4 ms·
Tesla says California's Autopilot action violates its free speech rights
- ceejayoz 3y ago> Tesla also claims that the DMV has no right to prosecute it for false advertising of Autopilot's capabilities because it knew perfectly well how the company had been describing it, but didn't take action before. "You can't pull me over for speeding, I've been doing it for years!"
- batch12 3y agoOr- when we were together you didn't mind, but after we broke up, you sought revenge. The love to hate (and the inverse depending on politics) relationship for all things Elon has been fascinating to watch.
- flutas 3y agoMore like "you've investigated me twice already, and found no issues apparently. Plus, why jump straight to suing instead of telling us to stop?" > "Claimant has been aware that Tesla has been using the brand names Autopilot and Full Self-Driving Capability since Tesla started using those names in 2014 and 2016 respectively," Tesla said. > "Before Claimant filed the original Accusation in July 2022, Claimant had never told Tesla to stop using these brand names or otherwise indicated to Tesla that these brand names or its advertising were in any way problematic." > Tesla also argued that the DMV has investigated its ADAS advertising twice before, in 2014 and 2017, and decided at the time to take no action. We asked the DMV why it waited after its investigations to file a claim against Tesla, but haven't heard back.
- ceejayoz 3y agoGiven that the article starts with "It may have taken more than a year, but Tesla has finally responded to the California Department of Motor Vehicles allegations...", complaints of this nature seem a bit rich. "You knew I was doing fraud" isn't a very viable defense.
- tgv 3y agoImagine the judge rejecting the argument: "you knew about this a year ago."
- marcinzm 3y ago>Plus, why jump straight to suing instead of telling us to stop? "I know you shot five people but instead of arresting you we'll just ask you to not do it a sixth time, okay?"
- beaeglebeach 3y ago[dead]
- YesThatTom2 3y agoI came here to say the same thing.
- qarl 3y agoWhy is it always about freedom of speech?
- dartos 3y agoIt’s vague and very well protected
- jdbernard 3y agoIANAL, but in my opinion this isn't actually a freedom of speech issue, it's a corporate personhood issue. Tesla the company should not have constitutional freedom of speech protections for it's marketing communications.
- creshal 3y agoBecause Elon's twitter friends claim to care about it so much, I guess.
- ape4 3y agoSpeech isn't entirely unlimited. Saying something that makes people over-trust your "autopilot" and kill other road users seems like a reasonable limit.
- raisedbyninjas 3y agoWhen the charge is you should have truth in advertising, the rebuttal of freedom of speech sounds better than lies in advertising.
- baz00 3y agoWell it's not about freedom of speech. It's freedom to tell lies publicly and not be held accountable for it by confusing what class of entity is making the speech. This is just covered by freedom of speech legislation. Telsa is acting in bad faith towards customers, the government and investors here.
- soco 3y agoAlso we are talking about a company not a person. Shouldn't that be a difference in face of legislation?
- gizmo 3y agoIt's a ludicrous defense. Regulators don't want to be seen as anti-business or as hampering innovation. It's perfectly reasonable for regulators to adopt a "wait and see" approach to outlandish claims about safety and self-driving technology. However, when it it's clear that Autopilot does not (and will not) behave as advertised, then they have every right to take action. Regulators took a similar hands-off approach to AirBnB and Uber, despite those companies violating many established laws. Despite the angry Taxi companies and Hotel chains angrily demanding enforcement and a leveling of the playing field. But regulators did nothing. Why? Because, despite their faults, AirBnB and Uber serve a real customer need. Crypto? Same story. Regulators waited to see if the crypto industry could deliver the promised value to society. If crypto is useful then it can be made to fit within the regulatory framework. If crypto is just a facilitator of fraud and ponzi schemes then harsh regulatory action is justified. Crypto largely has not delivered on its promises, and now the wheels of justice have started grinding. Delayed enforcement makes innovation possible, especially innovation of the "move fast break things" kind.
- calvinmorrison 3y ago> Regulators waited to see if the crypto industry could deliver the promised value to society. If crypto is useful then it can be made to fit within the regulatory framework. If crypto is just a facilitator of fraud and ponzi schemes then harsh regulatory action is justified. Crypto largely has not delivered on its promises, and now the wheels of justice have started grinding. the moment it was regulated like a security, it prevented anyone from using bitcoin/shitcoin as an actual currency.
- tejohnso 3y agoIsn't this more of a false advertising with risk of personal injury issue? Why should they be able to call it Full Self Driving if it doesn't drive itself, fully. Even if they do have fine print that says "The currently enabled features require active driver supervision and do not make the vehicle autonomous." Seems egregious to name something with a precise feature description and then completely contradict that description in fine print.
- ceejayoz 3y agoFalse advertising is indeed what California is going after them for.
- kjksf 3y agoNot in the legal sense. Per ChatGPT the government agency that can sue you for false advertising is FTC, not DMV. One of the DMV claims is that Tesla misrepresents FSD capability but they didn't sue Tesla for false advertising. Furthermore, it's not really a lawsuit. Per https://www.theregister.com/2022/08/08/tesla_california_autopilot/ https://www.theregister.com/2022/08/08/tesla_california_auto... DMV "filed with the Golden State' Office of Administrative Hearings (OAH) and allege that the company violated its manufacturer and dealer Occupational Licenses." They want Tesla to respond that notice and "If Tesla chooses to respond, there will be discovery and response filings, leading to a hearing before an OAH administrative law judge. And if Tesla dislikes the result, it has the option to file an appeal in Superior Court." Tesla wants (among other things) a jury trial, not a decision by OAH administrative law judge.
- ceejayoz 3y ago> Per ChatGPT the government agency that can sue you for false advertising is FTC, not DMV. I would strongly recommend you not go to ChatGPT for legal advice in the future. (Ask it about this; "No, you should not use ChatGPT or any other AI language model as a source for legal advice. While ChatGPT can generate responses based on patterns it learned from diverse data, it does not have the ability to provide accurate, up-to-date legal information. Legal matters are complex and often require a deep understanding of specific jurisdictional laws, recent legal developments, and the unique details of each case. Relying on AI for legal advice can lead to misunderstandings, misinterpretations, and potential legal consequences.") The complaint is readily available for you to review: https://regmedia.co.uk/2022/08/08/tesla_dealer_complaint.pdf https://regmedia.co.uk/2022/08/08/tesla_dealer_complaint.pdf > Respondent made untrue or misleading statements in advertisements in violation of Vehicle Code § 11713(a). https://codes.findlaw.com/ca/vehicle-code/veh-sect-11713/ https://codes.findlaw.com/ca/vehicle-code/veh-sect-11713/ > A holder of a license issued under this article shall not do any of the following: (a) Make or disseminate, or cause to be made or disseminated, before the public in this state, in a newspaper or other publication, or an advertising device, or by public outcry or proclamation, or in any other manner or means whatever, a statement that is untrue or misleading and that is known, or that by the exercise of reasonable care should be known, to be untrue or misleading; or to so make or disseminate, or cause to be so disseminated, a statement as part of a plan or scheme with the intent not to sell a vehicle or service so advertised at the price stated therein, or as so advertised. The basic legal concept that permits both the Feds and individual states to separately create and enforce rules on advertising is https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federalism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federalism.
- clouddrover 3y agoA million robotaxis on the road by 2020: https://www.thedrive.com/news/38129/elon-musk-promised-1-million-tesla-robotaxis-by-the-end-of-2020-where-are-they https://www.thedrive.com/news/38129/elon-musk-promised-1-mil... Woo! Hardcore!
- freetanga 3y agoThey are all parked at SolarCity.
- masklinn 3y agoOctober 2016: > We’ll be able to do a demonstration guide of full autonomy all the way from LA to New York. So basically from home in LA to Times Square in New York. And then have the car go and park itself by the end of the year. September 2015: > we are probably only a month away from having autonomous driving at least for highways and for relatively simple roads, my guess for when we will have full autonomy is approximately three years October 2014: > A tesla car next year will probably be 90% capable of auto-pilot, like so 90% of your miles could be on auto, for sure highway travel.
- londons_explore 3y agoThis seems like a waste of everyone's time. Tesla should market the vehicles as 'advanced driver assist', and authorities should let them do pretty much whatever they like as long as Tesla cars are killing fewer people per mile than competitors.
- marcinzm 3y ago>Tesla cars are killing fewer people per mile than competitors NHTSA data doesn't indicate so from what I read. Assuming by competitor you mean a recent car equipped with a competitors driver assist technology.
- mensetmanusman 3y agoCompetitor also means the average vehicle as driven by people who are on their phones. The roads have become more dangerous as we see in the data.
- mrpopo 3y agoContext matters in roadkill statistics. If a human driver risks causing more accidents on the highway when distracted and tired, a driving assistant risks causing more accidents in the city streets where there are more opportunities for failure. Also, roadkill becomes a legal case. You need someone to be legally responsible. Driving assistants blur these lines. It's not just a "killing fewer people per mile" problem (which would also have a huge causation/correlation issue).
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- TradingPlaces 3y agoFalse advertising is not protected speech. 15 U.S.C. §§ 52-55 https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/topics/truth-advertising https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/topics/truth-advertising https://uscode.house.gov/view.xhtml?req=granuleid%3AUSC-prelim-title15-chapter2-subchapter1&edition=prelim https://uscode.house.gov/view.xhtml?req=granuleid%3AUSC-prel...