16 ms·
I lean toward (2), and I think we have strong evidence for this in the form of 'shrinkflation', where firms redesigned their packaging to provide less product w
by anigbrowl 3y ago
I lean toward (2), and I think we have strong evidence for this in the form of 'shrinkflation', where firms redesigned their packaging to provide less product while maintaining prices or brand identity (eg making the packaging appear to be the same size while having lower product weight/volume). The fact that changing product packaging requires a significant investment in adjusting production lines says to me that it was a proactive decision rather a simple reaction to market conditions.
By contrast, eggs went up quite a bit a couple of years back due to a combination of increased demand and a coinciding outbreak of avian flu. But while one could feed chickens less or selectively breed for smaller eggs, the actual manufacturing of the egg is basically up to the animals rather than the accountants. If you crack open a fresh egg you pretty much know what you're getting and it isn't easy to change. It's not feasible to sell cartons with only 5 or 10 eggs rather than the more common amounts of 6 or 12 (or 30 if you have an insatiable appetite for them as I do). So there normal forces of supply and demand have reasserted themselves and prices have (somewhat) returned to where they were a few years ago. It's been easier to observe changes than for items like beef which I buy more intermittently.
- nradov 3y agoShrinkflation is hardly a new phenomenon. There is no evidence to indicate that firms were less greedy a few years ago. Temporary high egg prices were at least partly caused by a temporary supply shortage from a bird flu outbreak. That was somewhat different from the monetary issues which usually drive inflation. https://apnews.com/article/bird-flu-outbreak-turkey-egg-chicken-prices-afca48e861a54091d0e224a5fcbed17b https://apnews.com/article/bird-flu-outbreak-turkey-egg-chic...
- falcolas 3y agoIt's amusing to point out eggs as some kind of holy grail of how price moves naturally, when the two largest egg producers (Cal-Maine Foods and Rose Acre Farms) were just fined in federal court for price fixing.
- Aunche 3y agoKelloggs, General Mills, and Nestle hired lawyers that appealed to populism to convince jurors that egg producers price fixed with a probability of at least 51%. That's hardly proof of price fixing.
- falcolas 3y ago> finding that the egg suppliers had exported eggs to cut supply in the US market, as well as limiting the number of hens, reducing flocks and killing chickens earlier than they usually did. It was sufficient proof to convince a full jury, which makes them guilty of price fixing. They can certainly appeal, that's how the court process works. It's how all trials in the US work. Also, I have to take issue with the insinuation that these egg producers are the underdogs with a small business budget for lawyers themselves. They're the largest egg producers in the US with billions of dollars worth of assets.
- gruez 3y ago> > finding that the egg suppliers had exported eggs to cut supply in the US market, as well as limiting the number of hens, reducing flocks and killing chickens earlier than they usually did. Going back to your prior comment: >It's amusing to point out eggs as some kind of holy grail of how price moves naturally, when the two largest egg producers (Cal-Maine Foods and Rose Acre Farms) were just fined in federal court for price fixing. I mean, prices did move naturally. The egg producers reduced supply and price went up "naturally". In the case of covid "greedflation", you don't really need an explanation to explain the reduced supply and/or increased demand: covid and stimulus checks explain the situation pretty well.
- Aunche 3y ago> It was sufficient proof to convince a full jury, which makes them guilty of price fixing. Sure, but it's still the lowest burden of proof. My point isn't to make Cal-Maine the underdog. It's to point out the irony that anticapitalists will suddenly trust capitalists 100% whenever they say something that agrees with them, regardless of the motivations of such a claim. It's like when people use Microsoft's antitrust lawsuits as evidence as that all billionaires can't be trusted, yet they're completely uncritically accepting arguments made by lawyers who represented other billionaires. Of course the market is perfectly efficient, but 90% of the time it is, especially for commodities like eggs. It may be the case that this is getting worse, but no it is not possible for companies to suddenly decided to be greedy in 2021.