8 ms·
Isn't this pretty much an open secret? Doesn't everyone spy on everyone else, even when they're nominally allies? It's telling that Spain merely expelled thes
by kelnos 3y ago
Isn't this pretty much an open secret? Doesn't everyone spy on everyone else, even when they're nominally allies?
It's telling that Spain merely expelled these people, rather than locking them up and/or torturing them for information. I'm sure there's some sort of gentlemen's agreement that this is what you do when you catch an ally's spies.
- threeseed 3y agoYes everyone spies on each other. It's why embassies largely exist these days. The only reason you would expel someone is if it was overly egregious. Not sure what it is particularly special about this event.
- toyg 3y ago> The only reason you would expel someone is if it was overly egregious. Or if the two parties are in a tit-for-tat situation of some sort. There might be some diplomatic sabre-rattling going on, on some other topic. Also, more often than not you don't expel anyone because 1) it reveals the reach of your intel skills, and 2) it removes the capability to feed misinformation to the other party.
- notaspy_ 3y ago[flagged]
- germandiago 3y agoThere must be IMHO. For these things what you usually have is an arrest as a minimum yet they let them go. On top of that it was made public. Spain is turning at this moment, btw, in a dictatorship and I am not exaggerating. I am spanish. I am figuring out what to do and whether to leave or not. I have my family here so that's what keeps me here. Otherwise I would have left already.
- toyg 3y ago> Spain is turning at this moment, btw, in a dictatorship Seems a bit of a hyperbole for "Spain is under a fragile minority government". By that metric, the UK is a dictatorship in most years.
- HPsquared 3y agoFunnily enough, that word has been used to describe the UK system in particular. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elective_dictatorship https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elective_dictatorship
- germandiago 3y agoNo, this is not what I am talking about. I am talking about putting all people from a single party in absolutely all powers and institutions, making a law for 7 votes to govern and claim an illegal amnistey and after that, the plan is to pass it through, to say the Constitution is dead (which requires, in theory 2/3 or 3/5 of the chamber support to be changed) and do it on an illegal backdoor. Of course, those changes are going to be what less than half of the people want and in the electoral program none of that was announced. There is a person negotiating how to put himself out of jail because our president needed 7 votes. I mean, it is as if I was negotiating to not enter the jail because I commit a crime. Institutions where he already put his people: - Fiscal General del Estado (Dolores Delgado, was a minister of socialist party) Responsible for pushing forward or not criminal causes against depending who. - Correos (important for the mail vote) a very good friend of his. - Supreme court (Conde-Pumpido), a socialist. - Indra, company counting the votes, there were moves to put a majority of the board from the socialist party. - Agencia EFE (a few days ago): for news, public agency. A socialist friend of his, well-known for flattering the party since ever and working in the pro-socialist media groups El Pais and Cadena Ser (Grupo Prisa) and Cuatro when it was Grupo Prisa (not anymore, now it is Media Set) - CIS, the national organism for surveys... who publishes the surveys for many topics, they manipulate the sentences to torture them to say what they want (in the question there is the trick) and publish national surveys for elections vote intention. - TVE (spanish television): they had for over a year a "unique administrator" which is a total abnormality, Rosa María Mateos, during the pandemic. - During the pandemic: a person filtering, in our faces, what topics and questions were asked in the "press conferences" if you can call it like that. For me it smelled more to discretional selection and censorship. They usually took questions from tiny regional media with priority to the national ones that everyone reads... Yes, a filter: I tell you who and what can be asked. - During the pandemic: 6 months the parlament closed. 2 illegal lockdowns, no consequences. - Now they are trying to put a socialist majority in the CGPJ (Consejo General del Poder Judicial) so that the illegal amnesty gets through. - Law for "freedom of speech" for influencers, so that they can be prosecuted more easily depending on what they say... promoted by the unions that support them (UGT, Comisiones obreras). - There is a bunch of "institutional advertisement" by which newspapers get a bunch of money per year directly from the government. Do you think they are independent after this? Do not make me laugh... 554 millions... https://www.vozpopuli.com/espana/maquinaria-sanchez-dispara-554-millones-gasto-publicidad-institucional-doble-rajoy.html https://www.vozpopuli.com/espana/maquinaria-sanchez-dispara-... And there is plenty, plenty more. There was even a scandal where Delcy Rodriguez, with forbidden entry to Europe for narcotrafic, from Venezuela, came with 40 suitcases that god knows what they contained, entered without a passport stamp (obviously) and those suitcases we do not have even an explanation yet... what happened? Nothing. They lied about it. Nothing happened, to noone: https://www.vozpopuli.com/espana/politica/embajada-venezuela-barajas-delcy-rodriguez_0_1327668359.html https://www.vozpopuli.com/espana/politica/embajada-venezuela... Believe me, they are building a dictatorship. It is not about minorities governing, it is about controlling absolutely all information flow, all opinion, and workarounding any "balance and check".
- jfernandezr 3y agoSpanish here. You're overtly exaggerating, Spain is not becoming a dictatorship. This is the right and far-right having a tantrum because they've not been able to secure a government. Go spread your propaganda elsewhere.
- gafage 3y agoThat's a bit of an over-simplification of what actually happened these weeks. Or a tremendous over-simplification, rather. Not that I really care about the outcome (two parties could've won, and they are both progressive, so I will be unhappy either way), but the methods have crossed a few red lines.
- alfonsodev 3y agomight be an over-simplification but is right. Every year there are "indultos" (pardons?) happening, the famous Aznar's ones[1], and Rajoy's infamous "aministia fiscal"[2] but I guess is only now when it's convenient to push that narrative, no protests whatsoever for the other cases. Amnistia for tax evaders, it is democracy. Amnistia for those protesting making a performance-like referedum (everyone knew it would not actual effect), that's not democracy. It's a logic that I can not comprehend, I only can explain it if you consume so much mass media that you actually believe everything that is thrown at you. [1] https://www.eldiario.es/catalunya/gobierno-aznar-indulto-dia-personas-1-432-independentismo-quiere-amnistiar_1_10516718.html https://www.eldiario.es/catalunya/gobierno-aznar-indulto-dia.... [2] https://www.eldiario.es/economia/rato-franco-narco-100-beneficiarios-amnistia-fiscal-rajoy-han-salido-luz_1_10709088.html https://www.eldiario.es/economia/rato-franco-narco-100-benef...
- gafage 3y agoIt's not the same when you do it because you need it to be the president. I don't agree with pardons; it's something that simply shouldn't exist in this day and age. It doesn't matter to me what brand of progressivism does it.
- germandiago 3y ago
- pas 3y ago> [into] a dictatorship how? forming a coalition seems to be the opposite of dictatorship, no?
- germandiago 3y agoNot sure if you are spanish. I know how my representation system works very well but it is not even about that. It is about workarounding and putting all friends in the whole apparatus. See one of my comments above to see how many people from the socialist party have been put by government decision to manage highest position related to propaganda, justice system, etc. when socialist party had hardly representation compared to any other government and the story repeats again. The amount of abuse they did is really, really bad IMHO. The problem is the system also, yes. But it is more than that only. They think institutions are their private property or something like no other national party so far IMHO.
- pas 3y agoHungarian. We have seen it from VIP seats how the populist ideological blob ate everything, and how uncompromising uncooperativeness from weak opposition prevented them from even achieving an effective minority status. (So the blob has absolute majority in the legislature again, yeey.)
- alfonsodev 3y agoIs it sarcasm? you should tag it. if it's not, and you are talking about recent "amnistia" events, it's hilarious, because some people in Catalunya were prosecuted for crating a referendum, I guess for you that's not democratic and on the other hand exonerating those with charges related to it, turns the country into a dictatorship. What an irony. Btw, I'm not Catalan nor want Catalunya to part ways, far right wing narratives like the one you present only create more and more "independentistas".
- pvaldes 3y ago> some people in Catalunya were prosecuted for crating a referendum, I guess for you that's not democratic The "referendum" was obviously not democratic. You seem to have doubts still about that, so let me kindly illustrate you, about how real democracies work. There is not a single democracy, not a single one, where common people can replace unilaterally the powers of the state. Democracy does not mean that my friends and me can "vote" if we take your house and properties and chase you off, or don't do it (This is exactly what they were trying with the majority of the population in Catalonia). I can't create my own taxes, or decide that I am too beautiful to pay the taxes that I dislike. I can't replace the police and start driving like a mad in the highway while shooting people. I can't build my own army, or trial somebody unilaterally acting as prosecutor and judge. And of course I can't start an election, specially one that requires people to vote in a f*g cardboard urn, placed in the headquarters or a f*g political party. The power to start elections lies in the elected president. Period. The state has the monopoly of a lot of things. If you start elections by yourself is, first, a farce, and second, not democratic.
- david-gpu 3y ago> And of course I can't start an election, specially one that requires people to vote in a f*g cardboard urn, placed in the headquarters or a f*g political party You weaken your argument tremendously by using slurs like these.
- pvaldes 3y agoThe "democracy must allow scam referendums" fallacy has been discussed "ad nauseam" before. Here and on many other places. The term has been heavily weaponized by separatists and some of us are really upset to hear that BS again. Is like groundhog day. In any case is time to shut my mouth with apologies by the rambling. Lets better return to the real theme here.
- Garvi 3y agoIt would seem Spain lacks the political spine to even be outraged. Very telling indeed, but of much deeper problems here in the EU. I'm positive every single individual in this thread that is justifying these actions, would have the opposite opinion if the roles were reversed. It's a shamefully ignorant position to have.
- ben_w 3y agoIf you let rage drive you, your enemies will notice and use it to manipulate you.
- Garvi 3y agoAre you suggesting submissiveness to be an expression of strength and independence?
- ben_w 3y agoNo. I'm saying the one time I got in a fight at school, the target of my rage wasn't the person whose actions made me snap. I'm saying Saddam Hussein didn't cause the 9/11 attacks and didn't have WMDs. I'm saying you're choosing to make yourself vulnerable to false flag attacks. (I wasn't saying that expelling diplomats is an appropriate response, but that's also true).
- kelipso 3y agoEuropean countries are basically just US vassals. The spies are there to make sure they keep following the US lead. What will happen if they complain? They'll get ignored and it will just make it more obvious how powerless they are to do anything about it.
- ben_w 3y agoAnd that's why the nations of Europe are mostly interested in the EU and what it does/aims for. Much harder to push around.
- michalu 3y agoIt's mostly US spying on everyone else, especially their "allies" ...
- Zealotux 3y agoTo be fair, the French are spying on the US just as much (disclaimer: I'm French).
- TacticalCoder 3y agoGP is right and I'm not sure how'd that work for France... The US had more than 50% the GDP per capita France has and the US has 5x the population. That's kinda the whole point: the US is still the world's 1st power (a place France lost after losing the Waterloo battle, basically) and nobody has as much spying power as the US do (China probably come close). A country with 1/10th the GDP of another country cannot be spying "just as much". P.S: and let's not forget that France is exactly nowhere when it comes to tech, with the biggest players like Dassault and Thales being irrelevant tiny players compared to the american behemots. In the top 100 companies by market cap in the world the four french ones are... Hermes, Dior, LVMH, etc. I don't think these exactly help spying. P.P.S: I can see I'm downvoted by french "cocorico" readers ; )
- hnthrowaway0315 3y agoAnd US has military bases in EU which is super convenient for listening stations and spy centers. Back in the Cold War the US held even a heavier hand in EU.
- plopilop 3y agoI mean you seem to be simply reducing spying to the GPD, when it varies very much with the policies of a country. Israel is 27th by GDP but is a world leader in espionage, and especially in surveillance tools. Similarly France is good enough at spying that it got offered to join the 5 eyes (it did not work out because France asked the mutual non-spying clause to be applied, which the US refused). So while it is probable that the US has a bigger spying industry, it's also hasty to dismiss another player by saying "lol 10% of GDP" > Hermes, Dior, LVMH, etc. I don't think these exactly help spying Well France carried spying activities in Syria through Lafarge. Sometimes all you need is a foothold into the good places (Syria, or, for L'Oréal, rich circles)
- vbezhenar 3y agoWhen was the last time US expelled Spain spy? I couldn't find any obvious news about it.
- appleskeptic 3y agoThey would if they could. Spain is a weak little country that depends on the US for defense. The US is the most powerful country in history. There is no symmetry.
- AlecSchueler 3y agoSo if Spain can't do it to the US that would negate the claim that "everyone does it to everyone else," no?
- croes 3y agoIf the US are so powerful why were their spies expelled? Seems like Spain doesn't feat any consequences.
- impossiblefork 3y agoNo, and it isn't normal at all. Notice that this has literally led to the expulsion of diplomats, or, I suppose, spies sent out under diplomatic cover. That's extremely unusual between allies. Spying on allies, trying to bribe or blackmail their personnel etc., is not normal. It makes you a security threat, and making oneself a security threat isn't really compatible with being allies. Presumably this is why there is now this very public declaring of diplomats persona non grata-- both to remove the people in question and to signal that what has been done isn't okay. Seen another way-- normally, the person who becomes persona non grata is a Russian.
- appleskeptic 3y agoWrong, allies spy on each other constantly.
- impossiblefork 3y agoWhen did the US last expel a French, or Spanish or German diplomat? I'm pretty sure it's never happened during the NATO era. So either these countries don't use diplomatic cover or they don't spy on the US.
- roenxi 3y agoWhy would the US bother? Unless they propose not to engage in diplomacy, the replacement diplomat is going to spy on them too. It isn't like these are rogue actors, the spying is sponsored by their state. The only reason to even talk about it would be if they want to roll a particular diplomat who is hard to work with or if it was convenient to gin up a diplomatic incident so that they could pretend to be unhappy.
- impossiblefork 3y agoThe US does expel diplomats who engage in spying. For example, in 2022 they expelled twelve for spying in ways that threaten US national security. Even if you try to keep an eye they will of course try make keeping an eye on them difficult. The US feels it can spy-- with people having been found with wigs and whatnot, so to imagine that others can't, even if they are allowed to do things very freely is a little bit strange.
- lupusreal 3y agoSending the spies back instead of keeping and torturing them generally makes the most sense because you can get more in return for sending them back than torturing them. If you torture them what do you get? Sadistic satisfaction and maybe some useless information about their intentions and some of their colleagues, etc. You also get even worse relations with the US government which might escalate in a generally destructive way. Your own spies in the US might be tortured in retribution, or the US might release some dirt on the Spanish government to punish them, might tell the world that Spain tortures spies to harm the global perception of Spain, etc. But if you send them back unharmed, you instead get the cooperation of the US government in the investigation, a public apology from them which is good for public sentiment, and maybe various other concessions behind the scenes.
- molticrystal 3y agoWhat if Spain quietly disposes of them and tries to leave hints to anybody who comes later to investigate that Russia or a similar country responsible. Anybody who comes to replace or investigate after wards is very suspicious and should be monitored. For this round, you lose out on concessions, but if pulled off successfully you gain control over the situation, in addition you can get future concessions by an outing/capture whenever needed.
- bomewish 3y agoProbably the Americans would find out and it’s not an enemy you want. There would be retribution.
- fullspectrumdev 3y agoEspionage between civilised countries has fairly civilised almost customary rules since the end of WW2 tbh. Spies with diplomatic cover simply get expelled/PNG’d, illegals get detained, put on trial and kept for potential horse trading, and local agents (traitors) get dealt with as the country sees fit. Usually by imprisonment, these days. The status quo of these “rules of the game” being upheld has been the case for ages, it’s in nobodies interest to start breaking those “rules”.
- veidr 3y agoYes, that's correct. Everybody does it, but typically/historically allies, or even just non-enemies, prefer not to wildly escalate things.
- jerf 3y agoCompletely normal, as is catching them, expelling them, etc. What's news is that it's in the news. That's where the coded message is, not in the text itself.
- AndrewKemendo 3y agoYup. PNGs are common. The question is, why is this particular one being highlighted right now. It's really about what does Spain want the US to do?
- PNewling 3y agoSorry, what does PNGs mean?
- AndrewKemendo 3y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Persona_non_grata https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Persona_non_grata