7 ms·
Record global temperatures and U.S. billion-dollar disasters
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- quercusa 3y agoCuriously missing: "inflation-adjusted"
- FfejL 3y agoThe article REALLY ought to say so, but the underlying data is CPI adjusted. https://www.ncei.noaa.gov/access/billions/ https://www.ncei.noaa.gov/access/billions/
- chasebank 3y agoAs weather disasters dollar figures are directly correlated with housing, CPI isn't even close to a proper adjustment. CPI says the house my mom bought in 1994 for $114,000 should be $239,000 today. It's worth about $1.2M...
- micromacrofoot 3y agoThe value of that house has actually increased though as well as the cost of rebuilding it, even after adjusting for inflation.
- woodruffw 3y agoNo inflation metric is going to be perfect here, but CPI seems not unreasonable to me: disaster cost factor includes rebuilding costs, i.e. materials and labor pricing, not speculative real estate value. In other words: the "real" cost is probably somewhere between the CPI-adjusted figure and the inflation-adjusted real estate speculative gains. But either way, the trendline is the same.
- sparky_z 3y agoThat's dominated by the scarcity value of the land, not the value of the labor required to repair or replace the building on it. The "inflation" we should worry about here is contractor salaries and the cost of building materials. CPI seems fair to me.
- mensetmanusman 3y agolabor increases for houses when the value goes up like this...
- sparky_z 3y agoNot by 1000%.
- kraig911 3y agoHaha I was thinking the same thing. I feel though using dollars as a way to express both devastation and prosperity in cash amounts is disingenuous.
- dfgfek 3y ago>Yale Environment 360 Published at the Yale School of the Environment No, not "curiously". More like "maliciously"
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- netbioserror 3y agoPrices of things being destroyed goes up because of inflation, density of things being destroyed goes up because of population expansion. Unsure if anyone's keeping track, but Florida has had mighty large population inflows for years.
- throwup238 3y agoFlorida is also the worst state in the country as far as natural disasters go. Most of the state’s real estate is completely uninsurable and has to be backstopped by the National Flood Insurance Program which tax payers have to bail out every few years.
- faeriechangling 3y agoDiffusing the insurance bill like this not only helps win votes in a swing state, it lets people pretend that global warming isn’t an issue and never will be an issue for a few years longer.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoIs FL still a swing state?
- pc86 3y agoYes.
- alistairSH 3y agoSort of. At the state level, the GOP has veto-proof majorities in the legislature plus the governorship. Democrats have only won the state’s presidential election 5 times in the last ~50 years. And o e of those (Clinton) wasn’t a majority. But it’s close.
- phkahler 3y ago>> Most of the state’s real estate is completely uninsurable and has to be backstopped by the National Flood Insurance Program Which should not pay to rebuild there. Sure, pay to relocate/rebuild somewhere insurable.
- artur_makly 3y agoLast Sat night, Buenos Aires got hit harder than I've ever seen since I've been here in 16 years. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0PoGhrt8IGI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0PoGhrt8IGI 15% of all their incredible trees were destroyed.
- swader999 3y agoThese weather disaster stats need to be discussed as a percentage of GDP if they are going to be usefully compared historically.
- MattSteelblade 3y agoHere is the NOAA data referred to in the article which is CPI-adjusted https://www.ncei.noaa.gov/access/billions/ https://www.ncei.noaa.gov/access/billions/
- eouw0o83hf 3y agoA billion dollars fixes less every year due to inflation. Wouldn't we expect this to be the case most years?
- jeffbee 3y agoIt's in real dollars.
- KeplerBoy 3y agoNot most years, but frequently. An extraordinarily big catastrophe would probably hold the record for a few years until the next above average events happen. Our problem seems to be that the underlying distribution shifts fast. What once was a catastrophic freak event, is now barely average.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- otoburb 3y agoAnybody who owns property (landlords and personal property owners alike) will see insurance premiums spike up even more.[1] [1] https://www.nytimes.com/2023/10/12/realestate/as-natural-disasters-get-worse-so-do-home-insurance-premiums.html https://www.nytimes.com/2023/10/12/realestate/as-natural-dis...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Dolototo 3y agoInteresting how a few people look at the graphs witch spike quite strong (much more than just a.few percent) and indicate that this is absolutely normal and has nothing to do with climate change. Make out of it whatever you like, science tells us that climate change will erode our infrastructure and it will cost more than not doing anything.
- VincentEvans 3y agoClimate change denial has fluently shifted from outright refusal to accept the reality of an impending catastrophic change in climate - to refusing to accept human origins of the change. It now goes along the lines of “weather has always fluctuated dramatically since the ancient times and this is no different” without skipping a beat or admitting to pushing a counter-productive agenda for the last 20 years.
- faeriechangling 3y agoI’ve already seen people move on to “okay humans probably caused it but the economic models of the impact of climate change are wrong”
- hotpotamus 3y agoI wouldn't call myself a denier, but I've gone from accepting the science to mostly hoping it is in fact wrong because it doesn't look like humanity will be letting off the metaphorical accelerator pedal (not this year, maybe one of the next few years will see an actual decrease in carbon emissions?). What else is there but to hope it isn't so bad?
- dimensi0nal 3y agoStratospheric aerosol injection
- hotpotamus 3y agoI do think of it as humanity's half-assed solution and probably our best hope.
- alexnewman 3y agoHow did they inflation adjust it?
- kortilla 3y ago“There was inflation and interest in moving to sea level climates! News at 10”
- GreedClarifies 3y agoI see that many have noted that this is not inflation adjusted, which would be a good start. But more importantly, this needs to be as a percentage of the total infrastructure (or real estate to make it easier to compute) in the area. IIUC as a percentage of total real estate value the amount of damage has been going down over time, as one would expect.
- prometheus76 3y agoYeah but then you might not get that spicy headline...
- VincentEvans 3y agoWouldn’t adjusting historical values for inflation actually increase the magnitude of the numbers? Eg $100 in 1980s is $300 in 2023 (or whatever, not real numbers) - the number is larger, not smaller.
- the_doctah 3y agoI think that's the point...
- meheleventyone 3y agoYeah so the number of billion dollar disasters would normalize as a consequence. Older years would get more and later years less as the currency loses value from the former to the latter. Inflation alone means you'd expect more billion dollar disasters over time. Someone below points out that inflation alone wouldn't explain the growth though and beyond that someone else notes its adjusted for CPI.
- phkahler 3y agoAlso, why the number above some arbitrary value and not just the total dollar cost?
- occamrazor 3y ago
- oglop 3y agoThese “externalities” are starting to add up. I love that term. Such a quaint word invented by such clueless people to sweep under the rug such massive problems for so long. Not that it matters. The language may change but i doubt the macro behaviors do of citizens in advanced countries will. Look at meat consumption just as one example. I am amazed how often ive been cornered in my life by some person hand wringing over the climate who themselves eats meat, buys new and stylish clothing monthly, and doesnt catch a whiff of the irony.
- barbazoo 3y agoAnd at the same time there are lots and lots of people adjusting their behaviour to a new reality every day.
- happytiger 3y agoIn 2012, NCEI -- then known as National Climatic Data Center (NCDC) -- reviewed its methodology on how it develops Billion-dollar Disasters. NCEI held a workshop with economic experts (May, 2012) and worked with a consulting partner to examine possible inaccuracy and biases in the data sources and methodology used in developing the loss assessments (mid-2013). This ensures more consistency with the numbers NCEI provides on a yearly basis and give more confidence in the year-to-year comparison of information. Another outcome is a published peer-reviewed article "U.S. Billion-dollar Weather and Climate Disasters: Data Sources, Trends, Accuracy and Biases" (Smith and Katz, 2013). This research found the net effect of all biases appears to be an underestimation of average loss. In particular, it is shown that the factor approach can result in an underestimation of average loss of approximately 10–15%. This bias was corrected during a reanalysis of the loss data to reflect new loss totals. It is also known that the uncertainty of loss estimates differ by disaster event type reflecting the quality and completeness of the data sources used in our loss estimation. In 2019, six of the fourteen billion-dollar events (i.e., three inland floods events, California/Alaskan wildfires, tropical cyclones Dorian and Imelda) have higher potential uncertainty values around the loss estimates due to less coverage of insured assets and data latency. The remaining eight events (i.e., the severe storm events producing tornado, hail and high wind damage) have lower potential uncertainty surrounding their estimate due to more complete insurance coverage and data availability. Our newest research defines the cost uncertainty using confidence intervals as discussed in the peer-reviewed article "Quantifying Uncertainty and Variable Sensitivity within the U.S. Billion-dollar Weather and Climate Disaster Cost Estimates" (Smith and Matthews, 2015). This research is a next step to enhance the value and usability of estimated disaster costs given data limitations and inherent complexities. In performing these disaster cost assessments these statistics were developed using the most comprehensive public and private sector sources and represent the estimated total costs of these events -- that is, the costs in terms of dollars that would not have been incurred had the event not taken place. So these are numbers that were revised by consultants to be higher, aren’t just a measure of the direct impact of the event but of some made up estimate of what would have been the economics had it not taken place as “economic damage,” and built on comprehensive but uncertain data that is then compensated for with a model overlay that isn’t disclosed or discussed. This is a case where the more comprehensive the model you develop becomes, the higher your estimated economic impact from events correlates. Also the data is cpi adjusted. The part that’s left out is that they are including the kitchen sink and estimated damages to economic activity not actual damage, which is a methodological change to how damage is estimated and much higher — so it looks more expensive than historical events. I’d really like to see more objective effort in the design of this research as it smacks of agendizing the conclusion a little. Especially considering that the methodology for calculating economic losses was designed to produce a report called US billion-dollar weather and climate disaster loss estimate report (NCDC 2014). What were they going to do? Develop models that didn’t hit the billion dollar threshold? Especially when basically this is all designed around “Monte Carlo simulations,” which is a fancy-pants ways of saying “we used excel to produce an average with AVERAGE, STDEV.P, and VAR.P functions.” The problem there is that a Monte Carlo simulation requires assigning accurate and unbiased sources of multiple data input values to create a model of “uncertainty” or risk, and then it spits out results by averaging the outputs to obtain an estimate. But the results of a Monte Carlo simulation are subject to statistical variability. While the simulations provide estimates and probabilities, they are not precise predictions and it’s easy to change the outcome by selecting different inputs. https://www.ncei.noaa.gov/access/billions/ https://www.ncei.noaa.gov/access/billions/
- cassac 3y agoI’m curious to how close this tracks with population growth.
- paxys 3y agoIf you want to judge the severity of disasters over time I'd say it is best to do it based on objective scientific metrics rather than bringing inflation and real estate speculation into it.
- aaron695 3y ago[dead]
- steego 3y agoInflation doesn’t account for 5x increase in the last 20 years. Asking questions is good, but some of you should actually make an effort to answer your own questions. Knowing nothing else, do you have enough common sense to figure out if your pet theory actually makes sense? Have you simply tried comparing inflation rates with the rates of reported damage? Seriously, try it. Critical thinking start with your own conjecture.
- the_doctah 3y agoThere are other factors but you seem to be making an emotional argument.
- giraffe_lady 3y agoAre they wrong? You naming rhetorical techniques is certainly not any more sophisticated or useful to the conversation than them deploying them.
- _ea1k 3y ago> I’m sad to see HN members get so attached to easily invalidatable theories so quickly. Have we really lost our critical thinking skills? Yes? But it is hard, because some things do need data, and I honestly don't know where to find that. For example, Florida has a huge insurance and insurability problem. People here Florida and immediately assume hurricanes. But I'm hearing of issues in areas that rarely see a lot of destruction from hurricanes. OTOH, I hear a lot about roof damage from wind and hail lately. And there are more roofers using storm chasers than I've ever seen. Is this a significant factor? Is the data available? I also hear about limits on the ability of insurers to raise rates on existing homeowners. Supposedly this conflicts with rises in property values that are greater than the rate increases. Is that true? I see a lot of conjecture, but little proof.
- steego 3y agoA few prominent stormers really changed the game about 15+ years ago because they were very forward looking when it came to leveraging technology in the industry. APIs provided them with hail data and they used that data to send out targeted mailers before canvassing neighborhoods and capturing the business before their competitors showed up. When they find a lead, they would move quickly to get a 3D model of the home courtesy of a company like Eagleview, which creates models from their arial photo database, which they would then provide to insurance companies with accurate estimates so they could get started quickly. Needless to say, the process has been significantly streamlined to help homeowners deal with claims and get their roofs fixed, mostly to the benefit of the bigger stormers. I can’t provide publicly available data, but when you look at the aftermath of these storms from an arial and satellite imagery perspective, you will see these events have grown in terms of objectively destructive impact. I’m not suggesting there haven’t been dozens of other factors that have inflated the financial impact (codes, costs, appreciation, etc.). My guess is the cumulative impact accounts of these other factors accounts for less than half of the financial impact, but I have honestly not looked at the data.
- jeffbee 3y agoThere are lots of great places to build cities in America. Mostly, they are the places where older cities are languishing. Probably the best-sited city in the country is Chicago: abundant fresh water, massive untapped wind energy resources, inland navigation, moderate risk of natural disasters. Same for Cleveland, Detroit, etc. Most of the places we've been building for the last 50 years are the places with the worst disaster risks and the fewest natural advantages, like Houston and Miami.
- cozzyd 3y agoWell, Chicago does have flooding problems due to it being so flat and the legacy combined sewage - stormwater overflow system that can get overwhelmed. This is why we now have this awesome thing: https://mwrd.org/what-we-do/tunnel-and-reservoir-plan-tarp https://mwrd.org/what-we-do/tunnel-and-reservoir-plan-tarp. But it's not the same time of existential flooding that can happen in Miami or Houston...
- nradov 3y agoUnfortunately some of the best sites to build cities have been wrecked by politics. Why would any rational person choose to build in Chicago, or Illinois in general, after the damage caused by corruption and failed progressive policies? From a pure geographic perspective we ought to have a huge, thriving city at the confluence of the Mississippi and Ohio Rivers. But instead there are only a few struggling small towns like Cairo, IL. This is almost entirely a political problem.
- jeffbee 3y agoCairo Illinois has been routinely destroyed. I can think of no worse place to build a city than a confluence of the two of the biggest rivers on earth.
- nradov 3y agoSome of our largest, most prosperous cities throughout the world have been built at river confluences: Chongqing, Pittsburgh, Montreal, Sacramento, New York City (Manhattan), Allahabad, Belgrade, Buenos Aires, Cincinnati, Geneva, and the list goes on. Those locations have tremendous latent economic value as transportation hubs. Flooding risks can be managed. This type of civil engineering is one of the most ancient aspects of large-scale human civilization.
- zackmorris 3y agoI'm curious how HN readers would solve the looming insurance problem. Southern US states like Florida are becoming uninsurable due to climate risks raising the price above what residents can afford, which raises insurance costs for the rest of us in other states. The same thing is happening with car insurance, where the wealthy drive up prices on new vehicles to $50-100,000+, forcing the rest of us to carry higher liability coverage. And with medical insurance, where poor lifestyle choices, environmental threats like pollution/preservatives and monopoly pressures from not having universal coverage cause those of us in good health to pay $6,000/yr or more and a multi-thousand dollar deductible, which mostly defeats the point of having insurance. My feeling is that we'll either set reasonable limits for what will be reimbursed (around the the median cost of what's being insured) or insurance will divide into a two-tier system where the wealthy are covered by gold plans while the poor pay to keep the system going and receive pennies on the dollar in coverage. Which is why I feel that tying the price of insurance to income might solve many of these problems. But insurance used to work, so I feel like there's a deeper explanation or solution that I'm not seeing.
- lotsofpulp 3y ago> But insurance used to work, so I feel like there's a deeper explanation or solution that I'm not seeing. NFIP has been in place since 1968. These low lying, flood and hurricane places have not been insurable for 50+ years. All the other federal taxpayers have been subsidizing people living there. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Flood_Insurance_Program https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Flood_Insurance_Progr...
- calamari4065 3y agoNationalize insurance, maybe? An insurance company's one and only incentive is to charge as much as possible while paying out as little as possible, iow to profit as much as they can. Actually protecting the client or their property does not factor into the equation at all. If we nationalized insurance, maybe the entire country can subsidize these extremely high risk areas. We can also add a legal mandate that insurance not operate for profit, and should change premium rates to scale up and down with the real amount paid out. Or something, I'm no money surgeon. And before someone blusters about paying for other people's shit: yes, that's what a healthy society does. We should all care about the wellbeing of others. Feel free to propose an alternative solution that doesn't involve depopulating all of our low-lying lands and dumping those citizens somewhere with no housing, no job, and no money and just ignoring the suffering and death this will cause.
- sambull 3y agoThe climate will let us know the areas to avoid. The reinsurance company actuaries will enforce those.
- mrangle 3y agoThey mean to say that there were few billion dollar weather disasters in 1935?
- archsurface 3y agoThe percentage of weather events which are billion-dollar should increase given increasingly advanced infrastructure such as space launch complexes.
- ceejayoz 3y agoLaunch complexes, having to survive rocket launches, tend to be pretty sturdy.
- archsurface 3y agoComplex, not pad.
- ceejayoz 3y agoThere are zero incidents historically of a launch complex being a meaningful driver of a billion-dollar natural disaster loss. It's not a thing; it's not what's driving the increase in expensive hurricanes and Florida's insurance market. You'd have to knock over an Artemis rocket on the launcher or something.
- hellohihello135 3y agoPeople always claim that the weather “now” is somehow special. No matter when “now” is, the weather always seems unique to us. You can read people’s thoughts on weather from any century and it sounds very similar to what we are saying now.
- dang 3y agoUrl changed from https://e360.yale.edu/digest/billion-dollar-disasters-us-climate-change https://e360.yale.edu/digest/billion-dollar-disasters-us-cli..., which points to this.
- godshatter 3y agoThere has to be a better indicator of disaster severity than the economic impacts of the damage. If an area is hit that has built strongly in anticipation of such an event it will counter productively cause the size of that disaster to diminish in the results. Shouldn't we be looking at wind speeds, time spans of events, precipitation records, water level increases and other such values instead of anything having to do with economics? Watching a friend of mine dealing with insurance companies after a house fire I can guarantee that the values coming out of such processes aren't as tied to reality as we'd like to think.
- Proven 3y ago[dead]
- onewheeltom 3y agoBuckle up…
- egberts1 3y agoClimate Change worked by counting frequency of events! Oh wait. It is an off year. It shows by adjusting for CPI and inflation! Oh wait. Some cities are just getting bigger. It is obvious by increasing temperature reading stations by 14,200 since 1973. Oh wait, most are near heat-producing urban areas. It doesn’t show when adjusted by population density as well, … yet. Don’t worry, climatologists are still looking for that Holy Grail (statistical outlier).