14 ms·
The changing face of post-pandemic New York City
- cybrox 3y ago[flagged]
- bryanlarsen 3y agoDoes anybody have the stats for the metro area rather than just the city?
- TrueDuality 3y agoIf you click into the article, they have it broken down by boroughs.
- crazygringo 3y agoThat's still the city. The metro area is wider, things like Jersey City and Westchester etc.
- juped 3y agoJersey City is in the New York metro area, Staten Island is not.
- TMWNN 3y ago>Staten Island is not. As Wolfgang Pauli said after reviewing a paper, "That is not only not right; it is not even wrong". (And if you are thinking of claiming that Staten Island's lack of a bridge or tunnel connection to the rest of the city is a disqualifier, please don't bother.)
- juped 3y agoI hope you get that lobste.rs invite!
- jeffbee 3y agoThe CSA population declined 2.6% from the 2020 decennial census to the 2022 ACS. Note that these are not directly comparable surveys.
- renewiltord 3y agoThe census does and it's accessible https://data.census.gov/table/ACSDP1Y2022.DP05?q=population https://data.census.gov/table/ACSDP1Y2022.DP05?q=population If you click the drop down where it says "DP05: ACS Demographic and Housing Estimates" you can select which year's estimate you want to use (or use the Decennial Census). If you want a specific geographical area, click Geos. Then you can get data at whatever level you'd like.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- nicklecompte 3y agoThis is a very interesting question, and the linked study does not address it, only "net migration" to "other parts of the country." IANAD[1] but I suspect the census estimate data is not actually capable of addressing your specific question - how could you tell who was coming from where? But as jeffbee suggested there might be a way to tease it out. The study mentions remote work being part of the reason for the shift; this also confounds "city-to-suburb" versus "city-to-Midwest" migration since it's harder to cross-check against employment statistics - again, without more detailed surveys. [1] Demographer :)
- anyonecancode 3y agoWell, here's some anecdata: I'd been living in NJ for a few years before the pandemic and,just before the pandemic, had finally saved up enough for a down payment. We started looking summer of 2019, and were picky and not in a rush so were still looking when the pandemic hit. What this meant is I got to do a compare/contrast on my town's housing market. Right after everything shut down, there was no activity for a few weeks, but by spring things were restarting (with masking, or even virtual showings). What I saw is that inventory didn't increase -- maybe even decreased actually, as people weren't eager to move -- but demand became insane as people fled the city. Houses went for $50k or more over asking regularly -- the same houses we'd looked at the summer before and passed on because of shoddy construction or suspiciously strategically placed drywall in the basement. I actually kept a spreadsheet to help me figure out how much we'd have to bid to have a chance without over bidding. We were finally successful in 2021, so got to take advantage of the super low rates, even though we ended up paying more up front. Here's the summary stats I ended up with, sale dates 2020-06-25 through 2022-03-18 Square Feet Listing Price Sale Price List vs Sale List vs sale % diff Mean 1,993.36 $568,002.74 $615,661.54 $52,770.80 9.67% Median 1,872.50 $550,000.00 $610,000.00 $51,900.00 9.60%. Max 3,700.00 $1,399,900.00 $1,400,000.00 $225,000.00 37.28% Min 1,140.00 $300,000.00 $285,500.00 ($127,000.00) -19.54% Quartile 25% 1,607.25 $495,000.00 $527,750.00 $14,750.00 2.78% Quartile 50% 1,872.50 $550,000.00 $610,000.00 $51,900.00 9.60% Quartile 75% 2,300.00 $625,000.00 $690,499.50 $91,250.00 16.72%
- throwitaway222 3y agoWhere did they move? (FL?)
- toomuchtodo 3y agoMostly. People leaving Florida typically end up in Georgia or the Carolinas. > For example, most people moving to Florida moved from New York, the fourth largest state in population and a longstanding origin of Florida-bound movers. https://www.clickorlando.com/news/local/2023/07/04/florida-is-the-top-state-people-are-moving-to-we-want-to-know-why/ https://www.clickorlando.com/news/local/2023/07/04/florida-i... https://www.census.gov/library/stories/2023/06/state-to-state-migration.html https://www.census.gov/library/stories/2023/06/state-to-stat...
- mikeyouse 3y agoAbout twice as many people moved from NYC to CT/PA/NJ as moved to Florida -- which makes sense given that the people moving out are generally poorer than average and long-distance moves are expensive.
- dopamean 3y agoAnd they probably don't want to leave the area. It's difficult to leave a network (familial or professional) behind. I'd love to know how many people who made that move made it to start a family.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoAhh! This would be a cool longitudinal study for the census to follow up with. Asking “Did you move to form a family because where you left was too expensive?” but also observing the revealed preference (did they actually have a kid or kids after moving).
- xeromal 3y agoThere are a random amount of New Yorkers in my tiny city in N. Georgia. lol. Something is amiss. haha. They seem to fit in well though taking up shooting, four wheelers, and other traditional activities.
- pierat 3y ago[flagged]
- saalweachter 3y agoOnly around 0.4% of the city's population died of COVID, as of March 2023.
- ghj 3y agoThat's crazy high isn't it? That's 1 out of 250 people!
- fifilura 3y agoStill, over three years around 1 out of 40 die of other causes.
- flextheruler 3y agoDrug overdoses killed more than covid in NYC in 2021
- saalweachter 3y agoI mean, yeah, some absurd fraction of NYC (25%? 50%?) got it before we knew how to treat it. But it's less than a tenth of the total population loss, so it's probably not worth trying to figure out either if the actual toll was higher than the official death toll (maybe by a factor of two?), or if some in the first wave would have died by now of other causes.
- floxy 3y ago~1% of the population dies every year.
- michaelt 3y agoSources like [1] put New York at 379 in 100,000 people, or 0.379% making it the 15th worst hit US state. Bear in mind that even if everyone in the country lived to 100 then died of old age, you'd still have a 1% of people dying every year. [1] https://www.statista.com/statistics/1109011/coronavirus-covid19-death-rates-us-by-state/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/1109011/coronavirus-covi... [2] https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/fastats/deaths.htm https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/fastats/deaths.htm
- acheron 3y agohttps://www.theonion.com/8-4-million-new-yorkers-suddenly-realize-new-york-city-1819571723 https://www.theonion.com/8-4-million-new-yorkers-suddenly-re...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- cglan 3y agoI live in NYC. The problem is that there’s literally 0 housing. That’s it. Literally so many people want to move here, but you look on all of streeteasy on a given day and there’s like 500 apartments. In a city of millions. Sure you can pay more and get something. But it used to be that you traded a lot of quality of life (in unit washer dryer, dishwasher, ac, no walkups, cars, space, etc) for a lower price and the social aspects of living in a city. People don’t believe it, but cities used to be cheap. Now you literally pay more for less in all respects especially during Covid. As the prices have been spiraling up, you also get demographic shifts of only rich people or literally homeless shitting on the streets so you lose the cultural elements of having a diverse income unless you go deep into Brooklyn. I’m not arguing that NYC is not fun still. It’s still great. But without housing for a semi normal price (I can’t even get a place with a dishwasher for less than 2.5k in most areas), and a lot of it, the trade off for living in nyc is making less and less sense.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- necrotic_comp 3y agoThis is true. It's so depressing to have your salary and responsibility go up, but still have the same living circumstances as you did when you had your first job out of college. I still don't have a laundry machine or a thermostat, I have holes in my walls from when my landlord half-did things, my rent has gone up, and I'm expected to continue to do more and get more responsibility. Something's gotta give. I'm not sure what it's gonna be.
- bequanna 3y ago> It’s still great. I’ve been to NYC many times and have friends in their late 30s that live there. The ones that live there say the same (“it’s great”) but never elaborate. From the outside, it honestly looks like a dirty, difficult, chaotic city. Many restaurants, but all seem to be copy+paste coffee shop, Italian, etc or very low quality cafe/deli. Coming from the Midwest, it feels very old, dirty and poor yet somehow expensive and desirable. What am I missing?
- luxurytent 3y agoCities are amazingly resilient and it feels like every generation has a moment in which the city largest and most local to them is having a revival. Seems most large metros are going through some post-COVID pains: Increase in crime, extreme high cost of living, etc. New York will, like always, come back. But! The benefit to our mid size cities is great. We need these mid size cities to grow, and from my understanding, they have! Larger mid size cities mean a better national network for travel, more opportunities for jobs, growth, and movement of people/families. I'm here for all that.
- gandalfgeek 3y agoThe "resilience" argument was misused and misapplied during the pandemic. You also saw it used for school closures -- "kids are resilient". It seems to justify inflicting known harms by having faith in "resilience".
- wing-_-nuts 3y agocovid spread through kids like wildfire, often via asymptomatic infections which then spread to, and killed, elderly who just wanted to see their grandkids. The amount of pushback these measures got, when we were literally just trying to save lives and prevent disability through long covid absolutely staggers the mind and erodes my faith in humanity.
- Racing0461 3y ago> erodes my faith in humanity Opposite for me. Maybe people still care about freedom and agency after all.
- wing-_-nuts 3y agoOr maybe our inability to collectively act and sacrifice to save over a million people is damning. It absolutely gutted my faith that we'll successfully tackle climate change.
- Projectiboga 3y agoI think it's just less 'taxpayers'. I suspect there are numerous 'digital nomads' coming and going. The middle class is fleeing, and retail vacancies are expanding.
- Racing0461 3y agoYou are being downvoted but i also wonder what is the demographics of the people that are moving out.
- Projectiboga 3y agoI'm biased as I live in midtown east of NYC, so I see lots of turnover with rich foreigners and itinerate people floating through. But our losses are mostly the middle and lower middle class with ever more housing being owned by the rarely here cohort. https://www.businessinsider.com/cost-of-living-nyc-millionaires-wealth-tax-2023-12 https://www.businessinsider.com/cost-of-living-nyc-millionai... Before the pandemic the area between Lexington,& 5th aves 30th to 72, maybe 79, had an daily vacancy rate of 80%. I suspect that has increased This means on average, including full time residents, most flats sit above 4 out of 5 days empty. I live two blocks from this and see it. We are only crowded Sept, Oct and a couple of months in the spring, centered around the UN schedule and things like Fashion Week.
- tharne 3y ago[flagged]
- edmundsauto 3y agoI think there's the same amount of explanatory power if you just point at economic conditions. When the economy is bad, there is more crime, which tends to centralize in cities because the increased density means more anonymity plus a greater target market for thieves. Also, the 70s and 80s were peak times for young men who grew up with leaded gas poisoning. Previous generations did not have as much car pollution, car usage increased which led to those increases in crime. Perhaps quality of life is part of the equation but your comment tells us more about your preconceptions than about the reality of the situation.
- doug_durham 3y agoYou really think that the idea of defunding police is a bigger factor than a global pandemic that shut down the city and drove many small businesses out of the city? What an odd take.
- napierzaza 3y agoMy understanding is that generally NOBODY DEFUNDED THE POLICE ANYWAY. The mayor was a cop. I don't think he defunded anything. But it's still used as an excuse. "Someone had an idea of defunding the police, which is why people moved away..."
- tharne 3y ago> You really think that the idea of defunding police is a bigger factor than a global pandemic that shut down the city and drove many small businesses out of the city? What an odd take. It's tough to say, but seems like the defund the police movement "locked in" a lot of the damage caused by COVID and continues to exacerbate it. Rule #1 of getting out of a bad situation is to stop making it worse.
- dgaaaaaaaaaa 3y agoWhy do you think the decrease in population is attributed to crime/lack of safety?
- eatonphil 3y agoIt seems worth looking into what section of the population (either in terms of age or marital status or number of children or education or salary or whatnot) is moving out of NYC. For example, NYC still ranks at the top of where college graduates apply to [0]. [0] https://joinhandshake.com/blog/employers/where-are-college-students-going-after-they-graduate/ https://joinhandshake.com/blog/employers/where-are-college-s...
- junofan 3y agoThe comptroller’s report makes it look more like white flight. Especially figure 6.
- cft 3y agoNot sure how you drew that conclusion, from the original write-up: "The median wage of those who left the city in 2022 was $49,000, which was 18% less than those who left in 2021. Among those who left the city in 2022, 64% were non-White, which was higher than the 58% in 2021 and the 62% in 2019 and 2018."
- light_hue_1 3y agoIt's the opposite. Minorities are being pushed out. > Among those who left the city in 2022, 64% were non-White, which was higher than the 58% in 2021 and the 62% in 2019 and 2018. From April 2020 to June 2022, the population of all major racial and ethnic groups declined after a decade of increases, but did so at varying rates. White and Black populations in the city fell 6.7% and 6.0% respectively — greater than the overall population decline — while the declines in Hispanic (5%) and Asian (2.5%) New Yorkers were smaller.
- legolas2412 3y agoUmm, NYC is 30% white (so, 70% non-white). If among those who left were 64% non-white (or 36% white), if anything, whites are disproportionately being pushed out. Although I would not say there was any group who is a majority in NYC.
- deleted 3y ago
- shin_lao 3y agoMore taxes. Less service. Everything is outrageously expensive. Middle class gets crushed. If you've wealthy, no point in having your main residence in NYC (see, more taxes). Will get worse before it gets better.
- jeffbee 3y agoInstead of regurgitating your priors you could have simply read the article.
- airstrike 3y agoWhat he said is totally in line with the article? “In the pandemic’s wake, we see an altered population and it raises longstanding concerns about the cost of living, the growing wealth gap, the need to preserve a strong middle class, and the challenges of serving an aging population, while ensuring that families are able to raise their children here. We need the city to remain competitive on the world stage and a place where people want to move, put down roots and thrive.”
- airstrike 3y agoThis is it in a nutshell. And I don't see anything that points to those trends reversing in a meaningful way long term.
- jseliger 3y agoTragically, New York State's efforts to increase housing supply by applying laws at the state level seems to have failed: https://www.nytimes.com/article/nyc-housing-hochul-long-island-westchester.html https://www.nytimes.com/article/nyc-housing-hochul-long-isla.... If voters like expensive housing, I guess we'll keep getting expensive housing.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- steveBK123 3y agoYes a lot of people you think of as "NYers" are.. not, for tax purposes. Most famous people you know have enough flexibility that they can be in their West coast / Florida / Mountains / Beach / Westport / Greenwich / Short Hills / etc home 183+ days per year.
- om154 3y agoI want to see this for San Francisco. And, for every other U.S. city!
- nine_zeros 3y ago[flagged]
- esoterica 3y agoNew York’s population did not decline by 5%. The population estimates between censuses always undercounts New York relative to the actual census. The last population estimate for NYS before the 2020 census had the state’s population being flat relative to 2010 and it ended up being up more than 800k in the real census. Same thing is happening AGAIN here. https://policybynumbers.com/a-caution-about-the-use-of-census-population-estimates https://policybynumbers.com/a-caution-about-the-use-of-censu...
- Log_out_ 3y agoGood things the price of accommodation followed that trend.
- belligeront 3y agoMany people are reading this stat to say that NYC is dying because of post-covid crime or some other stat. I really think this is a misreading of the situation. I think it is far likely composition effects from: - High-income people who work remote or hybrid started demanding more space for work and living. Given NYC housing is basically fixed (there is almost no building), this trend has decreased the average number of people per housing unit. - As the article notes, "the city’s populace is overall older and wealthier": wealthier people use more housing per person and tend to have fewer children.
- ghaff 3y agoI'm not sure what the answer is but I'm also not sure why the downvotes. There are absolutely tradeoffs involved in living in a big city, maybe especially NYC. You might still choose to do so absent any specific work-related reason but no one can seriously suggest that taking a daily commute off the table couldn't seriously change the decision someone makes about where they live.
- eduction 3y agoThe comments here are funny. You have a bunch of people saying folks are fleeing NYC due to crime. Then other people saying folks are fleeing due to housing shortage and rents going up. It's like the old restaurant line, "no one goes there anymore, it's too crowded." Keep in mind, crime has risen for each of three years through 2022, and while that trend is worrisome, the actual number of crimes is only back up to 2006 levels. https://www.nyc.gov/site/nypd/stats/crime-statistics/historical.page https://www.nyc.gov/site/nypd/stats/crime-statistics/histori... That's not a year known as "the bad old days" or particularly dangerous, though you can certainly write the alarming headline, "highest crime in 16 years." (FWIW indications are the trend reversed this year https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2023-07-06/nyc-crime-dropped-in-most-major-categories-in-first-half-of-year https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2023-07-06/nyc-crime...) The population decline coincides with the pandemic and remote work, and from my own personal experience here that's a much bigger driver of people leaving. Many people fled to their vacation homes and never came back, other people bought new places upstate and moved. Like all cities, but probably more than most, NYC is at an inflection point where it's figuring out what its future looks like as work habits change. The offices won't all fill back up but aren't easily converted to housing. And frankly NYC's industries, though dynamic and high end, continue to face tech disruption, and Silicon Valley only has more economic strength every year. So there could be even more population loss. Rents seem to be softening. There could absolutely be a down period here, economically and otherwise. But if you look back at the history of the city, these have been the most fertile times culturally. Crime in the 70s and 80s went hand in hand with punk rock in LES, art scene in SoHo, independent film wave, birth of hip hop. There were some actual businesses that came out of all that. I don't want NYC to become that bad again, it's not good for the people who live here, but if there is a lull as the city figures out what it is, there will be a silver lining.
- busterarm 3y agoReported crimes. Keep in mind NYPD had its budget cut by billions of dollars and lost record numbers of officers over the same period. Part of accurate crime statistics is actually finding an officer to report a crime to and then them giving you the time of day. And that's if you haven't given up on the city already and aren't "mindin' yo own business". I lived in NYC from 1984 through 2021 and I can tell you unequivocally that in 2021 it seemed more like 1988 than 2006. If anything, the mid-2000s felt like the safest period of time that I lived in the city -- at the height of where a good party would be held in the same kind of places dead bodies would be dumped a decade or two earlier.
- locopati 3y agomoved out in 2018 after 18 years because i worked remotely and my mental health was frazzled. for much less rent, i ended up in a Catskills cabin in the woods by a stream, a short drive from any number of beautiful trails. bonus points for the luck of already being out of the city when the pandemic happened.
- gen220 3y agoJust curious, how did you find the rental? i.e. through Zillow / the regular listings culprits or was it something more localized? I've been interested in the idea for years, but I haven't seen any on Zillow that match the intersection of price <> accommodations, and I'm wondering if I'm looking in the wrong place.
- locopati 3y agoi got really lucky on one of the rental sites (don't remember if it was zillow or not). the prices have gone up ridiculously in 5 years, between pandemic relocations, the increase in remote work, and airbnbs taking away rental properties and houses for sale.
- asdajksah2123 3y agoWhat these numbers show is that all the stuff people claim about NYC is backwards. 1. These declines are until mid 2022. NYC's population has rebounded since then big time. 2. No, it's not crime deterring people. Crime is heading back close to historic lows. It's cost of living that's deterring people. 3. Rich people are moving in/staying/people in NYC are getting richer. It's the poor who cannot afford to live in NYC that are leaving.
- imbnwa 3y agoIt’s the same thing in Chicago. Gentry use to remain across the river but housing priced/designed for them has pushed past halfway to the Western end of the north side (everything above the Eisenhower expressway) and has been steadily marching south, already into Pilsen, Bridgeport, Bronzeville. I’m curious how much the Polish will put up a fight since they’ve had the Kennedy expressway separating them from the advance on the Northwest side; they’ve always been one of the largest ethnic groups, but if they’re anything like the state of the Ukrainians where there wasn’t enough young generations holding down the neighborhood I expect they’ll fall over in 10 - 15 years if things stay on course (that's from my boomer Ukranian landlord who grew up there and whose mother, whom didn't speak English and was the actual owner, lived above me in a two-story).
- JoshTko 3y agoDoubtful, rents have been increasing during that entire period https://www.zumper.com/rent-research/new-york-ny https://www.zumper.com/rent-research/new-york-ny
- dang 3y agoSubmitters: "Please use the original title, unless it is misleading or linkbait; don't editorialize." - https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html (Submitted title was "New York City population declined by 5.3% since 2020". ) If you want to say what you think is important about an article, that's fine, but do it by adding a comment to the thread. Then your view will be on a level playing field with everyone else's: https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&sort=byDate&type=comment&query=%22level%20playing%20field%22%20by:dang https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&so...
- action-k 3y agoIt is interesting to see which counties the population change has come from. My prior would have been that Manhattan (i.e. "New York County") has dropped a lot, while Queens and especially Kings County (i.e. Brooklyn) maybe even grew. But the data shows all counties (excl Staten Island / Richmond County) dropping ~5% over 2 years. HOWEVER... in Manhattan all that drop happened in 2021 and population actually grew ~1.5% in 2022... while in counties kept dropping ~2%/year. Certainly feels like that in Manhattan today...
- lo_zamoyski 3y agoHow much of the "Rebound of International Immigration" is the result of migrants being bussed to New York from the southern border?
- mancerayder 3y agoThe crime question of NYC is incredibly controversial, and a consensus is that crime is barely up, and where it's up, it's pandemic-related and back to "historical norms". There are two ways to gather crime stats: NYPD reporting them, surveys. Here's a problem with the former: the stats are easy to game: how people are charged, which crimes are responded to, and which reports are taken are all subject to adjustments. Anyone who's tried to get the police to file a report knows: you need to sometimes persuade. Then you have the DA. In Manhattan, Alvin Bragg was elected on a platform of de-incarceration. That means that he believes the 'carceral system' disproportionately punishes the poor and POC and further tears them from their communities. In his Day 1 essay, he outlines what he did: look the other way at property crimes such as shoplifting, and low level muggings and the like. He won't charge, and the police aren't going to stick their necks out for a suspect that's not getting punished (charges dropped or declined to prosecute). I'm happy to pull some stats from articles I saved that prove this. I saved them because it's incredibly unpopular (it's viewed as a 'right wing talking point' historically which renders it false prima facie). I can tell you anecdotally the aggression is something I haven't seen ever, mostly from vagrant types that live in stations and live a life of freedom to punch, smoke, defecate and worse. I know of physical assaults in mid town I hadn't heard about in decades, and I've seen hairy situations during rush hour that haven't existed in my entire time here. Are people fleeing? That's an easier debate. The city has a cycling in of students, new grads and internationals, and a cycling out of marrieds, and the terminally fed-up with communal living and loud crowded commutes. But the city won't die.