5 ms·
Flatpack field hospitals that can be airdropped to disaster zones
- syndicatedjelly 3y agoThis is what innovation in healthcare and med tech looks like. Versatile, affordable inventions that serve those in desperate need. Western med tech could learn a thing or two here.
- gumballindie 3y agoWhy would we downgrade to a tent?
- zakary 3y agoBecause in many places, especially disaster zones, a tent is a massive upgrade from the bare patch of dirt they often currently have to make do with. This isn’t to replace an inner city hospital, this is the make it fast and cheap to deploy the basic necessities of medical care.
- carlosjobim 3y agoMy impression is that when a disaster strikes a Western country, they have the capacity to airlift the people in need of medical attention to real hospitals in areas that weren't struck, instead of putting up tents and barracks in the disaster zone.
- gumballindie 3y agoExactly, plus western countries are usually smaller and services arrive quickly at the scene.
- user_7832 3y agoMinor nit, but countries like the US or Canada are huge and rescues can take a lot of time. However you don't need a portable hospital more than a rescue helicopter for a few injured/lost hikers.
- pests 3y agoThere's nothing to downgrade. Youre starting with nothing. This kick-starts the process then you can upgrade to current levels if needed.
- darth_avocado 3y agoBecause it’s cheaper, not everyone has pentagon budgets to set up a modern hospital in a disaster zone. Plus even if you did have all the fancy equipment, it takes forever to set up relief centers. After Hurricane Maria in Puerto Rico or after fired in Maui, it took days to setup basic relief centers. Imagine if you have these cheap “tent” hospitals available at every small nearby town, you could setup relief in a matter of hours.
- gumballindie 3y agoCorrect - but op said the west could learn a thing or two, when in fact it's the other way around.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- syndicatedjelly 3y agoThe West could learn a thing or two about how to produce affordable medical technology. Did you read the original article?
- robert_foss 3y agoThat.. is a tent.
- reactordev 3y agoYes, it is. A mobile field hospital is usually built around the premise of a tent. Germany, USA, UK, Russia - all have tent-based forward deployable field hospitals. https://www.dvidshub.net/image/6787138/348th-field-hospital-setup https://www.dvidshub.net/image/6787138/348th-field-hospital-...
- jessriedel 3y agoOK but the American field hospitals often only need to stabilize people because the expectation is that anyone needing serious treatment will be airlifted to expensive military hospitals in Germany or the US. In contrast, the victims of humanitarian emergencies in poor/developing countries usually need to be fully treated on site because they aren't getting airlifted anywhere :(
- reactordev 3y agoThat is correct. The forward deployable field hospitals are really nurse stations to stabilize any active medical emergency for transport or otherwise stop the emergency (not necessarily treat it, they’ll do what they can).
- creshal 3y agoThis is a side effect of recent US conflicts being low-intensity COIN operations involving brigade sized or smaller assets that spend most of their time in garrison. In a conventional conflict mobilizing entire divisions, as the US is now preparing for again, you will see far more capable field hospitals again, because the US won't have the necessary capacity (either in terms of airlift volume nor existing hospital beds) to afford this luxury.
- Beached 3y agosignificant difference between the quality and stability of the two tents. the one in the article looks like a stick will tear it asunder.
- rdl 3y agoWhen I was in Iraq/Afghanistan 2004-2010, one of my favorite things was working with the military hospitals (I sold satcom to a variety of clients, including medical use for radiology, and then worked on radiology PACS stuff). The Army Combat Support Hospital (think MASH tv-show...) guys could set something up like this really fast, but it was expensive hardware, required their own personnel, etc. This makes sense for the US military (massive logistics, budget, etc.), but not for others. Also worked (volunteer/charity) with some local clinics who didn't have these kind of resources, but did have great personnel, who could use more locally-acquired or bespoke solutions -- problem was it was slow, not uniform standard, etc. A cost-reduced, standardized, easily transportable hybrid is great. Ideally you'd use existing standardized readily available stuff with minimal medical/flown in stuff on top.
- ikurei 3y agoI love that you went there with an invasion force (not judging) but also helped local medical infrastructure.
- rdl 3y agoI went to Iraq despite being against the invasion (although very pro CIA/JSOC activities in Afghanistan in 2001, but anti Big Army stuff in Afghanistan -- I met some of the "first in" guys a few years later and double down on that belief now) to 1) get as far away from a girl I'd broken up with in 2003 in the US and 2) to do a startup IX business with some Iraqi expats (who'd moved to London in the 70s-80s) and 3) be close to the biggest news event happening in the world and see what it was like up close. The helping-out-with-medical happened 5-6 years later and was entirely due to the company I was contracting for having some connections at the founder level with Christian and medical charities who were also helping out there -- I can't really take any credit for "volunteering" for that, it was much closer to "voluntold", but I'm glad I did it.
- omneity 3y agoIn terms of “airdroppability to disaster zones”, hardly anything beats cardboard beds[0]. It is true that the field hospital in TFA is a much comprehensive solution. I just wonder what an equivalent would be if designed with similar minimalistic principles to the cardboard bed. 0: https://www.fastcompany.com/90962654/this-simple-design-turns-cardboard-into-an-emergency-bed-in-seconds https://www.fastcompany.com/90962654/this-simple-design-turn...
- lupusreal 3y agoTbh those look like they might collapse if you don't sleep still on your back, without tossing and turning. It doesn't really seem like a great fit for disaster relief for people who are under severe stress. If I were assigned one of those beds I think I'd lay it flat on the floor just so I don't have to worry about falling in the middle of the night.
- etskinner 3y agoI don't really get the point of this bed, how is it better than sleeping on the ground? The only reasons I can think of are insulation (which just a couple sheets of cardboard would do well, a 50% savings on material), and keeping away from pests like mice and cockroaches. Granted, those are decent reasons, but I wonder if spending the money elsewhere for disaster relief would be better. Am I missing something?
- azmodeus 3y agoCould be good for hygiene for patients to not sleep on the floor though disinfecting a cardboard bed could be hard
- creshal 3y agoSingle-use / regularly replaced disposable beds might be more hygienic in practice than to hope the staff has enough time for thorough disinfection.
- SanjayMehta 3y ago
- lionkor 3y agoLooks and sounds like it could use TeleSAN[1] as well! [1]: https://telesan.de/?lang=en https://telesan.de/?lang=en disclaimer: i work at one of the companies that worked on this
- adhesive_wombat 3y agoI've always thought it strange that countries like the UK with the NHS haven't standardised a modular hospital design where you can slot prefab modules into some framework. Need a CT suite on floor C? Labs on floor F? Need a new floor on top? And then (assuming the British government isn't feeling charitable, which is a good bet) you can export them at a profit or licence the design to other countries. Instead, every single hospital seems to be a money-pit full-custom design and changing one after the fact is almost entirely impossible without huge effort, which is why my latest medical appointment was done in an old laboratory, complete with lab benches round the walls with a high-school-style desk and two chairs awkwardly plonked in the middle. Obviously it's not a simple thing to design such a thing (not least the plumbing!), but the immense resources that go into full custom hospitals, the pain it causes when they become not what is needed, and the expense of modifying them really makes me think.
- bluedino 3y agoThe hospital construction industry is huge and wouldn't want that. And, a lot like college dorms, hospitals have become luxury. Basic hospitals would be a hard sell.
- adhesive_wombat 3y ago> The hospital construction industry is huge and wouldn't want that. Sounds very much like a them problem (assuming a government since 1948 could show such intestinal fortitude). > hospitals have become luxury Only if you allow the private sector to completely capture the entire industry from top to bottom including government and regulatory function (in the same way the US automotive industry made light trucks basically illegal where they could). That process of top-to-bottom capture having not yet been fully completed in the UK, I don't think you'll find an NHS hospital, even a new one, especially luxurious. A BUPA one, probably yes (but they also don't have expensive money sinks like grubby un-insured and un-moneyed patients, A&E departments to run or junior staff to train). And there's no reason you can't have luxury modules as an upsell, or even third party compatible models. It's how aircraft are configured. You get an empty fuselage and you choose the modules. But the difference is you could fit the same modules to the medical versions of Airbuses and Boeings.
- epstein 3y ago[flagged]
- cultofmetatron 3y agoI agree but the IDF would probably destroy it before it could hit the ground
- epstein 3y agoyeah, but at least we try
- senthil_rajasek 3y agoI love these IKEA hospitals and the quote at the end of the article assembled it all together, "The hospital is a small contribution by India to humanitarian work around the world,” she said. “We are now ready to share it with any country that needs it.” It reflects a new way of thinking and a fresh world view. A vastly different view from the one I grew up in (80s)... Which was huge headlines in NYT about how poor countries need aid and western aid organizations are helping them. When in reality it was "relief theater". Good luck.
- netaustin 3y agoTotally. During the early months of the pandemic when NYC was hit super hard, Samaritan's Purse set up a tent hospital in Central Park directly opposite the main campus of Mt. Sinai which was a marvel to see, I would run and cycle past it nearly every day. Another of my common running routes took me past the USNS Comfort, docked at Pier 90, and the Javits Center, which hosted yet another modular hospital. Then a little later, a modular morgue on Randall's Island, which is now the site of a modular migrant encampment. I later read that because of strict policies relating to a notion that only the "simple" cases, of which there were few, could be transferred, the temporary hospital facilities ended up underutilized. But the ability to surge capacity in a specific area is hardly constrained to parts of the world with fewer hospital beds. Public health crises and natural disasters in the USA are perfect candidates for this technology. I hope we can test this quickly, and if it works, buy a bulk pack.
- mike_d 3y agoThat is maybe an 80s world view at best. The United States government is extremely proactive and effective in providing international aid whenever a disaster strikes. Lets take the 2010 Haiti earthquake as an example, which happened at about 4 PM. The US ambassador declared an emergency, the joint chiefs issued an order for support, SOUTHCOM initiated its crisis response operations center, and the newly formed Joint Task Force Haiti was setting up calls with local ministers before the Haitian president even formally requested assistance that evening. At first daylight 3 surveillance aircraft were overhead surveying damage and identifying rescue targets, a US coast guard cutter that was in the area arrived in port to begin infrastructure damage assessments, and SJFHQ established a command post in country. By sunset US special operations has teams on the ground to assist with security, FEMA has an Urban Search and Rescue team rescuing trapped victims, and Air National Guard combat air controllers have taken control of the airport and turned it into the busiest single runway airport in the world for arriving aid workers and supplies. By the second day hundreds of troops from the 82nd Airborne have arrived, the State Department diplomatic security service is in the process of evacuating thousands of American nationals, and multiple Global Hawk drones are providing real time video feeds to rescuers on the ground. The third day the USS Carl Vinson aircraft carrier arrives where its deck is turned into a 50 bed hospital, and it would remain on station until the USNS Comfort hospital ship and USS Bataan causality receiving ship arrived the following week. An IKEA hospital is an amazing thing, but it isn't worth shitting on the massive international aid operations most major countries conduct as "relief theater." India itself is among these, their light helicopters and skilled pilots were vital during the initial response to the Nepal earthquake.
- sbrorson 3y agoInflatable buildings used for disaster relief. They can be trucked or air-lifted into place, then quickly inflated. https://federalfabrics.com/ https://federalfabrics.com/
- cushychicken 3y agoProudly made in Lowell, Massachusetts. <3
- sbrorson 3y agoYes, they still make textiles in Lowell!
- InCityDreams 3y ago[flagged]
- Finnucane 3y ago"can be . . . assembled faster than an Ikea bookcase. . . . It takes five trained people one hour to assemble the cubes " Unsaid--five trained people need more than an hour to assemble an Ikea bookcase.
- kjkjadksj 3y agoMust have gotten the Ikea assemblers from McKinsey
- malwarebytess 3y agoI'm not seeing any innovation here as distinct from what is already done for inexpensive field hospitals, except that it's in a retail tent. > Sharma says the hospital is the first of its kind in India, but is reluctant to make any grander claim as she is not certain of similar developments in other countries. Oh.
- jeffrallen 3y agoMSF uses inflatable hospitals: https://msf.org.au/innovation-inflatable-hospital https://msf.org.au/innovation-inflatable-hospital More choices for more contexts is more good!
- MPlus88 3y ago[dead]
- AlphaWeaver 3y ago> A tablet computer included in the cube pack is programmed to minimise assembly errors, and an alarm sounds if the wrong equipment is put in any given cube. This is incredibly smart! Guessing Ultra Wideband beacons in some of the equipment, so you know what cube it's in!
- aaron695 3y ago[dead]
- westurner 3y agoThe red ResponsePod tents tare designed for temperature extremes, 100mph wind, and rain. They're not very disposable. Cardboard tents are more sustainable than single-use tents. Med tents, sheets, and scrubs could be made of antimicrobial hemp fabric. Pop-up Hub tents like ShiftPod, Gazelle, and the Coleman Instant are quick to set up and sturdier than replaceable and splintable tent poles. - [ ] ENH: Tent pole splint and/or spares Tunnel tents also have high ceilings. Round structures like [geodesic] domes fare better in wind than sharp corners due to wind shearing force. Geodesic dome hub kits work with local lumber or other. Heaxayurt: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hexayurt https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hexayurt : > A hexayurt is a simplified disaster relief shelter design.[2] It is based on a hexagonal geodesic geometry adapted to construction from standard 4x8 foot sheets of factory made construction material, built as a yurt. [3] It was invented by Vinay Gupta. [4] Hexayurts are common at Burning Man. [5] Is there a passive thermal roofline container modification for latrines and dispensaries? TODO link - [ ] Heat pumps for disaster relief shipping containers In searching for the shipping container by the ResponsePod folks, I just found an awning specifically for the area between multiple shipping containers in a corral configuration; prefabricated container shelter. I couldn't find the link. It's a standard sized shipping container emergency response disaster relief dispensary with HVAC but not yet heat pumps FWIU. - [ ] An open set of plans and modular interface specs for disaster relief shipping containers
- westurner 3y agoThere are IFAK Medical kits with Molle straps; that tent walls could also support in a decent tent - [ ] ENH: sustainably disposable Molle straps
- amluto 3y agoI wonder if one could fold up an operating room tent and put the entire thing in an autoclave. Or, maybe more efficiently, have a tent frame that stays up and an inner all-fabric room that goes in the autoclave.
- OhNoNotAgain_99 3y ago[dead]
- mike_hock 3y agoflatpak install hospital