3 ms·
I've never owned a car made by GM, but a decision like this guarantees I never will. I don't buy their take that the safety issues are because Android Auto and
by kelnos 3y ago
I've never owned a car made by GM, but a decision like this guarantees I never will.
I don't buy their take that the safety issues are because Android Auto and CarPlay are buggy and have connection issues and other crap that cause people to use their phone directly. I've only had a new enough car to use Android Auto for a year and half now, but I've literally never encountered a bug that required me to touch my phone. If there are bugs on GM's cars, I expect that's an issue with the car's software, not Google's or Apple's.
Obviously GM is putting forth a bad-faith argument to justify their real reason, which is that they just want full control over the experience, and likely want to find ways to monetize things that people can do with their own interface.
Good luck with that, GM. Even if GM somehow manages to build a nice, performant, featureful, non-buggy infotainment system (yeah, right), guaranteed they're going to stop releasing updates for each car's version of it within 5-10 years of the car's release. Meanwhile, as long as my phone keeps getting updates, Android Auto will keep getting updates.
- evanelias 3y agoMy GM-made car does indeed have connectivity issues with CarPlay at least a few times a month. Turning my phone's Bluetooth off and on again fixes it, which makes me wonder if the problem really is on the phone side. On the other hand, it happens more often when switching between a built-in car app (like the 360 cameras app) and the Carplay app, which probably implicates the car's software more? In any case, it is pretty annoying. It sometimes happens at really inopportune times, which can be a distracting safety hazard just from the loss of connectivity/functionality alone (i.e. not even considering needing to touch the phone, which is illegal while driving in many US states.)
- AmVess 3y agoThat is a GM problem. I've never had Carplay connectivity issues across 4 different brands.
- piperswe 3y agoI've had connectivity issues with wireless CarPlay in my BMW, though admittedly they've been very rare recently.
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoI don’t have connectivity problems in my BMW, but sometimes have my GPS location 100 meters off, and will try to turn on and off Bluetooth to fix that. It sometimes works.
- evanelias 3y agoI probably should have mentioned that my phone is over 6 years old, which may or may not be a factor. Absolutely could be entirely a GM problem though. I haven't been too happy with the car lately, and don't think I would buy a GM vehicle again.
- plasticchris 3y agoI’ve seen wireless CarPlay connectivity problems in certain locations which makes me think there’s interference there and I’m driving through it.
- 65a 3y ago> guaranteed they're going to stop releasing updates for each car's version of it within 5-10 years of the car's release That's probably a feature and not a bug to them, since it damages the value or desirability of used vehicles.
- user2342 3y ago> I don't buy their take that the safety issues are because Android Auto and CarPlay are buggy and have connection issues ... Ack. From my experience, connection issues with Car Play are 100% due to the shitty software on the car's side and never on phone's side. I regularly have connection problems (i.e. black screen in Car Play when entering the car - a Fiat with UConnect 5). They can _always_ be resolved by rebooting the cars's entertainment system. _Never_ by rebooting the phone.
- danaris 3y ago> and likely want to find ways to monetize things that people can do with their own interface. There's no "likely" about it: they've publicly said that they intend to be making $25B/yr in subscription revenue from this.