5 ms·
On the one hand, as a matter of principle -- absolutely. On the other hand, bodycams run out of batteries or the electronics glitch or automated video download
by crazygringo 3y ago
On the one hand, as a matter of principle -- absolutely.
On the other hand, bodycams run out of batteries or the electronics glitch or automated video downloads get skipped, in ways that simply don't happen with paper notebooks or data stored in central databases.
To assume that it's always a dereliction of duty is not going to be reasonable in practice.
Like, for whatever reason my cell phone doesn't automatically sync my photos to the cloud even though it's supposed to. And instead of updating my apps overnight, it starts to update them when I unplug my phone each morning. And automatic OS updates never work, I have to do them manually. Technology's great but technology sucks, too. And I have to assume bodycam software is less reliable than iOS/Android.
- manicennui 3y agoIt's curious how these problems are highly correlated with the police doing questionable shit.
- Aachen 3y agoIs that an assumption, or based on any particular data set or even just a few data points you've anecdotally read about? The article doesn't mention this. It finds some cases where footage is (allegedly) unavailable, but does not look into how often footage is unavailable when nobody cares about it. If you think the cops are corrupt and delete footage of their own wrongdoing, that would need some backing up to be believable for me. Maybe in low-income/low-justice countries that's an assumption one can make, but not where I live at least.
- sonicanatidae 3y agoYou can google for 2 mins and find many examples of hardware mysteriously failing while an officer was violating someone's rights. You can also find many instances of the video being magically deleted..aw shucks. Are there exceptions, like you mentioned? Sure. Are there many, many instances of that being bullshit? Sure.
- amelius 3y agoIt's probably more likely that people complain publicly about failed hardware if the hardware indeed failed. If you search for "hardware was working fine", yes, you probably won't find much, because that's not something people complain about.
- sonicanatidae 3y agoWho's talking about complaints/feedback? I'm talking about numerous court cases, where bodycam footage was magically unavailable, when all of the circumstantial evidence pointed to crimes committed. I'm not after hunting all cops, or any of that horse shit. I'm referring to accountability beyond the current 6 week paid vacation, qualified immunity slapped on pretty much everything, being able to simply quit a job after committing literal crimes and get a job in an adjacent city doing the same thing, and stupid -isms, like "Yeah, that guy died not because we choked him until he couldn't breathe, but because of "excited delirium".
- Aachen 3y ago> Are there exceptions [where it's truly accidental] > Are there many, many instances of that being bullshit? Sure. If you're trying to be fair by including the former sentence, then that should also include a "many, many" before "exceptions" unless you have the data I was asking after. As it stands, this adds no further information > You can google for 2 mins and find many examples of hardware mysteriously failing while an officer was violating someone's rights. If you think the cops are so bad, what about the criminals? I'd also claim the cop was violating my rights if I did something wrong and it's my word against theirs. How are you ever going to know what happened there? You can assume the cop was corrupt and the citizen innocent in all those cases, but if it were knowable then the citizen would have brought it to court rather than to the media, so I'm assuming it's unknowable who was right in most of those cases There has to be a fraction of cases where their rights were not being violated as claimed and footage is still unavailable. Whether that is 1/10 or 9/10, neither of us apparently has the information to make such a claim, but you're making extraordinary assumptions without extraordinary evidence
- 3y ago
- bratbag 3y agoOr are you just more likely to notice the overlap?
- spurgu 3y ago> And I have to assume bodycam software is less reliable than iOS/Android. I'd argue that it's waaaay easier to make stable bodycam software than a stable mobile phone OS.
- crazygringo 3y agoExcept that I don't think the bodycam companies are hiring the same caliber of engineers that Apple and Google are. If they're like most other device companies, they're hiring the cheapest programmers they can find to write something quick and dirty, and not doing anything close to the level of review and testing that Apple/Google do.
- spurgu 3y agoFair point.
- jjk166 3y ago> On the other hand, bodycams run out of batteries or the electronics glitch or automated video downloads get skipped, in ways that simply don't happen with paper notebooks or data stored in central databases. Systems are going to fail, but they need to fail safely. If a bodycam is low on battery or not acting properly, there needs to be some notification for both the operator and department to know that the bodycam failed or is about to fail, and their procedure has to handle such cases. So for example have an indicator light that comes on at 20% battery power and officers need to return to the station and swap cameras when that light comes on, and battery levels at the end of a shift are logged automatically with a notification if any are returned below 10%. Of course genuine failures are going to happen from time to time. If an officer falls and damages their camera in the middle of a shootout, they're not going to call a timeout so they can fix it. But such instances should be rare, documented, and reviewed. The department should at any given time be able to produce a list of what footage they are missing and why they're missing it, and such reports should be audited by third parties. During the review, evidence should be collected - pictures of any damage, software logs, statements, etc. as well as actions taken during that missing time, which should be reviewed with increased scrutiny. So long as the discrepancy is properly documented, it's fine, though procedures should be updated to prevent a repeat of this particular failure mode. Basically if a critical piece of footage is lost it should be easy to show that this was an isolated incident and that it won't happen again. If they can't, then there is a fundamental problem at the top level of management. This is all standard practice in other high stakes fields like pharmaceutical production.
- stronglikedan 3y agoThey check their weapons before each shift. They should check their body cams just as thoroughly.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- lamontcg 3y ago> And I have to assume bodycam software is less reliable than iOS/Android. Uh, no? I'd naive assume it would be much simpler and more reliable, and that failure to do something like recharge or upload data would log an exception somewhere that would get immediate attention. When the 'IT guy' goes to work the next morning they should see that one of the bodycams didn't do its thing the night before and that bodycam should get replaced. The maximum window of failiure should be 24h or less, and multiple failures happening to all responding officers shouldn't really be possible since they should have a MTBF exceeding a year.