4 ms·
This law is a problem and should be fixed, but even if the law takes effect as written most start-ups will still be unprofitable and thus still won't pay income
by nradov 3y ago
This law is a problem and should be fixed, but even if the law takes effect as written most start-ups will still be unprofitable and thus still won't pay income tax.
- hodgesrm 3y agoUnfortunately it’s not that simple. You can’t deduct software dev (aka r&d per section 174) as an operating expense. Instead the expense is capitalized over 5 years. The effect is to make software companies look a lot more profitable than they actually are according to normal accounting standards. It hits bootstrapped companies particularly hard. Matters are of course more complicated than this because nothing in the IRS code is really simple at least as far as corporate taxes are concerned. It’s an incredibly stupid law.
- jncfhnb 3y agoThey generally are more profitable though. The dev costs are tangential to the revenue and expenses. If you spend $100 building your app and earn $100 that year, you can still sell the app next year. Perhaps you still need some dev work to maintain it. But it’s misleading to suggest you earned 0 profit. That dev effort is going to apply its value to the company over time.
- jopsen 3y agoIf the app / software still has value next year. The counter argument is that lots of software is short lived. Without someone maintaining it, software is often worthless.
- jncfhnb 3y agoThe fact that something needs to be maintained is not evidence that it’s not an asset. Perhaps the maintenance should be expensed. But people are kidding themselves if they think the majority of development is not making something that will be useful for longer than the immediate year. What does your company do? Oh we make X. Well developing X is building an asset.
- hodgesrm 3y ago> But it’s misleading to suggest you earned 0 profit. That dev effort is going to apply its value to the company over time. I would be with you except that Section 174 just says the following: [0[ .03 Activities that are treated as software development. Activities that are treated as software development for purposes of § 174 generally include but are not limited to: (1) Planning the development of the computer software (or the upgrades and enhancements to such software), including identification and documentation of the software requirements; (2) Designing the computer software (or the upgrades and enhancements to such software); (3) Building a model of the computer software (or the upgrades and enhancements to such software); (4) Writing source code and converting it to machine-readable code; (5) Testing the computer software (or the upgrades and enhancements to such software) and making necessary modifications to address defects identified during testing, but only up until the point in time that: (a) In the case of computer software developed for use by the taxpayer in its trade or business, the computer software is placed in service; and (b) In the case of computer software developed for sale or licensing to others, technological feasibility has been established, product masters(s) have been produced, and the computer software is ready for sale or licensing to others; and (6) In the case of computer software developed for sale or licensing to others (or the upgrades and enhancements to such software), production of the product master(s). It makes sense to think of some degree of capitalization for software development but this definition is not defensible for anyone who has the least understanding of how software businesses (including SaaS) actually work. It sounds like it was written in the 1970s. [0] https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-drop/n-23-63.pdf https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-drop/n-23-63.pdf
- jncfhnb 3y agoWhat is missing from this definition? The possibility of delivering it via an API? what is meaningfully wrong?
- gopher_space 3y agoContinuous Integration as legal fiction?
- pcthrowaway 3y ago"Unprofitable" startups will pay taxes on revenue that isn't really "profit" If a b2b startup has some contracts which total $1 million per year in sales, but their dev expenses are also $1 million per year, you're right, the startup is unprofitable. But now they'll still have to pay taxes on the $800K of sales after their 20% immediate-year deduction for dev expenses
- gizmo 3y agoOnly if the startup wishes to take advantage of R&D credits or otherwise wants to treat dev expenses more favorably than other expenses, which is optional. Otherwise revenue - expenses < 0 and no taxes will be due, like before.
- meetingthrower 3y agoThis. You can't have your cake and eat it.
- galaxyLogic 3y agoI think you MUST have your cake before you can eat it :-)