7 ms·
Studying stars with central black holes
- sgillen 3y agoMaybe it was put there by aliens from the future to punish earth for their sins? Sounds familiar somehow.
- dcminter 3y agoThe first two lines of the abstract are enjoyable. Worth skimming just for that!
- 23B1 3y ago[flagged]
- belter 3y agoWhy did you left out the second part? "... Despite this detail, our goal in this work to convince the reader that this question is interesting and that work studying stars with central black holes is well motivated. If primordial black holes exist then they may exist in sufficiently large numbers to explain the dark matter in the universe..."
- 23B1 3y agoIt literally matches the definition of clickbait.
- dr_dshiv 3y agoIs it a candidate for creating anomalous iron rich stars in the early universe?
- someotherperson 3y agoWhen thinking of dark matter, I've always wondered how we actually measure the density of black holes. My confusion lies in how we can derive the mass at the hyper-quantum state at the center of a black hole from the gravitational waves we observe as it loses energy. I'm not a physicist so my question might be silly.
- pattmayne 3y agoI assume we would measure the gravitational force, either via lensing or the behavior of bodies orbiting it. What's the connection to dark matter?
- LeifCarrotson 3y agoTo get density you need to know the volume in addition to the mass. As far as I understand, the volume is hard to measure and mostly theoretically derived, amd lensing and orbiting bodies would behave the same regardless of whether it was a point mass or low density sphere.
- pdonis 3y ago> the volume is hard to measure and mostly theoretically derived Not even that. The "volume" of a black hole is not even well-defined. A black hole doesn't work like an ordinary object. > lensing and orbiting bodies would behave the same regardless of whether it was a point mass or low density sphere. First, a black hole is definitely not a "point mass". Second, the density of a black hole is also not well-defined. Lensing and orbiting bodies do exhibit unique properties close enough to the black hole's horizon, but unfortunately we would have to be relatively close to the hole (meaning, in the same stellar system, not light years away) to distinguish them.
- dumpsterdiver 3y ago> A black hole doesn't work like an ordinary object. Black holes are ordinary objects, if they are anything at all. Take any normal object and give it the mass of a black hole, and what do you have? To claim that a black hole “doesn’t work like normal matter” seems to ignore that these entities have come to exist “normally”, or rather, through a natural course of events. It’s not that the black hole “doesn’t work like normal matter”, but rather that you refuse to accept that normal matter with the mass of a black hole (and hence, the observable properties we associate with black holes) are still “normal objects”. When objects of a certain class display certain properties, it’s not accurate to say “that’s not normal.” Instead, it would be accurate to say, “that is the normal behavior of objects once they reach this class or state.”
- HarHarVeryFunny 3y agoObligatory Chris Cornell performance: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ltc5EsuyBh4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ltc5EsuyBh4
- Astraco 3y ago[flagged]
- pattmayne 3y agoIf a star had a black hoke at the center wouldn't it eat the star?
- dcminter 3y agoThe paper answers this question amongst others.
- pdonis 3y agoNot necessarily. A black hole doesn't have any stronger gravity than an ordinary object of the same mass. And matter falling into the hole would radiate strongly (the paper calls this "accretion luminosity"), which would help to maintain an equilibrium with the rest of the star. That's the kind of model the paper is studying. How long such an equilibrium can last is a different question. The paper only briefly comments on this when it says that the time scale of the numerical simulations they did is of the same order as the hydrodynamic timescale of the Sun. That means, roughly, the time it would take the Sun to collapse to a white dwarf if fusion reactions in its core stopped, which is, I believe, tens of millions of years. So a star with a black hole at the center would not have the same lifetime as an ordinary main sequence star with similar mass, but it would have a long enough lifetime that would could not conclusively rule out that at least some stars we see have black holes at their centers.
- hinkley 3y agoA black hole at the center of a gaseous body would mess with the fusion cycle would it not? There’s no pressurized core at the center. Just a drain that all pressure exits into.
- jiggawatts 3y agoIt would be like a pinhole leak. A large enough container can maintain pressure even with a few small holes letting the contents slowly stream out.
- joot82 3y ago
- freddealmeida 3y ago[flagged]
- bozhark 3y agoCould a star be small enough to exist within a massive planet’s atmosphere of some substance? Could a star exist within a planet’s core?
- belter 3y agoThe smallest known Star is Jupiter sized. - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/OGLE-TR-122 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/OGLE-TR-122
- bozhark 3y agoCould Jupiter be a failed Binary Star?
- az09mugen 3y agoIt does not make really sense to talk about 'binary star'. It should be a 'binary stellar system' with 2 stars involved. With this meaning, if you intend to say Jupiter is a failed star and if it had been a star we will be living in a binary stellar system (Jupiter as a star + the Sun), then yes.
- euroderf 3y agoTwo sources of sunlight, often on opposite sides of the Earth, certainly would have changed the path of evolution, possibly even back as far as primordial slime.
- az09mugen 3y agoDefinitively ! I wonder how the 'circadian' cycle looks like on this kind of planet and how it impacts the life.
- layer8 3y agoI’d rather say it’s a successful planet.
- 3y ago
- m3kw9 3y agoThis is like conspiracy theory but for Astrophysics
- akomtu 3y agoWho is conspiring in this case?
- tomcam 3y agoThere's a 90s-style grunge song somewhere in here
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- popilewiz 3y ago[dead]
- yongjik 3y agoFun fact: it is believed that there are stars that have a neutron star at the core, formed by a giant star "swallowing" its companion neutron star. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thorne%E2%80%93%C5%BBytkow_object https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thorne%E2%80%93%C5%BBytkow_obj...
- az09mugen 3y agoThank you for this fact ! It makes totally sense after the object discussed here.
- beezle 3y ago"Once in its post-main sequence phase the Hawking star becomes fully convective and slowly swells over multiple Gyr to about 10 R⊙ and about 10 L⊙ causing them to appear as a sub-subgiant star, joining a relatively sparse population on the HR diagram." and then "The resulting increase in accretion luminosity causes the inner convective region to grow outwards, mix the He core with the H-burning shell, and quench fusion." Would the aftermath of all this be observable? Once fusion is quenched wouldn't the gas cool rapidly?
- pixl97 3y agoDefine rapidly? From my understanding any individual photon takes thousands of years to escape the dense inner area of the sun.
- pyinstallwoes 3y agoThe suns just the opposite side, a whites hole! But in the scenario in this paper… if there were a black hole in the sun does that make the plasma on the outside a natural Dyson sphere capturing energy from a black hole? Or maybe not natural tinfoil hat.
- thewakalix 3y agohttps://astronomy.stackexchange.com/questions/55461/what-would-happen-if-a-small-black-hole-fell-into-a-star https://astronomy.stackexchange.com/questions/55461/what-wou...
- belter 3y agoWhy is the title changed? Is HN now editorializing researchers Arxiv Papers!? Here are my suggestions... /s "Attention Is All You Need" - HN: "A New Twist on Neural Networks for Text Tasks" "ImageNet Classification with Deep Convolutional Neural Networks" - HN: "A New Way to Classify Images"