6 ms·
Pornhub, XVideos, and Stripchat hit with tough new EU safety regulations
- not_your_vase 3y agoI wonder how they decided to make Stripchat a large community, but not LiveJasmin. Or the other huge webcam sites.
- vinni2 3y ago“fulfil the threshold of 45 million average monthly users in the EU“
- dist-epoch 3y agoself-reported Could be guerilla marketing: "look at us, we are the 3rd porn site in EU"
- orangepurple 3y agoWhat happens at 44.9 million average monthly users? Why this distinction?
- paxys 3y agoWhat happens when you have sex with someone the day before they are legal?
- orangepurple 3y agoBefore or after 44.9 million average monthly users?
- Cthulhu_ 3y agoLegally, nothing. However, if they report it to the police you may be under investigation. Which may also lead to nothing. The law isn't that anal, pardon my pun.
- decremental 3y ago[dead]
- DeathArrow 3y agoThat's it! We, porn lovers, are gathering with pitchforks and scythes.
- bongobingo1 3y agoDoesnt something like this just push underage viewers into going to "non mainstream" sites to get porn, and probably the stuff there has a higher chance of being illegal or at least more "unusual" than what you'd see on pornhub?
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 3y agoThen they can deal with those "non mainstream" sites next or adapt their regulation? I don't understand the criticism of "they can just do <x>" because it's true for nearly any regulation or law.
- supergarfield 3y agoSome laws are much easier to evade than others, and some laws have especially bad side effects when evaded. (A law about e.g. requiring a certain type of government certification before a large construction project can be undertaken, for instance, would be far harder to evade than this one, and "they can just do <x>" would probably be a bad objection) Using non mainstream sites instead seems like a realistic way people are going to skirt this law, and those are very hard to regulate without other unpleasant side effects on Internet freedom. I think it's a reasonable concern to raise.
- richbell 3y agoPlaying a slow and ineffective cat-and-mouse game seems like a waste of time. Imposing a burden on a handful of mainstream websites that already invest significantly into "safety" will push people into sites that are less able or willing to do so. Unlike the target of most other regulations or laws, it is trivial to find and browse new websites and there is (almost) no cost or risk. The only way it can be effectively regulated is with draconian measures.
- viraptor 3y agoSome time ago probably yes. Now... is anything really mainstream/usual? We've had the incest porn videos on the front page for how many years now? Many porn subreddits and gen-ai porn communities are more chill and usual than pornhub in my opinion. At this point I'm not sure makelovenotporn is even mainstream and yeah... people could sure use it as an alternative for more "usual" content.
- top_sigrid 3y agohttps://archive.ph/SEewY https://archive.ph/SEewY
- braza 3y agoQuestion to the european residents: In the case that Brussels approves those regulations, for the European resident users that rely on those to be prohibited services (e.g. X payments [1], payments on those adult platforms, etc.) what kind of procedure can be done to ensure access? Is that even legal? [1] - https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-67749228 https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-67749228
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- InCityDreams 3y agoBack to jazz mags, randomly found.
- tephra 3y agoThe DSA has already been passed and there are no "prohibited" services (the digital service coordinator can under some special circumstances request a limited suspension of service in a member state but not a permanent if I'm not missing something.). Now I do think the DSA goes to far in many aspects (with some good provisions sprinkled in there) and I'm hoping it will not do to much damage. As for what one can do I'm not sure, VPNs are great and will continue to have a market I expect ;) (We probably ought to vote in better people as MePs as well...)
- vjulian 3y agoI find frustrating the amount of attention the government types pay to porn, given the array of priorities. These governments are rotten, and I mean that quite seriously.
- Kbelicius 3y agoThey aren't. This is about DSA which isn't about porn but big online platforms.
- paxys 3y ago[dead]
- Cthulhu_ 3y agoIt's not porn per se, it's exploitation of (usually) women, sex trafficking, and child pornography that's usually illegal. There's laws forbidding minors from accessing porn as well; they're not effective, but they're still in place to ensure it's not considered acceptable. If a porn site and / or the people uploading the content can't provide proof that the people involved are all of consenting age and consented to have their material uploaded, they're in the wrong.
- verisimi 3y agoThis is just part of the drive to de-anonymise the web. The governance system (corporations, government) will make it so irritating to use the internet, we will actually be thankful for legislation that de-anonymises us, so that we can remove the too-tight shoes we are in. All artificial, fake issues and fake solutions, but with a privacy win for the governance system at the end of the road.
- T3RMINATED 3y ago[dead]
- AndrewKemendo 3y agoSince the 70s-90s vibes are back I guess it’s inevitable that some startup is going to pitch “porn in a box in the forest” somehow.
- alephnerd 3y ago> porn in a box in the forest Or just host from Russia, Ukraine, and Vietnam like most shady streams already do.
- a2tech 3y agoIts like if geocaching had a sexy secret!
- doubled112 3y agoReal life's random loot box mechanic.
- ethbr1 3y agoCouldn't not read that in Tina's voice from Bob's Burgers.
- abledon 3y ago"Edge computing" has a whole new meaning!
- egorfine 3y agoSo... seems like european users will soon discover the joy of using VPNs daily, just like we in third world countries have been doing for years, right? It's implemented by the same government body that wants more IT startups for the EU and is constantly wondering why don't people come make companies in the company.
- brookst 3y agoIt’s a great place for innovation as long as you don’t care about porn or AI.
- poisonborz 3y agoAnd taxes, bureaucracy, enough workforce, and a few other things.
- egorfine 3y agoAnd taxes, bureaucracy, corporate law, right to use certain technologies, move money freely, attract venture funds, access capital markets, and the list goes on. Source: I'm in the EU right now on this very path.
- adql 3y ago...why ? it seems to be mostly about making sure content itself is, well, not illegal, not deanonymizing users
- papichulo2023 3y agoFrom what I understand, it is both.
- izacus 3y agoPerhaps read about what DMA is before making these statements? Why would you use VPN?
- ethbr1 3y ago
- password54321 3y agoMeanwhile Twitch is allowing more sexual content and Steam has for a little while now has allowed porn on its store. If you ever sort by most viewed or sold on any of these platforms it is hard to miss at this point and just another sign that society is deteriorating. This also won't change anything, not when people are less social which once again lockdowns didn't help with and led to an increase in porn consumption. https://www.nature.com/articles/s41443-020-00380-w https://www.nature.com/articles/s41443-020-00380-w
- brookst 3y agoTwitch reversed their policy after like a day, and Steam always allowed porn. “The world is deteriorating” is such a tired lament. Every generation says that, even as the world gets better by every meaningful measure. The word is change. The world is changing. That’s only bad if you think it was perfect when you were young and formed your worldview.
- password54321 3y agoThis is a naive take. Since lockdowns there is a number of research that shows that the world has become worse in many ways with mental health on the decline. Since then we also have two ongoing wars, with an increase in support for far-right policies. Your take may as well be the "this is fine" meme. >Steam always allowed porn This is obviously wrong.
- brookst 3y agoAny short term measurement will show blips. It’s like saying climate change isn’t real because it gets colder at night. On long term scales, everything is improving[1]. This is obvious to anyone whose ancestors were enslaved, unable to marry because of sexual orientation, or rejected for promotion because of gender. The world is not perfect (see the wars you cite) but it is so dramatically more peaceful than historic times that it really takes a huge bias toward doom to think otherwise. Fair point on Steam, I forgot they switched from an arbitrary and capricious policy to allowing porn in 2018. 1. https://ourworldindata.org/a-history-of-global-living-conditions https://ourworldindata.org/a-history-of-global-living-condit...
- camillomiller 3y agoIt has nothing to with porn, but rather with the fact that they are massive online platforms with millions of users. So, why exactly should they be exempted by the absolutely right compliance made to keep these large platforms in check? I am quite sick and tired of the HN kneejerk response to anything related to EU regulations. Just go live in a stateless libertarian state with Armstrong, Thiel, Musk and their bunch, and see how that plays out for you.
- JD557 3y agoIt's interesting to see PornHub in there, but not the other Aylo (former MindGeek) properties (YouPorn, RedTube...). I wonder if they could in theory bypass the DSA by just breaking PH into smaller services and hope for a split user base.
- beejiu 3y agoOnce they add an age-verification gate, it will surely push their MAU down below the DSA threshold. Does the regulations then still apply?
- Kbelicius 3y agoIf the numbers don't go over the threshold for a year the regulation no longer applies.
- Cthulhu_ 3y agoThat's what I'm thinking, if they're considered separate legal entities then these laws are easily avoided. Like a lot of other laws having to do with company size, profits, taxes, etc.
- jokethrowaway 3y agoCool Europe, another great gem nobody asked for. I don't know who's more dystopian between China and Europe these days. Now, if South America can solve its crime rate problem somehow we will all happily move there.
- ben_w 3y agoWeird thing, sexuality; who asked Apple to make sure no sex was accessible from apps installed from their App Store, even though the same apps on the Google Store didn't have that restriction? (At least, that's the reason given by Telegram and Discord for no adult content on iOS etc.). Conversely, last time I used a public toilet in a German shopping mall, there was a butt plug vending machine by the sinks.
- Tommstein 3y agoWhen I flew through Toronto once, there were condom machines in the bathroom. Leading to a whole host of questions starting with "just how snowed in do those fuckers (pun intended) get‽"
- Gud 3y agoThe European Union and Europe are not synonymous. I have moved out of the EU to Switzerland, partially to avoid shit like this. This authoritarian bureaucracy needs to die. It is doing more harm than good.
- danbruc 3y agoCan we not have anonymous age verification, the ID card signing some one-time challenge that the date of birth is before a certain date? And then just force everyone to implement this to prevent circumvention by going to smaller sites that are not covered by the regulation. This would certainly not be global, so it would require identifying the origin region to decide whether to present this challenge or not. Which could most likely be bypassed with a VPN but then again [almost] nothing will be without any loopholes.
- bogwog 3y agoGovernment ID based webauthn sounds like it could work to solve a lot of problems (bots and spam too). Although it'd be hard to use the internet if you're required to present one for major services (which seems inevitable). There are a lot of reasons someone may not have access to a government ID (e.g. slow bureaucracy) Maybe a nongovernment solution would work too, where certified service providers can sell keys that verify two booleans: is_human and is_minor.
- filoleg 3y agoSouth Korea does it, and from what my friends who lived there (ranging from living there for a year to multiple years) told me, it is about as bad as you would expect. For one, you cannot even access a ton of services and websites unless you got your alien resident card. Online shopping, games, most websites, tons of services, etc. It is such a shitshow, being without that alien resident card might as well make you non-existent. And it takes a while to get it even if you live close to a government office that schedules appointments for those, given it is a good old bureaucracy.
- racked 3y agoThe ultimate 'fuck you' would be for sites like PornHub to split into multiple entities to go under the threshold of 45 million average users per month. That would be nice.
- gumballindie 3y ago> mitigate the spread of illegal content like child sexual abuse material and deepfake pornography I suspect, as indicated by comments on this thread, that a lot of HN readers will be upset by losing access to such content.
- amai 3y agoMaybe a company with more than 45 million users is too big anyway. So they should be split up into smaller companies to avoid the generation of market monopolies.