5 ms·
'Green roads' are plowing ahead, buffering drought and floods
- seltzered_ 3y ago"A Good Road Lies Easy on the Land… : Water-harvesting from low standard rural roads" might be a helpful book for those interested in this: https://allaboutwatersheds.org/library/general-library-holdings/1596-A_Good_Road_Lies_Easy_on_the_Land.pdf https://allaboutwatersheds.org/library/general-library-holdi...
- WalterBright 3y agoSounds like something California could make excellent use of. Of course, they won't.
- hosh 3y agoFor more general design patterns for water management, see Brad Landcaster's book series, "Rainwater Harvesting for Drylands and Beyond". In the pictures in the article, the roads form berms, and the fields are basins. It doesn't just have to be roads -- walkways threading through a smaller scale can act as berms as well. The two volume book contains many other water harvesting structures. As a note, Andrew Millison has a youtube video about a river system that was developed in India over the course of centuries -- deliberately engineering a delta, with flood channels. They basically did what beavers have been doing in North America (slowing down and spreading out water) for ... longer than we humans have been around. These ideas are not new. They have been around for a long time. It's not that we found new ways to progress, but rather, rediscovering old methods that had been dropped in our rush for modernity.
- hinkley 3y agoI don't know where he got the idea, but I've also seen videos by Mark Shepard where he uses roads as spillways. Instead of running water retention parallel to access, he will run it perpendicular. I was never quite clear how he prevents the overflow from exiting the property at maximum speed. If your water retention system reaches capacity, by definition you cannot hold onto it, but water flowing at speed is also an erosion risk. It can lead to earthworks failures, which are about as bad as landslides.
- hosh 3y agoIf he slowed down the water so that it has a chance to pecolate, it might help. But that only expands the capacity, and there may be days when that overflows. I think Lancaster talks about the perpendicular flow, and also talks about ways to mitigate that with curves (as well as discussion about erosion patterns when water exits a structure too quickly, which in turn reshapes the terrain, sometimes going into degenerative erosion patterns). On-contour swales (or trenches) are good examples, especially when there are multiple tiers with overflow to increase the distance the water has to travel as it snakes back and forth across the contour and descends down a slope. There are multiple chances to slow down water and let it try to infiltrate. In his latest edition, Landcaster talks about gambesons (retaining walls), which he used to advocate. But because of long-term erosion patterns, those can fail pretty quickly.
- hinkley 3y agoHe's in Wisconsin. He's not thinking about dry season farming. On the other hand, if you are thinking about dry season farming, the government is already 150 years ahead of you and may fine you for attempting to hold onto more water than what can safely percolate in a day or two.
- hosh 3y agoThat depends on the scale and the state. I doubt the government cared that much 150 years ago; it was more about claims on surface and ground water. These days, past a certain scale, you’d work with an engineer to plan it out and get the permits.
- scythe 3y agoOne phenomenon I heard about recently is that new developments plant smaller trees in order to reduce impacts on power lines. While this achieves the nominal objective, the smaller trees are generally ineffective for shade and general thermal management, provide limited support for squirrels and birds, and generally result in a much inferior aesthetic. According to some models (which are difficult to test), trees improve air quality; smaller trees probably have less effect. But the costs of trees accrue to the developer (who may be a city), while the benefits are diffuse and difficult to measure. Moral hazard, unintended consequences, call it what you will; you have to know about the problem to fix it. In this article, we hear: >“The biggest asset for [the county government] in this program is the reduction of maintenance costs,” Maluki says. “It’s a two-way benefit.” What relates my first paragraph to this article is that I have read dozens of articles touting the benefits of trees in urban design and practically never see much attention paid to the forces in the decision process that keep trees out of cities. Yes, the emerald ash borer and [other story] played a role, but not all villains are so one-dimensionally bad. This article reads like another puff piece. Insofar as it engages with differing perspectives, they contacted an ecologist who doesn't want to build any roads, and he got two paragraphs. They didn't bother contacting anyone who builds roads and who has doubts about the project, though; their concerns are limited to about half of a sentence: >but road departments themselves have proved reluctant. “They don’t want the costs associated with designing and implementing [them],” he says.
- CrazyStat 3y agoA new subdivision went in across the major street from my neighborhood recently. The developer clear cut the forest, put in roads and cookie cutter houses, and then planted one small tree in front of each house. Many of the people who live there cross the busy main road to walk/jog/etc. in our older neighborhood, which has many more trees.
- dghlsakjg 3y agoI walk my dog in a section of land that is slowly being converted from second (third?) growth forest to a neighborhood. They are doing the same thing. Cut everything down, reshape the land, build houses, plant a ceremonial sappling. Every time they expand the area that houses are built on, the amount of runoff increases massively. It's very clear that most of the water is coming only from the areas that have been "developed". The unmolested land is very capable of absorbing the amount of water that comes down. This year they had to completely redo their flood/runoff drainage area and ditch system after they cleared another bunch of land and filled it in with a bunch of sandy fill. Must have cost 6-7 figures. No idea why they can't selectively harvest, and work with the existing topsoil.
- 11235813213455 3y agowe need to also think of the fact that the vast mojority of people move alone in a vehicle of 1500kg, this doesn't make sense for the environment, we need to go lighter and smaller
- brightball 3y ago> we need to also think of the fact that the vast majority of people move alone in a vehicle of 1500kg ...safely, at sustainable speeds 10-15x faster than they would be otherwise capable while solving the last mile efficiencies at the same time. Increasing the lifetime and repair/upgrade-ability of those vehicles would probably do more for the environment than anything else.
- bobthepanda 3y agoIf the built environment didn’t make them unsafe to use, e-bikes use a fraction of the battery and weight and cover most use cases, because most people are not doing things like moving a couch most of the time. The US has some of the most bonkers bike lanes I’ve ever seen; my favorite is a bike lane sandwiched between a main travel lane and a high-speed right-turn slip lane.
- monknomo 3y agothose are bonkers and yet, when there is no bike lane, it's usually even worse
- lostlogin 3y agoI’m not convinced it’s worse - I often bike on the road with a cycle lane next to me. Bins, rubbish, man holes, street signs, uneven surfaces etc etc ruin bike lanes.
- hibikir 3y agoIn large parts of the US, suburban distances and very bad biking weather make e-bikes cover relatively few use cases: When a shopping trip is a 15 minute car drive, and a typical commute to work is 40 minutes, the e-bike doesn't win at all. Perfect lanes don't cut bad distances, 100F summers or -10F winters. And often yes, what we see in US bike infrastructure is unsafe, leading to basically no cyclist using it. Bikes are great when your development pattern is Netherlands-like: Not dense enough for serious public transport to the home, or to do everything on foot, yet not so light that many trips go past 10 miles. I bet there's a few large metro areas that could support this, but in a lot of the country, it's not about unsafe lanes.
- tomohawk 3y agoAfter the destruction of the Marxist Derg regime in Ethiopia, this seems to finally offer some hope of restoring the ecology there. https://www.britannica.com/place/Ethiopia/Socialist-Ethiopia-1974-91 https://www.britannica.com/place/Ethiopia/Socialist-Ethiopia...
- TehShrike 3y agoThese sound like the sorts of techniques folks in the "permaculture" community talk about. My wife likes to watch/read stuff from that community. I'm glad the article linked to this PDF that gets more into the implementation details, I wouldn't mind going a bit deeper: https://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/102951623742853259/pdf/Green-Roads-for-Water-Guidelines-for-Road-Infrastructure-in-Support-of-Water-Management-and-Climate-Resilience.pdf https://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/1029516237428532...
- numbol 3y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Windbreak https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Windbreak