9 ms·
Amsterdam Switches to 30 Km/h on 80% of its Roads
- getwiththeprog 3y agoWith cars getting bigger in many places, I would like to remind policy makers that Speed X Mass = Force. Slowing traffic in urban areas is just good sense if we care about pedestrians.
- josephcsible 3y ago> Speed X Mass = Force That's not true.
- Tomis02 3y agoThat's a bit pedantic, no? You use acceleration to get speed.
- vbezhenar 3y agoSounds terrible. I wouldn't want to live in that city.
- gumballindie 3y agoIt is terrible. They introduced similar speed limits in parts of London UK and it sucks. It does help with noise pollution but driving in London on empty roads at 20 mph is horrible.
- olyjohn 3y agoSeattle dropped residential speed limits to 20mph some time ago. Havent followed up to see what impact that has had yet... Most roads though still kepts their old speed limits. What happens in the US when speeds are too low, is you get half the people obeying it, and half of them driving way faster. It creates a dangerous conflict q lot of times. People road rage like crazy in some areas and will do dangerous shit like pass slower cars in unsafe places, tailgate, cut people off, etc.
- lamontcg 3y agoThey haven't put in any road diets in Seattle and the cops aren't enforcing traffic laws so everyone just drives the way they used to. So you've got 25 mph limits on 4-lane stroads with no pedestrian traffic (like literally no sidewalks in one case I can think of) and everyone does 45 mph. It looks like they're going to start using speed cameras now instead of police enforcement (they certainly don't want to use police enforcement here, that would clearly turn out badly). They're trialing "racing cameras" to supposedly catch the kids drag racing at night, but it is obviously a way to introduce enforcement of the 25 mph limits without doing road redesign and to generate revenue. The result is pretty obviously going to be regressive taxation, because Seattle/Washington State runs everything via regressive taxation. So the traffic cameras are not being setup on W Seattle Bridge to catch white collar people commuting to the office, but are put on W Marginal Way which are going to catch blue collar workers. I'm just waiting for liberal Seattle to wake up one morning and realize the DOT is funding their bike lanes by regressive taxation through traffic camera enforcement, falling on the lower class and minorities, and see if their heads explode or not. There's a way to do it right like Amsterdam where they've already built all the infrastructure and done all the road diets, we're doing it the ass-backwards way by dropping the speed limits and setting up traffic cameras.
- toomim 3y agoIt also happened in Portland in 2018, and it sucks, and makes me avoid Portland. The speed limit is 20mph on most roads, no matter how many lanes of empty tarmac there is, what time of day it is, with how much visibility, how straight the road is, etc. It's a blind political statement with no regard to the actual roads and their circumstances.
- jacquesm 3y ago> makes me avoid Portland It worked!
- toomim 3y agoYour goal is to remove people from the city who value efficiency and productivity? Or are you saying that you don't like me, personally, and want me to leave?
- jacquesm 3y agoAre those the only two choices?
- 28304283409234 3y agoAnd also: do those options cancel each other, or other options, out? Also also: if so, then yes. To hell with efficiency and productivity. If they can't share, I don't care.
- jltsiren 3y agoIt can be a political statement, or it can be about noise and pedestrian safety, depending on the environment. Basically, it's irresponsible to drive faster than 30 km/h anywhere with a significant number of pedestrians. The risk of serious injury and death rises quickly above that speed, and human drivers cannot react quickly enough at higher speeds. You can justify a bit higher speed limits on major streets with significant traffic, as pedestrians tend to be more attentive when crossing them. But even then, the limit should be 40-50 km/h, as road capacity decreases and noise level becomes unacceptably high at higher speeds.
- henry2023 3y agoIf you take your average North American city and switched the speed limit to 30km/h. Yeah sounds like hell. Amsterdam on the other side is really not your average city.
- helloooooooo 3y agoYou wouldn’t ever need or want to drive if you lived there.
- joeman1000 3y agoYou mustn’t do much walking in your life then.
- toomim 3y agoOr maybe he's like me, and both walks and drives, and doesn't want anybody to have to sit in a car wasting their life for longer than necessary. Efficiency matters.
- CompuIves 3y agoIf you want to be efficient in Amsterdam, you take the bike or public transport. That has been faster than cars even before this change, and now more so.
- photoGrant 3y agoI like it mainly because this probably is limiting electric bikes more than restricting cars. It's a lil' difficult for cars to hit 50 /too often/ and I say this anecdotally but those bikes in a very 'bike friendly' city are blurring lines and only getting faster.
- jeroenhd 3y agoElectric bicycles aren't allowed to exceed 25km/h anyway, so legally only human-powered bikes can exceed the 30km/h speed limit. If the owners messed with their bikes to override the speed limiter, I doubt they'll care about the 30km/h signs. Mopeds and similar vehicles (the ones with license plates and mandatory helmets) will probably be hit the worst.
- CapsAdmin 3y agoIn Norway the law is stated such that you can get help from the bicycle engine to reach max 25km/h. It's not very difficult to reach 30km/h to 50km/h manually on a bicycle.
- jacquesm 3y ago50 sustained is trained athlete level. Normal cyclists can't do that for any length of time.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mfalcao 3y ago50 is literally faster than Tour de France pros maintain on flat ground. A regular person on a normal bike will have a hard time even doing 30.
- CapsAdmin 3y agoThanks for pointing that out.. Maybe 35km/h is a more reasonable ceiling. The reason I mentioned this number is because I found this article of some Norwegian middle aged woman saying she is reaching 50km/h explaining something with the speed limit of bicycles in Norway. However she meant that she reaches that speed downhill, which makes sense.. https://elbil.no/lovlig-elsykkel-i-508-km-t/ https://elbil.no/lovlig-elsykkel-i-508-km-t/
- toomuchtodo 3y agoSafer roads for all stakeholders. Well done Amsterdam. Progress is possible.
- quickthrower2 3y agoAnd probably not much slower. Most of the time of the journey in roads that are limited to 50km would be waiting in traffic and junctions. I wonder if perversely this might speed the average journey up? If a road can really only support 20km/h average when traffic lights etc. are taken into account then why try to shoot traffic through it at 50?
- Tomis02 3y agoThat's amazing. Meanwhile, in some other first world countries (allegedly): "come on bro, just one more lane, and increase the speed limit, that'll definitely fix traffic and make everything better".
- mvdtnz 3y agoAh this old strawman.
- quickthrower2 3y agoIn Sydney it is one more tunnel! I am not against it as the infra could be used by an army of electric buses that could be a psuedo-metro. Please do that!
- andyferris 3y agoThey kinda did that in Brissie!
- rtpg 3y agoSeriously, at least in France the big success story in my book has been the use of heavy-duty buses to expand transit networks. You just gotta take over existing lanes, and you make your main bus lanes have buses every 5 minutes or so. It's not ideal but it exists and works. Highly recommend as an alternative to wishing for metro lines.
- jacquesm 3y agoThey did the same thing in Bogota, Colombia. Massive project but when I was there it seemed to have paid off very well.
- quickthrower2 3y agoIt is adaptive! You can change the routes based on demand or even time of day.
- virtue3 3y agoYeah it's a known thing now that widening highways / adding more throughput does not ease congestion etc. https://www.nytimes.com/2023/01/06/us/widen-highways-traffic.html#:~:text=But%20while%20adding%20lanes%20can,along%20with%20it%20%E2%80%94%20often%20returns https://www.nytimes.com/2023/01/06/us/widen-highways-traffic....
- ElijahLynn 3y agoThe "quieter" aspect is no joke. For the first time in my life, I moved into an apartment near a busy road, the noise is very difficult and I have to wear silicone ear plugs/pillows at night just to sleep because of car noise, especially people with loud motorcycles and trucks and cars that think everyone wants to hear them at 2am. Outside of that over-the-top "flex" noise, just the car noise is fatiguing. One can say "well, you shouldn't live there" but after I experienced it I realised how much housing is built right by main roads and many people don't always have the most privilege to make that choice. So I think this is a big win for noise pollution, which affects everyone. We just don't realize how much it matters until we hear the inverse, which is silence. Then it's like "oh wow, I didn't realise how loud it was, that feels so much better".
- quickthrower2 3y agoIf people didn’t live in such places then the housing crisis would be much worse. Infact where I live I think main roads/trains are a requirement to get the zoning to build the apartments! I wonder if sound proofing (the expensive high density kind) might help? Depends if you are renting or not. It might cost a few $10k but could be worth it for QOL.
- ElijahLynn 3y agoSound proofing can totally work, and I actually think all apartments in an apartment building or maybe just all dwelling structures should have an average, min and max noise level in decibels with the windows open. It is really nice, and sometimes important to be able to get outside air into the home. Noise proofing only works (and it does work with the right windows, doors, floors, ceilings) if the windows and doors are closed. Once you open one even a crack, the noise comes pouring in like high pressure water.
- betaby 3y agoThat the thing, apartments in US/Canada are in 'trashier' pockets of the city. Single family homes are well located mostly and don't have such problems. Reason is simply - apartments were put there they are well after city was fully developed. Speaking from my experience in Toronto/Montreal areas. Thus I disagree about traffic noise, it's a necessary evil. Real evil is vast zones of single family areas in the city limits, especially close to metro.
- zwieback 3y agoThat's 18.6 mph, slower than the speed limit around US schools. Is the expectation people will go 20 or 25 mph (32 to 40 km/h) in reality?
- ls612 3y agoNo, the expectation is that the government can put up speed cameras everywhere and make a shit ton of money.
- Nthringas 3y agoi'm pretty sure that's only a legit business model in the usa
- worg 3y agoNope that's a business model in Mexico too
- mynegation 3y agoOh let me tell you about a speed camera on Parkside drive in Toronto that makes city literal millions every year.
- askvictor 3y agoAustralia has entered the chat
- sva_ 3y agoThe 100k population German city I live in recently reported they made 2 million Euro in this year so far (using speed cameras alone.) That doesn't seem like nothing.
- jacquesm 3y ago2 million / year is 5500 euros / day or about 100 infractions. On a city of 100k I'd say they missed a couple ;)
- throw0101b 3y agoSee also perhaps "Effect of reducing the posted speed limit to 30 km per hour on pedestrian motor vehicle collisions in Toronto, Canada - a quasi experimental, pre-post study" * https://bmcpublichealth.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s12889-019-8139-5 https://bmcpublichealth.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s...
- kart23 3y agoare bikes limited to 30 km/h also?
- caturopath 3y agoe-bikes are limited to slower than that, and the prevailing style of acoustic bike in .nl is hard to get past 30km/h.
- askvictor 3y agoeBikes are limited to 25km/h on the motor I believe. But given how many people cycle in Amsterdam, I'd be surprised if you'd get much chance to actually get to that speed (on an eBike or legBike) very often. But even so, the problem is not speed but momentum. A typical car+driver weighs at least 10x (actually, with modern cars it's more like 20x) a bike+rider. So at the same speed, a car will impart 10x the damage/force than a bicycle will. But cyclists are more careful as they don't have a protective metal box around them - if a cyclist collides with a pedestrian, the cyclist is almost certainly going down and getting injured, compared to a car, where the car occupant has zero consequences.
- kart23 3y agowhat do you mean given how many people cycle, are you not allowed to ride on the street with cars? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DiJUV3Av-W8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DiJUV3Av-W8 This guy is doing around 40kmh on a ride through the city. granted he's an extreme outlier, but it's definitely possible.
- jacquesm 3y agoThat guy is nuts and shouldn't be cycling at all. Many, many examples of endangering other users of the road because of his ridiculous speed.
- dbg31415 3y agoThat’s crazy slow! I can’t even begin to think of how long it would take to get anywhere. By comparison, “The Texas Transportation Commission is allowed to bump up the speed limit in certain sections to 75, 80 and 85 mph, according to the Texas Department of Transportation. The speed limit can be raised if the highway is deemed safe and reasonable..” Also.. you can typically avoid a ticket by arguing you were still driving at “reasonable and prudent” speeds as long as you don’t exceed the posted limit by more than 24 miles per hour. Or just donate to your local police department..
- Hikikomori 3y agoYou generally don't go Texas sized distances in Amsterdam.
- codezero 3y agoTexas has vast empty areas, comparing it to Amsterdam is really apples to oranges.
- carlgreene 3y ago> I can’t even begin to think of how long it would take to get anywhere. Amsterdam is laid out quite differently from any place in Texas…
- caturopath 3y agoI'm pretty sympathetic to both Amsterdam's 30km/h thing (and the campaigns for 20mph speed limits for most streets in many cities in the US) and Texas' 75mph-standard, lots-of-80 and -85mph areas policy. These are completely different situations. One is for rural highway (for 85, controlled access highway with underpasses/overpasses), the other is for city streets where people live, walk, bike, etc. Neighborhood streets in Texas don't have 75mph speed limits.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- olyjohn 3y agoThe reasonable and prudent thing sounds like one of those myths to me. Like people saying they get out of a ticket on some technicality like a misspelling of the car brand. That doesnt happen unless you have a lawyer who is golf buddies with the judge.
- whalesalad 3y ago18 miles per hour? My average pace on a bicycle is 20 mph. This is hysterical.
- codezero 3y agoMaybe more people will start riding bikes.
- dietr1ch 3y agoIt'll be interesting to see the average speed change after this? Traffic jams don't care about speed limits. I'm guessing that the improvements in efficiency (fuel, noise, wear) and safety are probably going to be worth it. Also, I don't see cars being a fast way to get through the city with today's speed limits, I'd say my 6km commute in SF is faster on bike, especially after accounting for parking.
- jacquesm 3y agoIt is very hard to be faster than a bike in Amsterdam.
- ignormies 3y agoThat's kind of the point. Part of the design of Dutch cities is to make the fastest, most direct, most convenient form of transportation _not_ the car. You use a car when you _have_ to, not simply as a default. If it takes longer to get to your intra-city destination in a car, that's the city working as intended.
- josephcsible 3y ago> Part of the design of Dutch cities is to make the fastest, most direct, most convenient form of transportation _not_ the car. That's only a good thing if you accomplish it by making other forms of transportation faster and more direct. It's a bad thing if you do it by making cars slower and less direct.
- 3y ago
- remh 3y agoSo many comments in here using the context of US cities and missed that Amsterdam (like most big european cities) is not designed for high throughput car transportation and as a result painting that decision as making things "crazy slow" and that it "sounds terrible". I highly encourage you to go live a week in a big old european city (Paris, London, Berlin, Amsterdam, Madrid) without renting a car to understand why it's not a crazy decision and how it can make the life of the residents so much better.
- BlarfMcFlarf 3y agoAmsterdam notably was designed for cars in the 70s afaik, but they consciously redesigned it over time. So I’m a few decades, it could be your American city.
- 65a 3y agoI mean it was quite clearly designed for water traffic first. I wouldn't describe it as designed for cars in comparison to say Los Angeles or Kansas City.
- Tomis02 3y agoLos Angeles was also not designed for cars. It was demolished for cars, as the saying goes.
- jacquesm 3y agoThe water traffic was the equivalent of today's trucks.
- 65a 3y agoProbably more efficient in some ways, definitely better for the environment.
- habeidnendnmd 3y ago[dead]
- tiffanyh 3y agoI really appreciate the web design of that government website. It’s modern but information density & accessible.
- askvictor 3y agoOne local government in Melbourne AU (very close to the city) announced they were doing this for a section of their roads (not including arterial roads). The head of the police force said it was ridiculous (so presumably they probably won't enforce it). Despite numerous studies showing the difference in safety for pedestrians, and the fact that most of these streets rarely go above that speed anyway, either due to traffic or physical constraints. But that's car culture for you.
- TheHippo 3y ago> To keep public transport running smoothly, in some places we are constructing separate lanes for public transport. Public transport is allowed to continue travelling at 50km/h on these lanes. So even more incentive to use public transportation.
- phero_cnstrcts 3y agoYes, WEF wants to abolish private ownership of vehicles so they can decide when and where you can go.
- wpm 3y agoLmao how do the readers of this site come to believe such obvious BS
- clnq 3y agoWouldn’t this cause more pollution? Lower fuel efficiency, increased congestion, more half-clutch inching, more stopping, more time spent by each vehicle on each road… …At least assuming the number and routes of travels stay constant. I used to drive a 2010 Diesel VW Golf, about 55kW, in Central Europe. It would take 4l/100km at 70kph and closer to 11l/100km when maneuvering slowly. 2.75x pollution diff per km in these scenarios. Sound is important, but cars also pollute the air.
- ignormies 3y agoNot in Amsterdam where - there are more bicycles than people [1] - only 27% of trips are done via car [2] - people travel half as many miles per day than the US [3] Unlike most cities, especially in the US but also elsewhere in Europe, other forms of transportation are actually dependable and more convenient alternatives to driving. Making driving less convenient will actually entice mode shift in Amsterdam, rather than simply be a nuisance. [1] https://bicycledutch.wordpress.com/2018/01/02/dutch-cycling-figures/ https://bicycledutch.wordpress.com/2018/01/02/dutch-cycling-... [2] https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0094119021001005 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S009411902... [3] https://www.peopleforbikes.org/news/best-kept-secret-dutch-biking-dutch-hardly-bike https://www.peopleforbikes.org/news/best-kept-secret-dutch-b...
- clnq 3y agoI don't think the three points you made are a consequence of speed limits or making cars inconvenient. They are a consequence of city planning and making public transit and bicycle transit convenient. I think cars are in quite inelastic demand for many people who use them in Amsterdam. There are people with cardiovascular conditions, people who need to transport others, carry heavy items, and so on. Incentivizing works better than punishing generally.
- jacquesm 3y agoInteresting that this got flagged off the homepage. Wonder why. If you flagged this would you explain why a development like this in a world capital is off-limits?
- charcircuit 3y ago>Wonder why Articles like this always cause flame wars between car haters and non car haters, and city dwellers and non city dwellers.
- jacquesm 3y agoIt's a major win for sustainable living regardless of whether you're a car hater or a city dweller or the reverse, after all: cars aren't banned, just slowed down to the same speed as the rest of the traffic, as are mopeds etc. It makes it safer for everybody.
- charcircuit 3y agoThe contents of the article don't matter. People will start flame wars since it's tangential.
- P_I_Staker 3y agoNo they will not. Not everyone has the toxic combination of stupid and lazy that you car drivers put into your tank every week... try using a tree or the earth. Feet don't need fuel.
- windows2020 3y agoReduce the speed to 5 so that an estimated 99.9% of pedestrian accidents are survivable and the city is silent.
- jacquesm 3y agoI'm pretty sure you'll find a fairly large chunk of the Amsterdam population would agree with that for cars but not for bikes.
- alienicecream 3y agoPeople have truly lost their minds with this fetish for safety. This is what happens when you don't have a good old fashioned war for a couple of generations. We are breeding weakness and fear.
- 28304283409234 3y agoGetting people out of cars and onto bikes and/or walking is weakening them? Hm.
- robocat 3y agoThey have introduced 30km/h limits in my city center (Christchurch, New Zealand). Also introduced synchronized lights to reduce traffic speed. Plus techniques to take traffic away from city center. And reducing parking. Traffic is now far more congested - as must have been expected by the planners. And people are avoiding going to the city center for shopping/meals/etcetera. AFAIK the planners do not measure outcomes: intention of changes is A/B/C but do they measure that A/B/C occurred? I think one major aim is reducing the number of cars hitting cyclists and pedestrians. No idea whether that is being achieved. The one council planner I know is a cycling nut! It is "interesting" watching the results of expensive cycling upgrades. On a per cycling trip basis (per person using the upgrades), the changes appear to me to be hidiously overpriced. Let's see how it pans out over the decades. I cycled to work every day for a while through the city center so I do understand some of the needs.
- whazor 3y agoI work next to a road in Amsterdam where cars are currently driving 50 and will have to drive 30. My view is that the cars always have to wait at the traffic lights, because it is too busy with traffic. So essentially they speed up to 50 just to stop again moments later. Therefore I think the time difference will not be very big.
- robocat 3y agoPerhaps, perhaps not. Depends on the timing phases of the lights. Certainly the new 30km/h and modified phases has caused noticable congestion where previously traffic flowed very well. Sure to be safer for pedestrians and cyclists because the traffic is now mostly at a standstill. On some roads you could race the phases and go 60 to 70 in a 50 zone. I would be interested to see a measure for the improvement in safety. People were careful on those roads, and can now be more cavalier e.g. cyclists lane splitting and pedestrians jaywalking through dense standstill traffic.
- jochem9 3y agoCycling infrastructure is much cheaper than car infrastructure. Way less material needed (narrower paths, less foundation) and much lower maintenance costs. Initial investment per cyclist might seem high, but you need to build it before they come. And they come. Just look at Amsterdam (became a cycling city in the 70s) or Paris (started investing heavily in cycling infra a little less than 10 years ago).
- lofaszvanitt 3y agoThis feels like it will backfire. Maintaining 30km/h is PITA with a car.
- hackerbeat 3y agoMy condolences.