6 ms·
Which Movies Are the Most Polarizing? A Statistical Analysis
- m348e912 3y agoI remember reading that Napoleon Dynamite was not only polarizing but it was incredibly hard to predict if someone would like it or not based on their previous viewing history. Netflix struggled with this in their rating system for a while. https://www.cracked.com/article_35884_that-time-napoleon-dynamite-broke-the-netflix-algorithm.html https://www.cracked.com/article_35884_that-time-napoleon-dyn...
- loloquwowndueo 3y agoNapoleon Dynamite. I guess you were a victim of autocowreck.
- m348e912 3y agoFixed thx
- jetrink 3y agoI wonder if that was due to how much awkwardness there was in the movie. * It's a divisive mood. Some people find it relatable and cathartic (and hilarious in the context of comedy), while others find it intolerable to the point that they will leave the room during awkward scenes. * It's not a common type of humor, especially in mainstream American movies, so people are unlikely to have many other awkward comedies in their viewing history. * Napoleon Dynamite took it to such a degree that even people who enjoy it in small doses might have become exhausted by it as the film went on. (As far as I can recall, that's how I experienced the film.)
- ghaff 3y agoIt's probably in cult movie territory. I vaguely remember not necessarily hating it but it's not something I would rewatch by choice. And cult movies--more or less by definition--are polarizing.
- izzydata 3y agoIt's awkwardness reminds me of dry British humor similar to The Office. Very few shows are like this in the US.
- ghaff 3y agoI think you're probably right. It's the sort of thing I can watch but I certainly don't love it the way some people do. I can even take or leave a lot of Monty Python (though some, e.g. Life of Brian, I do love).
- lordnacho 3y agoWhat's hard to tease out is people voting with the "so bad it's good" reasoning. Primarily horror movies are like this.
- mensetmanusman 3y ago[flagged]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- CoastalCoder 3y agoI'd finally managed to forget that film. I hate you.
- gh02t 3y agoDon't forget that there's a sequel. Edit: actually there are TWO sequels. You can't forget until you complete the Birdemic Cinematic Universe. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Birdemic_2:_The_Resurrection https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Birdemic_2:_The_Resurrection
- CoastalCoder 3y agoAlright, if we're taking the gloves off for this exchange, I'll counter with this: [0] [0] https://www.rifftrax.com/rifftrax-live-birdemic https://www.rifftrax.com/rifftrax-live-birdemic P.S. I'm sorry it came to this. Perhaps in another life we could even have been friends.
- gh02t 3y agoI've already seen that one. One of the best Rifftrax along with The Room and Twilight, fellow Person of Culture. Me and a bunch of friends used to be zealous bad movie watchers, though we don't do it as often now that we're all scattered.
- thighbaugh 3y ago[flagged]
- mensetmanusman 3y agoDon't Look Up was an interesting one. Some thought it was hilarious, some got depressed.
- mjhay 3y agoIt wasn't terrible, but the satire should have been much subtler. The cast of all A-listers came across as self-indulgent and annoying to me as well.
- thrdbndndn 3y agoI enjoyed the film overall, but I agree that the satire was quite heavy-handed, particularly with Jonah Hill's character. I understand that it was intended to be over-the-top, but it was too much for me.
- wharvle 3y agoYeah, the folks in my group who watched it had such a negative reaction I didn’t bother with it. But as I recall the complaint wasn’t that it was depressing, but that it was a movie length “do you get it? Do you get the bit? We better do it harder just to be sure.”
- logicchains 3y agoThat film was particularly interesting as (maybe unintentionally on the part of the film-makers) both sides of the political spectrum thought it was satirizing the other side.
- me_me_me 3y agoThis movie doesn't work tonally. It tries to be both serious and satirical. And it fails to make both of those world work together. In the Idiocracy what made it work is that the satire applied to the whole world except of the main character that we as audience identified with. You explore the boundaries of the new absurd reality with them. There isnt anything like that in Dont Look Up, its a strange mix of our current day reality with crazy illogical morons.
- k__ 3y agoI like that the top 15 contains movies I'd consider awesome and movies I'd consider utter garbage. As polarizing as could be.
- silvester23 3y agoI noticed that for every movie on the list that I like, I can totally see how others might not. But for most movies that I dislike, I just don't get how people can genuinely enjoy them. I don't know what that says about anything but I found it curious.
- gspencley 3y agoI'm the same way and I think this might be a manifestation of both the false consensus effect (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/False_consensus_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/False_consensus_effect) and false uniqueness effect (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/False-uniqueness_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/False-uniqueness_effect). When people like something we don't like, we are shocked that they could disagree with us as to how awful that things is. "Can't you see it?! The dialogue is unnatural, the premise is implausible, the production design looks like it was outsourced to the cheapest contractors money could find and the characters are unrelatable! What trauma must you have endured to actually enjoy that trash?! You poor thing!" But when it comes to something we like that other people don't like ... well, that's understandable after all. We're unique ;)
- hunters_laptop 3y ago[dead]
- WarOnPrivacy 3y agoI think I adore this list. 1. Plan 9 from Outer Space 2. The Passion of the Christ 3. Twilight 4. Pink Flamingos 5. The Texas Chainsaw Massacre 6. Transformers....
- mattigames 3y agoImagine if they had resurrected Jesus in plan 9, the polarization on that one would be out of this world!
- aredox 3y ago"I've seen Rocky Horror Picture Show at least five times, and I'm still unsure if it's a "good" movie" Well, at least it wasn't so bad that he balked at watching it one more time
- nemo44x 3y agoI think he’s saying this because the experience of seeing it at midnight with a performance troupe is distinct from the film itself. The experience can be fun even if the movie is possibly not.
- AndrewDucker 3y agoI've seen it multiple times because friends loved it. And I find it vaguely entertaining, so I sat through it, trying to work out what I'm missing.
- jonhohle 3y agoI’ve seen it multiple times and gone to several performances to figure out what I’m missing and figured out I’m missing nothing. It’s not good, and not so bad that it’s good. I’ll watch a movie my friends like a second time to see if there was something I didn’t get. Sometimes it clicks, usually it doesn’t. Edit to add: I typically don’t think movies should be watched multiple times to be enjoyed. There are occasions where expectations, state of mind, mood, company, etc. effect a viewing and something needs to change to get a different perspective. Sometimes enjoyment comes from the repetition (especially so bad it’s good movies), but that should be the exception.
- ghaff 3y agoI'm not usually much of a cult movie person. But I've seen Rocky Horror as a midnight movie, just watched it at home, own a bunch of stage soundtracks, and saw it live on stage a few weeks ago for the first time. And really like it even if it drags a bit in the second act. It's certainly not a great movie--and it's camp--but I enjoy it.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Mikhail_Edoshin 3y ago“Plan 9” is rather predictable: mostly valued low, but some find it interesting because of that badness. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0052077/ratings/ https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0052077/ratings/ A good Christian-themed movie will be much more polarizing and for real. For example “Old-Fashioned” (2014): https://www.imdb.com/title/tt2048824/ratings/ https://www.imdb.com/title/tt2048824/ratings/ (Found it by specifically searching Rotten Tomatoes for movies rated lowly by critics and highly by the audience. For “Old-Fashioned” the ratio is 17/83. For “Plan 9” the ratio is 66/45, nothing spectacular.)
- harha 3y agoOh this is also my metric for good movies and conversely I drive clear of high critics ratings with low audience ratings. Life's too serious already, I want to enjoy watching movies
- ghaff 3y agoEven Roger Ebert who I think was both an excellent film critic and more an everyman in his tastes than Gene Siskel had a definite film critic mode that was more highbrow than my tastes (which are not especially lowbrow). You probably don't/didn't get into that profession without having some degree of film snobbery.
- ghaff 3y agoI don't think that many people (anyone?) actually think Plan 9 is a good movie in the film critic sense. Rather it's something you should watch (or at least you used to) at a midnight movie showing because "it's so bad it's good" (or at least a lot of fun in the right context).
- ako 3y agoMost polarizing for me are the dramatized history movies like Napoleon. Most of the public will not be aware of what parts are true, and what parts are fiction. History will be remember as portrayed by these movies. They're basically committing falsification of history. It will be hard for the public to learn from history, if history is portrayed incorrectly in these movies.
- Eumenes 3y agoWas it any good? I haven't seen a movie in years but this one seemed interesting as a history buff. Getting Napoleon right and that whole era is incredibly challenging - even after reading several books about the guy and those times, I'm still confused.
- godtoldmetodoit 3y agoI thought it was pretty bad. It made Napoleon out to be uncharismatic and a total "simp" as the kids would say towards Josephine. He just comes off as a war monger Dictator who is ruining Europe for his single-minded vision of personal grandeur. That's not the read I get on the man from my reading, so I found it very disappointing from a historical perspective. From the "is it fun to watch" point of view... it was middling for me. Some of the battle scenes were cool, and there were some funny lines throughout that made me laugh, but overall as a story I found it pretty uninspired. Like, Gladiator had tons of historical inaccuracies as well, but it stood on its own as a really fun movie to watch and I can't put Napoleon in that category.
- Eumenes 3y agoThat's a bummer. It's prob the only movie I've looked forward to in a long time. Oh well.
- marcusverus 3y agoWe don't really get to see Napoleon the man. He is portrayed as an oddly bland man, passively floating through events, which is so incredibly at odds from the reality of the man as I understand him. Really, all of the character attributes that made him 'Napoleon the Great' have been cut out. None of his lasting martial or civil innovations are mentioned. It's hard to imagine that this was an accident, since Scott clearly took great care to portray Josephine (an aging, black-toothed, capricious bimbo whose thoughtlessness was regularly a problem for Napoleon) as a young, beautiful and strong woman who was apparently "cleaning up after" Napoleon. I got the distinct impression of a British director gleefully taking ole Boney down a notch.
- alexmolas 3y agoWhat a coincidence! I wrote about the exact same topic just some weeks ago [0]. [0]: https://www.alexmolas.com/2023/11/14/controversial-movies.html https://www.alexmolas.com/2023/11/14/controversial-movies.ht...
- logicchains 3y agoI'm surprised to see Biodome there, I never met anybody who disliked it.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 3y agoFor me it is surprising that the Passion of the Christ is not more polarizing. Even, or perhaps especially, as a Christian, although I appreciated it, it was brutal to watch. The violence felt very visceral. This was a movie I rate highly, but can’t say that I enjoyed watching.
- CoastalCoder 3y agoAgreed. I guess the explicit brutality makes sense if the goal is to help audiences understand the price that Jesus is said to have voluntarily endured. But even Southpark reckoned it was a lot of brutality to see.
- h2odragon 3y agoPoC was explicit gore porn, extremely well done. I've never understood how that was supposed to advance the actual messages of Christ that people find moving and helpful. I don't think it was. "The Revenant" had some of the same grinding brutality. We were allowed to say "this is just gore porn with no redeeming value" there, tho.
- razakel 3y agoIt's not really the sort of movie you'd watch if you weren't Christian or interested in religion.
- larrywright 3y agoI’m surprised none of Wes Anderson’s films are on this list. In my experience his work is incredibly polarizing. People either absolutely love it or can’t stand it. I’m in the love it category but I dig quirky films.
- francisofascii 3y agoAgree. I am in the can't stand camp. The colors, dialogue, stories, just don't appeal. But have many friends who love these movies, and I am the odd one. Maybe someday I will get it.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- larrywright 3y agoThe thing that makes me enjoy them is the attention to detail. He builds entire worlds and controls everything in them (at least once he got past his first few films). I’m the kind of person who enjoys watching a movie more than once and discovering new things each time, and his films are great for that. I call these kinds of films “black licorice movies”. Nobody is really impartial: they have strong feelings one way or another.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Mountain_Skies 3y agoNot surprised to see Bio-Dome on the list. Several people I know love that love but in general don't like Pauly Shore movies. Something about it makes it an exception and I'm not quite sure what it is.
- sjcsjc 3y agoI was amazed that some friends of mine hated In Bruges (after I'd been praising it to the skies). Didn't expect that reaction and it made me much more cautious about recommending films to people.
- yakubin 3y agoYou need better friends. ;)
- sjcsjc 3y agoHa. No they're great. Just different in that respect :-)
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- worksonmine 3y agoHad the same experience, I think it's a brilliant movie and my friends thought I was an idiot for wasting their time.
- sjcsjc 3y agoI didn't recommend Banshees to them, that's for sure.
- worksonmine 3y agoYou will probably enjoy The Lobster.
- sjcsjc 3y agoTa. You might like Wild Tales. It's on prime and in Spanish with subtitles. My son and his mates loved it too.
- 3y ago
- lqet 3y agoBased on my experience, 2001 should be on this list. I have seen people sit through this film in complete confusion, waiting "for the movie to start", and afterwards refusing to believe that anyone would voluntarily give up 2.5 hours of their life to watch this a second time.
- cogwheel 3y agoConsidering the list was generated from data, not just the author's opinion, I wonder what criteria you're using for "should". My guess is a lot more of the general population feels the same (negative) way about it, but your sample of people you've seen reacting to it is giving you selection bias, thinking more people enjoy it
- me_me_me 3y agonot many people have seen it, these days only limited and niche people would see 2001. For that reason the stats on it would be skewed towards people who would view it more favorably.
- ghaff 3y agoIt's a film a cinemaphile would watch today for either nostalgia or historic interest. Whatever its place in the film canon (which it richly deserves) I'm pretty sure the random theater-goer today would hate it and I wouldn't really recommend they go watch it.
- ericbarrett 3y agoI laugh so hard at the opening of 2001. Not the monkeys dancing around the monolith; rather, the opening title: the orchestration of Also sprach Zarathustra crescendos on "Stanley Kubrick." What an arrogant monument to himself! One wonders if he took it so seriously or if there was a wink and nod behind it. I do love the movie though. It drags on, and it's psychedelic in a way that doesn't really translate to modern, sober viewing; yet the special effects and researched realism larded into it would take Hollywood many more decades to embrace. And HAL is still a character for modern times.
- CoastalCoder 3y agoI know the data for this aren't publicly available, but I'm curious about this analysis for HN. E.g.: Which commenters have lots of highly upvoted comments and highly downvoted comments? Which comments receive lots of upvotes and lots of downvotes? Which comments experience significant swings / oscillations in score over time?
- tobias2014 3y ago"Tracking ratings variance by release year, we observe an increase in review variability starting in the late 1970s, followed by a precipitous decline in variance starting in the early 2000s." I'm sure there is also some time dependent effect in how people rate movies now vs. in the past. For a snapshot in current time, one would need to be careful to not include ratings from too long ago as society and norms change.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- crazygringo 3y agoThis is a remarkably excellent and in-depth article. It's not just a list of the most polarizing movies, but separates them out by categories and genres and tags and timelines and goes into speculating about the whys. Kudos to the author. The most interesting part for me was the user-generated tags most associated with polarizing films. The top five by rank: 1. Low budget 2. Jesus 3. Stupid 4. Musical 5. Jim Carrey All of which seem to make perfect sense, no matter which side of them you're on (except, well, #3 which is amusingly redundant/meta...).
- dTal 3y agoFilms are "polarizing" for many reasons, and this article attempts to categorize some of them - Low-Budget Cult Classics, Inescapable Franchise Films, Horror Movies That Went Mainstream... But there is one film in that list that defies categorization along those lines, and it happens to be the only film in it I have watched and enjoyed multiple times. A film quietly ignored by all the discussion. That film is Babe: Pig in the City. I am not eloquent enough to unpack what makes this film special. Fortunately, someone else is, and you can read their take here: https://junkee.com/babe-pig-in-the-city/299986 https://junkee.com/babe-pig-in-the-city/299986 . Some excerpts: "a fetish object made to satisfy a sexual proclivity that does not yet exist", "some hideous goo scraped off the surface of the human id", "What You Think About Babe: Pig In The City Tells Me What You Think About Art", and "essentially purposeless in its horrifying nature". It strikes me that the common feature that connects Babe: Pig In the City and the other categories the article mentions is a mismatch between the expected and received amount of "art house-iness". An arty film thrust into the mainstream through organic hype? Polarizing. A bland high budget corporate thing popular through the sheer weight of overmarketing? Polarizing. A haunting and wildly tonally inconsistent study of the crushing weight of society upon the underprivileged marketed as the sequel to a beloved and uncomplicated children's film with talking farm animals? Polarizing...
- wharvle 3y agoThat film’s on my to-watch list because everything I’ve heard about it is along the lines of “it’s… actually good. Not good for a sequel to a mediocre kids’ movie in the talking/telepathic-live-action-animals subgenre, but actually good. For adults.” It’s also trivia-bait, because it was directed by George Miller. As in, Mad Max George Miller.
- oboes 3y agoI'm surprised The Birth of a Nation didn't make it on the list. It's probably one of the most controversial films ever.
- wharvle 3y agoI don’t think a lot of viewers, in the last few decades, watch it without the context of knowing it’s film-historically very important. FWIW—subject matter aside, even—it was among my least favorite in a silent film binge I went on a couple years back. Of the 50ish silent dramas and art films I’ve watched (setting aside the comedies) it’s in the bottom 5. It’s actually one of only two I’ve bailed on (Tabu was the other). Only made it about halfway, the draw of “it’s important” wasn’t enough to keep me watching.
- ghghgfdfgh 3y agoWhy’d you bail on Tabu? I remember it being one of the more entertaining silent movies I’ve seen. As well as having a very memorable ending.
- wharvle 3y agoI dunno, for some reason I found the first 30 minutes or so excruciatingly dull and just didn’t care about where it was going. I really enjoyed Nanook, so was surprised. Possibly I just wasn’t in the right mood for it. [edit] and The Last Laugh, and Sunrise, though I was less enamored of Nosferatu than I expected to be. Enjoyed those too, to connect it to Murnau as well as Flaherty.
- dpee123 3y agoHey there, I'm the author of this article (but not the OP). Thrilled to see all the discussion here. I'm glad folks are enjoying the analysis—hope the findings aren't too polarizing.