3 ms·
Another part is that there is barely any training for QA people. Even your average CS course will only graze the top of the topic, most usually some prof dronin
by mschuster91 3y ago
Another part is that there is barely any training for QA people. Even your average CS course will only graze the top of the topic, most usually some prof droning on about Java unit tests on some really old version of Java and a testing framework just as old.
There are no "Software Quality Assurance" academic degrees, there's barely any research into testing methodologies, there's barely any commercial engagement in the space aside from test run environments (aka, selling shovels to gold diggers), and let's face truth, also in tooling. And everything but software QA is an even worse state, with "training" usually consisting of a few weeks of "learning on the job".
Basic stuff like "how does one even write a test plan", "how does one keep track of bugs", "how to determine what needs to be tested in what way (unit, integration, e2e)" is at best cargo-culted in the organization, at worst everyone is left to reinvent the wheel themselves, and you end up with 13 different "testing" jobs in a manually clicked-together Jenkins server, for one project.
> Defect Investigation: Reproduction, or “repro”, is a critical part of managing bugs. In order to expedite fixes, somebody has to do the legwork to translate “I tried to buy a movie ticket and it didn’t work” into “character encoding issues broke the purchase flow for a customer with a non-English character in their name”.
And this would normally not be the job of a QA person, that's 1st level support's job, but outsourcing to Indian body shops or outright AI chatbots is cheaper than hiring competent support staff.
That also ties in to another aspect I found lacking in the article: users are expected to be your testers for free aka you sell bananaware. No matter if it's AAA games, computer OSes, phones, even cars...
- wmichelin 3y agoTo play devil's advocate here, I did not _really_ get training for my software engineering role. I got a little bit from 1-2 college courses, but the vast majority of my role I had to pick up on the job or on my own. I can tell you, I definitely didn't get training for QA tasks, but here I am doing them anyways. It's just work that needs to be done.
- mschuster91 3y ago> To play devil's advocate here, I did not _really_ get training for my software engineering role Yeah and that is my point. It would be way better for the entire field of QA if there were at least a commonly agreed base framework of concepts and ways to do and especially to name things, if alone because the lack of standardization wrecks one's ability to even get testers and makes onboarding them to your "in house standards" a very costly endeavour.
- bsilvereagle 3y ago> if there were at least a commonly agreed base framework of concepts and ways to do and especially to name things All of the above exist, the International Software Testing Qualification Board is one of the entities offering certifications in this: https://www.istqb.org/ https://www.istqb.org/
- ThrowawayR2 3y agoISTQB/ASTQB's definitions and teachings aren't commonly agreed on by the testing profession, at least in North America, and their certification isn't seen as being of any particular value. I hear they're held in higher regard in Europe and elsewhere.
- philk10 3y agoA lot of people took it so they could put it on their CV/resume and get past the job filters, consultancies got their testers to do it so they could get past client filters ( from my experience when I was working in the UK)
- Swizec 3y ago> There are no "Software Quality Assurance" academic degrees, there's barely any research into testing methodologies, There's a lot of this actually. Entire communities of people working on software quality assurance. Practitioners in this space call their field "resilience engineering". The field likes to talk a lot about system design. Especially in the intersection of humans and machines. Stuff like "How do you set up a system (the org) such that production bugs are less likely to make it all the way to users"
- tester756 3y ago>Another part is that there is barely any training for QA people What training is in your opinion needed?