8 ms·
Amazing optical illusion or "glitch in the Matrix"?
- the_cat_kittles 15y agoI think the relevant wikipedia terms here are "Aliasing" and "Nyquist Frequency"
- streptomycin 15y agoI would have said "Poincaré map", as that's basically what this is, in some respect.
- sbarre 15y agoWhatever you want to call it, it's a very cool effect.. (edit: but thank you for providing some educational context! Off to Wikipedia I go..)
- egypturnash 15y agoAlso [wagon-wheel effect](http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wagon-wheel_effect http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wagon-wheel_effect).
- emmelaich 15y agoI mocked someone when he said he could see the effect in normal daylight with his eyes, but in fact I checked and could also see it sometimes! http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wagon-wheel_effect#Truly_continuous_illumination http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wagon-wheel_effect#Truly_contin...
- acqq 15y agoStrictly speaking, it's not an "optical" illusion at all -- you must film the drops with the camera. You'll see the effect only on the screen. Still, a clever idea to simply use a sub-woofer to kick the drops. I like it.
- jcampbell1 15y agoThe same effect can be achieved in real life by adding a strobe light.
- Florin_Andrei 15y agoThere might be a little bit more to it than that. I think the vibrating subwoofer actually nudges the droplets and shapes them, controls the flow and the way each individual droplet breaks off. Anyway, I'm definitely going to try this.
- MartinCron 15y agoI think the idea was to have a vibrating subwoofer and a strobe light, where the strobe light would simulate the synchronized framerate. It should work. I would try it but strobelights give me a headache.
- Dylan16807 15y agoEven at high frequencies? Because a strobe light gives you a lot more flexibility.
- Florin_Andrei 15y agoOh, I see. So then you wouldn't need a camera.
- acqq 15y agoYes I also think that if you can use strobe light and have the possibility to adjust the strobe frequency you don't even need a subwoofer, but for the proper "matrix-like" effect a lot of "frames per second" are needed and the camera gives certainly nicer result. In my opinion his setup was really quite optimal for what he presented.
- spatten 15y agoSee my comment above. You actually need the sound to create vibrations in the stream of water that breaks it up into drops. The coolest thing is that there really are drops here, it's not an optical illusion.
- yathern 15y agoMy question is would this be possible with a strobe light? Or even better, a florescent light? That would make some very impressive shows, if you could have a whole hallway with different streams, all synchronized to the frequency that the lights strobe at.
- weavejester 15y agoThat's an interesting idea, and it should be possible with a strobe. A florescent light oscillates too quickly though; the gap between the water droplets is going to be inversely proportionate to the frequency of the sine wave.
- omegant 15y agoI've done it in an almos empty disco, with some strobes and a cord with a key(or any other weight) at the end. I turned around the key (like using a sling). Playing a bit is pretty easy to make the key stop in the air like pointing in the direction you choose. Also you can see the effect in some videos of flying helicopters, they seem to be flying with the rotor freezed. It is Pretty cool!
- albertsun 15y agoI've seen it at a children's science museum, forget which one. They had a dark box you could look into with some kind of strobe which produced this effect in the box.
- tcas 15y agoThere's an exhibit at the Boston Aquarium that is exactly this with a strobe light. It's really cool to see in person.
- DanBC 15y ago(http://hackaday.com/2011/03/11/water-droplet-sculpture-using-leds-and-arduino/ http://hackaday.com/2011/03/11/water-droplet-sculpture-using...) There are plenty on YouTube. It is an amazing illusion. I find it hard to understand how "a drop" seems to stay the same shape. I need to think a bit more about that.
- maeon3 15y agoAnother trick is to take a rope and wiggle it at say 2 to 20 hz and take a strobe light to light up at 1 to 15 hz. In the dark the rope will show a perfectly formed sin wave which is spooky to look at. Another one is putting clear plastic wrap over a subwoofer, making it face upward, and sprinkling salt on the surface. The patterns it creates look like alien symbols as you explore the spectrum.
- EvilTerran 15y agoYou might be able to get a similar effect to the naked eye, if you used a sound wave at/near the same frequency as your local mains electricity, under incandescent mains lighting. A harmonic frequency might even work, too. I recall seeing a tool for fine-tuning vinyl turntable speed that used that form of the trick - it was basically a cardboard "record" with spokes printed on it every (* grabs a calculator *) 4.02deg, so as to appear to be stationary when rotating at exactly 33.5rpm under light flickering at 50Hz. Thought that was ingenious.
- jff 15y agoSure to cause humorous results for us Americans with our 60 Hz mains, if we were to import such a tuner.
- ktizo 15y agoThey often have a 50/60hz switch on them.
- ChuckMcM 15y agoI still have a turn table and it has stroboscopic marks on the rim for just that purpose. :-) Sadly I only have one more cartridge for it and after that, no more replacement needles. I prefer the water and corn starch on a speaker [1] to get standing structures of weirdness. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SbTHExJzJXs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SbTHExJzJXs
- judofyr 15y agoHere's a slightly more fascinating video of Oobleck (water + cron starch) on a speaker: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Yp1wUodQgqQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Yp1wUodQgqQ
- moe 15y agoTechnics turntables have strobe dots on the rim for calibration: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XLtlELevKdk#t=0m12s http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XLtlELevKdk#t=0m12s
- nirvana 15y agoCamera's are not the same as reality. They take images at a certain number of frames per second. 24, 30 or 60 are common frame rates for digital cameras. Thus, the camera is effectively its own strobe. Since the frequency in the speaker is 24 hertz and camcorders can be set at 24 frames per second, it is likely that this is what is happening here-- the speaker frequency is causing pressure differentials in the water, the water's surface tension causes the succession of drops to form similar shapes, and the camera taking an image at the same frequency of as the speaker makes things look still because the drops are in exactly the same spot each frame. You can notice on one of the lower bubbles further away from the spout the effect is less precise and the bubble seems to be changing shape or moving around.... this is because the effect of he speaker on the water decreases over time as the water gets further away and air turbulence causes the drops shape to pick up more randomness.
- rsanchez1 15y agoWe can read the description on the video, you know.
- shashashasha 15y agoThese kind of computer vision illusions are always really fascinating to me. It's kind of like a natural zoetrope effect. More: Bass String Video: https://vimeo.com/4041788 https://vimeo.com/4041788 The Phonotrope: http://www.jimlefevre.com/?page_id=200 http://www.jimlefevre.com/?page_id=200
- rsanchez1 15y agoThis is your universe at 24 Hz.
- pjscott 15y agoIt usually looks like the universe at any other reasonable frequency, unless you're doing weird things at a multiple of 24 Hz.
- bch 15y agozoetropes on bicycle wheels: http://www.designboom.com/weblog/cat/8/view/17851/bike-wheel-animation-by-katy-beveridge.html http://www.designboom.com/weblog/cat/8/view/17851/bike-wheel...
- marquis 15y agoBill Viola did this using strobe lights in an installation format. You can recreate this yourself easily with a programmable strobe. Thanks to Edgerton for the inventions. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harold_Eugene_Edgerton http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harold_Eugene_Edgerton
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- melvinng 15y agomy dog started acting up when I turned this on, any relation?
- petegrif 15y agoCool.
- JVIDEL 15y agoJust another trick like the "hovering" russian helicopter... The matrix didn't go BSOD when Crysis launched, it wont go because of a reverse stream of water...
- Blunt 15y agoreally an optical illusion? I heard two different flows of water splashing in the bucket which I would not expect if it was just an optical trick.
- essayist 15y agoSince water droplets look alike, you get the illusion, at the proper frequency setting, of water dripping up. I wonder how it would look if a different dye was injected into the flow every few seconds, just above the faucet. Presumably, the colors would appear to flow down as the water appeared to drop up.
- spatten 15y agoI spent a few years of my life staring at this exact effect. I was working on building a big industrial inkjet printer. The physics behind it is cool too, but not new. Lord Rayleigh first described it in 1878. Not exactly a glitch in the Matrix :). I have a patent somewhere on a minor tweak to the concept, but can't find it right now. Good times. More info: Just to clarify for everyone assuming that this is an optical illusion. It's not. The subwoofer is actually creating vibrations in the water stream that increase exponentially as the stream travels until their magnitude is larger than the diameter of the stream. At this point, the stream breaks up into drops. If you do this with a coloured stream of water (i.e. ink) and run a piece of paper under it, you will see individual drops of ink hit the paper. There are two types of inkjet printers. The most common is what you see in household inkjet printers, it's called Drop-on-demand. You spit out a drop by doing something to the ink. Ofter you heat up a resistor, converting some of the ink to steam and pushing out a drop of ink. The other type is called continuous inkjet. The way this works is you have a stream of ink, you stimulate it at some frequency which gives you drops at that frequency, and then you select some drops to hit the paper and others to miss. The project I was working on used conductive ink and selectively charged the drops before sending them between two oppositely charged plates, sort of like a cathode ray tube with ink drops instead of electrons. It was ridiculously cool technology, and a lot of fun to work on. The printer we were designing (never got to market in that incarnation) would have had paper going by at ~6 meters/second with very high quality, totally variable output. I thought we were going to disrupt offset printing in a big way. Sigh :). [edit] Ooo, found the patent. Great bedtime reading if you're interested: http://bit.ly/HXc6o2 http://bit.ly/HXc6o2
- jblock 15y agoIf you don't mind me asking, what ended up killing it? It sounds awesome.
- spatten 15y agoTwo companies doing the same thing both got bought by the same very large company. The other company kept going. We got shut down. I got to leave and start my own company (Leanpub), and everyone lived happily ever after. It was a great project, but I'm much happier now doing the startup thing than I was being a physicist.
- sp332 15y agoHere's a crazier version: https://vimeo.com/4041788 https://vimeo.com/4041788 The camera takes frames at 30 fps. But each frame is only exposed for 1/4000 of a second, which lets you see the string as if it is holding still during the frame. And finally, the camera has a "rolling shutter" so the bottom of the frame is captured about 1/50th of a second after the top. This creates the visible wiggle in each frame, as the string vibrates several times as the frame is recorded from top to bottom.
- loceng 15y agoDoes this signal our perception of the universe is structured by the energy's surrounding us? We did evolve along with all of these energies. The human mind is malleable and dynamic, not fixed like a 24 FPS camera lens (I imagine most humans don't have a fixed framerate for incoming sensory) - I do wonder if other critters with less dynamic minds would fail to some kind of trick. I wonder too if it was this kind of dynamic ability that allowed us to disconnect from a fixed reality, thereby giving us contrast, the ability to analyze our surroundings, and therefore consciousness.