7 ms·
How to think about science and becoming a scientist
- soccerniru 15y agoI disagree with a lot of points made here. First, this is focused exclusively on the biological sciences, and is largely not applicable to other fields (hence the title is misleading). Second, there are a lot of personal anecdotes which don't move the central ideas forward. Finally, there was little in the article that discussed how to think about science, most of it was how to pursue science. That being said, I agree with the sentiment. Most of what we teach undergraduates is about the knowledge science is produced, rather than about the process of doing science itself.
- mechanical_fish 15y agoI didn't read the whole thing - it's not concise, that's for sure - but the general advice seems to be: Go find a lab job and see if you like it. Though his examples are specific to biology, I can't figure out what part of that advice is specific to biology. I did it in experimental physics and it worked out just fine. Sure, the article is about about pursuing science rather than thinking about it. But that's the author's whole point. Enjoying a career is all about enjoying the day-to-day work: If you love thinking about DNA but don't love pipets, you're going to be unhappy a lot of the time, because life in the lab is about 10% deep thought and 90% pipets. (Or, in the semiconductor laser lab: 10% deep thought, 50% misaligned optics, and 40% mysterious process problems that you will never entirely understand, but which you will eventually solve by spending months on end turning knobs in a strategic manner.)
- mturmon 15y agoAgree about low information density of article. Same general advice applies in engineering: do your best to attach yourself to a lab, and see if it catches your fancy. Best way to test-drive a career choice. He's kind of down on textbook-and-problem-set coursework and large lecture classes. This is not universal. Some large lectures are large for a reason -- the professor is a star. And some textbooks are really good, and some problem sets are worth sweating over.
- sliverstorm 15y agoMost of what we teach undergraduates is about the knowledge science is produced, rather than about the process of doing science itself. Which is not entirely a useless endeavor; if you don't know about what has already been discovered, how can you build on it and go further? How will you know what has already been tried?
- solox3 15y agoIf one were truly amazed by science, nothing would be in ones way to becoming a scientist; the knowledge is all there, the tools are all there (reactants, catalysts and conditions for illegal materials notwithstanding), and if you are indeed one of these people who are destined to be a scientist ("he who seeks knowledge"), rather than an engineer ("he who wants hands-on") then there is nothing to explore than the minds of your own, or the minds of others (by means of scientific databases, readily available online).
- hippee-lee 15y agoSo how would you go about learning LC-MS/MS and applying the various separation techniques to small molecules or proteins? Instruments start at 250k and many in universities are decades older than what is currently used in industry. For small molecules, the most challenging (and exciting) library's of compounds are owned by third parties. It is my opinion that science, much like programming, one has to do it to learn it. There are limitations to the knowledge you gain without being hands on. See E.O Wilsons musings of the impact his formative years and post grad school wanderings in the south pacific. He is certainly a scientist but much of his knowledge and insight is due to the hands on approach he used to to gain that knowledge.
- bbgm 15y agoCompletely agree. I don't think I am going to put a 900 MHz NMR or an Orbitrap in my basement :)
- hippee-lee 15y agoI know! I can just hear my daughter, 'Daddy, turn that down. I'm trying to watch Doc McStuffins. Why do you have to do science on a Saturday morning?' Then there is the electrical bill and I already get hell from my wife for the water bill during the summer months.
- gammarator 15y agoMuch current research is published in journals so expensive that reading them is prohibitive without an institutional subscription.
- elliott34 15y agoArn't the biological sciences notorious for having way too many Phds than relevant research jobs/professorships available? Scientific research should be encouraged in undergrad with the caveat that it really only qualifies you for grad school. Instead, one could spend summers in internships and enjoy more employment opportunities upon graduation. Research can be fun, but reality bites.
- bbgm 15y agoI spent many summers in research labs doing different kinds of scientific projects (mostly in chemistry and physics). It was not only fun, but very rewarding and resulted in a strong foundation in scientific thinking which has always been useful, regardless of the specific job. Part of the reasons I moved towards the biological sciences in grad school was partly due to reality. As a quantum chemist (which I was at the time), opportunities were limited. It was also the time that computational biology was getting really interesting. I joined a startup 2 weeks after finishing my defense. Caveat: I haven't been a practicing scientist for a while.
- srconstantin 15y agoBasically I agree that "when in doubt, learn science." In American society, we have more of the norm of "when in doubt, don't learn any science." And that's counterproductive. In other countries, there are explicit and implicit reminders that science students are smarter than non-science students. In my dad's (European) high school, students were literally tracked from A to F; A was math, B was physics, biology and social sciences were somewhere in the middle, and vocational school was at the bottom. Harsh? Yeah. But it meant that generically smart and ambitious kids wound up in the hard sciences by default.
- roel_v 15y agoWhat country was that? In my original European high school, those with the highest grades went studying the classics, with maths being a fallback for those who didn't quite make the cut.
- literatish 15y agoInteresting -- my dad went to school in Ireland and had tracks similar to the previous commenter, the A track being the most math intensive (although everyone on that track also studied Latin and Gaelic). Where was your high school?
- roel_v 15y agoBelgium.
- bedris 15y agoTwo lines from the article: Scientists and engineers expand the size of the economic pie; lawyers mostly work to divide it up differently. Whenever possible, work to be a person who creates things, instead of a person who tries to take stuff created by someone else. There is an infinite amount of work in science because the universe is big and we don’t really understand it and we probably never will. New answers to questions in science yields more questions. Greenspun makes and attend to his discussion of what grad school in the sciences is like, especially this, his main point: “Adjusted for IQ, quantitative skills, and working hours, jobs in science are the lowest paid in the United States.” In other words, science is good for society but bad for the individual, from a purely economic standpoint.
- wenxun 15y agoMy friends and I build a website for scientists to discover & share journal articles that are worth reading, to discuss scientific ideas that are worth spreading, and to connect with people who share similar interests: http://www.pubup.org/ http://www.pubup.org/ . Please let me know what you think of the idea and the website. Thanks!
- beambot 15y agoThe idea is great, but just so you know... my experience in academia (anecdotal) suggests that Mendeley already has a pretty substantial lead: http://www.mendeley.com/ http://www.mendeley.com/
- wenxun 15y agoTrue, but it seems to me that Mendeley and us are addressing different aspects of the same problem
- beambot 15y agoCan you elaborate? The frontpage of PubUp seems strikingly similar to the "papers" page at Mendeley: http://www.mendeley.com/research-papers/ http://www.mendeley.com/research-papers/ I'm completely open to an alternative service (or even a complementary one). So... I guess what I'm trying to say: Give me, one of your intended customers, a compelling use scenario or value-add proposition that might compel me to switch.
- 2muchcoffeeman 15y agoIf you can, don't choose. Get 2 degrees. I studied physics. I make a lousy physicist, but I learned a lot, got to play with some cool stuff and it gave me a whole new appreciation of the world and how it worked. It is also the last time you get to play with lab equipment that costs hundreds of thousands of dollars. Absolutely no regrets.
- mukaiji 15y agoI am graduating this spring with a materials science degree from Stanford. Materials science has the absolute most boring set of classes (seriously, it's really bad). However, Material science also has what I think is some of the most ground-breaking, fascinating, and magical scientific research topics out there, from nanotech, biotech, and energy, to novel electronic form-factors, batteries & fuel cell, and much more. therefore: Degree Classes != Actuality.
- snowwrestler 15y agoThe profession of science is really, really hard, and generally does not pay well. But, when you learn something new in science, you have learned something that no one else knows, that is fundamental to the very structure of reality. To be a happy professional scientist, the emotional stimulus of that kind of discovery needs to be strong enough to carry you through all the hardship.
- wink 15y agoThat was awesomely inspiring and fun to read, actually makes me feel bad a little for pursuing CS :)