6 ms·
A new Suez crisis threatens the world economy
- h2odragon 3y agohttps://archive.ph/70DZE https://archive.ph/70DZE
- graphe 3y agoI wonder if it'll affect politics. People hate it when their local streets are blocked for protests. The protests are overseas and potentially affecting us locally. Has something recently like this happened before?
- bluish29 3y ago> and it claims that it is targeting “all ships heading to Israeli ports” until food and medicine are delivered to Gaza. Maybe we should try this obvious solution first, deliver "enough" food and medicine to people in gaza?
- ericfrazier 3y agoIt all goes right to Hamas so, no?
- 8b16380d 3y ago[flagged]
- cyanydeez 3y agoWe can't let one small genocide hold us hostage over one small far right ethnostate holding us hostage over...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dgellow 3y agoThat would confirm viability of the attackers strategy. They already are risking their life for this, they have no incentives to stop once their demands are fulfilled. In some ways that makes it now impossible to deliver food and medicine because that may be seen as a Houthi victory…
- ceejayoz 3y ago“Oh no, someone forced us to feed a million starving refugees. This establishes bad precedent!”
- DiscourseFan 3y agoUnfortunately, yes. War is very ugly.
- jakupovic 3y ago[flagged]
- DiscourseFan 3y agoJustice? I don't think anyone here cares about justice more than the Houthis, and there version of it is the total destruction of the US and Israel. They believe, literally, it is their divine mission to destroy those two states. How are the US and Israel supposed to respond to a group whose stated goal is their complete and utter destruction? Would it be just to give them any leeway, to give them any sort of victory they can boast about to gain more followers, more strength, in order to execute terrorist attacks against the US and its allies? Would it be just to endanger their own citizens just for a short peace that ends the moment the Houthis decide they have the power to advance further?
- keybored 3y agoThis sounds like Sam Harris logic. The most dangerous groups aren’t the most hateful or those who the most ambitious goals, like “destroy America”. It is those who are both powerful and have some stated or non-stated plan to do something. The US and Israel are much more powerful than these groups.
- JumpCrisscross 3y agoYou're arguing that America and Israel are more dangerous than Hamas? I mean yes, of course. That's the point of having a military.
- fny 3y agoHere’s the full quote: > The militant group’s motto includes the exhortation “Death to Israel. A curse upon the Jews,” and it claims that it is targeting “all ships heading to Israeli ports” until food and medicine are delivered to Gaza. But most of the ships being attacked neither are headed to Israel nor have Israeli ownership. While I sympathize with the notion that supplying aid might assuage the Houthis, it seems they’re ambitions are both greater and mistargeted.
- DennisP 3y agoOr maybe food and medicine to Gaza is their goal, but they lack the means or incentive to specifically target Israel-related ships.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> they lack the means or incentive to specifically target Israel-related ships They lack internal coherence. We’re talking about a group of warlords, after all. Nobody is in charge, which makes the notion of striking a deal ludicrous.
- perihelions 3y agoYou'd negotiate with (or threaten) Iran, not the Houthi warlords. These are, after all, Iranian cruise missiles (etc.) that Iran is giving to the Houthis for proxy fighting. Yemen's own capabilities are a non-factor.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> You'd negotiate with (or threaten) Iran, not the Houthi warlords Correct. Conspicuously, Iran hasn’t offered terms. Which makes sense. The chaos boosts their bona fides. And they’re selling oil through a separate channel.
- YouWhy 3y ago> deliver "enough" food and medicine to people in gaza? You assert that this case of piracy is driven by noble causes, as opposed to literally any use of force by any government in human history. Assuming that the Houthi demands are complied with, what should prevent the Houthis from using their military force to promote other causes, perhaps less noble, like enriching their own leaders (a.k.a., privateering and collecting ransom)?
- jakupovic 3y agoWell isn't that what people with big guns do now?
- keybored 3y ago> You assert that this case of piracy is driven by noble causes, as opposed to literally any use of force by any government in human history. This point can be made about any of the groups with weapons in this context. Including Israel. So it becomes useless.
- YouWhy 3y agoQuite the opposite. Piracy (more precisely: systematically and arbitrarily attacking vessels in the open seas) is not considered legitimate for any government - not the US, not China and certainly not Israel. The violation of this rule by itself is grounds for war by the injured governments (which, by the way include most of the EU and the US). The extraordinary claim here is exempting the Houthi extreme actions from the rule of not practicing piracy just because they are hostile to Israel. The above line of thought also begs the question of what other extreme actions are supposedly justifiable if the perpetrator happens to be hostile to Israel. Is it a get-out-of-jail card of some kind?
- keybored 3y agoOh, I read your comment as if you were equating nation states and pirates. But it seems that you were saying that, well if you can’t even expect X of nation states, then why should you expect it of pirates (which are worse)? Now I think I get it.
- H8crilA 3y agoWhile I agree that what's happening in Gaza is unacceptable and it needs more deliveries of aid, I doubt that it would fix the problem with North Yemen (Houti). Houti aggression on merchant ships is a political act. By attacking Israel they are sending a political message to their opponents that reads "if you attack us right now it means you're on the side of Israel". That's why it doesn't matter whether their garage built cruise missiles actually make it to Eliat, or not, whether they really stop shipping, or not. The shots are fired north at Israel, but the message is targeted south and east. They are in the middle of a civil war, a very long and extremely brutal one, and this tactic works given what their opponents think about themselves and the world. The EU/US response to this will be challenging, mostly because they cannot really threaten Houti power. North Yemen is already in a deeper ruin than most countries are after a war, their military industrial base is located in another country (Iran), and there are very small chances for an internal revolt. BTW, in this conflict China and the US and the EU are actually on the same side, though China will definitely try to sit this one out.
- rjzzleep 3y agoThe EU/US, and Israel could have easily avoided this entire thing if their first act had been to immediately condemn Hammas at the UN Security Council, and call for the immediate unconditional release of all hostages. All they needed was to show a little restraint instead of giving in to their revenge instinct. China and Russia are both hostile to Islamic terrorism. Nobody would have vetoed that resolution if Israel hasn't started immediately flattening Gaza. That is actually how Hamas would have lost its leg.
- CubsFan1060 3y agoI’m slightly confused. Are you saying that after October 7th a un resolution would have gotten hostages released and Hamas wouldn’t have attacked again?
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> Are you saying that after October 7th a un resolution would have gotten hostages released and Hamas wouldn’t have attacked again? No, but it would have looked good. That matters in international relations. The Arab world sees America as Israel’s surrogate; that makes it tough for Washington to e.g. strike a deal with Riyadh or Tehran to solve this Bab al-Mandan crisis.
- brighteyes 3y agoThat is already being worked on, of course, regardless of the Houthis. The Keren Shalom crossing from Israel to Gaza just opened, which should allow double the aid to reach Gazans, https://www.reuters.com/world/middle-east/aid-enters-gaza-through-israels-kerem-shalom-crossing-first-time-war-2023-12-17/ https://www.reuters.com/world/middle-east/aid-enters-gaza-th... That should be enough in theory. But see details in the article, there are many logistical challenges remaining to actually get it to those in need.
- snird 3y agoThere is enough food. Trucks with all the aid come in every day. Here, for example, is a report from Nov 26: https://edition.cnn.com/middleeast/live-news/israel-hamas-war-gaza-news-11-26-23/h_8323155d2f8ac70c9cbe7eb2059c663d https://edition.cnn.com/middleeast/live-news/israel-hamas-wa... You can find reports for every day. Don't take what a terror group says a truth.
- WJW 3y agoThere are broadly 3 ways this can end: - The Houthi rebels back down. - The West backs down and accepts a minor rebel group disrupting global shipping . - The Houthis get their shit kicked in. There is technically a fourth option where the West tries but fails to enact option 3 I guess, but I doubt it. Houthi air defenses are limited to whatever old soviet SAMs they can scrounge together. To be honest, I don't see the second option happening either. So we have options 1 and 3 left. I hope it's option 1, as there is enough war already in the world.
- Izikiel43 3y agoFor 1, they aren’t going to back down, 2 would set precedent and that’s a big no no, you don’t negotiate with terrorists. So that leaves us with option 3, a big delivery of freedom.
- ceejayoz 3y agoWe negotiate with terrorists all the damned time.
- Izikiel43 3y agoNot on the kind of things that threaten the mighty us economy, you don’t mess with the US dollar unless you are the fed. It’s cheaper and more effective long term to give them freedom than negotiating, next time they want something they just need to attack the strait again and that’s a bad long term policy to allow.
- feedforward 3y agoAnother option is Israel follows the overwhelming vote by the UN for a ceasefire.
- 8b16380d 3y ago[flagged]
- 3y ago
- LegitShady 3y agoThis is all catspaw stuff for Iran.
- thelastgallon 3y agoFirst Panama, now Suez. https://www.cnbc.com/video/2023/11/06/the-panama-canal-drought-crisis-is-intensifying.html https://www.cnbc.com/video/2023/11/06/the-panama-canal-droug... Shipping companies offering millions to jump long lines for drought-stricken Panama Canal: https://www.foxweather.com/weather-news/drought-panama-canal-december-latest https://www.foxweather.com/weather-news/drought-panama-canal...
- hackandthink 3y agoAnother obvious (non) solution: Egypt blocks ships to Eilat around Scharm El-Scheich. And everyone except the Israelis are happy.
- WJW 3y agoNo offense but this is one of those "programmer thinks they can find an edge case in a complex social scenario" cases. First of all your suggestion is directly against the Treaty of Constantinople, at least so long as Egypt and Israel are not at war with each other. Secondly, most cargo ships will be going to Haifa and there is nothing blocking ships from taking a quick detour via (say) Malta so that they technically don't have an Israeli port as their destination when they pass through the Suez canal. Thirdly, the Houthis have been attacking many ships and not just Israeli ships. There is not reason to believe that they would stop doing that.
- hackandthink 3y agoYou are right, this is an obvious non solution. I should have kept that stupid joke to myself.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dzhiurgis 3y agoPerfect. Israel wanted to build their own Suez canal for a while. See: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ben_Gurion_Canal_Project https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ben_Gurion_Canal_Project
- itsnotabtmoney 3y ago[flagged]
- jwie 3y agoGlobalism is an economic system so fragile marginal increases in shipping costs produce existential threats. This is either an unserious article or the entire notion of global economics needs revisiting.
- maxglute 3y agoIIRC Suez shipping cuts container costs by like 2%. But real threat is energy shipping.
- dgellow 3y agoTechnically if we would globalize the economy even more and develop more maritime routes the system would be more robust. It’s not obvious to me a system of localized economies would work better in the modern world.
- javajosh 3y agoI didn't read the article because of a paywall, while I tend to agree with your point, it misses some nuance. Globalism can be both fragile and resilient to breakage. So, for example, closing the Suez canal might result short-term increase in energy costs, along with all of the follow-on effects, but the global supply chain itself will "reroute around the damage" and take a less geographically optimal, slightly more expensive but still functional route. Also, a "threat [to] the world economy" need not be existential. The threat of recession is also possible, and likely with a situation like this. That said, I believe there ARE existential threats posed by globalism, particularly where inter-dependency is present for generations, such that either side of the relationship institutionally forgets how to maintain, repair or upgrade significant infrastructure. Arguably that is already the case for America with energy transmission equipment, semiconductor and PCB manufacturing, such that a war with China that began with a strike to those resources could not be recovered from.
- aerodog 3y ago[flagged]
- ethbr1 3y agoQuestion I've had about this, because there's a map in the article. The Houthis have been shooting missiles and launching drones at commercial shipping, but also at Israeli cities. [0] I like to think I understand how to read a map. The route from Houthi controlled territory to Israeli territory either (a) flies over Saudi Arabia or (b) flies over water immediately adjacent to Saudi Arabia. E.g. specifically Jeddah and Mecca. Why aren't the Saudis doing anything? They're fine with ordinance flying right next to their major population centers, launched by a group they've literally been bombing? [0] https://news.usni.org/2023/12/16/u-k-american-warships-shoot-down-houthi-launched-drones-in-red-sea https://news.usni.org/2023/12/16/u-k-american-warships-shoot...
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> Why aren't the Saudis doing anything? The House of Saud was normalising its relationship with Jerusalem [1]. Its Wahahabi population is significantly more conservative than it; protecting Israel by intercepting the Houthis’ missiles could cause a domestic issue. Also, Riyadh was happily bombing the Houthis in the Yemeni civil war. We asked them to stop [2]. There is likely an element of schadenfreude “we told you so” geopolitics going down. [1] https://globalriskinsights.com/2019/01/the-solidifying-of-the-arab-israeli-alliance/ https://globalriskinsights.com/2019/01/the-solidifying-of-th... [2] https://www.reuters.com/article/idUSKBN1422M5/ https://www.reuters.com/article/idUSKBN1422M5/
- maxglute 3y agoTrajectory from Yemen misses Jeddah and Riyadh by 100s of km. My guess is Saudi doesn't want to start shit with Yemen again, especially in defense of Israel. Even more so when Houthi's have demonstrated capability of hitting Saudi energy infra a few years ago and now ships in transit. Regional force balance has changed. Iran/Yemen has developed reasonably competent missile tech that they destroy regional energy infra and potentially to revert rich petro states into desert tribes while globe is warming. While robbing world of 1/3 oil/lng. No one wants to risk that over Israel, least of all arabs.
- ethbr1 3y ago
- cs702 3y agoTL;DR: A prolonged closure of the Suez route... * would pause a major source of income for Egypt, which is already in the midst of a financial crisis; * would raise the costs of trade as shipping is rerouted around Africa, taking more time, and insurance premiums soar, possibly triggering another global supply-chain crunch and another global inflation wave; and * could escalate into regional security crisis and military conflict.
- Mizza 3y agoWorth noting that one of Israel's many motivation for ethnically cleansing the Gaza strip may be to build their own alternative to the Suez: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ben_Gurion_Canal_Project https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ben_Gurion_Canal_Project EDIT: The quality of this article has declined significantly since I last read it, but it may also be complete nonsense. Thought it was interesting regardless.
- tamimio 3y agoTheir demand is simple and clear and it should not be even discussed or reach to this point in the first place, let aid and food into Gaza, it’s really not that complicated to achieve.