4 ms·
Recent data shows AI job losses rising, but the numbers don't tell full story
- TotalCrackpot 3y agoThe ultimate goal of capitalism is to make worker obsolete. But how will then people get food and other things?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- interstice 3y agoMore importantly (from the point of view of capitalism) whose going to pay for things
- randomdata 3y agoRobots don’t work for free. Perhaps they will pay.
- shagie 3y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robot_tax https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robot_tax https://news.mit.edu/2022/robot-tax-income-inequality-1221 https://news.mit.edu/2022/robot-tax-income-inequality-1221 (7 months ago, 74 comments https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35935554 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35935554 )
- mc32 3y agoIf automation = obsoleting workers, then What would Marxism do? Keep workers doing manual labor?
- zer0tonin 3y agoI'm not a marxist but if you're seriously asking this question, you might want to look up a short summary of Capital. Your question is one of the main points of the book. You'll be better served than asking around HN for this.
- lewhoo 3y agoDistribute the means of production.
- SiempreViernes 3y agoThat's not the equality being claimed, you left out the quite central "capitalist" modifier, so properly stated it is "capitalist automation = obsoleting workers". The Marxist response to automation is simply to let the workers have more leisure time.
- mensetmanusman 3y agoSomeone has to burn down Targets to rebuild them!
- beej71 3y agoAI will make it for us! Or something.
- dragonwriter 3y agoIn pure capitalism, the people that own capital would, and the people who didn't, wouldn't, where labor was unnecessary for production.
- pixl97 3y agoAh so the poor eating the rich and general society wide instability.
- ben_w 3y agoI'd say that's a likely outcome, but not the goal. Still, The Wealth of Nations is 1776 and The Communist Manifesto is 1848, and it shouldn't be a surprise that both look at bit naive with the benefit of hindsight. Hopefully there's some equivalent work for the impact of AI. Might already exist, I've not actually read "Fully Automated Luxury Communism: A Manifesto", merely some of The Culture novels from whence the title seems to have been borrowed.
- mensetmanusman 3y agoThe goal of capitalism is to fund capital equipment/assets that makes stuff better along some axis. This has the knock-on effect of creating massive wealth.
- heresie-dabord 3y agoNegative historical examples of what starving people do to survive are sufficient in number. But from a positive point of view, there is an entire food industry run by people making food for people. Food will be available. Growing food and bartering for goods and services are common among people. It's just that in the historical economic samples, there was relatively little wealth generated compared to today's economy. People in the future may have a Basic Income provided by the state. They may spend their time "day-trading", "click-farming", "video-viralising", or "brigading-for-dollars". ^_^
- esafak 3y agoWell yeah, you have also to quantify the number AI-enabled jobs created, and what happened to the displaced workers. The least capable workers are going to be displaced first and we need to find a way for them to make ends meet. I do not expect the newly-created AI-driven jobs are going to be compatible with their skills. As one industry after another is disrupted, it may prove too difficult for unskilled workers to have to constantly learn new skills, as they jump from one sinking ship to another. This is the present course we are on. There is also the possibility that superintelligence will render wide swathes of the workforce instantly obsolete. If that happens governments will simply have to take drastic action, so things won't be left to the market. But finding a job will only be one of our worries in that case.
- visarga 3y agoI don't get this logic. When you have empowering technology, you get market expansion, demand induction, and usually have even more work to do. AI creates opportunities, there's going to be competition and this will create jobs. I see it like Linux and OSS, of course it killed some paid software products, but it created a platform for companies to build even more and better than before. Devs still have jobs. AI is a platform, it's even more accessible than OSS, easier to use in any domain and has lower entry barrier. It will support a lot of jobs, and will be the best method to quickly retrain people for their new positions. What we're basically judging here is if automation and AI will progress faster than our greed. Will we ever say we have enough opportunities and we can stop our efforts now? I don't think so. People will work just like before because we can want more than we can get.
- losteric 3y agoIt's important to consider the rate of change and cost of job-switching. In America, there are no national programs for adult education, most Americans aren't aware of impending industry shifts, and 60% of Americans still live paycheck-to-paycheck without the time/money to adapt themselves. If AI replaces N repetitive customer service jobs with additional labor demand in engineering, product development, logistics, etc... hopefully new demand = N, but at the same time we really need to ask how practical it is for those N employees to fulfill the new demand. If they can't retrain, the result is some combination of higher wages for those with the skill, offshoring, and lower wages for those displaced into even less skilled labor.
- baxtr 3y agoSo they surveyed some people, asked for opinions and based on that wrote an article. Zero real world, specific examples. Just high level numbers and speculation. AI is actually creating a high number of jobs for consultants and other attention grabbing based professions.
- zer0tonin 3y ago> So they surveyed some people, asked for opinions and based on that wrote an article. It's CNBC, can't expect much better from them
- xkqd 3y ago> AI is actually creating a high number of jobs for consultants and other attention grabbing based professions. Right, but I think maybe a lot of the backlash against AI is that no one feels bad or even has much sympathy for these folks. They get to eat, and they’re eating really well. I think people are a little more worried about the Joe and Jane’s who don’t carry computer science degrees.
- apwell23 3y agoI think Allie K Miller doesn't have a CS degree either
- sebastiennight 3y agoDo you genuinely believe that the AI consultants of 2023 were unemployed or in college in 2022? Or maybe... could these people possibly have been [insert fad here] consultants for years beforehand, and therefore no significant net new jobs have been created so far?
- pcurve 3y ago"According to a recent report of 750 business leaders using AI from ResumeBuilder, 37% say the technology replaced workers in 2023. Meanwhile, 44% report that there will be layoffs in 2024 resulting from AI efficiency." These are specific enough to be credible. If you talk to leaders in customer service / call center operations, they've been planning this for years. Is this creating some new AI jobs? Sure. But that's a separate issue because peopel who are getting laid off aren't the ones taking up those new jobs. The layoff has been happening. Over 240 workers in a call center were laid off this week in KB Bank (a Korean bank) because AI-based consultation tool reduced call center volume by 20%. Plenty of real life examples happening across the globe. https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2023/10/03/ai-customer-service-jobs/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2023/10/03/ai-cust...
- skepticATX 3y agoThis a very poor article that is based entirely off of a ResumeBuilder poll. ResumeBuilder has been releasing junk AI-related polls since ChatGPT launched. Of course, actual government job reports show nothing of the sort.
- fizx 3y agoWhat's the difference between a job loss and a productivity gain?
- chank 3y agoHow and who is effected.
- pixl97 3y agoWhy not both? That doesn't mean it's necessarily a good thing at extremes. Lets imagine a fully automated world where 10 billionaires own all the land. For them productivity is pretty much infinity. They push a button and robots make it happen. But the 6th person that is not part of the owner class is effectively screwed in this world. They don't got no land, and they don't got no robots. They have no means of supporting themselves. The only way they'd survive is by slumming off for scraps of the wealthy. --- This is the question many of us are asking now. As things become more automated, what value are you going to add to require the ruling class to keep you around?
- ben_w 3y agoThe difference is which goes up, GDP or unemployment.
- darth_avocado 3y agoIs AI even there yet? Or are we using the term very loosely here?
- NameError 3y agoI'm not sure there's a good way to answer this question, people seem to have very different definitions of AI. The definition I learned in school was "AI is when machines do things that most people would say requires intelligence to do", which is (maybe deliberately) vague and prone to shifting over time. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AI_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AI_effect - the term "AI" used to include things like chess engines (and even simpler search algorithms), but once computers are able to do those things for a while and people get used to it, the term "AI" tends to shift and only refer to things that machines can't do yet. It's admittedly a bit of an unsatisfying answer, but whether AI is here is more a question of your definition of "intelligence" than anything else.
- ultra_nick 3y agoYes, we've had chess engines and spellcheck for years.
- phatfish 3y agoLLMs are definitely AI within the scope of text or even "conversation" generation. Just as AlphaGo is a Go playing AI within that scope. Obviously an AI that can have a human like text conversation has broader use than the Go playing AI. I find it curious that in sci-fi the idea of being human-like was considered the hardest task for an AI, and the walking encyclopedia which is never wrong bit was the easy part. Seems we did the hard part first with LLMs...
- ben_w 3y agoWe already had search engines for our walking encyclopaedias, which the chat bots can use if we tell them to. The hard part is making the physical androids walk without falling over, but even that got much easier when someone realised they could be trained in simulations and what they learned would transfer to the real world.
- deadbabe 3y agoThere’s many jobs that could be replaced by some well placed script or Excel macros. And yet they haven’t. Why?
- amelius 3y agoWhy hasn't upper management been replaced by ChatGPT?
- wharvle 3y agoPeople who can write and maintain those scripts and macros, and keep them useful and correct as part of a larger system, and who can keep all that running smoothly even through employee turnover, are relatively rare and mostly busy doing other stuff.
- deadbabe 3y agoSo this is why AI will also fail to replace many many jobs.
- heresie-dabord 3y agoSupplementary comment: If senior management were replaced by an LLM, the board of directors would need to carefully consider which LLM to use (e.g. who owns it, controls it, trains it, is liable for its mistakes and ethical and/or legal lapses in training). It seems like an easy fit to replace human roles that generate SUBs (Safe, Uninteresting Bloviation) for consumers to read and delete... until the management above these roles realises that it cannot safely outsource its SUBs.
- drivingmenuts 3y agoSome anecdata: I recently installed an AI coding assistant in PyCharm to help myself learn Python better. It's great at completing things for me and once I get used to it, it'll probably speed things up. But ... I feel like I'm not actually learning the language because I start a line, it finished the function and I look it over to ensure in makes sense, etc., but the actual act of typing out the code and thinking my way thru it as I type ... is gone. I've reduced myself to a QA checker for a computer in California or wherever.
- heresie-dabord 3y agoThat is not merely an anecdatum. Not thinking about the code == Not learning to code.
- drivingmenuts 3y agoWhich sucks, because Python is the easiest language I have seen. Up til recently, I worked with PHP, and I like Python waaaay more. There’s a few things I am still trying to get a handle on, but thanks to 20 years of programming, it’s mostly impatience driving the problem, not lack of ability.
- kkfx 3y agoJob losses will be/are: far less people for scanning and processing paper documents, a bit less about ticket checks/receptionist, a bit less translators, ... MOST of job losses will NOT be from "AI" but from mere rationalization in the digital-bureaucratic world. Signed XML/JSON for inter-banks communications, billing etc start to be widespread enough, many paperwork start disappear and so on. This is natural managerial evolution not even tech evolution per se and have nothing to do with "AI".