5 ms·
Prince Harry wins phone hacking case against British tabloid
- caycep 3y agoOk good for Harry but...only $180k against a company that has $60million budgeted for legal defense?!
- dkjaudyeqooe 3y agoPlus a million or two paying Harry's legal costs.
- nonrandomstring 3y agoA little surprising that a member of the royal family had no trustworthy advisor or technology aide to warn against 1990s cellphone message boxes. It's not like nobody knew. Likely someone did, but to no avail. Same for politicians with their definitely-not-quite-end-to-end calling and messaging. More than ever security has to be for everyone because now prominent and key people are just like everyone. Well, we always knew the royals are just like us, gawd blessem!
- midtake 3y agoNot all that surprising if you've worked with powerful people. For most of them, technical suggestions don't matter much and are ultimately weighed on a rubric of "whether someone else (who is also important) is doing the same".
- zactato 3y agoOften times I think lawsuit culture in the US is ridiculous, but maybe its justified in some cases. I'm astounded that he only got $180k from these lawsuits. I would expect a conviction like this to result in sums that would bankrupt the news paper. Even if dozens of other celebrities got the similar amounts it would be low. Also this article doesn't discuss the felony aspects of phone hacking. Was it not illgeal in the UK in the 90s?
- hollerith 3y agoYou mean "judgment", not "conviction".
- labster 3y agoYes it’s important to state that the tabloids don’t have any convictions, just some highly questionable judgements.
- whynotkeithberg 3y agoI might have missed it, but I don't recall seeing anywhere that they identified a specific person who was doing the hacking so I'm not sure who they would criminally charge. I believe it was definitely illegal as they had a computer misuse act in 1990.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- gbuk2013 3y agoThe BBC article on the subject mentioned somewhere around £100M of legal fees that were incurred in this case, so the damages are just the tip of the iceberg of what the newspaper company is on the hook for. The UK legal system damage calculation actually requires some justification of the damages sustained by the claimant.
- olliej 3y agoI would expect, in a just system, jail time for every "reporter" who did this, and every executive who approved of it. To stop the business I would expect a minimum payout of the entire revenue (not profit) of every published article and paper, payable to in its entirety to each individual victim. Instead none of the criminals are in jail, and the financial penalty was negligible compared to the income that came about from the crime.
- tzm 3y ago> "Vendetta journalism" Fast forward to today, it seems journalists are increasingly engaged in activism.
- D-Coder 3y agoThis has been a thing for many, many years (my guess is, since 5 minutes after journalism was invented). See "yellow journalism" (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_propaganda_of_the_Spanish%E2%80%93American_War https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_propaganda_of_the_Spa...).
- stonogo 3y agoLook up "scandal sheets" for examples over a hundred years before that!
- ejb999 3y agomore like activists are increasingly engaged as journalists.
- stonogo 3y ago"Fast forward" from a statement last week to this week doesn't seem like much time for anything to have changed. I'm also not sure anyone really expects high journalistic standards from tabloids. This kind of junk 'reporting' has been in Britain since the 1700s.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jfengel 3y agoThis is the Daily Mirror, who has been doing exactly this for decades. This kind of "activist" behavior is called "tabloid journalism" because of the tabloid format in which the Daily Mirror is printed. (Along with a few others. I don't know why the half-broadsheet format seems especially popular with such disreputably tactics. But regardless, this is absolutely nothing new for the Daily Mirror and its ilk.)
- 3y ago
- runlevel1 3y agoHow did they hack their phones? I vaguely recall it being possible at one point for an attacker to get into someone's voice mail by spoofing the target's caller ID and calling their carrier's voice mail access number. Was it something trivial to pull off like that? (Not to trivialize how violating that would be.)
- 4rt 3y agoThat was the main way. Another was some networks had a voicemail number you could dial into from abroad and then enter the phone number and pin of the voicemail box you wanted to access. Before this scandal nobody has ever changed that pin, or known about it, in the entire history of british telephony.
- d1sxeyes 3y agoYeah this was a big one. You’d get a mobile phone with voicemail enabled, and you could call 123 from your phone to collect your voicemails without a PIN. You could also call something like 07700007123 and then it would ask you to type your phone number and remote access PIN. Almost nobody knew that you could do that, and so almost nobody changed their remote access PIN from the default 1111 or 1234 or 0000.
- sdflhasjd 3y agoYes, it was a combo of either calling from any number and guessing the PIN (which was also likely to be still the default) or number spoofing to bypass the PIN altogether.
- stonogo 3y agoBritish tabloids have a long history of hiring people who have access to law enforcement tools in order to intercept private communications: https://www.theguardian.com/uk/2002/sep/21/privacy2 https://www.theguardian.com/uk/2002/sep/21/privacy2 One 150-year-old newspaper, News of the World, shut down in 2011 when it came out that they'd hacked the voicemail of a murder victim and, prior to that, several British military personnel who were killed in action. It wasn't publicized as to whether this was done via spoofing or via access to law enforcement tools.
- OliveMate 3y agoA lot of people overseas have the idea that British newspapers are prestigious titans of journalism due to how old and widespread they are, and I could scream from the heavens about how wrong that is. The tabloids are a dire stain on our society. This wasn't just Prince Harry or celebrities who were victims of phone hacking, it was ordinary people who weren't prepared for such an industrial violation of privacy and sheer decency from multiple newspapers. And it went on for decades[1]. In one case the mother of a dead teenager thought her daughter was alive because her phone's voicemail was being accessed. It turns out that The News of the World was doing it, it was such a widespread thing. And I'll never forgive the Conservatives for gutting the Leveson Inquiry[2] which went neck-deep in exploring how much of a mess the industry was. --- The sad thing about the court finding that Piers Morgan knew of the phone hacking is that it'll do nothing to him. The man is mired in decades of scandal and certain connections he made allowed him to bounce back every time. That, and the tabloid industry has an incentive not to act against their own lest all their dirty secrets get out there. I could talk about Morgan all day, but I'm still in awe at how we let him recover his career after 2004. He put British soldiers at risk when he published faked photos of British soldiers torturing Iraqis, and when they were found as fake, he outright refused to apologise for it and got fired. That ought to be a career-ending move, but having connections with Murdoch lets you get away with anything. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overview_of_news_media_phone_hacking_scandals https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overview_of_news_media_phone_h... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leveson_Inquiry https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leveson_Inquiry
- tycho-newman 3y agoWhere's Jeremy Clarkson? Its been a minute and perhaps he'd like to punch Piers Morgan again.
- brnt 3y ago> A lot of people overseas Maybe it depends on which sea you mean, but in my primary school, decades ago, British 'press' was held up as an example of what happens when a nation doesn't take newspapers seriously.
- 3y ago
- cf1241290841 3y agoBritish tabloids do this a lot https://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/news-world-phone-hacking-madeleine-139994 https://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/news-world-phone-hacki... >In the latest revelations, people linked to missing Madeleine McCann and murdered schoolgirl Danielle Jones are said to have had their mobile messages broken into by the Sunday tabloid’s journalists. >Police have also contacted families of victims of the July 7 bombings to warn them their phones may have been accessed in the days following the 2005 terrorist attacks. ... >The News of the World has been accused of hacking on an “industrial scale”. >Notebooks seized from former employee Glenn Mulcaire – the private investigator at the centre of the scandal who was jailed in 2007 – revealed 11,000 pages of documents and several thousand names of targets. >Police are now examining every high-profile case involving the murder and abduction of children since 2001.
- jm4 3y agoThat’s disgusting. It’s not right to call them journalists. They are no different than the scum who goes around doxxing people.
- cf1241290841 3y agoIts tabloids. I dont think many people call them journalists.
- Teever 3y agoBut not enough people call them criminals, or more specifically, the kind of people who can put them in jail.
- boomboomsubban 3y agoLinking to a Mirror article about the issue seems kinda shitty. I wouldn't be surprised if they had also hacked the phones of every one of the people mentioned in that story.
- cf1241290841 3y ago
- bandyaboot 3y agoHad to do a double take skimming through the headlines. “Woah, did Prince Harry win a Pwn2Own competition or something? That’s badass! Oh…yeah. That makes more sense.”
- borbtactics 3y agoOr, he won a phone case that hacked his phone
- manicennui 3y agoWhy aren't people in jail for this?
- micheal0147 3y ago[dead]
- micheal0147 3y ago[dead]