5 ms·
Of course it did. The question or debate is not if unconditional money helps, but if it's better than alternatives which may be cheaper, such as food credits. E
by paulpauper 3y ago
Of course it did. The question or debate is not if unconditional money helps, but if it's better than alternatives which may be cheaper, such as food credits. Even middle class people would benefit, like $750 to buy groceries. Inflation obviously will erode some of this new purchasing power.
- mbgerring 3y agoThe point is not that it helped, the point is that they used it to exit homelessness. This is important because of the pervasive and empirically incorrect assertion that people do not have housing because they simply choose not to.
- cwillu 3y ago“i correct“ -> “incorrect”, I presume?
- BurningFrog 3y agoSome people choose to. Any assertion that all or none do are wrong.
- cwillu 3y agoA lot of the debate is very sincerely arguing that it doesn't actually help, so making it clear that it really actually does is important to shut down some of the ignorance: “It may not be earth-shattering that providing money is going to help meet basic needs, but I do think it dispels this myth that people will use money for illicit purposes,” Henwood said. “We weren’t finding that in the study.”
- ska 3y ago> A lot of the debate is very sincerely ... I suspect a lot of the debate is very insincerely arguing that.
- kulahan 3y ago[flagged]
- paulpauper 3y agoHey give me $10k. I won't use it for illicit purposes, but I want the money. This is not a justification for giving money.
- zrail 3y agoThe government is very good at giving people money. It's less good at adjudicating whether people require that money. Replacing every government assistance program with direct, unconditional cash transfers would almost certainly be cheaper than the bureaucracy that must be maintained to ensure only "deserving" people get assistance.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ajmurmann 3y agoI'm very much in favor of UBI. Replacing literally "every government assistance program" has me worried though. I think for most folks this will work well. I do wonder about people with special needs though for whom that won't be sufficient. Might it be physical or mental disabilities, it can get more expensive quickly.
- zrail 3y agoSure. UBI would probably work best paired with universal healthcare that covers special needs cases.
- lukifer 3y agoI broadly agree with you, I favor UBI for similar reasons, though I'd maybe frame it less as "very good vs. less good", vs. just acknowledging the enormous overhead costs of means-testing, to say nothing of the consequences when bureaucracy turns corrupt or Kafka-esque. But devil's advocate: is there any reason the same outcome couldn't be accomplished with a negative income tax instead, leveraging a bureaucratic infrastructure which already exists and isn't going anywhere?
- zrail 3y agoI don't really care how it's delivered, as long as it's a regular payment throughout the year that people can depend on. (US specific) The monthly advanced child tax credit, effectively a negative tax, lifted hundreds of thousands of children out of poverty for the short time it existed. Building that into a permanent, regular, universal cash transfer is not mechanically difficult but is intractable politically.
- TriangleEdge 3y agoQuestion for economists: If you give everybody in the US $500 in food credits per month, do food prices go up, or do wages go down? Edit: Let's say there's an expiry function on the credits. Something like you get to keep 50% of the credits if they rollover.
- Alyoshi 3y agoin general that scenario means both go up, although i’m sure you can find weird edge cases. edit: for example, expiration of credit funds could lead to a reduction in wages if it meant less money is spent in the economy than taxed in it.
- eli 3y ago"Food credits" are an expensive and paternalistic Big Government approach to the problem. Is the idea that poor people don't know they need to buy food? Or that the government knows what you should be eating better than you do? SNAP spends something like $0.15 of every dollar on administrative and has complicated rules.
- paulpauper 3y agobetter and cheaper than the $750 going to drugs or alcohol? >Big Government Food credits or $750, you realize it's still coming from taxpayers either way? If someone is homeless it means that they already failed and need help. There is no way it cannot be paternalistic. The question is what is the best solution.
- ajmurmann 3y agoSometimes people have bad luck and typically people have a better understanding of what would help them the most than someone in a government office who has never met them before.
- eli 3y ago> better and cheaper than the $750 going to drugs or alcohol? It didn't. That was one of the conclusions of the study being discussed. At the risk of stating the obvious: someone who's homeless may need medical treatment or, you know, a home more than they need food at that moment. > Food credits or $750, you realize it's still coming from taxpayers either way? The method that costs much less to administer... costs much less to administer. > If someone is homeless it means that they already failed and need help. That's obviously not true. And also isn't how we view the taxpayer-funded fire department coming to put out a house fire.