9 ms·
Homes need to be built for better internet
- puchatek 3y agoCan someone explain the appeal of 1GB Internet?
- pixl97 3y agoYes. Not having to think about the speed of your internet.
- puchatek 3y agoBut when does that speed actually matter? Streaming 8k content can apparently be achieved with a 50mbps. So the article is concerned with applications that haven't been invented yet, did I get that right?
- phendrenad2 3y agoIt matters in brief periods of annoyance. If two kids are downloading the same 50GB GTA5 update, and two people are streaming netflix, and nobody gets upset, that's worth a few extra dollars to some people (not me)
- pixl97 3y agoMaybe you live alone or something, I have some days that will look like this at my place. 3 people remote working. 2 of them have streaming TV going at all times in their room. Then if the kids are home there are likely 2 other tvs going plus what they are doing with their phones.
- puchatek 3y agoOk, big families and several devices per person combined will result in bandwidth needs that seem over the top for any single application. Thanks!
- vlmutolo 3y agoThe real solution is to plan for having a low-power access point in every room. Maybe even hidden in the ceiling of every room. Everything gets faster and more reliable when you limit crosstalk. If anything, I’d want my future home to have WiFi-blocking walls and access points everywhere.
- HPsquared 3y agoWhat happens when you walk around the house?
- eppp 3y agoControllers that support roaming and handoff.
- yjftsjthsd-h 3y agoIn particular, 802.11r isn't that hard to support.
- lxgr 3y agoYou don't even need a controller for roaming/handoff (although it increases efficiency). Any standards-compliant 802.11 access point will support basic roaming, even across different vendors, since it can be entirely client/station-driven.
- s3p 3y agoHope you weren't downloading a file
- bdavbdav 3y agoIt’s more than fine. We have no cell signal (so WiFi calling), 5 UniFi APs. You can walk around the place and you wouldn’t even notice a transition.
- BenjiWiebe 3y agoIf downloading a file makes your WiFi calls bad, look into bufferbloat and CAKE.
- originate 3y agoWe could re-do the supply chain for residential construction or Buy existing tech that can arrive tomorrow, google: “Wi-Fi mesh”. Pick from a half dozen options.
- azinman2 3y agoWhich sucks. You’re constantly sharing bandwidth and operating noisey links between APs. Far better to just have multiple APs via Ethernet backhauls. Problem is people expect to put in a single WiFi-router-modem and be done. Radio doesn’t work that way.
- lxgr 3y agoHow exactly are you meshing through non-permeable walls? And if it does work (e.g. due to access points having better antennas and maybe positioning), it wastes spectrum like nothing else, which exacerbates that problem in high-density apartment buildings.
- hughesjj 3y agoAll I want is conduit for my Ethernet. When they're spraying up every cubic centimeter of the walls with insulation and fire proofing it gets super hard to maintain or run/re-run any cable
- 1letterunixname 3y agoGoogle's own mesh WiFi products (under Google and Nest brands) are shit. It took 8 months for the support morons to discover there were too many APs, with one taking all of the others down without any user-visible feedback. While I use Ubiquiti non-mesh now that only gets 600 Mbps max even with WiFi 6e NICs, hardwired works and provides dedicated, point-to-point bandwidth.
- pixl97 3y ago>It took 8 months for the support morons to discover there were too many APs Yea, the Unifi is nice because it will show you that. In theory if you're in a moderately noisy environment you can setup the hub to scan once a day and move channels around to maximize what you have. But in your case, you need to do the opposite (which if you rent you probably can't) and block as much wifi from outside as possible. Everyone getting wifi units and cranking them up to 100% radio transmit isn't great.
- thelastgallon 3y agoHomes need to be built better, period. (1) We need 240V outlets for EV charging (costs cents at construction time, costs $3000 - $8000 later) (2) We need electric panels and wiring future proofed and can also seamless upgrade to solar, battery, complete electrification of home with heat pump water heater and heat pump instead of a separate gas furnace (fridge and AC use heat pump already), induction stove. (3) Home electrification should allow power intake from car, eventually everyone is going to have electric cars. This will serve as emergency power, no need to buy a separate gas generator. (4) Indoor air needs a lot of work, in addition to heat pump for heating and cooling, we have to consider heat recovery, enthalpy recovery, humidity, UV and most importantly particulate matter. And mold prevention. Recent discussion on mold, lots of people reporting problems: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38543229 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38543229 (5) Homes can be built with solar shingles. Right now, we install a roof, then we install a structure to support panels and then panels. If we can just install solar shingles, it is just 1/3 of materials and far more importantly 1/3 of labor and a lot less than a third in time. We now have nailable solar shingles: https://www.gaf.energy/timberline-solar/ https://www.gaf.energy/timberline-solar/ (6) Electric utility (or the city) can lay electric and fiber at the same time. Either the city or electric provider can provide internet or give equal access to providers. We don't need any gas connections, homes can be completely electric. (7) Ongoing discussion on 48V POE for cars (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38557203 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38557203). Wny not 48V POE for most of home wiring? Most everything can be smart by default. I'm sure there are a lot more, but nobody is asking for these. Builders can just build these if people start asking for these as standard. Its a tragedy that people buy 50+ year old homes for 500K - 1 million USD, moldy, rickety, poorly insulated crap homes with so many ongoing issues and will cost hundreds of thousands to retrofit and make it livable.
- sokoloff 3y ago> We need 240V outlets for EV charging (costs cents at construction time I suppose that 25,000+ cents is technically cents, but that’s pretty far outside the ordinary use of the phrase.
- hk1337 3y ago> (3) Home electrification should allow power intake from car, eventually everyone is going to have electric cars. This will serve as emergency power, no need to buy a separate gas generator. That sounds good in theory and I know it's only for emergencies but I don't think that's going to last that long or be that beneficial. At least not right now. > (6) Electric utility (or the city) can lay electric and fiber at the same time. Either the city or electric provider can provide internet or give equal access to providers. We don't need any gas connections, homes can be completely electric. Do they even get buried at the same depths? My understanding was electrical lines get buried deeper than communications lines.
- georgelyon 3y agoGiven recent research into using WiFi to “see” through walls or at the very least track what humans are doing in a space, I would argue we should go in the opposite direction. I’m pretty happy with my current house and adversarial-to-WiFi cement walls. Sure, I had to run some cable and buy enough access points for about 3x the amount of square feet of my house (if you go by the advertised specs) but this is a one-time investment that is pretty small in the grand scheme of home-related things.
- sokoloff 3y agoThe wire might be one-time per 30 years. (The Cat-5 spec is only ~28 years old.) The APs are going to get replaced more than once a decade I think. We’ve been in our place 16 years and I’m on the third generation of APs, one Netgear that I moved here with, a set of UAC-AC-Pros, and a set of UAC-U6-LRs.
- georgelyon 3y agoSure, “very infrequently recurring” may be a more accurate label than “one time”
- engineer_22 3y agoAFAIK the wifi "see through walls" exploit requires an array of wifi routers. Even in lab conditions the imaging capabilities seem... aspirational. An adversary would be well served to stick to other forms of surveillance
- JohnClark1337 3y ago[dead]
- SoftTalker 3y agoAny technology installed in a home will be obsolete in under a decade. It's silly to deeply embed this stuff into the framework of the house. Remember all the people who spent big money running CAT5 to all the rooms? Then we got in-home WiFi and all of that cabling was just forgotten.
- teeray 3y ago> Then we got in-home WiFi and all of that cabling was just forgotten. Those folks just plugged APs into all that “forgotten” cabling and ended up with the best backhaul for their WiFi possible.
- hk1337 3y agoI don't think it should be run to every room but ethernet cables to the main places where you want solid internet connectivity would be good. Like an ethernet line to your TV for good connectivity on streaming devices and if you're going to use a room as an office. Everything else can be wifi. Maybe a few others just in case.
- Libcat99 3y agoI'm off the opinion that anything that can be wired should be. If a device is stationary and used often, wire it. It's not just about a better quality link that device, it also means less contention for your other devices that must be on wifi.
- icehawk 3y agoOne on every wall is my preference. My TV, computer desk, etc, won't be in the same place forever.`
- pixl97 3y agoEh, for most houses this is overkill. For one, they tend not to have a wring room to bring 20+ cables back to and put in to a patch panel. The other is that a great number of houses have a pretty singular optimal layout for a room. In your design my house would have around 40 drops, rather than 7. 40 makes no sense.
- ec109685 3y agoThis is why the Xfinity “10g” commercials are so disingenuous. They make it sound like the limit in homes for high quality simultaneous streaming and gaming is the cable internet connection instead of the home wifi network.
- yjftsjthsd-h 3y agoWell, it depends; if your downlink is 10Gb then yeah the local side might be a bottleneck, but some of us are out here on 10Mb internet connections and only benefit from upgrading the local network if it means better reliability.
- ec109685 3y agoTrue, but they don’t even offer 10gbs download
- RajT88 3y agoHis woes would likely much less if he could figure out how to fab a plastic plate to replace the metal one. (Or better: buy one which fits)
- latchkey 3y agoThey are like $10 on amazon. When I remodeled my place, I ran some power from another plug and I put my cablebox/wifi router into the wall (high up), behind a plastic door that lives behind the tv. Super easy and works fantastic.
- s3p 3y agoThe article makes no mention of which construction materials are supposedly 'better' for wifi signals.
- madamelic 3y agoYes, it is a frustrating article. Feels more like a Twitlonger than an actual news article. Mostly complaining and info-dumping vs offering up a solution or deeper information. If the author had dug deeper and reached out to experts, the article could have been great.
- jwells89 3y agoIn this realm, something I’m going to be doing some time soon is running ethernet through to the various rooms of my home, because it lacks this wiring despite being built in the 00s with a fiber connection being part of the original plan. While I don’t yet have a professional’s opinion, this is likely to be somewhat involved and expensive as it seems that walls will need to be cut open and in one place, floorboards pulled up. It could turn out that some of the existing wiring has conduits that could be used but I’m not betting on it.
- bcrosby95 3y agoOne dream I have is pulling out my baseboards, carving a channel into them, and putting ethernet cables in there.
- samtho 3y agoYou might not even need to carve it out: there is often a 3/8-3/4in gap where the drywall stops.
- gregmac 3y agoTips: get an "installer bit" -- this is a really long, flexible drill bit that lets you cut a hole for the mounting plate, and drill directly from there down into the floor below. In the ideal case, no drywall patching is needed at all. You mount a low-voltage retrofit box/ring in the hole you made and the keystone wall plate attaches to that.
- samtho 3y agoAlso, there is typically a small hole on the end of the installer bit, just below the tip, that lets you use it as “fish stick” and poke your pull line through after you drill the hole.
- drewmol 3y agoIf you not familiar check out powerline network adapters and access points. Not as good as cat6+ but better than WiFi as backhaul, I've been pleasantly surprised with the performance and throughput of the newer standards. You can get up to 2400 Mbps with the recent models.
- gregmac 3y agoThe majority of the complaint here is really that: * many new homes use metal "structured cabling" boxes (which block wifi signals) * the box is not in a central location (eg: usually in a corner of the basement near where cabling comes in) * Most people use their ISP-provided combination wifi/router * The wifi is then located inside the metal structured cabling box For most non-techie houses, if the access point is centrally located, it'll solve the vast majority of problems. However, to do this, practically, at least some of the following have to happen: * The router and wifi need to be separate units, with ethernet cables to the wifi location * The structured cabling box needs to be redesigned to be plastic or mount the router/wifi combo externally * All the in-house ethernet and outside connections need to be run to a location near the center of the house, such that there are minimal walls between it and each living space This isn't hard, it's just an incentives problem. Most houses don't sell for more money by doing this, so the builder has no incentive to fix it. ISPs have clearly decided that having a single modem/router/wifi combo is most cost-effective for them, and just let their customers deal with a less-than-optimal experience. In many cases people have little or no other ISP choice, so it's not like they lose the business.
- wlesieutre 3y ago> All the in-house ethernet and outside connections need to be run to a location near the center of the house, such that there are minimal walls between it and each living space If we're just talking wifi like 99% of people will do, this is literally one cable that needs to be planned. Shouldn't be hard, but like you said the people responsible for setting it up would need to care.
- samtho 3y ago> many new homes use metal "structured cabling" boxes (which block wifi signal) Which are not meant to house a wifi access point, these are fine for (wired) network routers and the modem, but if you have this setup, your wireless access point should really be on the ceiling.
- bluGill 3y agowe know that, the people who make those boxes know that. However the people installing network in most houses don't know that: they see a box in a useful location for having switches and think "I'll just put everything in there" even though that box is in a bad location for wifi and is metal.
- teeray 3y agoPart of the issue is that there isn’t really a professional class that is dedicated to home Internet like other home services. For Joe Homeowner, they call the plumber to put in a new sink, an electrician to hang a light fixture, the HVAC guy to put in A/C… and Comcast when the Internet is acting up? This would be equivalent to calling the city’s water department when your toilet is clogged with a Barbie doll. Electricians are the closest match, but usually telephone wiring is the closest experience they have to running Ethernet. They know nothing about properly setting up APs and the RF considerations. So when building houses, builders don’t bother, because getting that labor is specialized and homeowners are satisfied with the equivalent of a port-a-potty from Comcast in the living room because they don’t know any better.
- asperous 3y agoI looked it up and there is a whole industry of "low voltage" or cable networking installers. I think it's more a matter of cost and that people wouldn't think to do it if their internet mostly works.
- hervature 3y agoIn case people are curious, I had several lines of ethernet added throughout my home I wanted to add (cameras outside, ethernet port in garage, etc.) and I was charged $100 per line (they called them drops). This included going into my attic and doing as much as possible passing the ethernet inside the walls. When they went outside, they used conduit. I think most people would actually save money by dropping from 1Gbps to 200Mbps and using those savings to pay for a wired backhaul and good mesh network.
- hakfoo 3y agoPart of the problem is that even if you know this is what you want, it's a classic hiring problem. You're typically doing this once every what-- 20 years-- so you don't have a "default guy" and odds are you're one of maybe 3 households in your block of 450 houses who are even considering the problem, so it's not like you can ask your neighbours. What the market needs is a national franchise, maybe implemented as a co-op model-- enforcing some basic level of "predictably not great, but not terrible", and offering a one-stop pricing and quoting system. You know they won't be the cheapest or best, but the franchise structure sells confidence. If they try to take you for a ride, you can escalate to the brand, who has leverage over them, to get satisfaction before having to duke it out with the local Contractor Licensing Authority.
- turtlebits 3y agoIME, ethernet in every room is overkill. I had it in my previous house and only used it for in the office. What I'd be happy with is a few ceiling drops for APs in common areas.
- lxgr 3y agoWhy not give people the option? What's a guest bedroom today can become a home office tomorrow, and stability/bandwidth needs per room can vary accordingly.
- bastard_op 3y agoHome builders are probably the worst option to design a home network as they're only interested in mass-producing crap as quick as possible, and they have no idea the difference between cat5, cat7, or fiber. You're lucky if you get electrical outlets in the right places and orientation. My friend that is like me a network engineer just bought/building a new house, and was talking about getting a 8 port switch. I was like what, for a new, large-ish house? He was talking about just doing wireless, and I'm like ugh, but what about all your kids watching netflix on 8k+ tv's, all on wireless at the same time and complaining to you, you'll wish you had wired their tv's. Not to mention security cameras, doorbells, multiple AP's potentially, ethernet-based sensors for things, etc, all things that need Power over Ethernet too, or at least benefit from it. It got him thinking at least. Then he went back to the builder and the builder gave him 2 options, take what they give, which is an ethernet drop in each room in a random spot back to a closet of whatever cable they happen to have that day, or nothing. I'd have been pissed, and he was at that point. I told him better luck next time on his next house. It shouldn't take a network engineer to build a decent home network, but apparently it does and any home builder worth a damn should in the modern age should consider it.
- ponector 3y agoRegular homebuyers would not pay extra thousands dollar for proper network project. Unfortunately if you want a decent network - then do it yourself.
- bdavbdav 3y agoDIY is really hard to do (neatly) once built. Especially in the UK where even a lot of internal walls are brick.
- ponector 3y agoCould be messy, but possible. After all, our modern apartments are built with reinforced concrete first and then wires are laid into the walls, floor, ceiling.
- 3y ago
- madamelic 3y agoI wish ethernet only cost "a few hundred dollars". I am currently about $600 in the hole and I haven't even bought conduit, new drywall, or another switch. I am guessing it will be in the $1,000+ range when I am done. That's assuming I don't need to go get another 1,000 foot roll which I am guessing I might (doing 48 drops + PoE) --- While interesting, I don't think the article really was for me. It felt shallow and like an info dump rather than a real opinion piece. The solution to "I have bad internet" is ethernet yet the author seems against or as if it is stepping back into the past. We rely on wires to get it into the house generally, why are you advocating for getting rid of wires then being confused when your coverage sucks. The technology is there to have good wireless internet (wifi mesh driven by ethernet) but the author seems like they want to complain rather than looking at the problem rationally.
- mindslight 3y ago"Doc, the Wifi AP doesn't work very well when I put it in a metal box" ... "Have you tried not putting it in a metal box?" It feels like the author has a self-induced problem where she indeed knows better. But she's trying to emulate what she thinks a non-techie would do, and getting that quite wrong by limiting herself to fewer pieces rather than widely available off the shelf products meant to solve the problem properly. Obviously the metal box is meant for modem+router+switch, and then you hang wireless APs off of where the ethernet cables run to. When I was in an apartment that had a similar setup, I found it a bit limiting and still ran various ethernet lines under rugs and whatnot, but it was much better foundation than draping cables in hallways and stairways.
- rdl 3y agoThat was possibly the worst written tech article I’ve read in a while, despite generally agreeing with the premise of home Wi-Fi being important. I look forward to LLMs actually eliminating the bottom 75% of human writing.
- onetimeuse92304 3y agoNot sure what you mean. I am living in one of the worst place possible for Internet. I have over 400 2.4GHz APs accessible from my apartment. And it was built pre-Internet age with absolutely no forethought. And yet I have perfectly working Internet. Yes, when the network operator installed their AP it absolutely sucked. But I turned it into modem, put on my own pfSense box. Configured traffic shaping to reduce bufferbloat and ensure bandwidth is always reserved for things like zoom calls. Then I put on a decent (Ubiquiti) access point in every other room. I have reduced power of those access points so that they fall off naturally, this helps clients who move about the large apartment to roam. It does not make sense to have the AP radiate much further than the puny phone modem -- it just keeps the modem stuck to that AP while the AP struggles to receive signal from the phone. And so on. I have also upgraded almost all devices to 5GHz. 5GHz has much shorter range but it is actually a benefit -- it means less interference from devices of my neighbours. For security, I have separated VLANs and WLANs (separate for my work, for network management, for my family and their unsafe devices, for some legacy devices like printers and finally for guests). Everybody who visits me notices how well the WiFi works. I don't see how you need to build for "good Internet". "Good Internet" is just function of knowing what you are doing. It may cost a bit more to set up networking like mine. But this is drop in the ocean compared to trying to somehow improving your wifi coverage by chosing more expensive materials to build your house.
- ToucanLoucan 3y agoI mean, at the very least, running CAT-6 into every room of your aforementioned apartment and terminating them somewhere sensible with a fiber/cable endpoint wouldn't cost awfully much and would make everything you did here notably easier. Even if it's not used by a given tenant or owner, this stuff like any infrastructure is inherited by the next occupant. Since we got fiber internet, I've not touched a single coaxial line in my home, but when I sell it and move, that cable is still there, ready to be used by whomever buys it. Whether they will or not is obviously their decision to make, but at least this way the option is there. I see no reason why ethernet couldn't work similarly. Every house I've lived in has had a nest of coaxial cable lines in some corner of the basement or other utility area, and most have RJ-11 for phones too. I would also say that your last note: "a function of knowing what you're doing" does unintentionally I think really well at illustrating the problem. I do not have the slightest clue how plumbing works, but my home came designed from stock with working toilets and showers. I also have a fair bit of knowledge about electricity (enough to change outlets and switches anyway) but not enough to really build out circuits, and my home came designed from stock with appropriately placed (mostly) outlets ready to be used. My point being: people shouldn't have to know how their infrastructure works, and I would argue while a new entry and one that could use some standardization, Internet absolutely belongs in that category. Additionally, you're using some pretty top-of-the-line consumer electronics there with Ubuquiti APs. I looked into those some years back and to replace my Google Wifi's that I had at the time would've cost me about $1,500, which, I can afford and did consider, but ultimately never pulled the trigger on and I wouldn't be upset in the slightest if Joe Consumer looked at that price tag and had fit, since bottom-shelf wireless routers on the market do the exact same thing (distribute internet OTA) for like, $70. Now, I don't use bottom shelf personally, I have a mesh network too but mine doesn't allow me to tweak the power of the transmitters nor really do traffic shaping or service prioritization. This is, in my mind, akin to someone saying "there's nothing wrong with the highway, I have a Ferrari and I can get to work in 10 minutes if the cops aren't in the way." No kidding. You've bought one of the best answers to the question at hand, but not everyone can have that. And this is made worse by the fact that there are absolutely tons of shit quality routers built and sold every day that do a bad job of this task, and the only way to avoid that as a customer is knowing a decent amount about network administration so you know what to avoid. If a home fittings company made faucets that worked as badly as many routers out there do, they'd be sued into oblivion if not fined by the FTC for selling lemon products. I think we need more regulations on Internet-adjacent hardware so customers can have a baseline level of expectation that these things will function at the task they're built to accomplish to at least a certain level of reliability.
- fidotron 3y agoMy house was built in 1991 and consequently has a hilarious early 90s intercom wired throughout the house, with it being on the never ending TODO list to remove and replace with something reasonable. What is so curious is that even if you want to wire ethernet through the house (and I have to some extent) there aren't readily available decent things to shove on the wall that provide equivalent functionality which you can safely assume will not need replacing in five years. * The technology ecosystem just doesn't historically mesh well with the physical structure of homes at all. The whole success of Wifi is it allows us to be non committal about things. That we use it to connect TVs and doorbells to the network is really quite insane. I would like to see something in this space emerge and evolve, but it seems to be fundamentally incompatible with the VC backed tech industry at this point. * Guess what I'm trying to build.
- jaktet 3y ago* well everything points to an intercom like system so is what you’re trying to build not related to that l? (Since you said provide equivalent functionality) Maybe whole home audio with zones and voice communication?
- fidotron 3y agoThe wall units for doing that at least, only on digital infrastructure.
- bluGill 3y agoBefore someone says conduit in all the walls, that only works if the conduit comes out where you want something. Your intercom system probably terminates by each door at around waist level - which is unlikely to be where you want Ethernet cables to come out in the room - but perfect for an intercom. In the 90s people were starting to run phones to more rooms, but not to all rooms, at least those phone jacks would be in the right place. Likewise in the 90s people were running coax to more rooms - but a TV in every room was still seen as a sign of wealth and so most bedrooms wouldn't get it (the master would. though often that coax would be near the ceiling for watching in bed and thus not a great location for Ethernet.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- sowbug 3y agoIs there any value in preserving old phone lines these days? In my home I've kept vestigial coax runs because they're great for MoCA adapters, but I haven't been able to think of a reason to keep phone wires. So if I'm doing work on a room and they're in the way, I rip them out.
- petee 3y agoUnless you still have copper service, probably not. It was nice when phones would still work during a blackout, now its limited by local battery
- gizmo686 3y agoYou can run networking through phone lines similar to coax.
- teknopaul 3y agoCan't imagine. Occasionally run networks over power cables but I've never seen gadgets to do something useful with old phone cables. People used to have intercoms on them cables, but everyone has a phone in their pocket these days
- jmull 3y ago> brick, wood, drywall, plywood, concrete, metal, and acoustic ceiling tiles is usually cheaper than Wi-Fi-penetrating materials What are these alternative Wi-Fi-penetrating materials? And what trade offs do they have? (Cost is mentioned, but there many aspects other aspects to building materials besides cost and wi-fi penetration.) I’m thinking the author should start by not putting their wi-fi router behind a metal plate.
- engineer_22 3y agoGlass... But then the author remembered that those who live in glass houses...
- matthewaveryusa 3y agoWhat we really need are architects that add chases throughout the house so that you can add any matter of cable you want, be that electrical, plumbing, cable, fiber or cat. I have a chase in the middle of my house which used to be a chimney for a now decommissioned oil burner. I have all matter of cables going through there now, including, but not limited to two cat cables that provide ethernet to my attic and second floor. Not sure I would have been able to DIY it without that chase. If each house had a couple of these chases that would provide a ton of flexibility in terms of remodeling.
- Turing_Machine 3y agoYou might be able to do this for coax, fiber, Cat-N, or other low-voltage (or optical) communications lines, but code specifies minimum physical separation distances between gas, plumbing, sewer, and line voltage.
- noja 3y agoAn architect will optimise for liveable space. Whoever pays them can choose less liveable space in exchange for a chase. Most normal house purchasers won´t go for it.
- Retric 3y agoA chase doesn’t reduce living space, it may however compromise sound deadening between rooms.
- Vvector 3y agoDoes an 8" chase have that much effect on livable space? Would 2980 sqft vs 2979 sqft make any difference to most buyers?
- mlhpdx 3y agoNo, but it would add to build time and cost. And generally be one more thing to think about for the designer/builder and we know how that goes.
- 3y ago
- rmckayfleming 3y agoI just bought a house this year, the previous owners lived in it for about 2 years from brand new. Thankfully it has an ethernet drop to every room upstairs, and in reasonable places on the main floor. Far better than the situation at the last place I lived in. But annoyingly, it's all Cat5e! Sure, it's fine for gigabit, but now that I have proper networking equipment, I wish they'd have spent the extra few bucks and put in Cat6A or Cat7 so that I could get 10Gbps to my office from the rack in the basement...
- vardump 3y agoIf one wants anything more than 2.5g ethernet, one should just install single mode fiber, nothing else. Running 10g+ on copper is expensive and consumes too much electricity.
- chankstein38 3y agoDoes anyone else feel like 5G made this a lot worse? I used to get strong 4G LTE at my house but now that I have a phone capable of 5G and things around me have "upgraded" I can barely get a useable signal inside my house. Similarly, my local walmart is a deadzone now. Yay progress?
- kbar13 3y agothe overarching point behind the article hits but the specific example the author used is something i'm personally jealous of. ethernet going into every room? please i am stuck setting up runners along baseboards and drilling through concrete to run ethernet between floors...
- CapstanRoller 3y agoHasn't the USA collectively decided that houses are a luxury good? Forget "better internet" — many of us can barely afford any shelter, much less one that we can 'own'
- 1letterunixname 3y agoShelter is a luxury good. There are millions of homeless people on the street, ignored while the talking heads claim the economy is "better than ever".
- 1letterunixname 3y agoCat 8 wiring, patch panels, and racks. My shittastic apartment has Cat 5 wiring to 4 plugs while I can get 5 Gbps internet I can't use.
- kabanossen 3y agoWhat we really need is Ambient Connectivity. Check out Bob Frankston's (inventor of the spreadsheet) writings. https://rmf.vc/ambientconnectivity https://rmf.vc/ambientconnectivity
- boilerupnc 3y agoWhile the discussion has been on wiring and ethernet, I would argue making a digital twin scan for a new home construction before dry-wall goes up is one of the best small money investments I made for the ongoing upkeep of my home. No argument on all smart future proofing ideas for new construction (redundant wire drops, chase pull-wire pipes in 2-3 parts of the house, pre-wiring roof soffets for cameras, etc ...), but it has been priceless to be able to show service folks for big and small jobs ... an X-RAY of my home's studs, wiring and plumbing. I've been able to avert mistakes (protective plate for gas line sitting behind here), plan with the right assumptions (didn't realize there was a horizontal support board between those studs) and visualize possible remodel options (that exhaust duct could easily be re-routed to go out this wall instead). While digital twin scans are more and more common in commercial facility locations to document equipment for repair and insurance purposes - it's amazing to me that this still has not caught on with residential builders as a nice upsell option for trivial effort/cost. The digital twin should live with the deed and be handed over when the house changes owners. Every friend and service person I've shown it to - has commented - "wish I had that for my house".
- toomuchtodo 3y agoI would love to hear more about how you did this digital twin scan. Agree it should live with the deed along with a survey, makes life easier for everyone. Planting trees whose shade you may not sit in. (scholar of building sciences)
- zbrozek 3y agoPlease say more about what service you bought and what data product you got. I would be interested in doing the same.
- boilerupnc 3y agoReplying to all 3 comments ... I considered a couple of options. Option 1: I chose this path. I used this company [0] for convenience. They were easy to get a quick quote and found a person local to my area (I'm located in the mid-Atlantic) to do the scan. For < 4000 sqf homes - it takes about 3 - 3.5 hours to fully scan. Cost is dependent on size of area scanned and was in the 3 digit range. Post-pandemic, I suspect with a bit of hunting on gig websites, you can probably find local 3-d scanners who usually are hired by realtors for home-sale scans - but are equally willing to do other scan jobs as well. Many of them use Matterport equipment and from my small anecdote sample - scanning was a hobby which then got turbocharged into fun gig work by the realty virtual tour boom during the pandemic. They own the equipment ... and do scans for some side money. Option 2: Buy the scanner camera equipment and DIY.[1] At the end, I received a matterport model that was transferred to my free hosted account - limited to 1 model. While I have no need for more than 1, I did want to archive a backup of my model locally for safe-keeping. This project pointed me in the right direction [2] Closing thoughts. I love being able to travel back in time through a 3-d render of my home when it was still just the skeleton. There needs to be better ways to achieve archiving of the model - given its value in terms of cost to acquire and security. While I didn't appreciate it at the time, using the model for quick virtual measurements of areas within rooms has also been handy when looking at furniture and rugs. If I forgot to measure before going, I can pull it up on my laptop and get a quick ballpark measure within the house. I'm thinking of doing another scan after I'm fully settled in ... to easily capture and annotate my stuff for insurance purposes. [0] https://virtualspace.global/ https://virtualspace.global/ [1] https://matterport.com/ https://matterport.com/ [2] https://github.com/rebane2001/matterport-dl https://github.com/rebane2001/matterport-dl
- unethical_ban 3y ago>The Information Technology and Innovation Foundation (ITIF) noted in a recent blog post that if the US were to focus a significant chunk of its efforts on creating a better digital infrastructure instead of “fixing” our physical infrastructure, it would result in “superior longer-term economic growth, competitiveness, national security, and environmental benefits.” Presumptive industry lobby says to spend money on what they make money on. I don't like the phrasing that we need to make better wifi signals in a home "instead" of replacing lead pipes or repairing bridges. But yes, I wish homes were a bit more repairable, with chases as another commenter calls them. Currently in my apartment, I have an Ethernet cable running along 60ft of baseboard to wire my desktop to the router, with WiFi for the rest of the place. (This is the time of year where I think of my idea that fridges and freezers should be built to draw in outside air, for climates where ambient is cold enough for fridges without additional processing).
- BobbyTables2 3y ago[dead]
- BobbyTables2 3y ago[dead]
- bradley13 3y agoTo set the stage: European houses are different from US houses. Smaller, also a lot more concrete, brick and rebar. With that in mind, when we built our house a few years ago, I went for a combination of wired and wireless. Heavy users, like the television and the PCs in the office have dedicated cables. But running cables everywhere just didn't make sense - so most devices are expected to live on the WLAN. Since WLAN doesn't penetrate between floors, there is a central plug on each floor for an access point (or mesh satellite).
- busterarm 3y agoHousing developers are really bad at doing large scale low-voltage work. I used to work for an ISP here in the southeastern US and there were entire neighborhoods that had permanently shitty service because the housing developer decided to do the wiring on their own for the extra profits and did a terrible job of it. Then the individual communities never want to pay to have the work redone properly -- they think the ISP should eat the bill, even though we gave the developers the opportunity to do it right the first time. Doing hundreds of reworks of the last mile of service at once is expensive. Often we would come to some arrangement and heavily discount the wiring work down to like $30k from the community in exchange for exclusive contracts. The communities that wouldn't spend a dime were just permanently SOL.
- _8j50 3y agoCounterpoint: etherner on every wall is great and wifi should resistance is good because it can be used to track movements and even reconstruct conversations from a distance.
- thefz 3y ago> but I couldn’t (and still can’t) do anything about the cable Cthulhu monstrosity lurking behind a metal plate in my closet that drives most of my frustration. I wonder if this person has any idea of the amount of infrastructure the average house contains such as cable runs, pipes, chimneys and so on. Or they imagine things just "happen" magically when you flip a switch.
- simne 3y agoCould use slot antenna. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slot_antenna https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slot_antenna