3 ms·
In this comparison of public market capitalizations, I don’t think that is as relevant as the difference in global utility offered by the companies on the excha
by lotsofpulp 3y ago
In this comparison of public market capitalizations, I don’t think that is as relevant as the difference in global utility offered by the companies on the exchange. For example, the business with France’s highest market cap, LVMH, could vanish tomorrow and make almost no difference in utility to anyone except LVMH’s employees and vendors.
- realusername 3y agoProbably controversial on HN but I'm thinking the same about Apple, I could certainly imagine a phone landscape without them. Utility is subjective at the end of the day.
- abduhl 3y agoWhat operating system did you type this post on? Apple is more than phones.
- realusername 3y agoI'm currently using Linux with pop-os, both for work and personal stuff. I do have a macbook stored under my desk but it's only used for specific Apple-only stuff and it's really slow, not sure what's wrong with it.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoI can give a couple examples of utility, showing the difference between a business like Apple and LVMH. That is not to say Apple is completely and forever irreplaceable. Replace Apple with Google or Samsung. I had a completely uneducated, non English speaking great grandma living halfway around the world from all her grandkids. Due to the consistency, performance, and ease of use of FaceTime, we could easily video call to her regularly. I have a business where IT/tech support costs are way down due to implementing iPads for all the front line employees. Troubleshooting is as easy as turning it off and on, or replacing the device. Training is cheaper too. On the other hand, you have LVMH. I don’t see how anything they sell benefits 90% of the world’s population, and while people might buy expensive purses and whatnot, they will buy a smartphone first. Edit: another one I just thought of. I just helped someone calculate a return on investment using a shared spreadsheet in google drive. Clearly provided greater utility to me and my relative than me buying expensive clothing.
- alephnerd 3y agoApple subsidize OLED manufacturing by buying up Samsung touchscreens, which directly feeds into the photovoltaic manufacturing chain (solar panel and OLED manufacturing is largely the same). Apple subsidizes Telecom chipset manufacturing by buying up Qualcomm and Broadcom chips, which directly feeds into Military and Industrial IoT applications. Apple subsidizes SoC research and manufacturing, which directly feeds into Military and Industrial IoT applications. Apple subsidizes Battery research and manufacturing, which directly feeds into EV. BYD was originally a battery supplier for Apple before they entered the EV space. Apple subsidizes CPU and chip manufacturing, which directly feeds into smaller and more efficient chipset generations. Apple creating the first App Store in the World subsidized mobile app development, which directly fed into scaling out Digital Infrastructure like eBanking, BNPL, Microlending, etc China's entire dual use supply chain can be attributed to the scale of Apple (and Samsung's) supply chain there, and both companies are having a similar impact in Vietnam and India now for the exact same reason (eg. all Samsung OLEDs are manufactured in a suburb of New Delhi now, 50% of all Samsung phones are assembled in Vietnam, 25% of all iPhones will be assembled in India by 2025, Airpods and other small consumable electronics by Apple will be assembled in Vietnam, etc)
- realusername 3y agoI'm not saying they didn't have an impact, I'm saying I can clearly imagine a world without them. The consumer needs are very strong here anyways.
- alephnerd 3y ago> I can clearly imagine a world without them A world without cheap solar panels, cheap batteries, cheap electric vehicles, 3G/4G/5G internet, e-commerce and digital banking, and an industrialized China, Vietnam, and India. That is the second order impact Apple has had due to their massive economy of scale
- realusername 3y agoI don't agree with that analysis, any of that is happening, with or without them. We live in a consumer-first society and consumer needs are what are driving changes. Companies helping towards this direction are getting benefits and others are left behind.
- alephnerd 3y ago> the business with France’s highest market cap, LVMH, could vanish tomorrow and make almost no difference in utility to anyone except LVMH’s employees and vendors I disagree. I get plenty of utility drinking Glemorangie Scotch. My SO gets plenty of utility wearing a Louis Vuitton bag. Plenty of women get utility shopping at Sephora and plenty of men at TAG Heurer. Luxury goods provide utility by providing psychological and social validation. You might think it's bullshit but for most people it's important. Also, I'm fine paying a premium for LVMH's scotches over the crappy generic Total Liquor sells at almost the exact same price.
- nradov 3y agoThe point is that LVMH is easily replaceable. They do no real innovation, and if they disappeared tomorrow then consumers could obtain the same quality of luxury products from numerous direct competitors. Much of LVMH revenue growth in recent years has come from Chinese nouveau riche. That will not be sustainable as China now faces severe demographic and economic challenges.