3 ms·
Stuff like this really highlights how far European countries have lagged in commercializing innovation. Apple is just one of dozens (if not hundreds) of major
by alephnerd 3y ago
Stuff like this really highlights how far European countries have lagged in commercializing innovation.
Apple is just one of dozens (if not hundreds) of major tech companies in the US that have been on a rally. Having been in Europe a bunch for both work and extended family, it's crazy to see how horribly mismanaged the commercialization of innovation sectors like Software, Hardware, and Pharmaceuticals are compared to their equivalents in the US, Asia, and Israel. The European business community just doesn't respect technology, and acts like a bad parody of the Asset Baron archetype.
Fundamental research is strong in Europe, but commercialization sucks.
- capableweb 3y agoMaybe it's a balance thing? Hyper-focus on commercialization and maximizing shareholder value might make other aspects of society worse, and some countries rather not make those tradeoffs while the US at large is willing to make those tradeoffs. Even if "innovation commercialization" sucks in Europe, the EU is still the second largest consumer market in the world, so some of the things they're doing works, even if you're only focused on increasing capitalistic metrics.
- alephnerd 3y agoCommercialization isn't just maximizing shareholder value alone. It's also the creation of startups based on IP. If I have discovered an interesting pharmacological compound, or revolutionary ML workflow, or an optimized chipset - I'm less likely to get the funding and mentorship needed to scale out that startup in Europe compared to US, Asia, and Israel. The EU is a large consumer market, but in my experience in Deeptech and B2B driven companies, the EMEA market is almost always a rounding error compared to the American market. It tends to be larger than APJ, but that's largely due to the fact that large APJ countries will create a domestic competitor that undercuts the American startup. By falling behind in innovation commercialization, European countries will themselves face existential economic issues. For example, look at the Central European automotive industry and Electric Vehicles. Most of Central Europe (Germany, Austria, Hungary, Slovenia, Czechia, Slovakia, Poland) is heavily dependent on German ICE vehicle manufacturers like Volkswagen and BMW, but as Chinese and American EV competitors start eating market share globally, the value prop of the CEE Automotive Industry goes down, and has a downstream impact across other suppliers and industries (eg. Infineon, SAP, etc).
- gruez 3y ago>Hyper-focus on commercialization and maximizing shareholder value might make other aspects of society worse What does this translate to in apple's case?
- sgu999 3y ago>> Hyper-focus on commercialization and maximizing shareholder value might make other aspects of society worse > What does this translate to in apple's case? If we're only talking about products, it's rather obvious that they are fairly hostile to their users, and I've been one for more than two decades. As for "society" as a whole, I don't envy any of the low paid workers involved in the supply chain of an iPhone. And, of course, there is "some" environmental concerns to have... Not saying that a French "Apple" would do better though, they'd be equally bad. I'm only replying to your comment.
- delfinom 3y ago>commercializing innovation. That's your take? I see a different take. Europe has done more work than in the US in fighting the robbing of the middle and lower classes by the wealthy. Sure it still is a problem but wealth inequality is a huge deal. Apple exists because of rampant cut throat capitalism that comes at a cost to everyone.
- alephnerd 3y agoThe Median Household Income in the US is still much higher than in most Western European countries. Inequality exists in the US, but quality of life still not all that different from Europe in most social indicators. Even stuff like health insurance or college isn't all that different when factoring household income, and the fact that it is largely subsidized by employers and the government in the US. The UX absolutely sucks in the US though compared to equivalent systems in Europe though - an employer PPO plan in the US can give you easier access to GPs than a number of Single Payer plans in Europe, but the Single Payer plans in some European countries is just conceptually easier to use. That said, scale of things the US isn't some unequal hellhole third world country any more than Europe is some hedonistic post modern continent. The average European and American have largely comparable qualities of life, which makes the lack of innovative commercialization even more jarring.
- Tainnor 3y agoThe median isn't a good indicator for inequality. The Gini index is higher in the US than in most European countries (although the difference is admittedly not huge). I think Europe in general just manages to take care of the most vulnerable better. You can't bankrupt yourself because you have cancer - the plot of Breaking Bad doesn't make sense in Europe.
- alephnerd 3y agoI'd largely agree - the bottom 10% in Europe will have a better life than the bottom 10% in the US. That said, even factoring post-tax Gini, American QoL isn't all that different from the UK or Japan. The only large (>50mil pop) European countries with a better HDI than the US is Germany and the UK (though the UK is barely higher than the US). In 2023, France, Spain, and Italy all have developmental indicators the US reached in the early 2000s. So why is Europe so behind the US that much less developed countries like China and India, and formerly developing countries like Israel, Taiwan, South Korea, and Japan can outcompete European countries in various sectors of innovation?
- solardev 3y agoIt's a good thing. They have far nicer communities and societies because it's not all just capitalism for the rich. Sure, our Apples and Googles and Metas may be huge, but what does that do for the average American? It makes their housing unaffordable and their cities shitty to live in.
- supportengineer 3y agoAt work the parking lot of the building contains Teslas and Rivians. The surrounding streets are back-to-back illegally parked RVs. The contrast is overwhelming.
- philwelch 3y agoUnaffordable housing and (literally) shitty cities are a consequence of a completely different set of policy choices on the West Coast.
- solardev 3y agoDoubt it, they were getting that way through all the dot com bubbles. I lived through them there
- nradov 3y agoThere are plenty of shitty communities in France (and the rest of Europe) as well. Look outside the tourist areas.
- solardev 3y agoIt's better than shitty communities through most of the United States, isn't it? The US is the most gilded society I've ever visited, aside from apartheid South Africa...
- nradov 3y agoIt isn't. https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-66071455.amp https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-66071455.amp Or beyond France, check out living conditions in the Roma ghettos.
- InCityDreams 3y ago>, it's crazy to see how horribly mismanaged the commercialization of innovation sectors like... Pharmaceuticals are compared to their equivalents in the US, Asia, and Israel. My every-two monthly prescriptions (four different drugs) cost me €8 a time - I would put that under 'great management' (after all, why can't it be done in the States?) I have seen the 'well-managed' US equivalents - it's not that 'we' actually hate the rich, quite the opposite: just please not at the expense of our 'mis-managed(!)' societies.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dmos62 3y agoAre you implying that US is capital rich because of innovation? I think it is a source of innovation, but I could think of more convincing narratives for why it's rich.
- alephnerd 3y ago> Are you implying that US is capital rich because of innovation Yes I am. "Clusters of productivity-boosting patents correlated closely with three major waves of U.S. technological progress: the late 19th century’s so-called Second Industrial Revolution (which saw new railroad technology and the birth of electricity), the 1930s (new applications of electricity and the development of chemicals, including Bakelite, the first fully synthetic plastic), and the 1990s (revolutions in computers, communication, and genetics). The link between innovation and productivity held across sectors of the economy. For example, during periods when a given sector saw 30 percent more innovation than average, that sector tended to see up to 11 percent higher productivity." [0] [0] - https://insight.kellogg.northwestern.edu/article/measuring-innovation-patents-productivity https://insight.kellogg.northwestern.edu/article/measuring-i...
- philwelch 3y agoI agree with you but the US has many other economic advantages as well: a well-educated workforce, plentiful natural resources, tons of energy, and a fairly liberalized free market system. The innovation is the most important factor though.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoTwo huge oceans on both sides, friendly bordering nations, effectively no competition in the whole western hemisphere, and being primarily English speaking are other ones.
- philwelch 3y agoAt this point, speaking English is an advantage for other economies because it’s the language that Americans speak.