8 ms·
HBO Decides It Still Isn't Difficult Enough To Watch HBO Shows
- bryanh 15y agoArchaic C-level execs are still making the calls. This isn't unexpected.
- ssharp 15y agoAnd armchair C-level execs criticize without understanding the reasoning behind the decision. I don't like that I can't just buy a subscription to HBO Go (I recently dumped cable) or buy HBO shows on iTunes the day after they air, but there are lots of revenue-related reasons why HBO is restricting access to its content.
- PureSin 15y agoOatmeal about difficult of watching Game of Thrones: http://theoatmeal.com/comics/game_of_thrones http://theoatmeal.com/comics/game_of_thrones and how I feel as a non US resident: http://theoatmeal.com/pl/game_of_thrones/nz http://theoatmeal.com/pl/game_of_thrones/nz
- guccimane 15y agoAndy Ihnatko about Oatmeal about difficulty of watching Game of Thrones: http://ihnatko.com/2012/02/20/heavy-hangs-the-bandwidth-that-torrents-the-crown/ http://ihnatko.com/2012/02/20/heavy-hangs-the-bandwidth-that...
- gcb 15y agoHe's never going to be a paying customer anyways. before torrents he'd just show up at some friend with hbo. Today people don't mingle irl, so he downloads. People on 4Chan age group are found of watching streaming with chat on the side. It's pretty much the same shinding concept of yesterday.
- gte910h 15y agoThe Oatmeal, aka Matthew Inman sold a pretty sizable dating site. http://0at.org/pages/about http://0at.org/pages/about I'm pretty sure he's in the group of more money then time these days.
- sophacles 15y agoAnd how terrible a world it was when people mingled and watched TV at their friends houses -- reducing, NO STEALING, profits from the HBO... I am a giant theif, I take so much revenue from companies all the time, I need someone to sue the shit out of me for the following (to teach me a lesson and put me in my place): * I loan out my $1000 worth of rototillers to friends all the time, the manufacturers and rental agencies are losing piles of revenue from me. * I let people use my truck, and/or help them move things regularly. That is dozens of car purchases or rentals * I help my family and friends with computer issues and build them free websites occasionally -- dirty dirty hippy crap, poor companies are losing service calls all the time. * I cook meals from my garden, and invite people over to eat with me, grocers and restauranteurs probably should lynch me for denying their revenue. Stupid sharing and human kindness. Obviously we are just a bad, evil species.
- MichaelGG 15y agoBasically that just comes back to not wanting to face reality. One can go complain about lame people are that can't wait 3 weeks for the official release on iTunes, complain how lame it is that someone demands the content on their terms, etc. Reality is still that HBO is simply taking away the incentive to purchase the product. Right or wrong, that's the end result. So do they want to continue complaining, or actually try to make more sales? (And I'm sure HBO is aware of the tradeoffs, and feels like protecting their current model is more important than a few more digital sales. That might be a correct assessment, for now.)
- Locke1689 15y agoBoth things can be true. The parent is right that pirating content and not paying for it is not morally defensible if you believe that intellectual property has value. You are correct that people often do immoral things. A refusal to believe that people often do things which violate their own moral code is a denial of fundamental human nature. A smart distributor will say, "if we make barriers too high to easily own this content piracy rates will rise" while a smart pirate would say, "my actions are morally wrong but I don't care because it benefits me."
- tomjen3 15y agoDo you really want to open that can of worms? Because I won't argue the point any more, but piracy is theft when people loose something.
- icebraining 15y agoHN comments are IP. If everyone you upvoted asked you to pay $20 for the value they provided, would you? We all get value for free; life would be impossible if we didn't. So either you're like Andrew Joseph Galambos, who changed his name to not infringe on his father's, and who put a coin in a box every time he used the word "liberty" (to pay its supposed inventor, Thomas Paine), or your position is inconsistent and ad-hoc. A pirate is no worse for a creator than someone who simply abstains from the content. So in my opinion, either the two are wrong or none of them is. (Note to everyone else: ad-hominem trolls will be ignored)
- rickmb 15y agoWhich is a typical way of reversing the argument. The whole point of copyright and the free market is to do exactly that: to have as the end result consumers that can get what they want at an affordable price whilst allowing the original creators to make a living. Copyright violation is not "sin" like theft, respecting it depends entirely on actually making it work. If copyright is the only thing that actually stands in the way of that, it is being abused. To paraphrase the author: The world doesn't OWE the copyright owners enforcement at any cost. If you can't distribute it under your 100% terms, you have the free-and-clear option of not publishing it at all.
- viraptor 15y agoThe point he's missing is that we're in a global village. If your friends watch it, you'll know what happens because they will talk about it. Maybe you won't care, maybe you will enjoy it a little bit less with no suspense - depends on how social if your typical series watching. I don't see anything wrong with the approach though. Noone's saying that people won't buy the series on netflix once it's finally available. Although we know how likely that is...
- MartinCron 15y agoThe only thing that Andy Ihnatko gets wrong in his critique is that he claims the original oatmeal comic is funny.
- wpietri 15y agoThe "I will argue publicly with an imaginary straw man" is one of the laziest writing devices in the world. Gosh, I wonder who's going to win?
- jjcm 15y agoI think Andy is missing the point of the Oatmeal comic. It's not that people want the content right then and there. That's a minor part in the larger picture: acquiring content illegally is a better experience than acquiring it legally. Let's say I purchased season one on bluray, and just as I was coming home from the store my friend gave me a thumb drive with the torrented files on it. I wouldn't even open the shrink wrap. If the bluray disc gets scratched, I no longer have access to my content; I can back up the files on the thumb drive though. If I want to watch an episode, I have to sit through commercials on the bluray that I purchased; I can watch them immediately off the thumb drive though. If I want to project using a vga cable, I may run into content protection issues; the files on the thumb drive will work just fine though. It's not a matter of cost or wait time. It's that torrent networks provide a better, faster, easier, more portable, and simpler experience than the legal way.
- lotharbot 15y ago> "acquiring content illegally is a better experience than acquiring it legally." Recall this famous image: http://www.makeuseof.com/tech-fun/pirated-dvd-vs-legal-dvd/ http://www.makeuseof.com/tech-fun/pirated-dvd-vs-legal-dvd/ People get too hung up on small points in this discussion -- "it'll be out in 3 weeks, that's not very long" or whatever -- and miss the larger picture. The larger picture is that there are a lot of unnecessary barriers between consumers and content they're willing to pay for. Torrents are straightforward, they work right the first time, and they continue to work. Whereas some providers/distributors seem intent on processes that are slow, convoluted, annoying, frustrating, and that might eventually not even deliver the desired content (say, in the language of choice.)
- redthrowaway 15y agoContents of the article aside, techdirt regularly writes fantastic headlines. I wonder if it's just the individual authors having a flair for the zinger, or if they have an editor who spruces them up before posting.
- brandall10 15y agoThe thing that bothers me most about this is I credit HBO for leading the charge with innovative content that as a whole brought TV to a much higher level. They took big chances even when it wasn't profitable to do so. I've had a serious love affair with the network beginning with Dream On, The Larry Sanders Show, then moving on to Oz (yeah it was a 'male' soap opera I guess :), Sopranos, 6 Feet Under, Deadwood - which I didn't particularly _love_, but highly respected, and most of all The Wire (best thing to ever grace the screen IMO - they lost $$ on it throughout its run)... and then I killed my cable sub and haven't seen anything of their's since. Now Mad Men and Breaking Bad are my two favorite shows, they're both on AMC, and I can easily purchase each season on iTunes HD for just north of $30. Every episode is available hours after they originally air. I'd pay twice that much. Of course, the problem is HBO is just too tightly coupled to big cable. They're one of the main attractions, and as such the kickbacks they get are tied to contracts that prevent them from wresting their content to any great degree. Until this model changes, their A content won't see the light of day, and more draconian measures are likely to be put in place to thwart piracy. It's not HBO itself per-see, but HBO as a proxy for big cable; as a defense mechanism to prop up a flailing business model.
- jdludlow 15y agoOur experiences are nearly mirror images. I cancelled cable TV years ago. When Game of Thrones came out last year, I naively thought "No big deal. I'll just pay HBO for streaming." I was shocked to discover that there's no way for me to upend my wallet into HBO's coffers without funneling it through Comcast and buying multiple tiers of garbage that I care nothing about. I waited a year and bought the blu ray version, but I still can't understand why HBO wouldn't prefer to get their money earlier rather than later.
- tswartz 15y agoCompletely agree with you. I was very excited when I heard about the HBO Go app and was looking forward to paying HBO for their excellent content. Similarly I was frustrated to find you need cable TV and Comcast to use it. Still trying to figure out a way to see the new season of Game of Thrones.
- guccimane 15y ago"We've recently discussed the fact that HBO severely limits the availability of its shows to non-subscribers..." Really?! How dare they!
- sophacles 15y agoCut the disingenuous crap. The next 3 sentences state that beyond that, they are now, without warning, requiring paying subscribers to upgrade equipment to handle the HDMI encryption. The first sentence was merely contextualization. Further, the context of that sentence (via the link) was how difficult it is to legally pay HBO for the thing they are supposedly selling.
- guccimane 15y agoI know. I don't make any bones about this HDCP stuff being bullshit. They are screwing their own, paying customers. That's terrible. It's just that I really have no time for this entitled attitude that content owners are obligated to sell their wares to us when we want, how we want, at the price point we want.
- sophacles 15y agoIt's not entitled bullshit, that is a false dilemma and a strawman. It is pointing out hypocrisy. If they make it very hard to give them money, why the fuck should it be valid when they complain about not getting money? It's like a bum complaining it isn't enough when you give him your spare change. edit: accidentally a word
- homosaur 15y agoThey aren't obligated. And let me check.... yep! Turns out my computer still can reach the Pirate Bay! So there's your choice, philosophical discussions are worthless.
- tomjen3 15y agoThey are certainly not obligated to sell me anything. I just take my business elsewhere. Monopolies are bad, right?
- tomjen3 15y agoActually they make it difficult to watch it _legally_. Lets not pretend that most people don't get it from a much more convenient source: (example pulled from google): http://thepiratebay.se/torrent/7153447/Game_of_Thrones_-_Season_2_Episode_1_ http://thepiratebay.se/torrent/7153447/Game_of_Thrones_-_Sea...
- guard-of-terra 15y agoIt's fascinating to watch how much opportunity they are throwing out of the door. According to blog monitoring service blogs.yandex.ru, Game of Thrones is third most discussed TV series in Russian speaking countries right now. Obviously a huge number of people watch it from various of sources: original torrents, translated torrents, streaming... But HBO gets exactly zero from this. They just don't want anybody's money. They do nothing.
- wpietri 15y agoI'm sure they want it. But as any Game of Thrones watcher knows, the alliances that you make in the pursuit of power and wealth mean you can't always do what you want. Yet.
- guard-of-terra 15y agoAs any Game of Thrones watcher should always remember: While you're busy fighting for power and wealth, somebody is eating your lunch at the same time. Instead of fighting for the share of wealth, you should perhaps figure out a way of making more wealth or at least preserving it.
- henrikschroder 15y agoHodor.
- kamjam 15y agoThe funny thing is because they just made it more difficult for people who are paying good money to subscribe to their service, they may well have driven a whole bunch of people to cancel their subscription and go down the illegal route because it is so much easier, and cheaper than buying a new cable box! Crazy!
- reustle 15y agoHBO Go on the iPad doesn't let you stream to your TV via the VGA cable, so they forced me to do this this weekend: http://i.imgur.com/Og3MH.jpg http://i.imgur.com/Og3MH.jpg
- greggman 15y agoTHIS is exactly why PG made his call to kill old media. HBO could be making bank by allowing either PPV online, subscription online or commercial supported. They have some of the best shows ever. But for whatever reason, out dated contracts or old thinking they are throwing money away.
- citizenparker 15y agoHBO is making bank. Until we as consumers vote with our wallets and change our behavior by canceling subscriptions, nothing will change for HBO or their bottom line.
- davidpetersen 15y agohbogo.com is still the best website I know of for watching any tv channels shows. HBO subscribers get access to every single show the second it comes out, and it remains available forever. I can go back now and watch every episode of every HBO show. So while I empathize with all of your complaints that HBO makes it too hard for non cable/DirecTV subscribers to subscribe, I think they are due credit for putting all of their content online when most other channels have not.
- acuozzo 15y ago> I can go back now and watch every episode of every HBO show. Really?! Can you watch ``Tales from the Crypt'' or ``The Kids in the Hall''? Can you really watch _every_ episode of _every_ HBO show in the following list? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_programs_broadcast_by_HBO#Past_programming http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_programs_broadcast_by_H...
- res0nat0r 15y agoHBO aren't idiots. They've done the math and for now they've found it IS more profitable for them to only allow you to get their content with a cable subscription. Why does when it come to big media everyone thinks the companies are run by 12 year old morons when they don't agree with their policies? Hurting Game of Thrones Through Piracy Won’t Change HBO’s Business, It Will Just Get the Show Cancelled: http://www.filmschoolrejects.com/features/hurting-game-of-thrones-through-piracy-wont-change-hbos-business-it-will-just-get-the-show-cancelled-rfure.php http://www.filmschoolrejects.com/features/hurting-game-of-th...
- scott_s 15y agoThey've done the math and for now they've found it IS more profitable for them to only allow you to get their content with a cable subscription. I doubt that. Rather, I bet they've made a conscious choice to only be a content provider, not a content distributor. That's a fundamental business change. I say this because if HBO decided to make the change, and enabled, say, a $10 online, streaming subscription, I think they'd make more money than they do now. But that would likely upset their current deals with the cable companies, and it would be a fundamental business model change.
- jfb 15y agoI say this because if HBO decided to make the change, and enabled, say, a $10 online, streaming subscription, I think they'd make more money than they do now. They don't think so. And they have the internal numbers to back up their decision. HBO is a very smart and well run company, and they make buckets and buckets of money from their deals with the cable companies. You (and I) would love to be able to buy access to their content without paying Comcast (or DirecTV &c.) but the number of people holding that position is VASTLY OUTNUMBERED by the number of people willing and able to pay $40/mo or whatever on top of what is considered a utility service. That's not going to change fast, and there's no point for HBO to get those arrows in their back when Apple/Amazon/Netflix are charging ahead regardless.
- bsandbox 15y agoCertainly possible that they would make more money, but I doubt it. Doing some (very) rough math, HBO has about 28M subscribers. Cable customers pay $18 bucks a month for HBO, of which HBO usually gets 50%. So an overnight change in the business model would require 28M subscribers at about $9 / month. Just as a point of comparison, Netflix, with a much larger catalog of shows and movies, has something of the order of 25M subscribers Obviously an overnight change would not happen, there would be a transition over several years and the streaming subscribers may well be supplementary to existing subscribers. But during the transition, cable company partnerships would be strained and existing revenue would be at risk. Not to mention the capital investment required to provide the content reliably, dealing with the multitude of streaming devices, providing customer support, marketing the product directly to consumers and all the other things that cable companies take care of (albeit badly). Netflix is making bold changes in its business model and it's certainly not an easy thing to do. Ultimately, HBO's core competency is in creating amazing content. It's arguable if they'd make more money by changing their business model, but I'd wager that HBO execs simply do not want to have to deal with all the distractions from their core mission that would occur by doing so.
- hjkl 15y ago"...HDCP encryption, a newer part of the HDMI standard..." I don't think that's true. My understanding is that HDCP encryption has been around for as long as HDMI has been around. For example, Blu-ray discs/players use HDCP to encrypt their content. It seems strange that these DVR boxes don't support HDCP. Maybe some of the heat should be directed towards DirecTV for using such non-compliant hardware.
- alexbell 15y agoI hope Netflix's original content gets good/becomes a large enough library to threaten HBO. They would offer subscriptions over apps, set top boxes, and maybe even browsers shortly after. Content providers need to be smacked around by someone like Netflix in a big way.
- amosson 15y agoThis move fits with HBO's (and really every content provider's) anti-piracy strategy. Namely, content needs to be encrypted from the time it leaves their server's to the time it is decoded by the screen. The reason for this is simple, if they achieve this goal, they can argue that anyone who provides an unencrypted copy of content must have violated the DMCA (which has provision against tampering with encryption). Whether the technologies have cracked (the article points out the HDCP has been) or whether the provider ever prosecutes isn't the point, the content providers feel they need to reserve their rights at any cost. Many folks (techdirt included) argue that piracy is just marketing. For instance, it allows HBO to reach an audience they wouldn't reach otherwise. They even speculate that the Game of Thrones ratings bump was due to piracy. While that may (or may not) be true, in most industries, companies control when, where and much to spend on marketing. For HBO (or any content provider) all these decisions come down to economics and how they can maximize their profits. In this new case (adding HDCP to their streams) they probably judged that the number of customer's they'd loose was pretty small and making the change would allow them to further their strategic goals.
- voyou 15y ago"if they achieve this goal, they can argue that anyone who provides an unencrypted copy of content must have violated the DMCA (which has provision against tampering with encryption)" How does that help them, though? Anyone who provides an unencrypted copy has infringed on their copyright, so HBO can go after them on those ground whether or not they also violated the anti-circumvention provisions of the DMCA. It seems to me this would only be useful if they think they can actually prevent people from circumventing their DRM.
- njs12345 15y agoI wonder how much revenue you'd raise on Kickstarter if HBO agreed to release The Wire into the public domain for a certain sum. Enough to make it worth their while? I think so (especially if they released the source material so people could get it in HD, not currently available)..
- rmc 15y agoprobably very little to release it as public domain, since people could then sell and keep all the profits themselves. It would kill their chance to sell it themselves. A Creative Commons licence (CC-NC-BY-ND (non-commerical, attribution required, no derivatives)) might be better.
- tptacek 15y agoI just pay for HBO. It's one of the few channels on TV I actually appreciate having. That's HBO's business model: they want subscribers. They don't care how difficult it is for you as a non-subscriber. As a subscriber, HBO has made it incredibly easy for me to watch HBO shows: I have access to virtually all of them online on demand.
- Tycho 15y agoI have access to virtually all of them online on demand. Can most people subscribe to HBO? Or do you need to buy it along with lots of other stuff? If all people need to do is pay the subscription then I struggle to see what all the fuss is about.
- tptacek 15y agoI believe you may need basic cable. In fairness to this thread that I just barged into and started shouting on (per usual): I have to concede that if you're one of the people that doesn't want to own a TV, it is annoying that HBO won't just let you pay for a subscription directly (that I know of). They could just sell access to HBO GO. On the other hand, give them some time. HBO GO is very new.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- pavel_lishin 15y agoI don't think it's possible to get just basic cable and HBO; you typically have to get some sort of bonus cable package, and then tack on the HBO package onto it. Last time I looked, you needed a level 2 tier of service, and then a bonus subscription which came with HBO and two other channels I couldn't give less of a shit about without medical help. Things may have changed, this was about five years ago.
- Androsynth 15y agoI have a TV, but no cable. I wish I could access HBO the same way I access Netflix, on my Roku box. I would happily pay the same amount as cable subscribers pay for HBO. However I suspect that since they are owned by Time Warner, it won't get any better. Big cable companies are actively trying to prevent themselves from becoming dumb pipes.
- hooande 15y agoLet's not forget what they say about how HBO works financially... softcore pornography and boxing pay for all of the "Game of Thrones"-level masterpieces. While they have produced unfailingly inspirational television, it's not a core part of their economic engine. It's a shame that non-subscribers can't see all the programming, but we wouldn't have it at all if it wasn't for their business model. As good as HBO's programming is, it probably wouldn't be economically feasible if it had to be directly supported. There might be enough income from itunes to (barely) support breakout hits like GoT, but it's unlikely that all of the shows that led up to it would have earned enough money to stay on the air. Cable companies may be evil, but HBO definitely needed them in order to start. They can't be expected to unwind the relationship on the promise of netflix streaming sales to come. (Disclaimer: I love HBO and will watch anything they make)
- ralfd 15y ago> softcore pornography and boxing pay for all of the "Game of Thrones" Well, softcore pornography and violence is not that much different to Game of Thrones. ^^
- zerostar07 15y agoSuppose someone created a landing page where guilt-ridden torrent downloaders can spend a reasonable amount (say $2 per episode) to get rid of their guilt, would HBO accept the money?
- elemeno 15y agoIs't that option just called buying the shows from iTunes or on DVD?
- tomflack 15y agoWhat about where it simply isn't available? The question isn't about the different ways to give HBO money, it's about if they'd accept that money.
- rmc 15y agoNo, because torrents are available to more people than iTunes or DVDs. Try living outside the USA and/or using Linux.
- elemeno 15y agoAmazon ships worldwide, region free DVD players are pretty much the norm worldwide as well. I really do think you'd have to stretch to find somewhere where a torrent is available but it's impossible to get a DVD. If you're just trying to contribute back to those who made the content you're enjoying, just get the DVD regardless of if it's the right language or subtitles or region, and then merrily torrent away know that you've at least done the right thing on a moral basis.
- beloch 15y agoCable provides a lot of entertainment, but it's expensive, especially if you pile on premium channels like HBO. Just as telephone landlines are slowly dying as people decide a cell-phone is enough, cable is dying as people move to strictly on-demand services like Netflix or iTunes. Why pay for 900 channels with nothing to watch when you can get just the shows you want anytime you want them? Even if people spend more on iTunes and netflix per month, the practice still psychologically seems less wasteful. HBO's latest shows are not available anywhere but over the air on HBO. e.g. Game of Thrones Season 2 cannot be watched on Netflix or purchased on iTunes. Those who run HBO probably think of this as being good, since it forces people to subscribe to HBO. Unfortunately, people who have gotten rid of their cable subscription aren't going to get it back just so they can watch HBO's latest shows as they air. They might intend to wait until those shows become available on iTunes or Bluray, but it's also highly probable that they'll give in to temptation and just download them from pirates. This is HBO's real problem. There is a big market for their shows that only the pirates are serving.
- chris_wot 15y agoThere are two perspectives on HBO and piracy. The first is that they are losing money due to piracy. The second is that they aren't losing money, just not gaining it. I suspect they are betting on the second perspective. Foolish, but seems to be there business plan.
- JVIDEL 15y agoHBO was born with Cable, it was disruptive back then because TV in those days was boring, dull, repetitive and way too family-friendly. They don't "understand" the internet, just like TV channels of old didn't understand that not everybody was into Dukes of Hazzard and The Andy Griffith Show re-runs.
- himanx 15y agoya HBO has done a lot to change and it looks like it lwaeding toward something marvelous technocharm.com