learners construct mental models to understand the real world by building tangible personally meaningful shareable microworlds, and learn by discovery and exploration, by leveraging information they already know to learn more, and architecting their own educations. This paper reviews the history of inclusivity in The Sims franchise over two decades, and explains some techniques for imagination, persuasion, identification, empathy, storytelling, and education, which can also make other games more inclusive, expressive, and enlightening. [...] https://docs.google.com/document/d/13u-kNaWC2AAd-L0_5OoLc_-x0sxs6dFfeJr28DIxufU/edit?usp=sharing https://docs.google.com/document/d/13u-kNaWC2AAd-L0_5OoLc_-x... Dumbold Voting Machine for The Sims 1 https://donhopkins.medium.com/dumbold-voting-machine-for-the-sims-1-3e76f394452c https://donhopkins.medium.com/dumbold-voting-machine-for-the... >Just before the 2004 presidential election, I created and programmed a downloadable Dumbold Voting Machine object for The Sims 1, as interactive agitprop to raise awareness about the problems of voting machines. I wrote this article about it, which I’ve now updated and included some new links and videos! >You can download and install the Dumbold Voting Machine in your Sims installation, then you can place it on a table on your lot, and click on it to pop up a pie menu to play around with the voting machine. Or you can simply read on to find out what it does (which will spoil all the surprises)! >At first look, it appears to be a fully functional voting machine. But it actually has a lot of infuriating bugs, hidden features, gaping security holes and malicious easter eggs that simulate problems with real voting machines, and it shows illustrated pop-ups to educate players about the real-world problems and issues of electronic voting. >The High Concept >The high concept, from a game design perspective [i.e. “bullshit alert”]: The Dumbold Voting Machine is intended to be a simple but intriguing puzzle you can “hack into” (like the cheat mode of The Matrix video game), while learning about real issues. It integrates interactive real-life “public service announcements”, subversive “product displacements”, and constitutionally protected “free speech”. It addresses late breaking news, current events and political opinions. It’s free speech and political commentary rendered as executable multimedia software. The Dumbold Voting Machine acts out the story interactively, in a way that’s fun to play and experiment with. It breaks down in frustrating “failure modes” with egregious “security holes” that illustrate some difficult problems with actual electronic voting machines in the real world. It’s meant to stimulate discussion, illustrate how computer programming is free speech, and why all election software should be open source and publicly inspectable. [...]
- brainzap 3y agoI played and tried many board games. These day I only play the ones with rules that are understood on the first try/first game.
- IshKebab 3y agoI feel like that's almost all games? Which ones are you thinking of that can't be understood on the first play?
- yummypaint 3y agoWingspan tends to trip people up alot on the first play. It seems more complicated than it is
- cpitman 3y agoThere are lots of euro games that require a full play through to understand the game. And even then, many popular games where everytime I play with a new group I expect the rules to have been misunderstood in new ways. Look at Root, a very popular game. It has one long manual just for your first play, and then an even longer manual that explains all the rules. They recommend you read that one later.
- boerseth 3y agoA lot of games are incredibly involved, requiring a long explanation and rundown of the rules at the start of a session to all those not already familiar with it. It's a common enough issue that Shut Up & Sit Down made a 15 minute video on mastering "the teach" [1] I don't think I've had a single gaming night lately where there isn't some explanation stage to every game, where it is eventually decided that "it will make sense once we start", yet frequently everyone agrees that it will be a lot better next time. Then you have games like Root where learning about the insanely intricate rule-set and how the different factions interact is almost half the point and fun of playing it, still a process after multiple sessions. I've never played that one, however. Seems too daunting. [1] https://youtu.be/P5fjDaFuft8?si=jN5LUnOBv9iqTGvI https://youtu.be/P5fjDaFuft8?si=jN5LUnOBv9iqTGvI
- andrewstuart 3y agoThe article suggests the trend is for board games to be getting more complex. I hate complex board games. I just don’t have the time or interest level in spending hours learning rules that probably make the game less fun. Genius is a board game that has super simple rules and is easy to play and still has depth. Perfect example is Carcassonne.