6 ms·
Greyhound bus stops are valuable assets
- starkparker 3y ago> Houston, Philadelphia, Cincinnati, Tampa, Louisville, Charlottesville, Portland, Oregon, and other downtown bus depots have shuttered in recent years. Bus terminals in major hubs like Chicago and Dallas are also set to close. Greyhound and other companies have relocated their stops far away from city centers, which are often inaccessible by public transit, switched to curbside service or eliminated routes altogether. The Portland depot closed two months before COVID arrived; the ticket booth moved one whole block south. Two years prior TriMet had tried to buy it and turn it into a parking depot for its buses and trains. The new curbside stop is closer to parking. Nothing moved more than two blocks from Union Station. The old 30,000-square-foot building became a 96-bed county-run homeless shelter, which the city needs a hell of a lot more than a bus terminal. https://www.portlandtribune.com/news/greyhound-station-to-remain-homeless-shelter-through-winter/article_8ed54d21-82fe-53ce-b7ee-c5fa292760fb.html https://www.portlandtribune.com/news/greyhound-station-to-re... https://www.oregonlive.com/commuting/2019/09/greyhound-moves-out-puts-portland-bus-terminal-up-for-sale.html https://www.oregonlive.com/commuting/2019/09/greyhound-moves...
- tclancy 3y agoHow does this single example disprove the claim?
- AnimalMuppet 3y agoPortland was part of the claim. So it at least disproves the claim for Portland.
- starkparker 3y agoI never suggested it did. It's just significant context not in the article.
- chasil 3y agoAs far as Chicago is concerned, the obvious answer is to find room at Union Station. For some unknown reason, neither CTA ("The El" and subways) nor Greyhound/Trailways are directly connected to the Union Station building; each is at least a two block walk, with limited accessibility. Only Amtrak and Metra trains are inside the building. CTA does have a bus stop outside across the street. Putting everything into one facility would make it easier to use all of it. Edit: there are a couple of potential reasons for this. First, Amtrak likely does not want to compete with Greyhound on fare pricing. Second, adult beverages are sold within Union Station and Metra is particularly friendly towards them; Greyhound is very much not.
- jdeibele 3y agoMy daughters take FlixBus up from/down to Corvallis (Oregon State) and Eugene (U of Oregon) and the stop is a couple of blocks north of Union Station, as you say. I took a different bus to Eugene, The Point, where you buy tickets from Amtrak but the bus is run by a different company. The bus boards right outside Union Station in Portland. The nice thing for me was that I able to show a ticket for that day to the two security guards and was able to use the restroom. I'm not sure I could have talked them into it otherwise. I was dropped off at the Eugene Amtrak station where there weren't any security guards. I see restroom access as a competitive advantage but The Point only goes up and down I-5 so it's limited in appeal. https://www.oregon-point.com/ https://www.oregon-point.com/
- givemeethekeys 3y ago> "As Greyhound terminals close, transit advocates say the public sector needs to step in to play a larger role in supporting intercity bus travel." I wish the article would cite the transit advocates that are in favor of this.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- yaomtc 3y agoWhy wouldn't transit advocates be in favor of more support for intercity transit?
- bluGill 3y agoThat can be different from supporting these terminals though. Which is why a citation would be nice: so you can drill down into why they think this is bad. Maybe you disagree, maybe you agree, but until you understand the issue you cannot form an opinion. You may even agree with all their reasoning and still favor closing the terminals because there are considerations they are not considering. (I consider myself a transit advocate, but I'm not sure if I'll write up my thoughts: that would take a lot of time/effort to put into words. In any case you didn't ask that question)
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> Why wouldn't transit advocates be in favor of more support for intercity transit? The solution for intercity transit is obviously trains and aircraft. The primary disadvantage of intra-city trains is the expense of building a rail line to less traveled parts of a city, but nearly every city already has at least one intercity rail line. The reason intercity passenger trains aren't more popular is that Amtrak charges almost as much as a plane ticket costs but then gets you there much slower. Which is in part caused by low ridership, which subsidies for intercity buses would only make worse.
- pavon 3y agoIt's not just price. Amtrak routes cover a tiny fraction of the routes that greyhound does, and likewise only a fraction of cities/towns have airports. At least in the past, Greyhound was often bundled with Amtrak to complete trips. Many of the existing freight rail lines aren't suitable for passenger use even if there was demand to support them, and even if they were the are still tons of town with no rail passing through them. Using the highways we've already built and are going to maintain either way is more efficient than building out completely different infrastructures for public transit and personal transportation.
- jewayne 3y agoNext year, the youngest Boomer will turn 60 years old. As the Boomers age out of driving, the lack of other options is going to become a major political issue. The post-war babies still have enormous clout, and I highly doubt they will accept a total loss of mobility when they're no longer comfortable navigating busy stroads and highways. They will soon be the ones pushing for better intercity bus / passenger train options.
- bluGill 3y agoThey should be, but more likely they will just push relaxing driving standards so they can continue to drive despite not being safe. Same as nearly most other retirees are doing. Most retirees seem to drive less, but only a few have stopped. I don't think it has occurred to many that transit could be an option - unless they already live in a place where transit is useful and thus they are using it. Even then few seem to think they could get transit in other places they want to visit.
- pavel_lishin 3y agoFor some of them who live in certain suburbs - like Plano, TX - they've likely lived most of their adult lives without ever actually seeing public transportation, much less using it.
- jewayne 3y agoMeh. I think those with means quietly vote with their feet, not quite aware of what they are doing. Have you ever been to / seen video of The Villages? Golf carts and pedestrians owning the street, with cars as guests. And this might be the most politically conservative place in America. Yes, they probably need an at least one experience of good intercity transit before they see it is possible, but now that the Brightline is running in The Old People Holy Land of Florida, many will have it.
- SoftTalker 3y ago> more likely they will just push relaxing driving standards so they can continue to drive despite not being safe Statistics don't bear this out. The most unsafe drivers are the younger ones.
- RandallBrown 3y agoI'm not sure that Greyhound needs large bus terminals. A couple years ago, a canceled Amtrak necessitated me taking a very long Greyhound ride. I started at the Greyhound station in LA and got dropped off at a McDonalds in the very small town of Lordsburg New Mexico. Other than one bus transfer in Tucson all the stops were at gas stations or parking lots. Their terminals were actually much worse stops because people tended to congregate there and Greyhounds attract an interesting group of people. It was a horrible experience overall, but the stops were very much not the problem.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoI don’t necessarily disagree with you, but there is something to be said for considering this critical infrastructure. If the bus stops are going to be strip mined for the real estate value, then there should be some sort of agreement to find better termination points for this transit. In Chicago, Union Station and both Ohare and Midway airports come to mind, as they are multi modal and also have taxi and public transportation systems plugged into them already. You can hop on the blue line at Ohare or the orange line at Midway. Union Station plugs into Metra and Amtrak. If America has traditionally relied on the private sector for this (robust bus terminal hubs), we’ll have to revisit the public sector delivering in its place. “Minimum Viable Infrastructure” or something like that.
- gbacon 3y agoIt’s a decaying service that even a “stubborn transit user”[0] does not want. Propping up this zombie is actively harmful. [0]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38686993 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38686993
- toomuchtodo 3y agoTwo questions: How do we continue to serve a transportation consumer population that can only afford bus tickets? If we decide to continue to serve this population, how do we do it in a manner consistent with developed world standards? If the zombie must die to be reborn, reasonable. But to double tap it in the head and these people go without long haul transportation seems untenable. And high speed rail isn’t getting built any sooner than a decade from now. In the meantime, those not of means need long haul transportation to be solved for.
- mauvehaus 3y agoThe Cleveland station is a stunning example of the Streamline Moderne style the article mentions. Highly worth a visit if you're in town: https://www.cleveland.com/life-and-culture/erry-2018/10/f6f32551a81767/clevelands-stunning-greyhound.html https://www.cleveland.com/life-and-culture/erry-2018/10/f6f3...
- mayormcmatt 3y agoThanks for presenting the term to that type of architecture: I've not known what's it's called and really, really love the look. Timeless, to my eyes.
- gumby 3y agoTL;DR: Once again, private equity strip mines ifrastructure.
- bufordtwain 3y agoNoel Philips' recent youtube video about his cross country Greyhound trip gives a realistic view of Greyhound. It's not at all flattering.
- paulette449 3y agoTravel YouTuber Noel Philips documented his experience on a long distance greyhound journey published a couple of weeks ago. ("I spent 5 Days on America's Longest Greyhound Bus. It was hell." [1]). Noel expressed huge empathy for the folks he shared the journey with recognizing that here is a desperate need for Greyhound's services, their customers tend to come from low/no income backgrounds and the company by and large treats them with contempt. [1] - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z8QGTaGwxxc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z8QGTaGwxxc
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoI did a 5 day trip on greyhound twice as a teenager. Once the southern route (from Vicksburg to Seattle via LA and through Texas and Arizona) and once the northern route (from Vicksburg to Seattle via Chicago and through Montana). The bus stopped at every prison on the route, and the prisoners from Texas and Arizona would get off at LA or Sacramento because they had nowhere else to go, it was sad. But mostly everyone was cool, if a bit smelly (well, I was also, not showering after a couple of days things get dank). My dad really couldn’t resist the $60 go anywhere fare they were running at the time. It was definitely an experience though. I met some nice people, had some weird experiences, I think back on it fondly.
- Natsu 3y agoA friend of mine took a bus to visit me recently. He spent many extra hours because a bus driver saw someone in line smoking, then just abandoned everyone at the stop for that. Plenty of strange people demanded his seat & ticket and it wasn't any too clear that they had their own. Not to mention all the times he was left with long walks or in strange areas in the middle of the night.
- hbarka 3y ago“Last year, Alden subsidiary Twenty Lake Holdings purchased 33 Greyhound stations for $140 million. Alden is best known for buying up local newspapers like The Chicago Tribune, New York Daily News and The Baltimore Sun, cutting staff, and selling some of the iconic downtown buildings.” “Twenty Lake Holdings LLC, a subsidiary of Alden Global Capital, purchased 33 Greyhound stations from the U.K. conglomerate FirstGroup late last year.” https://www.axios.com/2023/11/18/greyhound-alden-bus-stations-close https://www.axios.com/2023/11/18/greyhound-alden-bus-station... https://www.theguardian.com/business/2021/oct/21/firstgroup-announces-125m-sale-of-its-greyhound-bus-service-in-the-us https://www.theguardian.com/business/2021/oct/21/firstgroup-...
- screye 3y agoI don't see the article addressing how crime and homelessness play into downtown bus transit. Downtown greyhound terminals are the most consistently delipidated and crime prone (seeming) parts of the city. As a poor student, I took a ton of grey hound buses and the central drop off locations always looked shady. Big bustling cities would drop you in the middle of the city's worst poverty. While smaller crumbling cities treat the greyhound stop as homeless central. I'll say, my experience is more so in the North East corridor which is more densely populated and the bus networks are well used. As long as greyhound buses are the choice transportation of the drug addicted, there is no amount of sugar that will make them seem appealing. Even as an stubborn transit user, I have sworn off intercity buses in both the US and surprisingly Europe too. Just the smell is enough of a deterrent.
- AtlasBarfed 3y agoThe article has some point, but to yours I doubt they point out how cities use intercity busses to dump homeless off on other cities: https://www.pbssocal.org/shows/democracy-now/clip/cities-give-thousands-of-homeless-people-one-way-bus-tickets-to-leave-town https://www.pbssocal.org/shows/democracy-now/clip/cities-giv...
- WorldMaker 3y agoIt's a chicken-and-egg/gordian knot problem isn't it? Buses are still the cheapest mode of inter-city transportation, well below airplanes and below trains (not to mention the bad state of passenger train travel in the US where buses have been left as the only non-airplane options between some major cities). As the cheapest option that should mean they have the widest audience in theory, but also as the cheapest option they have also become the only option for certain portions of the populace. In the race to the bottom of capitalism they focused too much on the cheapest passengers and lost a lot of reasons to enforce cleanliness and standards in the name of cost efficiencies. In theory, they could try to expand back to more "premium experiences and amenities" raise some prices and try to expand from just the poorest passengers, but they risk losing the most regular passengers they have. In practice, they also always have a hard time competing with the "premium experiences" of air travel because even accounting for the time overhead of TSA and "be two hours early to be on time for your flight", buses still lose when it comes to overall travel time. I don't think there's currently an easy market-based solution to solve the chicken-and-egg/gordian knot problem of the very ugly local maxima of poor service for the cheapest passengers only that inter-city buses currently have maximized for rather than trying again for cleaner, better inter-city buses. (Maybe it needs more public infrastructure and support; maybe it needs an entirely new competitor to shake things up, like now might just be the ripe time for the disruption of something like inter-city electric dirigibles to be a best of both worlds lower priced [especially as diesel gets more expensive], no TSA but some of the time savings of more direct air travel. That probably isn't going to happen, because this timeline isn't that cool, but we can collectively dream and there are startups on HN that think they can do some version of that disruption.)
- AtlasBarfed 3y agoThis seems like bad policy, because it's my prediction that highway self-driving and EV drivetrains will make intercity bussing much cheaper. The transport / fuel costs will be 1/2 to 1/3, the labor cost will probably drop from some amount of automation, and the repair/maintenance costs of EV drivetrains is a lot lower. The recharge time isn't a big deal with passenger transport, since there is the station dropoff/pickups and the stops at places to eat. With some degree of good highway self driving or remote driving, you could even use smaller vans that are less capital intensive. Or even an intercity car service.
- citrate05 3y agoI don't understand why highway self-driving would help save on costs. You would still have to exit the highway to make stops, and that means you would need a driver to be on board the whole time, right?
- wkat4242 3y ago> "Roughly three-quarters of intercity bus riders have annual incomes of less than $40,000." Wow. The US really has a much higher cost of living. Here in Barcelona if you make that much you're actually making pretty good middle-class money. Most of my friends make around 25k and some even own their flat. The idea that you're a "poor bus-rider" with "only" 40k salary... Wow.
- skyyler 3y agoMay I ask how much a normal 1br apartment costs in your area?
- wkat4242 3y ago1br are scarce and tiny but I guess around 600-700 per month. Less than 200k to buy (and this is in Barcelona so prices are higher than elsewhere)
- nitwit005 3y agoThe median household income is around 75k, so they're definitely relatively poor. Look up what American rents are, and you'll see the main cost of living issue.
- wkat4242 3y agoWow 75k is a fortune here. I don't even make that much and I'm an enterprise architect for a fortune 500 with global responsibility. This explains a lot. I often shudder at the cost of tech products these days. But I guess by American standards it's not so bad.
- nickd2001 3y agoIn USA decent food (not full of cr*p and gonna wreck your health) cost, in my experience, twice as much as UK 20 yrs ago, might be 3x now. If you need healthcare, expect big bills, even if you're insured. Many parts of USA you gotta drive everywhere, which is costly. A family might need 2 cars. Seems to me a fair proportion of the larger US salaries get swallowed up. And don't forget you have to work 40 hrs a week vs 37.5 which amounts to 2 weeks extra a year, and Americans generally get 2 weeks vacation vs in UK 4 weeks legal min, often 5 weeks or more. And US employment law is often you can get fired at the drop of a hat. Having no security like that would be called a "contractor" in UK, and compensated accordingly ;)
- 71a54xd 3y agoTbh I'd take a greyhound any day over a Spirit airlines flight.
- miachelbrown 3y ago[flagged]
- olliej 3y agoI love that I can't see CNN content because it needs me to disable my ad blocker to ensure my privacy. :-/