10 ms·
Does quantum theory imply the universe is preordained?
- gavinray 3y agoWhen I was a teenager I had an idea: If you rolled marbles down a hill, assuming that identical starting conditions were applied each time, then the marbles' paths and final position would be the same each time. This also implies that if you know the starting conditions, you could calculate the state of any point in time from there. It made me curious whether you could apply this same logic to our universe -- though I get the feeling it's not quite as simple a system as marbles on a hill.
- EA-3167 3y agoThe fundamental question here is whether or not you can get identical conditions in the first place. If for example spacetime is quantized, then it might be that the basic unit of our reality displays the sort of quantum behavior that makes it so hard to predict outcomes. It wouldn't just be a complex system, it would be an essentially random and ever-changing system. By the same token it could be the opposite, maybe it's just a really complex system as you were speculating about, and while nothing is random, it's essentially impossible to predict. In essence, is this a universe where a version of Maxwell's Daemon could conceivably exist, or is it a universe that even a god-like being would find random? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maxwell%27s_demon https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maxwell%27s_demon
- sim7c00 3y agoi think for physical systems this might hold true in some way, though, i am not a physics person at all. it just 'feels' that way to me. however, life is also there, and life doesnt nessesarily follow such rules, as actually most of (intelligent?) life is not physical. (emotions, thought etc.) but does have impact / effect on the physical. i dont think non physical things are so determenistic. (maybe they are, but it doesnt 'feel' that way to me)
- sheepdestroyer 3y agoWhat makes you say that life is not physical? There seems to be no reason to believe that it's not. On the contrary it seems most plausible that everything, including emotions, thoughts, decisions, are just chemical and electrophysical reactions. Thus deterministic.
- tedivm 3y agoIf those physical reactions occur at or are influenced by the quantum level then they stop being deterministic. Hence the article.
- digging 3y agoFor classical physics it's basically true[1]; see Laplace's demon. I recall also independently inventing determinism as a kid after I realized how easily I'd been swayed by external factors into buying one toy over another. For non-physical things, such as emotions and thought... well, we have no actual proof they're anything but physical. We just don't have proof that they're entirely physical, either. But the simplest explanation is actually that they are completely physical processes and just as deterministic as everything else (which is to say, possibly not at all, depending on how QM is resolved). [1] "Basically true" here means it's not strictly true (by that I mean it's not true in all possible cases) - but classical physics itself is not strictly true, thus relativity and QM... which are themselves not strictly true. We're still trying to find the theory that accurately describes all of physics.
- mensetmanusman 3y agoWhen you imagine a red ball, where is that red ball physically? Not the atoms of the neuron configuration etc., but the plane of existence where you place the red ball.
- digging 3y agoI don't understand the question or how it relates to my comment, can you elaborate what you mean by "plane of existence"?
- aeonik 3y agoThere's a good documentary called "The Secret Life of Chaos" that has a fairly cool overview of this concept. Though it's just the beginning of a very deep rabbit hole, possibly unending. Here is a link: https://www.dailymotion.com/video/xv1j0n https://www.dailymotion.com/video/xv1j0n
- ewhanley 3y agoThere's also a decent (not documentary) limited series that explores the idea of determinism. It's pretty good and may be of interest. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Devs_(TV_series) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Devs_(TV_series)
- aeonik 3y agoThanks for the suggestion, two episodes in so far, and it's really good.
- qingcharles 3y agoHighly recommend Devs as an intro to a deterministic universe.
- gpderetta 3y agoIf the path of the marbles were to be determined by some sort of gate in the path that would open or close depending, via a Geiger detector, on whether some uranium atom had decayed, then, as far as we know, the path would be truly unpredictable.
- taeric 3y agoMy mental model for this is to consider boiling water in a pot. You can make easy statements over how long it will take for all of the water to evaporate. It is, to my understanding, impossible to discuss any particular molecule or atom. That is to say, the closer you get to the atomic behavior of atoms, the harder it is to make "deterministic" descriptions of what is going to happen. We often describe this in terms of "coin flips" as you can make a decent discussion over what you will see on 1000 coin flips, but you cannot make such a statement over what you will see over 1.
- pants2 3y agoYou can create a marble run and have marbles more or less follow the exact same path every time. However, on some scale there is an unpredictable nature to things like Brownian motion which affect the run in subtle ways. Perhaps you could get closer if you could account for the physical properties of every particle in the system beforehand, but a some scale these interactions are driven by quantum mechanical processes that aren't predictable even with perfect information (as far as we know). To look at it another way, the entropy of a system is always increasing, so you don't have enough information when the marble is at the top of the hill to know the exact outcome when it's at the bottom (on a quantum scale, or over a long enough period of time).
- mensetmanusman 3y agoThey would be the same until some number of zeros, past which, Heisenberg uncertainty takes over and you cannot predict.
- hkmaxpro 3y agoThe Nature article and your comment reminds me of [1]: What if the hill is a perfectly symmetric hemisphere, so that every path down the hill is equally valid? In fact, this is precisely the shuttlecock analogy in the Nature article, even though that analogy is talking about the quantum Universe initial boundary state, as opposed to the hemisphere example in classical Newtonian mechanics. I guess the shuttlecock analogy isn’t that useful after all, since it fails to set apart quantum Universe theory from Newtonian mechanics, in that the latter can also have no boundary. [1] The Dome: A Simple Violation of Determinism in Newtonian Mechanics https://sites.pitt.edu/~jdnorton/Goodies/Dome/ https://sites.pitt.edu/~jdnorton/Goodies/Dome/ https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37012347 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37012347
- elromulous 3y agoThis does make me wonder: how do we know that random quantum processes are truly random? This gets philosophical very quickly. But for our purposes: independent, uniform, etc. But how do we know there isn't another (earlier) way to observe the result in some fashion.
- variadix 3y agoI think Bell’s inequality implies the state can’t be deterministic but hidden. I’m not sure how you could evaluate the “quality” of the randomness, or if there are existing results analyzing this.
- nyssos 3y agoWe don't. What we know is that we can't have all of 1. locality (no backwards causation / FTL information transfer) 2. determinism 3. counterfactual definiteness (unperformed measurements still have single definite results: we can talk meaningfully about what we would have seen had we done a different experiment) 4. QM gives correct predictions. Objective-collapse interpretations (like the version of Copenhagen described in introductory textbooks) reject 2: collapse is fundamentally indeterministic. Everett (the badly misnamed "many-worlds" interpretation) rejects 3: "measurement" is just what unitary evolution looks like from the inside, and from that perspective always has multiple outcomes. Superdeterminism rejects 4: QM is wrong, but the initial conditions of the universe were for some reason set up in such a way as to prevent us from carrying out any experiments that would demonstrate that.
- cb321 3y agoBricmont does a good job of discussing entropy, arrow-of-time, and irreversibility, information and probability in a purely classical statistical mechanics setting in https://arxiv.org/abs/chao-dyn/9603009 https://arxiv.org/abs/chao-dyn/9603009 . Bricmont has continued to write/expound upon these ideas ever since and more recently "come out" as a non-local hidden variables proponent of the de Broglie/Bohm variety which rejects your (1. locality) for which you left out an example. :-) Sometimes people refer to giving up "locality" in this context with the mouthful "a preferred fundamental foliation of spacetime". { "fundamental" here does the work to block the Cosmic Microwave Background / "average rest frame" which people have no trouble treating as a preferred inertial reference frame that is "merely contingent" not "fundamental", although Ernst Mach might have begged to differ, but that is further afield. :-) }
- DebtDeflation 3y agoI think, ultimately, there are only 3 possible explanations for the paradoxes of the quantum world. 1) superdeterminism (everything including our choices in quantum experiments today were fully determined at the instant of the Big Bang), 2) something "outside" our observable reality acting as a global hidden variable (whether something like the bulk in brane cosmology or whatever is running the simulation in simulation theory) or 3) emergent spacetime (if space and time are emergent phenomena then locality and causation are not fundamental).
- digging 3y agoActually, how are 1 and 2 different? If 2 simply refers to another layer of reality, don't we still have to figure out if it's deterministic or not? I suppose if it has its own completely different (or slightly different[1]) physics, we'd be starting over, but we'd still work our way back to the question of top-level determinism eventually). [1] Referring to cosmological natural selection as a theory of the "fine-tuned" universe: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cosmological_natural_selection https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cosmological_natural_selection (a fun favorite of mine but not looking likely)
- hermannj314 3y agoIt's simulations all the way down.
- DebtDeflation 3y agoFair point. I'm assuming that additional layer of reality is deterministic.
- hnthrowaway0328 3y agoI have been thinking about this. Definitely not a Physicist or even a Scientist, but how do we figure out the world that the simulation occurs? I think one lead we can have is that simulations are called simulations because they try to emulate the real world (the one simulations are running). By observing from inside the simulation what kind of input and reaction the "God" people has when we output something, we might be able to understand the "real" world better. It's like the "people" in the Sims game -- given they are of their own mind, they can figure out some rules of our world. But then how can we jump out of simulation to really really figure it out?
- __turbobrew__ 3y agoI have yet to see a subscriber of superdeterminism not look both ways before crossing the road.
- digging 3y agoA good quip, lol. But of course they would, because they must, because the feeling of control (that is: the unconscious belief in control) is just as intrinsic as the actual absence of control.
- voxl 3y agowhich in other words makes superdeterminism unfalsifiable, because any attempt to do so can be met with "it must have been that way"
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- digging 3y agoAbsolutely. I find it an interesting thought experiment and nothing more unless and until we determine some way to actually see through the veil and identify these extra-universal hidden variables. (At which point our conception of the universe may expand to include these variables and whatever else exists in that outer layer.)
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- throwawaymaths 3y agoOf course every other QM interpretation is also unfalsifiable, e.g. Copenhagen (we have no definition of what constitutes an observation) or many-worlds (obviously unfalsifiable save for actually tunneling through into another universe and coming back to tell the tale)
- GoblinSlayer 3y ago
- PheonixPharts 3y ago"Random" is a property of your mind, not of the world. If I shuffle a deck of cards in a way that you don't know about, then the next card I pull is "random" to you even though, obviously, if one were to turn the cards face up nothing would have changed about the order of the cards, but now the next card would be fully deterministic. I could likewise sort the deck with an algorithm completely unknown to you. I could perfectly predict the next card pulled because I know the algorithm, and yet the next card would still be random for you. Heisenberg uncertainty principle is more a statement about the limits of knowledge than about "God throwing dice". Randomness often has a supernatural property in the popular mind, but is really just a statement about how much information we have about an event. The famous Bayesian philosopher ET Jaynes refereed to this tendency to confuse the randomness as a property of the world rather than our mind as the "Mind Projection Fallacy" [0] 0. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mind_projection_fallacy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mind_projection_fallacy
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- danbruc 3y ago"Random" is a property of your mind, not of the world. Limited information about the initial state is one source of randomness but not necessarily the only one. Whether there is true randomness in the universe is at very least an open question.
- PheonixPharts 3y agoCan you clarify what "true randomness" means out side of the context of human agency and perception? Can you also give an example where "true randomness" would differ from the randomness I describe on the actions a human would take? That is to say, if a my internal model of the world tells me a coin landing on heads is 50/50 how does "true randomness" or not of the resulting coin toss impact how I should gamble on coin tosses? imho the idea of "randomness" separate from our own internal state of belief is a nonsensical concept, but would appreciate examples to the contrary.
- munch117 3y agoAppealing to quantum theory to defend free will does not make sense. If the quantum randomness is fundamental, and reality is stochastic at heart, that makes it non-deterministic, but it doesn't make it any less mechanical. It's in the name, after all: Quantum mechanics. If there is any guiding light to the randomness, any pattern to how the random choices come out, then it's not really random, is it? So, if you think that a deterministic reality is devoid of free will, then you must equally think that a Copenhagen-interpretation fundamentally stochastic reality is devoid of free will.
- nwiswell 3y ago> If there is any guiding light to the randomness, any pattern to how the random choices come out, then it's not really random, is it? Well, yeah, that's the point. By definition, a deterministic model of reality means there is no room for a free agent to make decisions: things couldn't have worked out another way. But a mechanism that appears random provides at least the potential for a free agent, since randomness is exactly what it looks like when you cannot predict system outputs purely from system inputs. It's really a semantic issue. It's not that it's a source of randomness that we're after in order for free will to be possible, but rather non-causality, and quantum mechanics does provide some potential in that regard.
- dotsam 3y agoI find the idea of computational irreducibility useful for rescuing a type of free will in a fully determined world. Computationally irreducible programs are perfectly deterministic, yet you can't predict the output before you run them, and nor are there any shortcuts to get there before running them for the first time. The program running in our brains for 'free will' can be computationally irreducible in this way. No-one can say with perfect accuracy what we will choose to do in advance, not even us. For me, this kind of free will is enough, though it is rather deflationary when compared to some kind of godlike non-causal free will. I think that if we search for non-causal free will, we lose any hope of explanation or understanding: presumably if it's non-causal, then anything can happen, for no reason.
- tromp 3y ago> All the observed complexities can be regarded as partial descriptions of a simple fundamental reality: the Universe’s wavefunction. As an analogy, a perfect sphere can be cut into many chunks with complicated shapes, yet they can be put back together to form a simple sphere. As another analogy, the 100-bit lambda calculus term (λ 1 1) (λ (λ λ λ 1 (2 (λ λ λ 3 1 (2 (λ 2)))) (3 (λ 4 (λ 4 (2 1))))) (1 1)) (λ 1) is a binary tree containing all (infinitely many) closed lambda terms at its leaves. Thus including representations of all possible data and all programs.
- dd1988 3y agoFascinating - familiar with basic lambda calculus, but trying to wrap my head around this. Can you link to anything that explains more about how this works?
- tromp 3y agoA more readable form of the program is given at [1]. The tree contains all combinators built up from the single point basis A = λxλyλz. x z (y (λ_.z)), which is encoded as bit 0 (left branch), while bit 1 (right branch) encodes prefix application. [1] https://github.com/tromp/AIT/blob/master/ait/allA.lam https://github.com/tromp/AIT/blob/master/ait/allA.lam
- ericfrazier 3y agoProving the world operates without free will is trivial.
- mensetmanusman 3y agoJust die and see?
- ericfrazier 3y agoIf you want. I've proven it without dying.
- MrGinkgo 3y agoNot sure if this is just a moot point, but I'll say it because I'm genuinely curious to hear what people have to say. Anytime I hear theories like this, I feel wary of accepting it as an air-tight reliable outlook because of human limitations. Like, our understanding of quantum physics and all natural laws come from what we can percieve and measure, but there's bound to be phenomena which we can't percieve or measure (either yet, or ever) which limit our understanding of the universe. I understand that science is a constant process, and that we shouldn't jump to conclusions of any theories being "truth" because of this process, but anytime anything like this comes up, I'm always wary of the consequences that occur from all the people who DO dogmatically assert that it's undeniable, especially with how easily theories of predeterminism tend to enable unproductive, nihilistic outlooks. I don't necessarily see science as trivial pursuit because of our human limitations, but I feel like not enough people have learned their lesson about the consequences of eagerly accepting a "work in progress" as "ultimate truth".
- moritzwarhier 3y agoVery well put! > I don't necessarily see science as trivial pursuit because of our human limitations Me neither, quite the opposite, but the problem you are describing has always been a problem when discussing metaphysics, as it is commonly called. Science is aware of its limitations, that's what makes it science. But sometimes, people tend to conflate a materialistic world view (maybe even strong determinism) with believing in the scientific method. The "belief" I mean here is strongly tied to assigning the appropriate role in ones thinking to scientific facts. Proving an all-encompassing scientific world view is a logical paradox.
- broscillator 3y ago> But sometimes, people tend to conflate a materialistic world view (maybe even strong determinism) with believing in the scientific method. I would say more than sometimes. It seems that if you're not like that, you're immediately labeled religious.
- thefaux 3y ago
- at_a_remove 3y agoI've never seen some consensus as to the definition of free will to the extent that it was testable. As in, "What experiment can we perform to show this thing has free will?" or "Define free will in such a fashion that a universe with free will is notably and different from a universe without free will, in a manner we can detect." If we cannot do that, I am not even sure what the point is of discussing the concept. It is like some box we are told lies sealed in a distant continent, and we argue about what is in the box. Why? We'll never know, and the answer doesn't seem to change anything.
- karaterobot 3y agoI have not heard a convincing explanation of how the universe could produce the Monorail episode of The Simpsons merely by a certain configuration of energies in the first moment of the big bang, and the consequences of thereof. The most obvious argument is that the Monorail episode of The Simpsons is not only possible in at least one of the infinitude of quantum, deterministic universes, but inevitable, and that the seeming absurdity is merely my inability to acknowledge my anthropic bias. Nonetheless, I laugh every time I think about the motion of particles leading unavoidably to the invention of everything required for someone to type "I call the big one Bitey!", and for me to appreciate it, or believe—as I must—that I appreciate it. The mind reels!
- twiceaday 3y agoThe three body problem is impossible to solve analytically. The state space is clearly all connected but in a way that cannot be short-cut. You have to walk it deterministically one state at a time. Once you reach some interesting state, you know that you will always reach it from your initial state. It is inevitable but in general impossible to predict. There is no simple story to tell as to why you'd end up there, you just do as a culmination of the state-path up to that state. We've reached a state where that Simpsons episode was created. It's very interesting and was impossible to predict from all the way back during the bing bang. Maybe it was inevitable?
- mewpmewp2 3y agoIt was inevitable, there is nothing else it could have been. How could it have been something else? What would have had to make it something else and if there was randomness why would it matter?
- aap_ 3y agoThe cosmic ballet goes on.
- dist-epoch 3y agoI have a similar problem as you, I just can't understand how determinism makes the lion's atoms move exactly in the direction of the gazelle's atoms. At the same time, I also can't ignore the large number of very famous and accomplished physicists which take determinism very seriously.
- Xcelerate 3y agoI feel like “deterministic” and “predictable” are often conflated. Suppose I give you the output of encoding a secret message with a one-time pad. Can you predict the message contents without the one-time pad? No. Does that mean the output was generated non-deterministically? No. More generally, there are strings with Kolmogorov complexity of at least the length of the string but for which the conditional Kolmogorov complexity is very small given some other string. In this sense, it’s quite possible that quantum mechanics is fully deterministic and there is a hard limit on our ability to predict the future (so for all intents and purposes, quantum mechanics is at some level indistinguishable from true randomness to us despite there being no randomness whatsoever in the laws of physics). In fact, I think the former actually implies the latter: Consider a completely classical, deterministic universe (or at least imagine a high fidelity molecular dynamics simulation of our lightcone of the universe). Then all of the actions that humans take in an attempt to predict future observations are fully pre-ordained. Why should it be the case that these actions just so happen to lead to output that describes another subsystem’s behavior to arbitrary precision? That would be a strange coincidence to have for whatever set of laws describes the time evolution of this hypothetical universe. Mathematically, how many universes like that are even possible? What sort of bizarre initial conditions would there have to be for this to be the case? My take is pretty simple: 1) the universe is fully deterministic and 2) quantum mechanics appears inherently random to us because we are inescapably part of the system we are trying to study and predict. So now the interesting question: is there is an experiment that can distinguish between the case of a fully deterministic universe and one with non-deterministic processes, given that the two would seem to appear the same as far as human observation is concerned?
- GoblinSlayer 3y agoIf an experiment has a consistent deterministic model, it indicates determinism, because it should be impossible to model indeterministic experiment deterministically.
- Animats 3y agoNo new info. From the article: "So how deterministic is the Universe? The answer will depend on the final theory that bridges the divide between quantum physics and relativity — and that remains a far-off prospect." Unless physics is totally noise-free, with zero randomness, there is indeterminism. There are so many chaotic processes that amplify randomness that any randomness at all will cause wide divergence in outcomes. Whether or not noise and free will are the same thing is a question for theologians. Rudy Rucker addressed that question in passing in one of his SF novels.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- lern_too_spel 3y agoIf you can't control the noise, there is no free will. If you could control the noise, that would be measurable. You need both to be able to control the noise and to not have that be a direct consequence of another physical process in order to demonstrate free will.
- jakeogh 3y agoDeterminisim is impossible because randomness is baked in; knowing position and momentum isnt a thing, and as far as we can tell the only closed systems are light cones. Odd that the article didnt mention Heisenberg. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21253267 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21253267
- lern_too_spel 3y agoRandomness doesn't imply free will. I was responding to the last paragraph of GGP's comment.
- GoblinSlayer 3y agoNoise doesn't necessarily participate in reasoning, it can be just a factor to ignore or smooth out. You can calculate 1+1 at a random moment of time, but the result will be 2 - deterministic in spite of present randomness.
- FredPret 3y agoI always see references to free will when certain people start talking about quantum mechanics. Why do people care if free will exists or not? It doesn't seem to affect anything I can think of. - It feels like it exists; it feels like I'm making my decisions. Even if my whole life is a series of decisions calculated by me in some inevitable way, the calculations still had to happen in my head, and the experience of deciding was part of that. Therefore I own my decisions either way. - For that reason, a criminal is just as guilty of their crime, whether they spiritually willed themselves to rob the bank, or whether they are predetermined to. The decision to rob the bank happened in their head. - Punishment for a crime makes just as much sense either way and for the same reason. Seeing criminals get punished will affect the calculations happening in nearby brains, possibly lowering the chances they will in turn decide to rob the bank. Removing errant decision-making matrices from society should reduce the amount of badness. - All of the opposite things are also true for rewarding good behavior. What would you do with a CPU that can do nothing but churn out malware due to a design flaw? What if it's a CPU that only does amazing things? Or if it's some mix of both? It seems very similar to how we'd treat people who behave differently.
- jddj 3y ago>For that reason, a criminal is just as guilty of their crime, whether they spiritually willed themselves to rob the bank, or whether they are predetermined to. The decision to rob the bank happened in their head. > Punishment for a crime makes just as much sense either way and for the same reason. Seeing criminals get punished will affect the calculations happening in nearby brains, This could be a local maxima. I'm not sure there is a reason (other than us having arrived at it, which does count for something) why blaming, and particularly hating/attributing evilness to people for performing a certain act while operating under an imagined agency is more effective than some alternative. It's possible that there could be a means of dissuading others from the behaviour without that illusion/emotional baggage. It could arrive at the same conclusion (incarceration, for example) but more compassionately. Does that matter? For the bigger picture arguably not, but for the human experience maybe.
- FredPret 3y ago
- bobsh 3y agoIt is massively distributed, the universe, with each local structure having its own determinations. It’s not pre-ordained so much as it is jit-ordained, where each thing (and sub-thing) is doing its own jitting, with each and every change of local state.
- RagnarD 3y agoShort answer: absolutely not. The whole idea actually originated in wholly mistaken idea that Newtonian mechanics implied that the universe was a big clockwork, unfathomably complex but still predetermined. This rests on the false philosophic view that Newtonian mechanics are the only form of causality (or more broadly, that the laws of physics are the only form causality.) Free will is a type of causality emerging from a particular kind of entity. It in no way violates any other type of causality, and vice-versa. Free will can't violate physics; you can't say "I have free will, therefore I can throw this ball to 50% of light speed." It pertains to an entity with free will making a choice among certain finite possible choices at any given time.
- AndrewKemendo 3y ago> Describing the precise positions and momenta of all the particles involved requires so much information that any statement of the initial condition is too complex to be a law. >Hartle suggested that quantum mechanics can solve this complexity problem. Because a quantum object’s wavefunction is spread out across many ‘classical’ states (cat alive or cat dead, for instance), you could propose a simple initial condition that includes all the complexities as emergent structures in the quantum superposition of these states. So the one theory I have that I have absolutely no backing for and I recognize is not really falsifiable is that the purpose of humanity is to build general intelligence… general intelligence is then supposed to build Laplace’s demon Laplaces demon actually counting all the things would look like a giant condensation aka slowing down and “freezing” because there is no more entropy left and everything is pulled together which is the event that kicks off the next iteration of the universe, a.k.a. “the big bang” which then redistributes everything back out again (not sure why) Again: I do not endorse this as what actually happened it’s just a crazy idea that feels right to me.
- DontchaKnowit 3y agoPretty sick sci fi novel plot in there at the least
- AndrewKemendo 3y agoHey, if it worked for L. Ron Hubbard right…?
- kromem 3y agoIf anything, it seems like QM existing makes a pretty good case free will also exists looking at more recent tech developments. We have virtual worlds that could be described deterministically, such as with procedural generation and a seed function. Often, these functions are theoretically continuous. But also often, there's a mechanism by which the continuous function converts into discrete units. Why? In order to track state changes to what would otherwise be deterministic by free agents (i.e. players changing stuff). That reality goes from continuous behavior to discrete upon interactions with free agents, and then goes back to continuous if the persistent information about those interactions is erased, looks a lot like what we might expect from a universe that needed to keep track of changes by free agents in an optimized manner (such that information erasure resets behavior back to functionally defined continuous behavior and not tracking discrete units). Interestingly, this was predicted by the earliest philosophers thinking about quantized matter being solely governed by natural laws. They reasoned that if the laws of motion governing quanta were singular outcomes, that free will could not exist, thus given their belief in free will they hypothesized that quanta had variable outcomes which they likened to a 'Swerve' moving in a different direction suddenly from the other option. Over 2,000 years before we had experimental evidence that not only was matter made up of quantized parts, but that those parts were best described as moving probabilistically with variable outcomes. That the behaviors of these quantized parts is time reversible seems less indicative of determinism and more like they serve the function of state tracking for interactions.
- amai 3y agoAs the flow of a river on the big scale the flow of the universe might be entirely predictable. But we are living on the smallest scales of the universe. So we might simply not experience this determinism of the universe, as a molecule in the river might not notice that the river is flowing into the sea.