18 ms·
Bitcoin mining used more water than New York City last year
- mistercheph 3y agoHow much water has been used by the AI industry?
- constantlm 3y agoHow much water did the banking industry use? Or the gold mining and storage industries?
- lxgr 3y agoAgriculture probably also uses more, but you can’t eat Bitcoin.
- TaylorAlexander 3y agoComparing bitcoin to the banking industry is so absurd to me unless you account for users served. How much water per user served did the banking industry use? It makes sense that banking uses a lot of resources in total because it is a huge industry, serving hundreds of millions of people worldwide, if not billions. Bitcoin serves what, at most a few tens of thousands of users? I heard people talk about the electricity usage of the banking industry in comparison to bitcoin and its the same thing. Yeah it takes a lot of energy to heat and cool every bank in the world, but it is serving several orders of magnitude more people than bitcoin and offering way more services. Can I walk in to a bitcoin building and get a loan for a new car? Nope.
- lolbase 3y agoPerhaps it could be compared to _just_ FedWire. But even then, FedWire handles about $4t of transfers per day. That's a couple orders of magnitude more than BitCoin. And that's literally one service, from one bank.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- TheDudeMan 3y agoThat is a reasonable comparison. Bitcoin can do that much volume as well (without much change in water “usage”). The difference being that one is controlled by the US government and one is not.
- TaylorAlexander 3y agoBitcoin can handle $4T in transfers a day?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- TheDudeMan 3y agoAt ~700,000 transactions per day, if the avg txn value is $6M, then yes.
- kkielhofner 3y agoTo put it in perspective Bank of America alone has over 60 million customers. 60 million real people. People that forget a password, lose their wallet, encounter fraud, need to walk into banks occasionally, use debit cards/deal with cash/ATMs, credit cards that are also accepted everywhere, and as you point out financing products people can actually use (not some crazy smart contract DEX who knows what), need help, have questions, etc, etc, etc. Safety deposit boxes to notary services the list just never ends. This is just retail. Plus little things like at least trying to comply with the law, customer protections, regulation, oversight, fraud departments, etc. People that even bring up comparison to the banking or financial system in discussion of bitcoin power usage instantly have zero credibility. Although the same could be said for almost any comparison between bitcoin and the banking system. It has total users measured in the 7-8 figures tops after 16 years for many valid reason.
- junofan 3y agoWell yeah it’s called regulatory capital for a reason. Banks are happy to provide token services in exchange for mispriced loans from retail to support their nonretail biz. It’s cool I can walk into a BoA branch in my neighborhood; in exchange I can’t get a house for less than a million bucks. Number one rule of banking is retail’s getting fucked. Most people would be better off with a narrow bank.
- imtringued 3y agoNothing stops you from borrowing Bitcoin loans and using that to pay for your house... except the risk that Bitcoin goes up from 40k€ to 60k€ and your loan got 50% more expensive and there you go, your comment becomes pure hypocrisy. The idea that 11 people bidding up 10 houses is going to radically change if you have Bitcoin or a narrow bank is ridiculous. If people borrow Bitcoin for the loan, they will still have to outbid everyone else at exactly the same price measured in dollars, because eleven people are bidding up 10 houses. I am honestly quite tired of nonsense like your comment. If the economy is in general equilibrium, then there is no meaningful difference between Bitcoin and the dollar. If there is no general equilibrium, I would expect Bitcoin to be further away from it than dollars.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- boppo1 3y agoGolf courses in Arizona and SoCal
- sc68cal 3y agoWhich one provided more economic value to society? It wasn't Bitcoin, that's for sure.
- mistercheph 3y ago*extracted [...] from society
- Ekaros 3y agoAnd wouldn't bitcoin likely use almost same amount of servers if they provided same services? Moving numbers around on ledger is only part of it. Heavy computing is in all business rules and internal logs and traceability. And you are not getting rid of those situations where one service called an other even if final ledger is immutable...
- bdcravens 3y agoThis is always the default response to these conversations, but I think it should be evaluated in different terms: what is the ratio of resources consumed to value created/maintained?
- thelastgallon 3y agoThis is on top of the water used for power generation. Electric power generators are the largest source of U.S. water withdrawals and account for about 40% of total water withdrawals in the United States. Water withdrawals by U.S. thermoelectric power plants reached 52.8 trillion gallons in 2017: https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=37453 https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=37453 I guess its not sufficient that we waste trillions of gallons of water on fossil fuels, we must find new ways to waste water.
- aaron695 3y ago[dead]
- 4death4 3y agoIs it really wasting water? For instance, I don't really consider drawing water out of rivers in the East to be a waste of water, because ultimately they flow into the ocean and become salt water. Also, I'm going to assume the power plants don't violate the laws of conservation of matter and the water re-enters the environment somewhere.
- junofan 3y agoArticle fails to disclose Alex de Vries actually works at the DNB—the Dutch central bank. Seems to be a propaganda piece aimed at dissuading younger people from exploring alternative financial systems by tying their use to climate change. I wouldn’t expect much truth here.
- thelastgallon 3y agohttps://archive.is/EKOQ1 https://archive.is/EKOQ1
- JCharante 3y agoHow much water was used for animal agriculture? Both bitcoin and animal agriculture are unnecessary and only serve to please certain people.
- presbyterian 3y agoYou’re right, Bitcoin is directly comparable to a thing humans have done for sustenance for all of recorded history.
- JCharante 3y agoYes they are because they are both activities that take up resources. And both are unnecessary because humans can feed themselves without using animals.
- diegoholiveira 3y agoAnimal agriculture is unnecessary? Really?
- JCharante 3y agoObjectively, yes. You don't need meat or animal products to survive. It's a luxury.
- bdcravens 3y agoCotton is one of the most water-intensive crops, but when evaluating anything, we need to look at ROI. Most of the conversations around crypto tend to ignore this.
- rowanG077 3y agoI don't think people ignore it. It's just that ROI for crypto has not materialized.
- diegoholiveira 3y agoNew technologies are expensive at the beginning. Nothing new here.
- richbell 3y agoBitcoin was created ~2009. The cost is only going up, by design.
- diegoholiveira 3y agoI didn’t say it will become cheaper overtime. New technologies that require massive amounts of bandwidth and CPU/GPU power are expensive. And those will not became cheaper overtime.
- protocolture 3y agoCool.
- ericd 3y agoI guess we have to deal with a bunch of this kind of reporting again now that BTC is recovering its value. While I’m certainly no fan of the environmental impact Bitcoin had in its last bull run, I like Lyn Alden’s point that having access to a stable banking system and a currency that isn’t subject to massive devaluation at the whims of your government is a luxury that many of us enjoy, but that many in the rest of the world do not. Many are stuck saving in currencies that could have their values wrecked at almost any time, in bank accounts that could realistically be frozen or drained by their governments unilaterally with little recourse, especially if they’re a suspected dissident. Obviously, BTC’s value is far from stable, but its future value is at least not certain to be much lower, and it gives people an escape hatch from almost certain financial repression, basically being forced by their government to fall back the financial ladder that they’ve been working for a large portion of their lives to climb up.
- pdpi 3y agoYou just described why I entered the space, and for a while I was proud to say that were actually catering to those needs. Unfortunately, the whole industry has turned into get rich quick schemes and investment toys for rich kids.
- andsoitis 3y ago> stable banking system and a currency that isn’t subject to massive devaluation at the whims of your government In practice, BTC value is more volatile than currencies in advanced economies, no?
- npoc 3y agoOnly in the short term. Holding for at least 4 years sees you through the "price discovery" noise while it's growing
- PoignardAzur 3y agoYeah, I feel like "your 4-figures investment will eventually start growing again after years (unless the bubble pops for good)" isn't what people are thinking of when they hear about bringing stable banking to impoverished countries.
- 4death4 3y agoI'm interested in the question: why does Bitcoin use water? Apparently some of the water comes from cooling power plants, but a lot of the water usage comes from hydroelectric power. From the study the WSJ article is based on: > Iran’s high reliance on natural gas for electricity production lowers the water footprint of its mining activities in comparison to countries like Canada and Norway where water-intensive energy sources like hydropower have a more significant role than Iran. Depending on the source, using hydroelectric power is not really a waste of water. For instance, another WSJ article linked from TFA [0] talks about using hydroelectric power from the Niagra river. At night, there is often surplus energy generated by hydroelectric power plants along the river. Both Canada and New York have pumped storage hydroelectric plants to handle the excess power generated at night from both hydroelectric plants like the ones along the Niagra river as well as nuclear power plants. And still there is excess power at night. You're actually doing the state of New York a favor if you can put excess night time electricity to use. 0: https://archive.ph/y3CFt https://archive.ph/y3CFt
- lxgr 3y agoAh, here goes the "recycling otherwise wasted electricity" myth again. I just don't buy it from an economics point of view: Bitcoin miners don't stop mining as soon as literally anybody else needs the electricity – they stop mining as soon as local electricity prices make it uneconomical for them. In the end, they'll accordingly always contribute to raising prices from the demand side and will at least sometimes be pricing some other consumers out or, worse, raising the electricity price enough for gas turbines to have an economic incentive to start producing. (Renewables have an effectively free marginal cost per joule but are inflexible/unpredictable; gas turbines are expensive but flexible.) Additionally, some types of hydroelectric plants support variable flow – they can just increase storage levels instead of running their turbines at maximum capacity.
- 4death4 3y ago> Ah, here goes the "recycling otherwise wasted electricity" myth again. I just don't buy it from an economics point of view There’s not really anything to “buy” here. I just described how the New York Power Authority generates power. Here’s a press release from last August announcing a new facility for 20 MW of storage with a target goal of 6000 MW of storage by 2030 [0]. This is just battery storage and doesn't include other storage like pumped hydro. It’s just a fact that NY has excess electricity from hydroelectric power plants. 0: https://www.nypa.gov/news/press-releases/2023/20230825-utility https://www.nypa.gov/news/press-releases/2023/20230825-utili...
- khaki54 3y agoI didn't realize bitcoin used some sort of hydrolytic reaction that destroys water.
- roschdal 3y agoIt's time to stop the Bitcoin madness. Never forget Sam Bankman-Fried and FTX.
- aurareturn 3y agoThere have been tens of thousands more largeish scams in crypto. SBF and FTX was just the biggest one.
- TheDudeMan 3y agoNever forget Bernie Madoff and the USD.
- PeterStuer 3y agoThere's 'using' as in using naturaly present gravity running water through turbines to produce electricity (hydropower) coming out clean and usable, and then then there is 'using' as in turning it into sewage as in the NYC cases. Unsurprising to see the WSJ deliberatly suggesting both are comparable.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 3y ago"In 2021, Greenidge Generation, a Bitcoin-mining and power-generation company gained global attention for allegedly discharging large volumes of hot water into New York's Seneca Lake. The company had repurposed a once-abandoned power plant for Bitcoin mining in 2019, leading to increased carbon emissions and water usage. Residents raised concerns that the warm water discharges were heating Seneca Lake to beyond state water-quality standards. In 2023, environmental groups sued Greenidge Generation for violating the Clean Water Act and other environmental regulations, though this lawsuit was dismissed in the same year." https://www.cell.com/cell-reports-sustainability/fulltext/S2949-7906(23)00004-6 https://www.cell.com/cell-reports-sustainability/fulltext/S2...
- lisa611 3y ago[dead]