5 ms·
> And I think Apple should be receiving at least as harsh antitrust scrutiny as Google. They both deserve antitrust attention, but Apple is the far worse offen
by echelon 3y ago
> And I think Apple should be receiving at least as harsh antitrust scrutiny as Google.
They both deserve antitrust attention, but Apple is the far worse offender.
The cellphone is more essential than the car, and here are these two companies basically owning and taxing the roads, fuel, destinations, activities, and in-car entertainment. And you can't upgrade or change anything.
- xattt 3y agoIt sounds like you're advocating to nationalize app stores, much like other public utilities should have or should continue to stay in public hands.
- scarface_74 3y agoYes because what could possibly go wrong with the government controlling content
- smoldesu 3y agoNothing worse than the status-quo, presumably: https://www.theverge.com/2021/4/1/22361762/iphone-russia-startup-local-apps-yandex-mail-ru-law https://www.theverge.com/2021/4/1/22361762/iphone-russia-sta... Given that US/FIVE-EYES surveillance is a prerequisite for all American smartphones, I'd at least appreciate them using their state power to benefit the customer for once. The US' negligence in prosecuting any of the transparently corrupt FAANG companies makes it obvious how they don't want to butcher any of their own cash cows. Trusting corporations to dissent this late in the game is a futile and sad way to watch your hope for humanity deteriorate.
- scarface_74 3y agoSo you really think the state controlling content is not going to be more restrictive than private corporations? And why are you quoting an article about Russia?
- smoldesu 3y agoNo, I think the state will do a better job at preserving individual freedom than the free market will. Normally I wouldn't take that stance, but the alternative is Apple's lock-in mentality and Google's neverending advertisement/data treadmill. Given that a secure smartphone is off the table anyways, I'd prefer the state as a custodian for digital rights. Plus, then nobody's confused about who holds all the power. > And why are you quoting an article about Russia? To emphasize the scope of influence on Apple software and the precedent for state control.
- scarface_74 3y agoWhat country are you living in? You mean the one with the highest incarceration rate in the world? Both sides are have been guilty of suppressing free speech that they don’t agree with.
- dang 3y agoCould you please stop posting in the flamewar style? You've unfortunately been doing a lot of that. It's not what this site is for, and destroys what it is for. If you wouldn't mind reviewing https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and taking the intended spirit of the site more to heart, we'd be grateful.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dataangel 3y ago> So you really think the state controlling content is not going to be more restrictive than private corporations? Yes, because then app restrictions that violate free speech/press will get slammed by the supreme court.
- scarface_74 3y ago
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoNationalization and competition are hardly the same thing. In one case you still have a monopoly, but operated by the state. This generally goes poorly. A state agency is only weakly accountable to voters and not really accountable to customers at all. This is only marginally better than a private monopoly, if at all. In the other case you break a private monopoly and move to a competitive market. The competitors are directly accountable to customers, who can choose someone else if anyone tries to charge high fees or the customers otherwise don't like you.
- scarface_74 3y ago[flagged]
- burnished 3y agoNo one mentioned side loading here and it seems clear that you pulled the weakest possible interpretation of their point to respond to. Please don't do that.
- scarface_74 3y agoSo exactly who is forcing you to choose a closed ecosystem when there are literally hundreds of Android phones you can choose from?
- appplication 3y agoSide loading, while mentioned, is both the most common and argument I’ve heard. I don’t think that’s bad faith they thought that was implied. What other interpretations would be common?
- omeid2 3y agoIt is more like complaining that Tesla wouldn't let you purchase electricity from a 3rd party that isn't sanctioned by Tesla.
- scarface_74 3y agoAnd if you chose to buy a Tesla knowing they in advance?
- omeid2 3y agoAs long as Tesla isn't approaching a dual-poly or worst a monopoly, that is on me. But if the choice is between two car manufacturers because your work parking, your banks' branch access, your governments' departments driveways, the city halls where a lot of events are organised, and just about anywhere you want to go is designed to allow only cars from these two car manufacturers, then knowing "in advance" is pointless; because there is no real choice.
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoThe problem with Apple is that while they don’t have a monopoly on cellphones, they seem to have a monopoly on good cellphone experiences. Your choice is a couple of platforms that are closed but works decently well, and other more open platforms that are much more chaotic and poorer user experiences. Linux phones or android phones not running Google’s stack being examples of the latter.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoThat's not really the problem. Suppose there were two cellphone platforms and they were both equally terrible, or equally good. But each one locked the customers out of their own property -- you have to use their app store, their cloud services, you can't install their operating system on anyone else's hardware or vice versa. Mandatory lock-in to all of their other services, competition impaired. This is not okay just because there are two of them instead of one, because it's what causes there to be two of them instead of dozens. You can't enter the market without replicating the entire vertically integrated conglomerate because someone who makes only hardware, or an operating system, or an app store, can't use it with the existing ones. It removes consumer choice, and each of the conglomerates could continue extending the stack in either direction until you have to buy your house and car and all of your groceries, appliances and media from the same company as you get your phone. This is not the same thing as vertical integration. The same company could make a CPU and an app store without having them bound together so that you can't choose one without the other. You could choose to get everything from the same company, but you shouldn't be required to just because that's what the company wants.
- jauntywundrkind 3y agoIt feels silly to me to assess based on number of companies playing. If the market were three or four companies all behaving exactly like Apple, there still is a clear & present need for government intervention, a clear "consumer harm" by creating technological intermediary overlords with total control over information technology. Apple defenders love pointing out that there is choice, that folks can go to Android. But what if Android were just as lawful-evil malevolent a force?